Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think kids are more immature since lockdown

86 replies

mummyofthreeplus · 20/05/2022 11:08

Seeing my DS (13 and in year 9) and the way him and his friends act it seems more like the way my older dc would have acted I’m year 7 or even 6. I have a friend who is a teacher and she says far more behavioural issues and friendship problems that pre covid and even in sixth form far more issues with not doing work and poor attendance. Has anyone else noticed this that it seems like kids are now a lot “younger” for their age since covid?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MsMarch · 21/05/2022 13:22

Thebeastofsleep · 21/05/2022 11:48

Sharing is a false concept that's forced on children too young to understand, so no, not a bad thing. I don't intervene in my children's friendship conflicts, I let them work it out themselves otherwise they never will. 2/3 to shouldn't be reliant on other 2/3 yo for speech development and delayed speech at that age is down to the parents if theres not an underlying SALT issue. Again, basic sled care tasks are a parental issue. We shouldn't be needing schools to sort that out. If lockdown has highlighted crappy parenting I don't think that's a bad thing.

As for being unable to deal with things in age appropriate ways, I think as a society we have unrealistic expectations of what age appropriate is for most children.

Agree - but mostly because so many seem to think that 14 year olds should barely have to tie their own shoe laces, never mind be able to fulfil any task that takes genuine independence or even a small level of street smarts.

Encouraging our children to be immature - including in terms of lack of independence, inability to navigate social interactions etc is not a good thing. Confidence and competence does not mean, as another PP has pointed out, smoking behind the bike shed.

ReadyToMoveIt · 21/05/2022 12:53

Thebeastofsleep · 21/05/2022 11:48

Sharing is a false concept that's forced on children too young to understand, so no, not a bad thing. I don't intervene in my children's friendship conflicts, I let them work it out themselves otherwise they never will. 2/3 to shouldn't be reliant on other 2/3 yo for speech development and delayed speech at that age is down to the parents if theres not an underlying SALT issue. Again, basic sled care tasks are a parental issue. We shouldn't be needing schools to sort that out. If lockdown has highlighted crappy parenting I don't think that's a bad thing.

As for being unable to deal with things in age appropriate ways, I think as a society we have unrealistic expectations of what age appropriate is for most children.

Of course, it’s all the parents’ fault. Silly old me.

Thebeastofsleep · 21/05/2022 11:48

ReadyToMoveIt · 21/05/2022 10:25

You don’t think it’s a bad thing that 7/8 year olds are unable to navigate friendship issues/deal with conflict, without significant adult intervention?
Or that 2/3 year olds are struggling with developing friendships as they having learned basic concepts such as sharing? And that their speech is ‘immature’?
That teens are unable to manage their own workloads at school?
That some children are struggling with basic self care tasks?

Children are supposed to ‘mature’. It’s how they become functioning adults. Being ‘mature’ doesn’t mean smoking behind bike sheds, it means being able to deal with things in age appropriate ways.
Being ‘immature’ doesn’t mean playing with ponies and dolls, it means being unable to deal with things in age appropriate ways.

Sharing is a false concept that's forced on children too young to understand, so no, not a bad thing. I don't intervene in my children's friendship conflicts, I let them work it out themselves otherwise they never will. 2/3 to shouldn't be reliant on other 2/3 yo for speech development and delayed speech at that age is down to the parents if theres not an underlying SALT issue. Again, basic sled care tasks are a parental issue. We shouldn't be needing schools to sort that out. If lockdown has highlighted crappy parenting I don't think that's a bad thing.

As for being unable to deal with things in age appropriate ways, I think as a society we have unrealistic expectations of what age appropriate is for most children.

ReadyToMoveIt · 21/05/2022 10:25

Thebeastofsleep · 21/05/2022 10:03

Yes I think they are and I don't think it's a bad thing at all.

You don’t think it’s a bad thing that 7/8 year olds are unable to navigate friendship issues/deal with conflict, without significant adult intervention?
Or that 2/3 year olds are struggling with developing friendships as they having learned basic concepts such as sharing? And that their speech is ‘immature’?
That teens are unable to manage their own workloads at school?
That some children are struggling with basic self care tasks?

Children are supposed to ‘mature’. It’s how they become functioning adults. Being ‘mature’ doesn’t mean smoking behind bike sheds, it means being able to deal with things in age appropriate ways.
Being ‘immature’ doesn’t mean playing with ponies and dolls, it means being unable to deal with things in age appropriate ways.

tttigress · 21/05/2022 10:07

I think we will be living with the consequences of lockdowns for many years

Thebeastofsleep · 21/05/2022 10:03

Yes I think they are and I don't think it's a bad thing at all.

babybythesea · 21/05/2022 07:28

Chickenburgers
There’s not much you can say! There’s not much we can say either. It depends a little bit on the child but just lots of repeating to try and get the message through.
”He doesn’t want to play your game. That’s ok - we don’t all have to do the same thing. He isn’t being mean and he still likes you. So can you tell me your choices? You can play his game, or play something different without him. You can’t force him to do what you want. It’s not because he doesn’t like you and he’s not being mean. He just wants to play something different today. What will you choose?” I have the advantage of actively being able to distract- “Look, they’ve got the football out - shall we go and join in?”
”She looked at you? Ok, well, even if you don’t like it you can’t stop that but are you hurt? Or are you ok? Yes, you’re fine, aren’t you? So it doesn’t really matter if she looked at you does it, because you are ok. So don’t worry about it any more.”
”You’ve both said something a little bit but silly haven’t you? But I know you are super good friends really so how can you work it out together? That’s a brilliant idea - well done. Do you think next time you could have a go at working it out out first and tell me afterwards what you decided to do? That would be amazing!”

I do try and finish every one of those conversations with reassurance and praise. “You’re ok. Well done - brilliant choice.” They aren’t being deliberately difficult- they are telling me in the only way they have that they aren’t feeling happy or they can’t cope. So I need to tell them that they are fine and safe and it’s ok and their friend does still like them until they’ve properly internalised that. If that makes sense.

ChickenBurgers · 20/05/2022 22:58

babybythesea · 20/05/2022 13:56

I work with Y1 and 2. Yes, they are more immature. But it is how this shows that is important. They play as they have always played, it's not in the types of games we see immaturity. It's their dependence on adults.
The number of them that need help with basic tasks like cutting food and zipping clothes has shot up. They also need far more help with navigating friendship issues. I spend a huge amount of time dealing with 'she looked at me and I didn't like it' and 'he doesn't want to play my game' than I used to. They find it hard to sort out disagreements on their own and we hear about Every Single Squabble! We have children in tears with reasons like "She made a loud noise and I don't like it."
And far more tears generally in the morning coming in to school over missing home, missing mum or dad. They just seem more fragile.
But poor little souls, none of our children have yet had a full year in school.
In general, it is this area that is the legacy of lockdown for my class, not academically.

You have described eldest to a T. He constantly tells me such and such sneered at him, such and such didn’t want to play the same game as him, such and such glared at me today. Most days I get these reports from him and I’m at a loss of what more I can say to him other than “ignore it” and “were they ACTUALLY doing xyz?” He is also so much more clingy to me, he went from happily going to visit spend time with family to endless “I’ll miss you too much”, which is slowly getting better, but with lots of back steps. He even randomly says he doesn’t want to go to school some days as he’ll miss me too much, where pre covid he’d happily run in every day without fail. Lots of tears from various children at drop off too. It’s awful for them.

Cherrysoup · 20/05/2022 22:56

Not surprising, but omg, Year 7 in particular are frankly unsocialised! The behaviour is noticeably worse/less mature than previous years. I think Year 8 had it worst, but their behaviour seems far better. Granted, I’m only looking at one school, but there are far fewer incidents with the older groups.

ChickenBurgers · 20/05/2022 22:48

10000%. My eldest sons teacher has said to me this cohort (Y2) are very different to every other cohort she’s had. For Y2’s in particular, they’ve never had a full school year until this year and lots of the groundwork is laid in reception and Y1 and a lot of that was missed due to lockdowns or school restrictions and as such. My son is fine academically, but his ability to navigate friendships, playground squabbles etc has definitely been negatively impacted and he is still very much in a younger mindset in that regard.

babybythesea · 20/05/2022 22:30

Also, to add to a PP about money, yes. That’s the one academic area that they do struggle with more. They can do the maths (Fred has 20p and his sweet costs 17p. How much change will he get?). But they can’t put it into coins. What coins can you use to make 13p? Because they used to know that there were only certain denominations of coins even if they were unsure what those were. Now, they have no clue that you don’t get a 3p piece. They haven’t been shopping and if they have it’s largely done by card. The money lessons have been … interesting!!

gotthis · 20/05/2022 22:27

rooinspace · 20/05/2022 12:13

Yes - we’ve also noticed it with recent university graduates / those that graduated just pre-Covid. It seems a lot of the “growing up” and etiquette learned through working in offices etc. has been missed during covid.

I do think university students were particularly neglected during Covid. Online sessions for a year were less than ideal. I gather there were frequent technical issues, or lectures were just not posted. I imagine looking at a screen with just a few faces visible is a much less stimulating experience than being in a room full of people. Only seeing faces can be very difficult for people who rely on body language and other cues. Plus, as you say, there was no in person work experience. Students struggled with isolating, I believe it was on the news that some accommodation was being guarded by security, and students were stuck in their rooms with no food. Students were told to return to campuses for teaching, pay in advance for accommodation, then found it was entirely online and they would have been better off at home. For all of this they were charged full fees. I do wish more had been done for them.

icecreamcart · 20/05/2022 21:27

@PAFMO tired. Probably depressed. Told to keep everyone safe. Not to please themselves. Disgusting policy.

RobertaFirmino · 20/05/2022 20:58

Children, you say? Immature? Well yes, they generally are...

MrsSkylerWhite · 20/05/2022 20:28

Dixiechickonhols · Today 12:30
They’ve lost 2 years of their lives. If you are only young it’s a huge chunk of your life. Socialising online and zoom instead of in person activities is not the same.

We learn through experiences“.

indeed, though alternatively, they’ve had the time and space to develop at their own pace, without external pressures.

(for children in stable homes, obviously. For those in less secure situations, it will have been God-awful and will have long- lasting consequences)

Dauncets · 20/05/2022 17:40

Most people, parents and teachers, do their best most of the time. Very few people actively want to fuck up anything or anyone. I don't think it's about blame but about realising that all of our kids have been through the mill a bit and trying to help them, while recognising that we ourselves have all been through the mill too and maybe aren't as resourceful and creative in terms of problem solving as we were prior to January 2020.

SleepingStandingUp · 20/05/2022 16:48

PAFMO · 20/05/2022 15:55

I'm a secondary teacher, and yes, mentally and psychologically, most kids are 2 years younger than their age.
It's not as clearcut as the lockdown opponents would like it to be though

Our most troubled kids are:

The numerous girls with eating disorders, every single one an average to good student before lockdown. During lockdown they became excellent students. People helping them with work, copying stuff from other sources, downright blatant cheating, no exams. Now they're back and they're back to being average-good but that's no longer good enough for them and their parents. They are questioning why they were getting top marks in lockdown and not now. And they then turn on their own bodies.

The first year senior school kids who present as 8 year olds. Academically as well as psychologically. Every single fucking Mumsnetter who banged on for weeks about "my child isn't going to log on, we're jumping in puddles and watching Joe Wickes then we're going to bake" needs a long hard look at themselves. And we pick up the pieces and get the grief at the same time.

Our 18 year olds are doing exams and planning on university and getting upset when they're not getting the offers OR the expected grades.

Also agree with pps about a sheer inability to know how to behave in a group setting. It's hard to put your finger on, but petty fighting, tears at every little thing. Odd examples like literally not being able to wait till break for a snack. Our HT has had to issue a letter to parents to say no more coming and collecting them before the end of lessons, I had a class last week late on in the day and 10 kids had been collected early. Why? Tired. They are 17.

It's all quite bizarre.

Would it be fair to assume your kids were able to access school as you were still going out to work? Even if you wrote working from home, seems reasonable to assume that your actual skills in teaching exist and could be utilised somewhat in your own kids.

Unlike people trying to work at home with kids who couldn't access school and don't know how to teach kids, people who didn't work but had other caring responsibilities (I mean home schooling with new born twins was AMAZING!) and again don't know how to teach, people who had to keep their kids locked up longer due to CEV, people who's mental health or who's children's mental health wasn't overly conducive to home schooling.

No you shouldn't get grief for my kid being behind, and collecting a 17 yo early cos they need a nap is ridiculous but most parents tried their hardest to do the best by their kids

Dixiechickonhols · 20/05/2022 16:23

Rainbows leader is giving up (Guides age 5) She’s run group for years and post covid intake are hard work no idea how to take turns, circle time, too adult dependant etc. Group will close as there’s no one else volunteering.

MajorCarolDanvers · 20/05/2022 16:23

TheKeatingFive · 20/05/2022 16:13

DH and I worked full time throughout lockdown with a 5, 4 and 1 year old at home. They mainly sat in front of the TV. Wasn’t much else we could do.

Well quite. Similar situation here. The quality of our school provision was shocking. So yeah, people can fuck right off with the blame game here.

Same here - our schools were dreadful and never did any online teaching or anything interactive at all - all we got were pdf worksheets and some links to youtube videos.

We resorted to documentaries with Bear Grylls and Newsround whilst we were working.

Triffid1 · 20/05/2022 16:22

@PAFMO I don't think anyone was blaming teachers. But you're very quick to blame the parents.

Lockdown was shit. People were stressed and scared. Trying to work and manage children. Trying to suddenly become teachers (for years, teachers have complained that parents don't appreciate their skills and effort but then are all surprised when parents can't magically become brilliant teachers overnight?!).

School provision and online teaching was erratic and inconsistent - I listened to a woman complain because her state-educated year 4 child was "only" getting an hour teaching a day. At that point, my DC had each had ONE half an hour group session with a teacher....).

Even children with relatively stable home environments, opportunity to learn etc, missed out on a LOT of socialising and things that build confidence, resilience and maturity in regular times (eg special assemblies, school performances, school reward schemes, sleepovers, playdates, trips out etc etc).

Many children weren't active and got more overweight.

Our children are going to feel it for a while. They are less likely to be independent. They are definitely less mature and struggle with friendships and other issues.

None of this should be dumped on the parents, most of whom did the best they bloody could.

Dixiechickonhols · 20/05/2022 16:20

It’s developmental stages though. You don’t go from mum taking you everywhere to getting train to a big city in one go. They’ve missed the in between.

TheKeatingFive · 20/05/2022 16:13

DH and I worked full time throughout lockdown with a 5, 4 and 1 year old at home. They mainly sat in front of the TV. Wasn’t much else we could do.

Well quite. Similar situation here. The quality of our school provision was shocking. So yeah, people can fuck right off with the blame game here.

WakeWaterWalk · 20/05/2022 16:12

Getting themselves out and about in a (somewhat) self-organised group and using public transport is part of maturation of teens imo and ime.

Whatalovelydaffodil · 20/05/2022 16:08

Oblomov22 · 20/05/2022 12:32

Definitely. Ds2 compared to ds1 huge. Ds1 had been out partying by this point, Meeting up with friends to play football getting the train to different places to facilitate meeting up and playing football and then going to McDonald's etc.

But, they are starting to. At least.

I am not sure doing those things mean that you are mature!

ReadyToMoveIt · 20/05/2022 16:04

PAFMO · 20/05/2022 15:55

I'm a secondary teacher, and yes, mentally and psychologically, most kids are 2 years younger than their age.
It's not as clearcut as the lockdown opponents would like it to be though

Our most troubled kids are:

The numerous girls with eating disorders, every single one an average to good student before lockdown. During lockdown they became excellent students. People helping them with work, copying stuff from other sources, downright blatant cheating, no exams. Now they're back and they're back to being average-good but that's no longer good enough for them and their parents. They are questioning why they were getting top marks in lockdown and not now. And they then turn on their own bodies.

The first year senior school kids who present as 8 year olds. Academically as well as psychologically. Every single fucking Mumsnetter who banged on for weeks about "my child isn't going to log on, we're jumping in puddles and watching Joe Wickes then we're going to bake" needs a long hard look at themselves. And we pick up the pieces and get the grief at the same time.

Our 18 year olds are doing exams and planning on university and getting upset when they're not getting the offers OR the expected grades.

Also agree with pps about a sheer inability to know how to behave in a group setting. It's hard to put your finger on, but petty fighting, tears at every little thing. Odd examples like literally not being able to wait till break for a snack. Our HT has had to issue a letter to parents to say no more coming and collecting them before the end of lessons, I had a class last week late on in the day and 10 kids had been collected early. Why? Tired. They are 17.

It's all quite bizarre.

I knew it would be all the parents’ fault 😂.
DH and I worked full time throughout lockdown with a 5, 4 and 1 year old at home. They mainly sat in front of the TV. Wasn’t much else we could do.

Swipe left for the next trending thread