Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you had heard the news re dwp are to be given powers of arrest?

61 replies

Graphista · 19/05/2022 22:34

Popped up in my Facebook feed, shocked to see it being widely reported in regional newspapers yet I cannot find any mention of it on bbc news anywhere and I can't see it being widely reported in national media

I think this is absolutely appalling! They aren't police officers they don't have anything like the training or understanding of the law.

I find this deeply worrying that people with such a vested interest in the outcome of such actions will be allowed such hugely damaging powers - not just of arrest but to give search warrants etc too

What the Hell! We are no longer sleep walking into a "police state" we are now living in one!

I for one will be contacting my Mp tomorrow about this I am so disgusted and horrified by this.

This is literally criminalising the poorest and least able to defend themselves in our society

OP posts:
AlternativePerspective · 20/05/2022 09:31

Benefit fraud is a thing though. And “they should go after those who don’t pay tax first” isn’t a get-out.

Of course they should go after those who don’t pay tax, but crime is crime.

orwellwasright · 20/05/2022 09:23

Their fanbase will love it. It's a vote winner for sure. Might not get passed the Lords though. They tend to be a bit less fascist.

Farahilda · 20/05/2022 09:19

Well it looks like they're setting up a specialist investigative department, modelled on HMRC investigations branch

I'm mildly surprised there isn't one already

I don't see how it's an assault on human rights, as there is no 'right to commit a crime and get away with it'

Whoever arrests those suspected of crime (ie whether they can in certain cases have those in the investigations branch do it, like HMRC, or if they have to call in a police officer) the prosecution process that follows would be the same

Brieandcamembert · 20/05/2022 09:10

Of course we should reduce benefit fraud. You should only ever be on benefits for the shortest time possible and only if you absolutely cannot work. It's a last resort safety net. Too many people claim to be unfit for work but really could.

Benefits should be there for the absolute sickest and most disabled unquestionably. Short term to top up wages yes but only if you aren't knowingly making your situation worse e.g. having more kids.

Turquoisellama · 20/05/2022 09:03

I wonder whether the next piece of news will be that they will be contracting out this new work to their pals (and getting a cut of the profits).

Turquoisellama · 20/05/2022 09:01

It'll also be a way round having to prove fraud on the balance of probabilities, in front of an actual judge. Yet again, they want to undermine the legal system and bypass the legal process.

Cantfollowmeround · 20/05/2022 01:16

They dont care that it's against human rights because them losing so much money and not having as much to go to people who need it trumps that. I still disagree though because I wouldnt want people looking through bank accounts and transactions and people deserve to have treats. Being on benefits shouldn't be a punishment and a life of misery. Most of the time it's not even enough to live on and they set you up to fail.

Gingerkittykat · 20/05/2022 01:01

That's terrifying.

When I split up from my abusive ex he accused me of tax credit fraud, it was hard enough waiting for 12 weeks to get my claim reinstated but if the DWP had powers of arrest and to come into my home it would have been a lot worse.

Gingerkittykat · 20/05/2022 00:47

elizabethdraper · 19/05/2022 23:29

www.rte.ie/news/ireland/2020/0630/1150548-cab-arrests/

All of these criminals claim the dole and live in pimped out council houses

The last arrest i seen, there was over 2k worth of after shave confiscated

The article doesn't mention benefit fraud or council houses at all and is also Irish. It looks like these people were committing a huge scale money laundering operation and not benefit fraud.

Sortilege · 19/05/2022 23:39

I don’t know what they do in Ireland, but in the UK, that’s not the average profile of an interviewee under caution at the DWP office.

carefullycourageous · 19/05/2022 23:35

Graphista · 19/05/2022 23:06

@carefullycourageous the callousness is on a whole other scale to even previous Tory govts isn't it?

Yeah, it is grim to watch. I used to think you could vote Tory as a decent human, but surely you have to be a nasty bastard to vote for this lot.

Sortilege · 19/05/2022 23:31

There are already civil penalties though, or administrative penalties (adpen) as they call them, which is to pay it all back plus 30% on top. What are they going to institute instead? Stocks and rotten tomatoes?

Bearing in mind the people who do commit benefit fraud are usually desperate, coerced or just chaotic, and mostly very poor. What do we need other than the existing options of adpens and criminal proceedings? It sounds like an excuse to scare people with an arrest and intimidate them into accepting a harsh civil penalty, whether they’re guilty or not. People should at least get due process if arrested. Civil penalties are for civil proceedings.

elizabethdraper · 19/05/2022 23:29

www.rte.ie/news/ireland/2020/0630/1150548-cab-arrests/

All of these criminals claim the dole and live in pimped out council houses

The last arrest i seen, there was over 2k worth of after shave confiscated

Turquoisellama · 19/05/2022 23:26

They are introducing civil penalties so that people who commit fraud are punished - but fraud is a crime, so they're going to find an easier way to go after people than to use the criminal system. They will need far less evidence under a civil system. I think they will be aiming to drive a lot of people out of the benefits system, though fear. People who qualify for benefits. Not to save money really, just because of ideology and hatred and disdain of people who are not like them.

elizabethdraper · 19/05/2022 23:24

www.cab.ie/

Works pretty well in Ireland

Userxxxxx · 19/05/2022 23:20

What an insult to people who suffered employers knowingly committing furlough fraud and who will have gotten away with it, HMRC didn't exactly give me any confidence as 1 of a number in the workplace affected, they practically said here's to waiting many, many years for the employer to be brought to task.

In 2013 there was a company endorsed by the job centre that a bunch of us did a week's full-time work trial through with none other with a JCP+ knowing - did we get paid, hell no, we were sent to the job centre to sign on though if it was our time and quite encouraged clearly to keep benefits over a wage for the period! The company involved never parted with an actual penny. Ugh, what next.

ObjectionHearsay · 19/05/2022 23:19

All you have to do is hide money in your PayPal account apparently, so I've been told by a few.

So if you are claiming UC and making the odd quid on the side doing "whatever" you hide the proceeds in your PayPal account which the DWP can not access.

People have been doing this for years now.

But I digress, I don't think the DWP should have any more powers than they already have. They've ruined enough lives and sadly been the reason some people have sadly passed away.

Sortilege · 19/05/2022 23:16

I agree @Graphista - they will profile people, they will get sued for it, their travels will pick up overpayments that THEY have caused and then they will get all excited “plastic policeman” and arrest people for being victims of official error…Sooner or later somebody’s will die because benefits are being suspended in an excitable manner.

It has disaster written all over it.

Sortilege · 19/05/2022 23:11

2thumbs · 19/05/2022 22:40

You do realise that, for example, HMRC currently have arrest powers?

Have you seen HMRC staff versus DWP staff?

Have you compared the average benefit fraud amount to the average tax evasion figure?

The DWP make enough erroneous accusations as it is, (as well as overpaying much more than is defrauded), and these plans also allow them to trawl data sets to identify suspects, which is a dramatic new move. There had better be a plan to massively improve training.

This is a charter for Audrey to go full Minority Report.

Graphista · 19/05/2022 23:06

@carefullycourageous the callousness is on a whole other scale to even previous Tory govts isn't it?

OP posts:
Graphista · 19/05/2022 23:06

Or they want the rights to look at pretty much anyones bank accounts and expenditure.

They may start with certain "types" of claimants but such laws if passed would open the gates to wide ranging oversight of our personal and private data.

For those thinking "I work I don't claim benefits" bear in mind that as far as this govt is concerned ANYONE who gets ANY kind of state help is a scrounger and must prove they are the deserving poor and not the undeserving poor.

This would include everyone who claims child benefit, childcare help etc

So if you think this won't affect you think again.

Very very few people and families are doing so well these days that they receive no help at all ever. Plus you never know what's around the corner.

OP posts:
carefullycourageous · 19/05/2022 23:03

This government is truly disgusting, they are corrupt and cruel.

Graphista · 19/05/2022 23:02

It was first I saw it on Facebook but I have followed up since and seen it is being reported in various reputable regional papers plus on the gov website here

https://www.gov.uk/government/news/new-benefit-counter-fraud-plan-set-to-save-taxpayer-2-billion

including the right to look at your bank account without telling you.

And it would appear without having to actually specify who's bank accounts they seem to be getting rights to look at anyone and everyone's with very little in the way of cause

And I totally agree I am sick to death of the poor being targeted for supposed minimising of fraud reasons but not the huge corporations and dodgy wealthy individuals!

This is utterly unconscionable

OP posts:
flirtygirl · 19/05/2022 22:53

The government own link above says benefit fraud is at low levels but of course they will do this instead of looking at tax fraud, government tender fraud, Mp expenses fraud etc

Crunchymum · 19/05/2022 22:53

Another misdirection. Sigh.
Another strike against the poor. Sigh.