Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The cost of childcare make working difficult!

169 replies

Istherehopeforme · 19/05/2022 22:49

Currently work part time and children go to daycare - 80% of my salary goes on this bill
so very little “ take home pay”. I enjoy my work and need to keep my professional registration up so wouldn’t consider not working despite the lack of financial benefit!
An opportunity in my team has come
up to be full time and as much as I think I’d actually not mind working full time the sums just don’t add up- with full
time daycare rates for one toddler and after schools for older child ( plus full daycare rate for one child in summer rather than after school rate) I’d be taking home £350 a month ! Actually slightly worse off than now .
I mentioned this to a friend today in passing that I was disappointed that will realistically be years before I can advance in work and she went off on one about how I knew I’d need daycare when I planned children, it’s just to be expected and accepted and basically shut me down.
I found this rude considering she and her husband earn double what my household does and her child attends a heavily subsidised daycare due to the area they live in.
Aibu I being unreasonable to be upset at how difficult it is being a working parent ?

We use tax free childcare , have no family option to help, there are no childminders in the area with availability currently so can’t reduce the childcare costs. My partner earns more than me so not worth him reducing hours .

OP posts:
user1497787065 · 20/05/2022 08:09

Sorry when I had my children there was no subsidy for childcare from the government/tax payer. That only kicked in when they started school. Either pay for childcare and accept the cost or not work and look after your own children.

I'm so tired of these threads insisting there needs to be greater government funding.

I know this is an unpopular opinion but there are choices.

NerrSnerr · 20/05/2022 08:08

We are very fortunate that my husband works too so even though I only make a few hundred pounds a month now we manage fine.

You need to reframe this. Why would childcare be considered to come out of your wages? It comes out of the whole pot.

AppleandRhubarbTart · 20/05/2022 08:06

Yanbu OP. It's very hard, leads to (usually) women with skills we need being pushed out of the workplace and all stems from a societal choice we simply don't need to make.

And anyone bleating any form of you knew all this when you decided to have kids is invariably being a twat, but especially when their privilege means they don't encounter the worst of it it. Consider getting new friends.

Snoken · 20/05/2022 08:06

brookstar · 20/05/2022 08:00

redsky but the narrative is important.
While it might not make a difference to the overall financial situation of the family it does make a difference to the family dynamic.

Why should the default position that women are responsible for paying for and organising childcare in order to progress their career while her husband carries on without ever having to consider how to judge childcare and a career?

I absolutely agree with this! It is devaluing the womans contribution and achievements when it is spoken about this way. OP herself is saying all those years in uni and this is all I can contribute with after childcare. This is simply untrue and it makes the OP look like she thinks she is a failure when in fact the cost is both of theirs, not just hers. Stuff like that makes women think, why do I even bother working when I don't get financial gain from it, but the in the bigger picture it is so, so important to keep your career going, and look at childcare cost as shared.

redskyatnight · 20/05/2022 08:06

brookstar · 20/05/2022 08:00

redsky but the narrative is important.
While it might not make a difference to the overall financial situation of the family it does make a difference to the family dynamic.

Why should the default position that women are responsible for paying for and organising childcare in order to progress their career while her husband carries on without ever having to consider how to judge childcare and a career?

I didn't mention women in my post. I mentioned a calculation against the salary of the "lower earning parent". Why have you assumed that the default position is that this is the woman? As you have equally assumed that OP organises childcare, which is not something she mentions.

Fizbosshoes · 20/05/2022 08:05

I heard a report on the news this morning that the government are mooting the idea of the childcare ratio becoming 1:5 for 2 year olds, in England, in line with Scotland. (Its currently 1:4)

I think the purpose was to make childcare more affordable (I didn't hear the first part of the report) although I feel that puts the onus on nursery staff rather than the government themselves.

Pandarinio · 20/05/2022 08:04

brookstar · 20/05/2022 08:00

redsky but the narrative is important.
While it might not make a difference to the overall financial situation of the family it does make a difference to the family dynamic.

Why should the default position that women are responsible for paying for and organising childcare in order to progress their career while her husband carries on without ever having to consider how to judge childcare and a career?

I agree it is important and says a lot about how a woman's work is viewed compared to a man's.

Pandarinio · 20/05/2022 08:03

BananaShrimp · 20/05/2022 08:02

And to OP: Yes childcare is expensive and it sucks. There are millions of families where one parent (usually the mum) can’t afford to work for five years. The ones who are really fucked are low earning women with high earning partners. Because they don’t earn enough to offset the cost of childcare but they can’t get any support because their partner earns too much. Then he buggers off and leaves her, so it’s a double whammy of losing that time at work then losing his salary too.

Or he might die.

Anyway I agree. It is important, even if it does all come out of one shared pot.

riotlady · 20/05/2022 08:02

BananaShrimp · 20/05/2022 07:52

Are people really so stupid that they can’t understand how the cost of childcare is weighed against the cost of mum not working and staying at home to do the childcare herself? Fuck off with your “it’s a joint expense” stupidity. You’re just being facetious. Families have to work out their finances as a whole, not as individuals. The family pot is only £350 better off if OP works, and that’s the same no matter whether you regard childcare as a sole or joint expense.

This! So bloody tedious to see all these smug little posts of “it’s a joint expense”. Of course it is, but if you’re weighing it up against the other most common viable alternative (lower earning parent stays home) then OBVIOUSLY it makes sense to weigh up that persons wage vs the cost of childcare.

BananaShrimp · 20/05/2022 08:02

And to OP: Yes childcare is expensive and it sucks. There are millions of families where one parent (usually the mum) can’t afford to work for five years. The ones who are really fucked are low earning women with high earning partners. Because they don’t earn enough to offset the cost of childcare but they can’t get any support because their partner earns too much. Then he buggers off and leaves her, so it’s a double whammy of losing that time at work then losing his salary too.

brookstar · 20/05/2022 08:00

redsky but the narrative is important.
While it might not make a difference to the overall financial situation of the family it does make a difference to the family dynamic.

Why should the default position that women are responsible for paying for and organising childcare in order to progress their career while her husband carries on without ever having to consider how to judge childcare and a career?

lemon88 · 20/05/2022 07:59

Waxonwaxoff0 · 20/05/2022 07:48

It's roughly about £1k a month usually, not £1.5k.

And yes, impossible if you have 2, but 30 hours free childcare kicks in at 3 years old so that would be a very temporary thing. Once the nursery years are over, the woman on £40k is much better off than the woman on minumum wage, so they're not "screwed." It's just a painful temporary expense.

1.5k here in the south east

Lazerbeen · 20/05/2022 07:57

Yes childcare settings should receive more support from the government so they are more affordable and not at the expense of making staff pay even more dire (although they're mainly on min wage anyway so not sure how that's possible). But as no matter what way you swing it, it disproportionately affects women negatively it'll never change.

RancidOldHag · 20/05/2022 07:57

only 80%?

Yes, I mean 'only'

Our net household income did not increase for the first three years of my returning to work (and this was over 15 years ago)

Maybe the costs haven't risen as sharply in relation to earnings as I thought they had.

And yes you do need to see it as a household expense, not something that is 'your' cost

That might mean your household net income has only risen a bit (or, as for us, did not rise at all). But the family have also bought greater financial security (no longer the risks of having only one earner), better prospects for 3-5 years time, and considerably better long term prospects for the adults if pensions savings are also augmented.

You might have a point if you had both suspended pensions contributions and the household was still working at a loss - something major has to give.

But you're seeing an increase, and that is a good thing on top of the other plusses.

Pandarinio · 20/05/2022 07:57

What if your husband wasn't in the picture, would you wish you'd worked full time then? I'd do whatever it took to make you happy careerwise.

forinborin · 20/05/2022 07:56

It's roughly about £1k a month usually, not £1.5k.
Where? In London I couldn't find anything cheaper than £1.8K a few years ago, and I was even prepared to move for a cheaper nursery (as I had two with one year gap, so at the same time). Even breakfast/ afterschool club is north of £500 for one now, for two it is like a second mortgage.

redskyatnight · 20/05/2022 07:54

user1494050295 · 20/05/2022 07:37

Can we please change the narrative on this. It’s a joint expense. Yawn

So tedious when people keep saying this.

That's only relevant if the family have separate finances. If they pay all bills from a single pot it makes not a jot of difference to the overall amount that the family have left over.

It's reasonable to calculate the amount that the lower earner will have left after "paying" childcare because this gives a notional comparison on how much better the family will be better off if the lower earning parent does not work. Which is why most people say something like what the OP did.

OP should also remember that she needs to calculate other things such as pension when doing her "is it worth it" calculation.

If there is financial abuse in the relationship, that's a whole other issue, and will not be resolved by suddenly announcing that childcare is a joint expense.

BananaShrimp · 20/05/2022 07:52

Are people really so stupid that they can’t understand how the cost of childcare is weighed against the cost of mum not working and staying at home to do the childcare herself? Fuck off with your “it’s a joint expense” stupidity. You’re just being facetious. Families have to work out their finances as a whole, not as individuals. The family pot is only £350 better off if OP works, and that’s the same no matter whether you regard childcare as a sole or joint expense.

Reigateforever · 20/05/2022 07:51

You shouldn’t have the full childcare cost coming out of your wage but to be paid proportionally by both yours and your partner wages, they are fifty per cent his after all. This will enable you to advance in the workplace and have a a good pension. You just have to grit your teeth for the next few years for the benefit in the future.

DillyDilly · 20/05/2022 07:49

But it’s not just you that is paying for childcare, surely your DH should pay for 50%?

Waxonwaxoff0 · 20/05/2022 07:48

forinborin · 20/05/2022 07:42

I took an example of one child of toddler age going to nursery. Will be completely impossible if you add another one.

It's roughly about £1k a month usually, not £1.5k.

And yes, impossible if you have 2, but 30 hours free childcare kicks in at 3 years old so that would be a very temporary thing. Once the nursery years are over, the woman on £40k is much better off than the woman on minumum wage, so they're not "screwed." It's just a painful temporary expense.

brookstar · 20/05/2022 07:44

Well how does your husband currently afford childcare for his full time job?

Excellent question.

forinborin · 20/05/2022 07:42

Waxonwaxoff0 · 20/05/2022 07:39

I don't know anywhere that childcare is £1.5k.

I took an example of one child of toddler age going to nursery. Will be completely impossible if you add another one.

Applegreenb · 20/05/2022 07:40

I agree with @Tamzo85 people should only have children if they can afford to have them. Screw people with lower wages they shouldn’t be having children at all. It should most definitely be a class system, middle and upper class only and anyone in a lower class be a subservient to the higher classes and their children.

Why stop there let’s take is further, you should only have children if you want stay at home with them while your DH goes to works and provides, therefore no nursery’s are needed for little Fred and Charlotte.

If you end up being a single parent or DH loses his job and can’t afford your life style your children should be taken away and given to an upper class couple or can’t have their own children.

Or maybe just maybe @Tamzo85 you should move to the USA they seem to be heading into more of a hand maids tale situation, you might find it agrees better with your beliefs

Waxonwaxoff0 · 20/05/2022 07:39

forinborin · 20/05/2022 07:34

No. Paying 1.5K out of 2.5K (40K net) leaves you with less than £225 out of £1400 (min wage).

I don't know anywhere that childcare is £1.5k.

Swipe left for the next trending thread