Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed the boys ‘won’t play with girls’

184 replies

Leopardpj · 19/05/2022 22:28

DD is 4 and in reception. She tells me a lot of the boys in her class say they don’t ever want to play with her as they only want to play with boys. I don’t think she is lacking in friends but I think she is confused about it and is wondering what’s so bad about being a girl and it’s this that is bothering me. I don’t want her feeling it’s uncool or a negative thing to be a girl which I think is an impression she is starting to get. I feel as if this wouldn’t be tolerated if it was a comment being made about children from a religious or ethnic group etc and am wondering about asking the teacher whether she could keep an ear out for this sort of talk and try and nip it in the bud? Or perhaps that’s OTT and I am being unreasonable to think you can stop boys from saying/ feeling like this (I only have DDs so no experience with boys!) thanks in advance !

OP posts:
AllThingsServeTheBeam · 20/05/2022 13:40

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 20/05/2022 12:51

They also hopefully understand that the rules and laws around employment have very little to do with what’s allowed in your social group.

I can’t and don’t discriminate against Jeremy Corbyn supporters in the workplace but by God I’d not be happy if I was told we had to have one along when I go out for a nice meal.

I feel the same way about Tories

PleaseYourselfandEatTheCrusts · 20/05/2022 13:33

My son's school seem to be really hot on this and boys and girls play together fine. They are in year 3

I don't really understand why any school wouldn't tackle sexism the same way they would if it was racism. I don't understand why any parent wouldn't want to stamp it out either.

SleepingStandingUp · 20/05/2022 13:22

@SlightlyGeordieJohn No-one’s mentioned gendered toys or games though

It’s natural and healthy for the genders to gravitate toward each other in the playground and want to do boy and girl things

What's wrong with preferring to play with boys? This usually means the girl in question likes football, and chase and climbing trees, and more physical activities. The only way to get that sort of fun at an average primary is to play with the boys

He started school in September and immediately we got "boys and girls aren't friends"; "boys can't play with girls"; "I don't like X because that's for girls"

but there are no boys in her ballet class and no other girls in her preschool football class

I was engaging in the wider conversation rather than just the OP

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 20/05/2022 13:11

SleepingStandingUp · 20/05/2022 13:03

Do you think it’s fine the other way round though? Should a group of girls be forced to include boys in everything they do, even if they don’t want to? No one is saying everything but I don't see why girls should be allowed to say no boys but boys can't say no girls. If Tommy wants to play dolls he shouldn't be barred by girls because he's a boy just like Lydia shouldn't be kicked out of Dino club.

As they get older and their biological differences become apparent it's different - of course Jed shouldn't have to be included in the girls wrestling team and Lola shouldn't have to invite him to her sleepover.

No-one’s mentioned gendered toys or games though, just that one group of friends is single-sex.

These are two very different things. If my child told me that football was for boys I’d tell him why he was wrong, but if his closest friends were boys then there’s nothing wrong with that.

slashlover · 20/05/2022 13:11

What's wrong with preferring to play with boys? This usually means the girl in question likes football, and chase and climbing trees, and more physical activities. The only way to get that sort of fun at an average primary is to play with the boys.

Really?

SleepingStandingUp · 20/05/2022 13:05

Tamzo85 · 20/05/2022 12:54

It’s natural and healthy for the genders to gravitate toward each other in the playground and want to do boy and girl things.

It would be more harmful to force them together when they don’t want to be and that will only breed resentment.

How much actual gender difference is there at 4 tho? And surely reinforcing that certain activities are gendered one way or the other isn't great. What does that telly Eliot about his gender if he really wants to play dolls, or Lucy about hers if she's desperate to play dinosaurs?

SleepingStandingUp · 20/05/2022 13:03

Do you think it’s fine the other way round though? Should a group of girls be forced to include boys in everything they do, even if they don’t want to? No one is saying everything but I don't see why girls should be allowed to say no boys but boys can't say no girls. If Tommy wants to play dolls he shouldn't be barred by girls because he's a boy just like Lydia shouldn't be kicked out of Dino club.

As they get older and their biological differences become apparent it's different - of course Jed shouldn't have to be included in the girls wrestling team and Lola shouldn't have to invite him to her sleepover.

2Rebecca · 20/05/2022 12:59

Adults choose their friends and who they spend time with, children should be able to do the same unless 1 person is being excluded by everyone.

Tamzo85 · 20/05/2022 12:54

It’s natural and healthy for the genders to gravitate toward each other in the playground and want to do boy and girl things.

It would be more harmful to force them together when they don’t want to be and that will only breed resentment.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 20/05/2022 12:51

SoupDragon · 20/05/2022 12:44

as soon as kids leave school and join the real world they are expected to suddenly just switch and completely get that they can't say 'I don't want Jane in my team at work, it's a boys team, and I don't want it spoiled by a woman who will be getting all emotional and changing the dynamic'.

They learn it along the way between 4 year's old and when they start work. Obviously. 🙄

They also hopefully understand that the rules and laws around employment have very little to do with what’s allowed in your social group.

I can’t and don’t discriminate against Jeremy Corbyn supporters in the workplace but by God I’d not be happy if I was told we had to have one along when I go out for a nice meal.

x2boys · 20/05/2022 12:49

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 20/05/2022 12:40

I'd be speaking to the school. Both wexes need to learn that it's not acceptable to exclude other people or treat them differently on the basis of their sex alone.

I am shocked that people on here think it's ok though school and kids can do this infront of parents and teachers, but as soon as kids leave school and join the real world they are expected to suddenly just switch and completely get that they can't say 'I don't want Jane in my team at work, it's a boys team, and I don't want it spoiled by a woman who will be getting all emotional and changing the dynamic'.

If we want adults to treat others as equals, we need to start teaching them when they are kids, surely?

You do realise that there is a big difference between four year old and ,16-18 year old?

Cyw2018 · 20/05/2022 12:47

My DD is 4 and says she won't play with/doesn't like daddy because he is a boy and that he should play with the dog (male) and I should play with her. She is also going through a very pink faze.

My understanding from friends is that this is all quite common at this age, and I assume it is just a normal developmental schema, and DD is working out her identity, and how she differs from others.

Obviously as soon as daddy suggests doing something fun, all is forgotten!!

x2boys · 20/05/2022 12:46

Imaginary · 20/05/2022 12:10

In my experience it's always boys who don't want to "play with girls", not the other way around, because girls are seen as "less than".

What a load of crap ,I remember not wanting to play with boys when I was that age it works both ways .

SoupDragon · 20/05/2022 12:44

as soon as kids leave school and join the real world they are expected to suddenly just switch and completely get that they can't say 'I don't want Jane in my team at work, it's a boys team, and I don't want it spoiled by a woman who will be getting all emotional and changing the dynamic'.

They learn it along the way between 4 year's old and when they start work. Obviously. 🙄

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 20/05/2022 12:44

Stompythedinosaur · 20/05/2022 12:39

I totally agree with this.

People who think it is OK for a little girl to be excluded on the basis of her gender need to have a think about how they absorbed such a sexist viewpoint.

I would raise this with the school.

Would we also accept kids not wanting to play with someone because of their religion, because they were black, because their family didn't have much money? Why is gender different?

Do you think it’s fine the other way round though? Should a group of girls be forced to include boys in everything they do, even if they don’t want to?

I’d find that to be very problematic. It’s one thing to encourage mixing, but completely different to force any single-sex group to have to include the opposite sex.

MangyInseam · 20/05/2022 12:42

TempsPerdu · 20/05/2022 10:30

My experience was that up to about age 5 boys and girls happily play with everyone, then there's a patch where they become very aware of sex and girls play mainly play with girls and boys with boys, then after a couple of years they go back to playing with everyone. A developmental stage rather than something to fix

This is what I’d expected to see as a parent too, and what I’d experienced when teaching Early Years/KS1 up until a few years ago. But with my own DD and her peers the sex separation phase seems to have arrived much earlier - I noticed it creeping in soon after DD started nursery at 2.

All the preschool activities seem extremely gendered too - DD does both ballet and football, but there are no boys in her ballet class and no other girls in her preschool football class (despite it being specifically for 3-5 year olds, and having several female coaches) Our music class, which she’s attended since she was about 18 months, started off pretty equal, but all the boys gradually dropped out and now there’s only one boy to about ten girls in the group. And at this stage I’m sure it’s mostly parental influence rather than the children already expressing a strong preference for specific activities.

I think you are largely right about parental influence, but I have noticed something similar with relation to kid's music classes and I think it's a different issue. Similarly, a lot of the boys seem to have a harder time sitting still and fcusing at the same age as the girls - I think their fine motor coordination seems to be behind as well. Which is to say, I suspect it reflects differences in the average developmental curve in that age group, and the classes grouped by age are set more towards what is appropriate for the average girl. So more often the music classes aren't a great fit for the young boy students.

I have wondered if this may also be a factor with some other activities, though maybe less obviously.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 20/05/2022 12:41

*sexes

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 20/05/2022 12:40

I'd be speaking to the school. Both wexes need to learn that it's not acceptable to exclude other people or treat them differently on the basis of their sex alone.

I am shocked that people on here think it's ok though school and kids can do this infront of parents and teachers, but as soon as kids leave school and join the real world they are expected to suddenly just switch and completely get that they can't say 'I don't want Jane in my team at work, it's a boys team, and I don't want it spoiled by a woman who will be getting all emotional and changing the dynamic'.

If we want adults to treat others as equals, we need to start teaching them when they are kids, surely?

Stompythedinosaur · 20/05/2022 12:39

Imaginary · 20/05/2022 12:08

Surprised that so many people think this is fine.
I think it's misogynistic, and these boys are absorbing that culture from a young age. It's not ok.

I totally agree with this.

People who think it is OK for a little girl to be excluded on the basis of her gender need to have a think about how they absorbed such a sexist viewpoint.

I would raise this with the school.

Would we also accept kids not wanting to play with someone because of their religion, because they were black, because their family didn't have much money? Why is gender different?

prettyteapotsplease · 20/05/2022 12:37

I remember this at school - boys wouldn't play with girls because 'they're soppy' and girls wouldn't play with boys because 'they're too rough'. 'Twas ever thus.

PeekAtYou · 20/05/2022 12:37

It works both ways. Girls tend towards girls and boys tend towards boys. Children see adults do this too- mums's friends are generally female and dad's friends are generally male so it is unreasonable to expect our kids to buck this trend.

I'm not promoting gender stereotypes with that comment. I remember girls having a lunchtime slot for football when my dd was at primary about 10 years ago presumably because a mixed game is more likely to end in boys dominating and girls unable to enjoy a good time.

Based on my kids playground stories, there's often a mixed sex chasing game going on and in infants the girls and boys are equally matched for that sort of game so it works well.

While I agree that older siblings can influence younger ones, primary school is very sexist ime. I've heard comments like "Boys don't like writing" or "Girls don't like maths" which is problematic. These were made at parents evening with my child sat there so I can only imagine what it's like hearing it regularly year after year.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 20/05/2022 12:36

SleepingStandingUp · 20/05/2022 12:29

I have a group of close female friends but I also have close male friends. Having a group that's single sex isn't the same as saying "I don't talk to men because they're stinky". This isn't about a group of boys wanting to play boys only for one afternoon, it's about ingraining the "boys all do this and girls all do that. Boys all play with this and girls all play with that" ink little children who will take it to heart.

No one needs to be told off or get in trouble, but I do think schools should do what they can to make sure the girls get a chance to play with the dinosaurs and to feel like that's OK, and the boys can play in the doll house and feel like that's OK. And of course parents should too, but all parents know the true God's in our kids life are TEACHERS

But there was none of that mentioned in the OP. No suggestion that there were gendered toys, or activities, it was only said that some of the children wanted to play only with others of the same sex.

MangyInseam · 20/05/2022 12:34

It's totally normal. Kids at that age think about categories in a really different way, it doesn't reflect the way they will think as grown ups. It's quite common for kids in this age group to gravitate more towards single sex groups. They also will sometimes give reasons that don't especially reflect the real reason (they might just prefer to play with a particular kid, someone else being a girl seems like a plausible reason not to include her.) That kind of after the fact justification is really common in that age group and is cognitivly normal development.

SoupDragon · 20/05/2022 12:33

Imaginary · 20/05/2022 12:10

In my experience it's always boys who don't want to "play with girls", not the other way around, because girls are seen as "less than".

In my experience, this is nonsense.

SleepingStandingUp · 20/05/2022 12:29

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 20/05/2022 11:46

Are any of those saying something should be done willing to admit having a group of close friends now who are all one sex?

I’d find it amazing if the people saying it’s wrong always make a point of ensuring there’s a man in the group when they go out with female friends (or vice-versa.)

I have a group of close female friends but I also have close male friends. Having a group that's single sex isn't the same as saying "I don't talk to men because they're stinky". This isn't about a group of boys wanting to play boys only for one afternoon, it's about ingraining the "boys all do this and girls all do that. Boys all play with this and girls all play with that" ink little children who will take it to heart.

No one needs to be told off or get in trouble, but I do think schools should do what they can to make sure the girls get a chance to play with the dinosaurs and to feel like that's OK, and the boys can play in the doll house and feel like that's OK. And of course parents should too, but all parents know the true God's in our kids life are TEACHERS

Swipe left for the next trending thread