Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think low carb is just another faddy diet?

196 replies

trilobiterevival · 20/05/2022 15:22

(And it works for some people, much the same as other diets. We know this. And some people are sensitive to carbs, so I am not including them in this AIBU).

But I think most naturally slim/fit people eat carbs. They just don't gorge on them.
Many who go low carb began quite overweight and were probably eating large portions before. Changing their diet and becoming more mindful is likely the reason for weight loss, not the total annihilation of all carbs.
It's all a bit evangelical isn't it?

Plenty cultures enjoy rice, bread and pasta. But I have seen these foods described on MN as.... and I quote.... "nasties'. What utter, utter tripe. There is a huge difference between a serving of wholegrain rice and a sugar festooned donut!

There are healthier carbs than others, like most foods, but it is very easy to locate bread made with only a few ingredients, similarly to what you could make at home. The excuse that all bread is full of sugar and oil is a cop out IMO.

Most people I know who are slim and healthy eat bread or pasta, or both. It isn't the work of satan. It is quite easy to incorporate healthy carbs into one's diet, whether daily or weekly and stay healthy and slim. I wonder if those who claim they can't eat carbs or else they gain a ton of weight immediately are not able to them it in moderation, so it's easier for them to just quit.

For the record I don't favour low fat diets either, I also believe that fat is good for us.

Unless you have a health related issue that requires you to reduce carbs, then I think YABU! Grin

OP posts:
byvirtue · 20/05/2022 20:02

I’m slim but as I approach 40 to maintain my 20 something figure and weight I have had to halve my carb intake.

it’s not a diet, I still theoretically eat what I want but I eat a lot less as I can feel my metabolism slowing as I age even if I’m probably burning more calories (desk job in 20s vs running after a small child and looking after large house/gardens and never sitting down in 30s).

Omega33 · 20/05/2022 19:57

I don't think carbs should be demonised, but the only time I successfully lost weight was on a low carb diet. If I reduce my calories but still eat plenty of carbs, the volume of food is smaller and I feel hungry, which makes snacking more tempting. By cutting out/down on carbs I could pile my plate high with veg and eat much more food for the same number of calories.

Limeseverywhere · 20/05/2022 19:55

My friend has lost 5 stone on the Keto diet. She has done well but personally I think she is too slim now and it’s become an obsession, she won’t touch any carbs and even drinks low carb wine. IMO, she has lost the weight because she overhauled her diet and now eats small portions compared to the huge ones before.
I have been slim all my life, have always eaten carbs but one thing I do is eat my food in small portions, I never overload my plate with carbs, everything in moderation.
If carbs are so bad then why were the majority of people, pre the last few decades, mainly slim even though potatoes and bread were the staple of their diets back then?

Snowpaw · 20/05/2022 19:48

I don't think carbs are evil or a sin, or any of those things, but I do know that as someone with PCOS I am more likely to develop diabetes in the future as it brings with it insulin resistance and all sorts, and I just know that sugar does not do me any good. I love it, I love bread, I love pasta and everything else. But my hirsutism does not. Nor does my mood, or my energy levels. When I eat low carb, all of my symptoms improve and life is happier and more balanced for me. I sleep better, I look better. I wish I had the metabolism of others, but for me I know they are not a good choice.

Againstmachine · 20/05/2022 19:48

Calories in Vs calories out does not explain why some people get fat and others don't.

It really does , it's physics its not a made up thing.

Your DH will not be gaining weight as he will have hit a point where his intake matches his outgoing calories.

gwenneh · 20/05/2022 19:45

Calories in Vs calories out does not explain why some people get fat and others don't.

So thermodynamics is selective? Or is it more likely that people overestimate their TDEE and don't/can't adjust accordingly?

KellynchHall · 20/05/2022 19:41

So to lose weight insulin must be low. It's the storage hormone of the body. If it raised it tells cells to store glucose as glycogen and for fat cells to store fat. You cannot burn off your fat stores while insulin is elevated.

Both protein and carbs trigger insulin. But carbs, particularly refined carbohydrates will trigger it the most. By lowering carbs you reduce insulin and therefore fats can be released from fat tissue and used for energy.

When people diet using calories as a measure you will still be reducing the insulin because you will either cut back on chocolate or cake or crips. Or you will eat smaller portions.

Calories in Vs calories out does not explain why some people get fat and others don't. I know all the thin people think it's because us fatties are gluttonous beasts but in reality that isn't true. My DH has been obese for years but his weight is perfectly stable. Does he eat too much - yes, but why then isn't he continually getting fatter? Don't tell me he is perfectly balancing his calories in Vs calories out because that takes some serious in depth knowledge about his metabolic rate which he does not have.

Ginandcrispsarebliss · 20/05/2022 19:35

Slimming world worked for me. Lost 4 stone and kept it off. I know what works for me.

MarshaBradyo · 20/05/2022 19:25

I’ve never been able to diet in the traditional sense, nor really had to when younger

But late 40s low carb is good ime, and not faddy as it’s easy to do long term

Againstmachine · 20/05/2022 19:19

Do those who berate people for "cutting out whole food groups" feel as strongly when they are around someone who eat a very low fat diet? Or does fat not count as a food group?

Nope fats are a necessary part of food groups, fat ensures the body runs correctly same as carbs.

People who have lost weight doing keto have lost because of CICO not because of the Keto diet.

Lougle · 20/05/2022 19:06

I can't speak long term yet. I started a low carb diet 2½ weeks ago.

I'm early 40s, used to be very (too) slim. Really fast metabolism so could eat anything and not put on weight.

In my late 30s I started to accumulate weight around my stomach. I have a tendency to post meal sugar dumps, too.

More recently, I was starting to get quite intense shakes between meals. I would literally feel faint, dizzy and as if I hadn't eaten a meal for the whole day. The only way to stave it off was to eat a snack.

Since I've started the new diet I haven't felt hungry between meals. I haven't had shakes between meals.

The blood pressure medication I was taking (for chronic migraine, not blood pressure) have been cut in half already because my blood pressure has reduced.

Who knows, I might in time find a balance that allows moderate carbs. Right now, low carb is suiting me.

Blossomtoes · 20/05/2022 19:06

ComtesseDeSpair · 20/05/2022 16:27

I think that low carb is often recommended as a weight-loss diet because it’s very easy to eat a lot of calories in pasta or bread and not really notice it. Cut them out, and it becomes a lot more difficult to overeat on basically proteins and vegetables.

I don’t think refined carbs are bad, but neither are they the sort of things we evolved to eat, either: grain-based diets are only as old as human agrarian history is. Limiting them and relying on unrefined carb sources like roots, pulses, vegetables and lentils instead is healthier (and the basis of low carbing, as opposed to no-carbing or keto.)

Spot on. Whether naturally slim people eat carbs is irrelevant, they’d be slim whatever they ate. Low carb is the perfect way for me to lose weight. It means I can basically eat whatever I want, including mayo on my salad, lots of cheese and full fat Greek yoghurt - all things that I love. Basically we’re all different and what works for some people doesn’t for others.

gwenneh · 20/05/2022 18:58

glamourousindierockandroll · 20/05/2022 18:50

Do those who berate people for "cutting out whole food groups" feel as strongly when they are around someone who eat a very low fat diet? Or does fat not count as a food group?

Why wouldn't it be the same? Fat is also a macronutrient, and avoiding it rather than balancing it is just as much an issue.

glamourousindierockandroll · 20/05/2022 18:50

Do those who berate people for "cutting out whole food groups" feel as strongly when they are around someone who eat a very low fat diet? Or does fat not count as a food group?

Suprima · 20/05/2022 18:37

catscatscatseverywhere · 20/05/2022 16:45

"I am one of the aforementioned people and I can’t eat carbs with every meal unless I calorie count which is miserable and triggering. I am currently 8.5 months pregnant with morning sickness still and I am eating whatever I can stomach- but I’m looking forward to going back to my way of eating. You call it ‘faddy’ but my diet of Greek yogurt and berries, salads with avo oil and protein and meat and veg for dinner is much more nutritious than one completely reliant on grains."

Who said that diet completely reliant on grains is something considered healthy and sustainable? You're missing the point.

The NHS recommended ‘healthy diet’ is completely reliant on grains

The average british diet of toast or cereal for breakfast, meal deal for lunch and spag Bol/curry and rice/pasta carbonara/shepherds pie…whatever…is completely reliant on grains

gwenneh · 20/05/2022 18:30

venusandmars · 20/05/2022 18:20

@Underroad I'm similar, low carb (carbs coming mostly from healthy veg) and higher fat has almost completly reversed a health condition. I now take a sub-cinically dose of medication.

Interested - what would happen if you started eating carbs again? Would the condition return, or is it actually properly reversed?

doadeer · 20/05/2022 18:30

I agree.

I live near a Planet Organic and I was thinking last time I was in how so much of the shop is dedicated to restricted diets, dairy free, gluten free, keto, low carb.... As if these are the healthiest options.

My mum and grandma are in fantastic shape and eat carbs every meal. I was brought up to be balanced and not eat a lot of processed foods - that was key in our family, real home cooked food. Low junk.

StuntNun · 20/05/2022 18:28

I think low carb, along with many other dietary approaches, attracts orthorexia-types who become obsessed with whichever diet they are on then they become almost evangelical about it because they think everyone else should do the same. Realistically I don't think there is a one-size-fits-all approach to diet. My brother has a rigid calorie intake set to match his fitness tracker calories burned and he maintains a normal weight. I eat low carb high fat and don't count anything and I maintain a normal weight. I couldn't do what he does, and he wouldn't want to do what I do. I saw a post on Facebook today from a woman that was eight days into a dry fast, i.e. no food or drinks for eight days, with another two to go. There's no way I would do that in a million years but it seemed to be working for her no matter how extreme it seems to me.

venusandmars · 20/05/2022 18:24

@Lynnthesearesexnotgenderpeople it's not as boring as my dh's muesli for breakfast; sandwich, crisps, juice, apple for lunch, and then whatever I cook him for dinner.

I eat so much more of a variety. Breakfast might be a boiled egg, or yogurt with a few raspebrries and hazelnuts, or a cheese omelette, or left over vegetable soup from yesterday.

venusandmars · 20/05/2022 18:20

@Underroad I'm similar, low carb (carbs coming mostly from healthy veg) and higher fat has almost completly reversed a health condition. I now take a sub-cinically dose of medication.

knowinglesseveryday · 20/05/2022 18:17

I totally agree that healthy carbs are not bad for you. That said, Kings university (Tom Spector department) research says that different foods and diets affect people differently.

Troisfoisfilles · 20/05/2022 18:13

I am going to disagree massively. I lost almost 5 stone doing keto. At first very strictly, then just keeping my carbs low. I have maintained the weight loss for almost 3 years now and although I’m not zero carbs, I do try to eat healthier breads and pasta keep them low. I also only eat them in the evenings.
So for me, carbs were evil. They were definitely what was causing my weight issue. This might not be the case for all, but for me it really was!

venusandmars · 20/05/2022 18:06

@trilobiterevival
OP your opening post is so, so SO judgemental.

'naturally slim/fit people'
'gorge'
'began quite overweight'
'large portions'
'not able to eat them in moderation'

These words are not about carbs, they are about eating habits and a little about genetics.

Of course, yes, there is a difference between a serving of wholegrain rice and a sugar festooned do[ugh]nut they have completely different nutritional profiles. On any low carb discussion I have never seen anyone disputing that. IF you're going to eat 50g carbs, it's clear where it should come from. Unprocessed or low preocessed food.

Sure, bread can be made with 4 or 5 or 6 ingredients. I've been there, done that, bloody delicious. But most bread is bought from shops. It has upward of 20 ingredients. Cheap bread has even more, including an 'inert' ingredient that is added to clean the bread making machines. If you're time and money poor then that is the bread you will buy. I challenge you to find affordable bread made with 'a few ingredients'.

Carbs ARE necessary. Any healthy diet will include them. But where do they come from? I'd rather get carbs from a locally grown cauliflower than from rice produced in Asia. I'd rather eat mushrooms, tomatoes, cheese, that come from my local farmer than avocado or mango. I'd rather have minimally processed carbs from a turnip (swede) or brussel sprouts, than from Mr Kellog's sweetened All Bran. I'd rather have a locally caught mackerel than Tiger Prawns from Indonesia.

I try to eat a diet that has less meat and more vegetable, but I would never eat the highly processed 'fake meat' stuff that is promoted as healthy eating.

Infared22 · 20/05/2022 18:00

I am with you!
I hate all these diets. Slimming world, WW, Atkins, keto etc. they all create disordered eating, by the fact you have to either cut a food group out or point/syn ‘bad foods’

I have genuine sympathy for people who think these work. Research calorie deficit, it’s what all these diets create if you do them ‘right’ basically consuming less calories than what you burn out in a day. I am 5ft 8in, do 10k steps a day, and with my current weight my maintenance calories are 2200, meaning I can eat that many and not lose or gain. 1800 calories is my deficit amount, meaning only eating this means I lose 1lb a week. Yes people say ‘I struggle to track my calories’ but a week or 2 with a digital scale and a consistent diet and you quickly pick up how many calories are in meals for it not to add work to your day. I also have chocolate most days and definitely eat carbs everyday.

Fad diets make me rant.

ditavonteesed · 20/05/2022 17:42

I agree that anyone evangelising about any way of eating is annoying but low carb diets work for a lot of people and are definitely sustainable. Things like diabetes and pcos are helped without the insulin spikes of carbs. Losing weight isn't always as simple as calories in vs calories out for a lot of people and you are lucky if it is. There are many conditions that create hunger and low carbing is the only way that can be controlled.

I have been overweight my entire adult life, also very fit, do a lot of exercise and ate controlled calories. Nothing ever helped me lose weight till I tried low carb high fat diet. It works for me, I'm happy, I've maintained my weight for over a year and I'm not hungry all the time time anymore. That said I literally don't care what anyone else chooses to eat. I'll do me and you do you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread