Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think kids are more immature since lockdown

86 replies

mummyofthreeplus · 20/05/2022 11:08

Seeing my DS (13 and in year 9) and the way him and his friends act it seems more like the way my older dc would have acted I’m year 7 or even 6. I have a friend who is a teacher and she says far more behavioural issues and friendship problems that pre covid and even in sixth form far more issues with not doing work and poor attendance. Has anyone else noticed this that it seems like kids are now a lot “younger” for their age since covid?

OP posts:
VintageGibbon · 20/05/2022 15:58

They're bound to be. If they are 10, then one fifth of their entire life so far has been curtailed by lockdown. They have missed key interactions that help them develop social skills and communication.

PAFMO · 20/05/2022 15:55

I'm a secondary teacher, and yes, mentally and psychologically, most kids are 2 years younger than their age.
It's not as clearcut as the lockdown opponents would like it to be though

Our most troubled kids are:

The numerous girls with eating disorders, every single one an average to good student before lockdown. During lockdown they became excellent students. People helping them with work, copying stuff from other sources, downright blatant cheating, no exams. Now they're back and they're back to being average-good but that's no longer good enough for them and their parents. They are questioning why they were getting top marks in lockdown and not now. And they then turn on their own bodies.

The first year senior school kids who present as 8 year olds. Academically as well as psychologically. Every single fucking Mumsnetter who banged on for weeks about "my child isn't going to log on, we're jumping in puddles and watching Joe Wickes then we're going to bake" needs a long hard look at themselves. And we pick up the pieces and get the grief at the same time.

Our 18 year olds are doing exams and planning on university and getting upset when they're not getting the offers OR the expected grades.

Also agree with pps about a sheer inability to know how to behave in a group setting. It's hard to put your finger on, but petty fighting, tears at every little thing. Odd examples like literally not being able to wait till break for a snack. Our HT has had to issue a letter to parents to say no more coming and collecting them before the end of lessons, I had a class last week late on in the day and 10 kids had been collected early. Why? Tired. They are 17.

It's all quite bizarre.

TheKeatingFive · 20/05/2022 15:38

Well, not exactly a surprising result now is it?

icecreamcart · 20/05/2022 15:20

Lockdown damaged kids. Disgusting policy.

neverbeenskiing · 20/05/2022 15:12

I work in a secondary school and we have noticed that social maturity, particularly in this years Y8 and Y9, took a massive hit post-lockdown. So many kids who cannot resolve even the most minor friendship issues without adult intervention, kids who cannot tolerate others differences or not getting their own way. We also noticed that many kids came back having forgotten how to say "please" and "thank you". We were all worried about kids being behind academically but honestly the biggest piece of 'catch up' work has been re-learning manners, social skills and empathy.

ladymalfoy45 · 20/05/2022 15:08

I left a long term post because SLT thought it was acceptable for a Y11 pupil to throw a chair at me and threaten to rape me ‘because really they’ve not been in school for two years’.
Agency said ‘ all schools are like this at the moment’.

MsMarch · 20/05/2022 15:01

ReadyToMoveIt · 20/05/2022 14:58

And you so often see threads on MN where people are moaning that ‘kids today’ can’t cook a meal or do basic chores, or find their way across a city, or take responsibility for the own homework etc. But now apparently being ‘less mature’ is a good thing?

It's magical thinking of a sort. This utopia people remember. A bit like watching period dramas - it's all about the nobility and the one "sassy/cheeky" hero/heroine from the working classes who get out. It's never about the endless death/damage of children due to poor maternity care, poor nutrition, poor hygiene etc.

"Ooh, we had such a wonderful childhood, children grow up so fast" but no sense of irony that the wonderful childhood was based on independence and freedom and not sitting around being waited on hand and foot.

ReadyToMoveIt · 20/05/2022 14:58

And you so often see threads on MN where people are moaning that ‘kids today’ can’t cook a meal or do basic chores, or find their way across a city, or take responsibility for the own homework etc. But now apparently being ‘less mature’ is a good thing?

ReadyToMoveIt · 20/05/2022 14:55

MsMarch · 20/05/2022 14:52

I am loving all the "they're more like children of the past, and not growing up too fast".I think it's hilarious - 70 years ago my dad was walking to school at a young age, left school at 15 etc. I try with my kids but there's no doubt that I was expected tot take much more responsibility for cooking/cleaning/tidying at a much younger age than my DC do. When was this mythical period where children were innocently and happily playing with dolls and never saw or experienced anything bad or only had to play and be young?

That’s what I thought! My mum used to get the bus on her own into her local city centre when she was 7 for her dance classes! Her and her sister were left alone while my grandmother (single parents) worked nights when they were 6 and 8, with instructions to bang on the wall for the neighbour if they needed anything!
Ahh the good old days where kids could be kids, eh?

MsMarch · 20/05/2022 14:52

I am loving all the "they're more like children of the past, and not growing up too fast".I think it's hilarious - 70 years ago my dad was walking to school at a young age, left school at 15 etc. I try with my kids but there's no doubt that I was expected tot take much more responsibility for cooking/cleaning/tidying at a much younger age than my DC do. When was this mythical period where children were innocently and happily playing with dolls and never saw or experienced anything bad or only had to play and be young?

Triffid1 · 20/05/2022 14:49

babybythesea · 20/05/2022 13:56

I work with Y1 and 2. Yes, they are more immature. But it is how this shows that is important. They play as they have always played, it's not in the types of games we see immaturity. It's their dependence on adults.
The number of them that need help with basic tasks like cutting food and zipping clothes has shot up. They also need far more help with navigating friendship issues. I spend a huge amount of time dealing with 'she looked at me and I didn't like it' and 'he doesn't want to play my game' than I used to. They find it hard to sort out disagreements on their own and we hear about Every Single Squabble! We have children in tears with reasons like "She made a loud noise and I don't like it."
And far more tears generally in the morning coming in to school over missing home, missing mum or dad. They just seem more fragile.
But poor little souls, none of our children have yet had a full year in school.
In general, it is this area that is the legacy of lockdown for my class, not academically.

this is definitely true for DD. She was an extraordinarily independent toddler and while she could be a bit sensitive and insecure at times, started school no problem. But Covid hit when she was in reception and now she is much more emotionally dependent on us than I would expect for her age or, more importantly, than I think she would have been at this age if it wasn't for covid.

ReadyToMoveIt · 20/05/2022 14:45

LilacPoppy · 20/05/2022 14:33

You say it like the “immaturity” is a bad thing op? It really isn’t.

It depends on how the immaturity is manifesting though, doesn’t it?
Still playing with dolls etc at an older age than ‘usual’, fine. Unable to deal with emotions, unable to carry out age appropriate tasks/self care etc… more of a problem.

Dixiechickonhols · 20/05/2022 14:42

Depends how immaturity shows. Eg immaturity in terms of navigating traffic is potentially a huge concern. Studies used to show children up to age 10 ish couldn’t judge speed of traffic safely. If that age is now 12 then it has huge implications as we expect secondary age to get to and from school alone.

LilacPoppy · 20/05/2022 14:33

You say it like the “immaturity” is a bad thing op? It really isn’t.

Thepeopleversuswork · 20/05/2022 14:28

I'm not sure "immature" is quite the right word. I certainly have noticed that my daughter (Y6) has struggled emotionally with things in a way I wouldn't necessarily have predicted. Her confidence was much lower after lockdown in a number of ways and it has affected the way she relates to her friendship groups etc.

ReadyToMoveIt · 20/05/2022 14:05

Dauncets · 20/05/2022 13:40

Agree that dwelling on things is unhelpful. But, recognising and naming a problem is the first step to working towards a solution for it.

Sweeping things under the carpet only for them to rear up years later hidden in maladaptive behaviour like aggression, alcohol and substance abuse etc may be a traditional approach but it's probably not the best.

Exactly this. Ignoring it is just storing up problems for the future.
I have one in year 3 and one in year 2. Both their teachers have said that they’re having far more friendship issues than usual. So many children spent so much time alone that they’ve missed a crucial step in learning how to develop friendships and deal with conflict. They’re having to run special ‘friendship classes’ to help the children learn how to deal with issues that arise. The children are far more fragile emotionally.

TheTurn0fTheScrew · 20/05/2022 13:59

Stompythedinosaur · 20/05/2022 12:42

I've seen quite the opposite. By necessity my 11yo has had to become much more mature in terms of studying independently, making her own lunch and lunch for her little sis sometimes when I was in work meetings. I've seen this in friend's dcs too.

Yes, same here. DC2 was in Y4 when lockdown started. As I was on calls all day when at home (I was in work other days) she had to take more responsibility for her own learning. I think I was slightly tougher than her teacher in terms of not letting her dash something off in 10mins and then doing a fun activity when I knew she could do better (not teacher-bashing - I only had two kids to nag and was desperate to keep her quietly learning while I worked).

Plus there were times when I needed to call into work for a 1-2 hours. She'd be left longer than I'd probably have done if it weren't for lockdown. The 13 yo was in the house but doing her own learning in a different room, so she had to be self motivated and attend to her own needs for those periods.

She's maintained the habit of putting more effort into her work which has been great.

babybythesea · 20/05/2022 13:56

I work with Y1 and 2. Yes, they are more immature. But it is how this shows that is important. They play as they have always played, it's not in the types of games we see immaturity. It's their dependence on adults.
The number of them that need help with basic tasks like cutting food and zipping clothes has shot up. They also need far more help with navigating friendship issues. I spend a huge amount of time dealing with 'she looked at me and I didn't like it' and 'he doesn't want to play my game' than I used to. They find it hard to sort out disagreements on their own and we hear about Every Single Squabble! We have children in tears with reasons like "She made a loud noise and I don't like it."
And far more tears generally in the morning coming in to school over missing home, missing mum or dad. They just seem more fragile.
But poor little souls, none of our children have yet had a full year in school.
In general, it is this area that is the legacy of lockdown for my class, not academically.

Dauncets · 20/05/2022 13:40

Agree that dwelling on things is unhelpful. But, recognising and naming a problem is the first step to working towards a solution for it.

Sweeping things under the carpet only for them to rear up years later hidden in maladaptive behaviour like aggression, alcohol and substance abuse etc may be a traditional approach but it's probably not the best.

Dixiechickonhols · 20/05/2022 13:39

Things haven’t just snapped back to normal in terms of opportunities for children.
Lots of clubs and activities haven’t restarted. volunteers have stepped down, things closed for financial reasons and places are limited/long wait list eg Brownies.
School trips etc take a lot of planning and are usually arranged a year in advance. Vaccination rules for children abroad and general uncertainty mean things still haven’t restarted.

Sally872 · 20/05/2022 13:37

I would say yes but in a good way. My 12 year old and her class seem like 12 year olds rather than growing up too fast.

Suppose it depends on the age and stage if it is a positive or negative thing.

bumblingbovine49 · 20/05/2022 13:27

AnotherTroyforHertoBurn · 20/05/2022 11:32

My DS is 21 soon, he is quite underwhelmed by it, when questioned he said to be quite frank Mum I still feel about 19 in my head. The ramifications whilst I agreed with some of them of the lockdowns will go on for a long time. 🙁

Don't most people feel younger in their head than they are?. Except for young children that are. I am 58 and remember not being able to believe I was more than 18 years old throughout my 20s. In my 30s I felt like I was in my 20s in terms of not deep down believing I was a 'grown-up and I now feel like I am in my 30s or 40s in my head. Certainly not like I am nearly 60!

It is very easy to say that the Covid environment changed many children for the worse. It will undoubtedly have changed many of them but whether it is all bad for all of them is another matter.

Also, most generations of people have something in their lives that affects them deeply, it is very rare across the world that nothing happens in a generation that negatively affects the population. I admit that the post-war years in most Western European countries were generally pretty good, but those are a short and geographically limited exception in the context of all of history

I am not trying to trivialize the negative effect of Covid on a lot of children and young people but I honestly think that dwelling on 'how bad it was and how the lives of young people are 'ruined' does not help anyone.

Naimee87 · 20/05/2022 13:19

I think the endless amount of pointles youtubers who are in their late teens, early 20s behaving like children with their pointless hide&seek challenges and prank videos has had a huge part to play here too. Especially with lockdown as well where kids were even more glued to screens. If i hear the phrases whats up guys, like subscribe, comment one more time.... 😂

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 20/05/2022 13:14

TBF society across the board doesn't quite seem the same as it did in 2019. Understandable with kids though - if you have a 5 year old they were isolated from many forms of development for 20% of their life. Many teenagers won't yet have gone through small landmarks that they perhaps would have done, first trip out alone to meet friends, joining a sports club/hobby. Lots of y6-y8 kids won't have done their first solo trip to school.

lurchermummy · 20/05/2022 13:12

Yes I think they've basically missed out on 2 years of growing up and doing normal stuff