Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed the boys ‘won’t play with girls’

184 replies

Leopardpj · 19/05/2022 22:28

DD is 4 and in reception. She tells me a lot of the boys in her class say they don’t ever want to play with her as they only want to play with boys. I don’t think she is lacking in friends but I think she is confused about it and is wondering what’s so bad about being a girl and it’s this that is bothering me. I don’t want her feeling it’s uncool or a negative thing to be a girl which I think is an impression she is starting to get. I feel as if this wouldn’t be tolerated if it was a comment being made about children from a religious or ethnic group etc and am wondering about asking the teacher whether she could keep an ear out for this sort of talk and try and nip it in the bud? Or perhaps that’s OTT and I am being unreasonable to think you can stop boys from saying/ feeling like this (I only have DDs so no experience with boys!) thanks in advance !

OP posts:
Tamzo85 · 20/05/2022 16:51

TempsPerdu · 20/05/2022 16:41

@shewasa99 Yes - but what constitutes ‘bossy’? IME the kind of assertive behaviour that is described as ‘bossy’ in girls is seen as strength or good leadership when applied to boys - part of the ‘boys will be boys’ thing.

And I’ve seldom heard boys described as bossy anyway - as I said upthread, it’s very much a gendered insult.

@TempsPerdu

Bossy is the kid who comes in and takes over activities and tries to organise other kids when they don’t want it. And continuously wants to be in charge even though it annoys other children. It is never seen as “leadership” in boys or “boys will be boys” - that’s just something those who actually are bossy or don’t want to see that their kid is (usually because they are too) say because they can’t jive with accepting people find their controlling ways obnoxious.

And so they blame sexism, and try to act like if the kid (or them) in question was a boy bossing people around that would be great leadership - when in fact the kid doing it is just bossy, because if there were actually kids happy with them being”the leader” no one would have a problem and they wouldn’t be getting called bossy.

There is no such thing as “good leadership” with small children if some of them aren’t happy with other kids forcing their “leadership” on them. It’s just bossiness.

Perhaps it’s more recognised in girls because the potential for fights amongst the boys is kind of an equaliser in that respect that ensures it doesn’t get to far out of control.

Palease · 20/05/2022 16:50

My little boy started nursery at 2 and a half and after a few months I noticed all of the children he mentioned most (his friends) were blonde haired boys, like him. Maybe children just like those that look similar to them?

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 20/05/2022 16:45

purpleboy · 20/05/2022 16:35

You assumed, rather than knew, and that assumption was based on prejudice. I know that my little boys will face prejudice like yours as they go through life, but that doesn’t mean I have to happily accept it.

A correct assumption it would seem, and I wonder why that is? Could it be because as a female I have faced decades of sexism so I can recognize it pretty quickly, or it could be that your general tone is a dismissive superior one that aligns quite often with male attitudes through male socialization that all started with boys subtly being shown and told they are better and more important than girls.

Do you not see the irony in such a sexist post?

No, actually, you probably don’t.

TempsPerdu · 20/05/2022 16:41

@shewasa99 Yes - but what constitutes ‘bossy’? IME the kind of assertive behaviour that is described as ‘bossy’ in girls is seen as strength or good leadership when applied to boys - part of the ‘boys will be boys’ thing.

And I’ve seldom heard boys described as bossy anyway - as I said upthread, it’s very much a gendered insult.

Tamzo85 · 20/05/2022 16:41

TempsPerdu · 20/05/2022 15:58

@MangyInseam

That’s an interesting perspective on the music class thing, and I think there may be some truth to it. I have, though, also noticed that the few boys remaining (in that class and other, more stereotypically ‘girly’ activities that we do) are almost always South or East Asian in background - could be coincidence, or could be to do with differing cultural ideas around masculinity, perhaps?

I also know a fair few preschool aged boys who have started football classes, strongly disliked them, were given a few ‘months off’ and were then restarted on the classes by their parents, who couldn’t accept that their sons just might not like football, or might prefer a different activity!

@TempsPerdu

It seems like a lot of boys pick music back up later when they are inspired by something to do so, then they get a guitar or whatever. Perhaps the fact basically all childrens musicals are catered to girls has something to do with this, also a lot of music teachers for younger children seem to be women.

Obviously there are still a lot of adult male musicians and a lot of teenage boys doing music in their own way. But whatever is happening in primary schools it’s pretty clear it isn’t engaging the boys.

But then again perhaps boys just are inclined to become more interested in music at closer to teenage age and girls earlier? That is often how it appears in my experience.

purpleboy · 20/05/2022 16:37

TempsPerdu · 20/05/2022 15:50

Oh ffs it's not sexism it's a perfectly normal developmental process. It's how kids develop their own sense of identity and self

I’m very much with @Beamur and @Stompythedinosaur on this. No, what was specifically described in the OP isn’t sexist, and children opting to play mainly in single sex groups isn’t an issue per se. Teachers shouldn’t be in the business of policing who should be playing with whom, unless it is directly impacting on the well-being of one or more of the children.

But I think what I and some other posters are recognising is the way that this gendered play can feed into early socialisation and the perpetuation of gender stereotypes, and this is an area where teachers and early years practitioners can wield some influence. This stuff - the idea that boys taking up more space is the natural order of things; the assumption that girls shouldn’t like dinosaurs or football, or that boys can’t do art or ballet - develops via parental and societal influence from a very early age, and schools and early years settings can often end up perpetuating stereotypes unless they’re very alert to how young children are being influenced by their environment and peer interactions.

Boys shouldn’t be returning from school and describing girls en masse as ‘bossy’ or ‘chatterboxes’ (‘bossy’, in particular, is a deeply gendered term). Girls shouldn’t be describing boys are a group as ‘naughty’ or ‘yucky’. No one group should be allowed to use space at the exclusion of others (at every single school I’ve worked at football-playing boys dominated the playground unless there was a designated no-ball or girls’ football zone).

And there are value judgements attached to these ideas. Never, throughout many years of KS1 parents’ consultations, did I come across a parent who was concerned that their daughter enjoyed football or construction play. However, I did have several who asked me to discourage their sons from using the art, role play or even Lego area because (and one father did actually use these terms), they were concerned their son were ‘too effeminate’ and not engaging with ‘proper outdoor rough and tumble’ with the other boys.

It’s a tricky one for schools and nurseries to recognise and tackle, because societal influences can be subtle and insidious, and gender stereotypes are still so deeply embedded in our culture (I’d actually argue that in many ways we’re going backwards in this regard). Just the other day a friend was telling me how her 3-year-old Encanto-loving daughter now refuses to sing along to ‘Surface Pressure’ because ‘Luisa is too strong for a girl and her muscles are too big’. Schools shouldn’t try to police friendships, but they should ensure that all children have equal access to a range of play opportunities, space is shared equally between the sexes and negative gendered language, however subtle, is discouraged as much as possible.

Great post, I feel there is a poster on here who could learn a lot from reading and thinking critically about this subject rather than just ignorantly dismissing it and remaining ignorant.

purpleboy · 20/05/2022 16:35

You assumed, rather than knew, and that assumption was based on prejudice. I know that my little boys will face prejudice like yours as they go through life, but that doesn’t mean I have to happily accept it.

A correct assumption it would seem, and I wonder why that is? Could it be because as a female I have faced decades of sexism so I can recognize it pretty quickly, or it could be that your general tone is a dismissive superior one that aligns quite often with male attitudes through male socialization that all started with boys subtly being shown and told they are better and more important than girls.

shewasa99 · 20/05/2022 16:17

TempsPerdu

Boys shouldn’t be returning from school and describing girls en masse as ‘bossy’ or ‘chatterboxes’ (‘bossy’, in particular, is a deeply gendered term). Girls shouldn’t be describing boys are a group as ‘naughty’ or ‘yucky’.

Agreed and perhaps those girls and boys who are bossy should stop being bossy, particularly at play time.

Beamur · 20/05/2022 16:10

TempsPerdu
Thank you for your post. That's expressing my feelings on this subject too.
Sexist stereotyping hurts boys as well as girls.

BiscuitLover3678 · 20/05/2022 16:03

I guess it depends what kind of play they’re doing? It might not be that they don’t want to play with girls, but they don’t want to play whatever game the girls are playing and they happen to be a group of girls. Something to talk about that and make that difference. Do they play different games? As that can also be looked at.

It makes me uncomfortable for children to be forced to play with someone else. I’d suggest more variety of play types and see if that helps then integrate more. Unfortunately some of these kids will be overtly told very sexist things about what games to play and with who.

TempsPerdu · 20/05/2022 15:58

@MangyInseam

That’s an interesting perspective on the music class thing, and I think there may be some truth to it. I have, though, also noticed that the few boys remaining (in that class and other, more stereotypically ‘girly’ activities that we do) are almost always South or East Asian in background - could be coincidence, or could be to do with differing cultural ideas around masculinity, perhaps?

I also know a fair few preschool aged boys who have started football classes, strongly disliked them, were given a few ‘months off’ and were then restarted on the classes by their parents, who couldn’t accept that their sons just might not like football, or might prefer a different activity!

Stompythedinosaur · 20/05/2022 15:55

Thanks for this really articulate post @TempsPerdu. You have said what I wanted to say much more clearly!

TempsPerdu · 20/05/2022 15:50

Oh ffs it's not sexism it's a perfectly normal developmental process. It's how kids develop their own sense of identity and self

I’m very much with @Beamur and @Stompythedinosaur on this. No, what was specifically described in the OP isn’t sexist, and children opting to play mainly in single sex groups isn’t an issue per se. Teachers shouldn’t be in the business of policing who should be playing with whom, unless it is directly impacting on the well-being of one or more of the children.

But I think what I and some other posters are recognising is the way that this gendered play can feed into early socialisation and the perpetuation of gender stereotypes, and this is an area where teachers and early years practitioners can wield some influence. This stuff - the idea that boys taking up more space is the natural order of things; the assumption that girls shouldn’t like dinosaurs or football, or that boys can’t do art or ballet - develops via parental and societal influence from a very early age, and schools and early years settings can often end up perpetuating stereotypes unless they’re very alert to how young children are being influenced by their environment and peer interactions.

Boys shouldn’t be returning from school and describing girls en masse as ‘bossy’ or ‘chatterboxes’ (‘bossy’, in particular, is a deeply gendered term). Girls shouldn’t be describing boys are a group as ‘naughty’ or ‘yucky’. No one group should be allowed to use space at the exclusion of others (at every single school I’ve worked at football-playing boys dominated the playground unless there was a designated no-ball or girls’ football zone).

And there are value judgements attached to these ideas. Never, throughout many years of KS1 parents’ consultations, did I come across a parent who was concerned that their daughter enjoyed football or construction play. However, I did have several who asked me to discourage their sons from using the art, role play or even Lego area because (and one father did actually use these terms), they were concerned their son were ‘too effeminate’ and not engaging with ‘proper outdoor rough and tumble’ with the other boys.

It’s a tricky one for schools and nurseries to recognise and tackle, because societal influences can be subtle and insidious, and gender stereotypes are still so deeply embedded in our culture (I’d actually argue that in many ways we’re going backwards in this regard). Just the other day a friend was telling me how her 3-year-old Encanto-loving daughter now refuses to sing along to ‘Surface Pressure’ because ‘Luisa is too strong for a girl and her muscles are too big’. Schools shouldn’t try to police friendships, but they should ensure that all children have equal access to a range of play opportunities, space is shared equally between the sexes and negative gendered language, however subtle, is discouraged as much as possible.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 20/05/2022 15:39

Stompythedinosaur · 20/05/2022 15:37

@SlightlyGeordieJohn you are a man who feels they are an expert is sexism and have the right to lecture women, with lived experience. This is a misogynistic perspective. You are confident of your superiority in a subject you have no experience of because of your privilege.

Your attempts to denigrate me personally ("get over yourself", comparing me to insulting and misogynistic cartoon characters) rather than answering the actual argument is very telling.

I'm going to stop here because I suspect you are on mn solely to get a rise out of others.

Why would you possibly think you know more than someone else? Has it occurred to you that any attitudes that you experience are as a result of the way that you speak to people?

Stompythedinosaur · 20/05/2022 15:37

@purpleboy thanks!

Stompythedinosaur · 20/05/2022 15:37

@SlightlyGeordieJohn you are a man who feels they are an expert is sexism and have the right to lecture women, with lived experience. This is a misogynistic perspective. You are confident of your superiority in a subject you have no experience of because of your privilege.

Your attempts to denigrate me personally ("get over yourself", comparing me to insulting and misogynistic cartoon characters) rather than answering the actual argument is very telling.

I'm going to stop here because I suspect you are on mn solely to get a rise out of others.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 20/05/2022 15:32

purpleboy · 20/05/2022 15:29

@SlightlyGeordieJohn I just knew from reading your posts that firstly you would be male and second you would have boys.

You are completely missing stompys point, there is no problem with anyone wanting to be in a single sex group of course, everyone should be free to play with who they want to, but when little children are saying they don't want to play with any children from the opposite sex, because they are (insert whatever childish name) they we as a society should be looking at where those ideas have come from, parents, teachers, society, gendered expectations and norms, it's not acceptable for my dd to say she doesn't want to play with a boy because boys are smelly, but it is fine if she doesn't want to play with him because he knocks down the Lego. It's not ok for her to be excluded from playing football with the boys at break because she is a girl and girls can't play football, despite the fact she play football at a better standard than most of the boys.(but they wouldn't know that because no girls are allowed)

Stompy wrote a very eloquent and factual post of which there is an abundance of evidence to support and your comeback rather to engage and try to understand what they were saying was to tell them to "get over themselves"
When people are unwilling to listen and take on boards other points of view even if they make you uncomfortable because you have boys, we as a society can't move forward.
I understand this all seems very minor to you, but a lot of this feeds into the way women are seen. It starts young and it should be dealt with.

You assumed, rather than knew, and that assumption was based on prejudice. I know that my little boys will face prejudice like yours as they go through life, but that doesn’t mean I have to happily accept it.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 20/05/2022 15:30

Stompythedinosaur · 20/05/2022 15:13

What an exceptionally rude and arrogant response.

If it is natural for boys and girls (and men and women) to segregate, why are their posters who have different experiences? If it was natural, it would presumably be universal.

Of course it wouldn’t. Natural and universal don’t mean the same thing at all, and it’s not rude to point out when someone is being infantile and argumentative.

As an example; it’s natural to be attracted to women with blue eyes, but it’s not universal. It’s natural to like chocolate cake, but it’s not universal.

May I ask; have you ever come across the character Millie Tant, in Viz comic? If not, I think you’d be amused at her japes and high-jinks based on finding offence everywhere she goes.

purpleboy · 20/05/2022 15:29

@SlightlyGeordieJohn I just knew from reading your posts that firstly you would be male and second you would have boys.

You are completely missing stompys point, there is no problem with anyone wanting to be in a single sex group of course, everyone should be free to play with who they want to, but when little children are saying they don't want to play with any children from the opposite sex, because they are (insert whatever childish name) they we as a society should be looking at where those ideas have come from, parents, teachers, society, gendered expectations and norms, it's not acceptable for my dd to say she doesn't want to play with a boy because boys are smelly, but it is fine if she doesn't want to play with him because he knocks down the Lego. It's not ok for her to be excluded from playing football with the boys at break because she is a girl and girls can't play football, despite the fact she play football at a better standard than most of the boys.(but they wouldn't know that because no girls are allowed)

Stompy wrote a very eloquent and factual post of which there is an abundance of evidence to support and your comeback rather to engage and try to understand what they were saying was to tell them to "get over themselves"
When people are unwilling to listen and take on boards other points of view even if they make you uncomfortable because you have boys, we as a society can't move forward.
I understand this all seems very minor to you, but a lot of this feeds into the way women are seen. It starts young and it should be dealt with.

Pantheon · 20/05/2022 15:23

I would mention it to the teacher. Maybe the topic could be talked about during circle time.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 20/05/2022 15:18

Stompythedinosaur · 20/05/2022 15:13

What an exceptionally rude and arrogant response.

If it is natural for boys and girls (and men and women) to segregate, why are their posters who have different experiences? If it was natural, it would presumably be universal.

What an odd comment.

Lots of things are natural but not universal. Having children, for example.

Stompythedinosaur · 20/05/2022 15:13

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 20/05/2022 14:55

Oh dear. You seem to be looking for offence everywhere, and have chosen to find it now in little children playing together?

It’s good that you accept your own prejudice, and so hope that you are working on it, but please don’t be so presumptuous as to assume that others share any hatred that you feel.

What an exceptionally rude and arrogant response.

If it is natural for boys and girls (and men and women) to segregate, why are their posters who have different experiences? If it was natural, it would presumably be universal.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 20/05/2022 15:04

Tamzo85 · 20/05/2022 14:56

@PleaseYourselfandEatTheCrusts

They do it f because the school forces them too - it’s not normal. Is it sexist for boys and girls to self segregate? I guess so but then nature is sexist I guess. It doesn’t mean one is worse than the other. If it’s sexist then who cares?

But to act like it’s the same as racism is just wrong. Race is skin deep and only ignorant people believe the races are different - but boys and girls and men and women truly are different. We have different hormones that affect or thinking, moods and other things - some differences in our brains have already been conclusively proven. We need to just accept that it’s alright that we’re different instead of living in la la land because for some reason we don’t want it to be true.

I wonder if posters like the one you’re responding to think it’s sexism if someone is only attracted to one sex, and if they feel that that’s as bad as racism too.

Tamzo85 · 20/05/2022 14:56

PleaseYourselfandEatTheCrusts · 20/05/2022 13:33

My son's school seem to be really hot on this and boys and girls play together fine. They are in year 3

I don't really understand why any school wouldn't tackle sexism the same way they would if it was racism. I don't understand why any parent wouldn't want to stamp it out either.

@PleaseYourselfandEatTheCrusts

They do it f because the school forces them too - it’s not normal. Is it sexist for boys and girls to self segregate? I guess so but then nature is sexist I guess. It doesn’t mean one is worse than the other. If it’s sexist then who cares?

But to act like it’s the same as racism is just wrong. Race is skin deep and only ignorant people believe the races are different - but boys and girls and men and women truly are different. We have different hormones that affect or thinking, moods and other things - some differences in our brains have already been conclusively proven. We need to just accept that it’s alright that we’re different instead of living in la la land because for some reason we don’t want it to be true.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 20/05/2022 14:55

Stompythedinosaur · 20/05/2022 14:51

You are being disingenuous; it’s not sexism to have a single-sex group of friends. Calling things like this sexism is idiotic, and does harm by trivialusing genuine cases of discrimination.My wife has a group of female friends that she goes out with and I have a group of male friends. To pretend that this sort of thing is sexism is ridiculous.

Skimming over for a moment the fact that I do not require a man to mansplain what sexism is to me as a woman.

The fact that you do something and want to continue to do it is not a marker of whether it is sexist or not. We all are products of a misogynistic society, we have all internalised misogynistic views.

Oh dear. You seem to be looking for offence everywhere, and have chosen to find it now in little children playing together?

It’s good that you accept your own prejudice, and so hope that you are working on it, but please don’t be so presumptuous as to assume that others share any hatred that you feel.

Swipe left for the next trending thread