Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Batshit Neighbours - how would you respond to this message?

160 replies

carolinesfrog · 20/05/2022 12:01

This message is from the neighbours of a rental property my Mum has.

Neighbours HATE the tenants, who are perfectly lovely people. Neighbours like to complain a lot. Neighbours have sent this message.

How would you reply?!

Batshit Neighbours - how would you respond to this message?
OP posts:
yellowsuninthesky · 20/05/2022 16:06

I am a permanent homeworker, see no clients, and just work from a spare bedroom on a computer. I even had to inform my insurers and the council tax people about this when we moved here

I think there are an awful lot of people working from home who've done neither of those things. This is quite useful: www.gov.uk/introduction-to-business-rates/working-at-home

I would have thought that insurers wouldn't care if you are working in a home office. In fact it's better you are there than going out to work because you less likely to be burgled if the house is occupied.

As for running to the OP and MN, maybe the mother has a good relationship with the OP and you know, talks to her about things?

yellowsuninthesky · 20/05/2022 16:00

I’m a landlord. It is standard to have a clause not allowing tenants to run a business from home

Such a standard clause sounds completely unenforceable post covid. But even before covid there would have been lots of people working from home, both as employed workers but also running their own businesses (whether legal consultancy, book-keeping, graphic design, web design). I know such a clause is there to prevent someone turning the house into a scrapyard or something but to be enforceable it would have to be specific.

saraclara · 20/05/2022 15:50

You'd have to pretty much write off a car to damage a gabion cage, so surely there can be nothing that needs paying for in that regard.

GCRich · 20/05/2022 15:47

Not read the full thread, but IMHO OP needs to -

(1) Find out what the business is and whether there are any legal issues with it.

(2) Consider whether there are any covenants in the title documents that are relevant (there probably aren't, but presumably it is possible that no-one other than the occupant and guests have access rights over shared driveway - customers do not.)

(3) Consider whether the rocks some sort of obstruction that the neighbour has no right to place (title docs again)

(4) Consider whether to advise the tenants' customer to seek compensation for damage to car from "illegally" placed rocks.

(5) Ignore and block if appropriate.

godmum56 · 20/05/2022 15:43

Mummyoflittledragon · 20/05/2022 15:40

I’m a landlord. It is standard to have a clause not allowing tenants to run a business from home. Your mum should check this and insist the gabion be moved in such a way that it is a) not encroaching on her land and b) visible from a car, therefore a stacked height. Failing that, it needs to be removed completely. Any racist, vile comments are completely separate from these issues.

For the sake of neighbourly relations, I think it would be wiser to agree with the neighbour to erect a small boundary fence part way between the properties and agree in writing to maintain this 50/50. Or allow them to erect one at their expense and with your mum’s agreement to the appearance, placement, height, length etc.

but the land might be owned by both houses?

Mummyoflittledragon · 20/05/2022 15:40

I’m a landlord. It is standard to have a clause not allowing tenants to run a business from home. Your mum should check this and insist the gabion be moved in such a way that it is a) not encroaching on her land and b) visible from a car, therefore a stacked height. Failing that, it needs to be removed completely. Any racist, vile comments are completely separate from these issues.

For the sake of neighbourly relations, I think it would be wiser to agree with the neighbour to erect a small boundary fence part way between the properties and agree in writing to maintain this 50/50. Or allow them to erect one at their expense and with your mum’s agreement to the appearance, placement, height, length etc.

LakieLady · 20/05/2022 15:12

I think they want your mum to pay to fix the Gabion cage as they've provided the size of it.

I think so too, but no way is this anything to do with OP's mum. The most I would do is ask the tenants to ask their visitors to drive carefully when leaving.

fyn · 20/05/2022 15:11

Of course it’s an unreasonable request, it’s nothing to do with your mum if a third party has hit a cage of stones. If the neighbour has a problem they should talk to the person that hit the stones, your mum isn’t their keeper.

Lolliepoppie · 20/05/2022 15:09

Seems like a they have concerns about a business being run from a domestic address, which seems fair enough.
Are the tenants allowed to run a business from home and who owns and pays for maintenance of the shared drive?

LakieLady · 20/05/2022 15:07

Tessasanderson · 20/05/2022 13:09

Can we have some guesses at what the business is please?

My guess is a brothel

Home hairdressing or beautician.

Happyplace88 · 20/05/2022 15:03

I wouldn’t believe they’re running a business until you have proof. NDN sounds an absolute busybody and clearly dislikes neighbours. Also not reasonable at all to assume people will hit his car and drive off. What a weirdo.

NumberTheory · 20/05/2022 15:03

I think there are several issues here:


  • Tenant potentially running a business (there are issues with this in terms of whether the council allows it and if they have the insurance in place and also issues from your mum’s perspective in terms of whether she has the right insurance, mortgage, contracts etc, in place- and whether she wants to be renting out a residential place to someone using it as a place of business as potential for greater risks).

  • Tenant being cavalier about neighbour’s property and tenant’s guests’ (or clients’) behaviour. (So it is between the neighbour and whoever damaged their property, but you probably dont’ want a tenant, however lovely they’ve been, who doesn’t try to get guests or clients to be decent to those in the neighbourhood - they probably won’t be decent to your mum’s property either.

  • The neighbour’s placing of the stone cage - is that a shared drive with right of way for both houses for cars passing over? Has neighbour placed it so it’s half on your mum’s property? I can understand why neighbour’s done it if there are a lot of cars that seem to have been cavalier about damage, but your mum needs to make sure her property rights aren’t at risk from this action.

Testina · 20/05/2022 15:01

Should your mum be a landlord if she can’t deal with a neighbour complaint without running to you and MN?
She could at least take her role serious enough to join a landlords forum.

LakieLady · 20/05/2022 14:59

carolinesfrog · 20/05/2022 12:23

Thank you all! I think past interactions with this neighbour have evidently made us see this as an unreasonable request when it perhaps isn't so.

Neighbour sounds like a bit of an arse, tbh. And if the tenants are otherwise good tenants, I wouldn't be inclined to get involved. Good tenants are worth keeping!

Damage to the gabion is between him and the driver of the car, not really the tenant or your mum. And I'd be wondering if the gabion has been placed in such a way as to make it difficult for people to get on and off the drive of your mum's house, OP. A friend has that sort of drive, where the first part is shared and it then splits into 2, and they're not allowed to put anything on the shared section.

Running a business from a residential address can be a planning issue (there was a memorable parking thread on here some years ago, where a neighbour was running a dog grooming business from home, and that was dealt with as a breach of planning permission by the council).

I'd be minded to suggest he takes it up with the appropriate authorities, and leave him to work out how to go about it. It's not your mum's problem.

WouldYouIfYouCould · 20/05/2022 14:59

Eh? What’s batshit about the message? If my neighbours ran a business and one of their clients damaged a Gabion cage (they’re quite expensive caged stone walls) then I’d be pretty pissed off too and concerned they might cause more damage.

Booboobibles · 20/05/2022 14:58

I definitely think you should report the tenants to the council and wreck their livelihood. Inflict as much stress as possible. Make them understand that being a tenant means being a second class citizen.

Then evict them because they can’t pay their rent. Yes, that sounds like a good plan🙄.

Serendipity79 · 20/05/2022 14:56

I have a shared drive and neither me or the neighbours are allowed to put anything on it without the others agreement so if the gabion is on a truly shared driveway then it shouldn't be there at all without your mums agreement.

If its a shared access drive up to two privately owned driveways then the stones need to be on their driveway alone.

If a driver has hit their rocks they need to take it up with them - nothing to do with your mum

Badlifeday · 20/05/2022 14:53

My insurance is less because I park on a drive than when I had to park on the street. Presumably they think the chance of it being hit on your own drive is small! (Or stolen, though I can't see why it couldn't be stolen from my drive just as easily really). However parking on a shared drive increases risk, and a drive shared with a business even more so.

saraclara · 20/05/2022 14:50

BowerOfBramble · 20/05/2022 14:44

Unless your mum's tenant has opened a mcdonalds drive through/gun shop, I think it is a batshit message.

The summary is: "We are worried that your tenant's guests will hit our cars on the shared drive, so we put a box of rocks in the way (which is nothing like the size/shape/visibility of a car) and someone HAS hit it. You see! What are you going to do about it? Yours, people who have far too much time looking out the windows."

Yep. I bet that rock cage is too low to be easily seen in a rear view mirror.

BowerOfBramble · 20/05/2022 14:45

P.s. obviously the mum/agent should check about the business thing, but that's nothing to do with the neighbour.

BowerOfBramble · 20/05/2022 14:44

Unless your mum's tenant has opened a mcdonalds drive through/gun shop, I think it is a batshit message.

The summary is: "We are worried that your tenant's guests will hit our cars on the shared drive, so we put a box of rocks in the way (which is nothing like the size/shape/visibility of a car) and someone HAS hit it. You see! What are you going to do about it? Yours, people who have far too much time looking out the windows."

TaranThePigKeeper · 20/05/2022 14:39

There are certainly issues if running a business from a residential property, where clients visit the home, relating not only to the need for public liability insurance but council tax & business rates (if part of the building is used only for the business then this will apply); and planning permission is needed for some functions, not least due to the likely increase in traffic and parking issues, but also to ensure no nuisance or caused to neighbours.

I am a permanent homeworker, see no clients, and just work from a spare bedroom on a computer. I even had to inform my insurers and the council tax people about this when we moved here.

This isn’t a message to be dismissed.

Watchkeys · 20/05/2022 14:24

If someone hits their car, it's between them and the driver. It's that simple.

Whether they ought to be running a business is a totally different issue, and they're not even asking about that.

It's got nothing to do with you. If you want to respond with anything, just tell them they'll have to take it up with the driver, if anything happens, just like they would if their car was hit in the street.

DeskInUse · 20/05/2022 14:23

I guess several things need to happen

Your mum needs to check if they are running a business and how that impacts insurances, rents, mortgages etc

As for responding, they may have a point if a car has just hit something of theirs, maybe send back

'Thanks for the informing me'

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 20/05/2022 14:22

taylorsdoinapart · 20/05/2022 12:14

Well, it's hardly a batshit message is it. It's at least alerted you to the fact that they're running a business from the property, which may or may not affect the owners insurance/mortgage etc. They're making the owners aware of potential issues.

This - it’s hardly a batshit message.

And you / your mother would be mildly batshit to ignore as it raises fair points