Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed the boys ‘won’t play with girls’

184 replies

Leopardpj · 19/05/2022 22:28

DD is 4 and in reception. She tells me a lot of the boys in her class say they don’t ever want to play with her as they only want to play with boys. I don’t think she is lacking in friends but I think she is confused about it and is wondering what’s so bad about being a girl and it’s this that is bothering me. I don’t want her feeling it’s uncool or a negative thing to be a girl which I think is an impression she is starting to get. I feel as if this wouldn’t be tolerated if it was a comment being made about children from a religious or ethnic group etc and am wondering about asking the teacher whether she could keep an ear out for this sort of talk and try and nip it in the bud? Or perhaps that’s OTT and I am being unreasonable to think you can stop boys from saying/ feeling like this (I only have DDs so no experience with boys!) thanks in advance !

OP posts:
PandoraP · 20/05/2022 20:53

I think you are over thinking this massively. My dd refused to have anything to do with boys until she was 13. It’s not sexism when they are 4.

Tamzo85 · 20/05/2022 20:48

Anyways, half these boys who don’t want to play with the girls now will be chasing after them begging for (or dreaming of) a date once they hit their teens so ha!

Tamzo85 · 20/05/2022 20:46

@SleepingStandingUp

Relax it’s just my opinion. However I will say all this “it’s all socialisation” is a bunch of malarkey. No, it’s real, boys and girls really are different, even at that age and especially (as you’ve alluded to) when the hormones really kick in. I like to think that they can all find there place even those who aren’t interested in doing what most of their other classmates do, but there’s no point trying to press them into having no difference, it won’t hold unless your forcing them.

The important thing is that we teach boys and girls who aren’t as interested in the same things as others of their gender and find it harder to find their place, that there is nothing wrong with them and they are just as loved and valuable as their peers who behave in the more common masculine and feminine ways.

alpenguin · 20/05/2022 20:38

My youngest is 5 and he’s forever coming out with crap about stuff being for boys and girls and how girls can’t do x,y,z or play certain games. It enrages me because I’ve spent his entire life not enforcing stereotypes, he has long hair, wears princess dresses if he wants, paints his nails, plays superheroes and football and just is a kid. Someone is feeding him this crap and I’ve no idea who. I spent my entire childhood justifying wanting to play with boys and being told girls cans do that so I really wanted my kids to grow up in a different time.

I’ve no answers but I’m just so sad this crap still gets peddled by kids and their parents.

SomersetONeil · 20/05/2022 20:35

… and just to counter-balance, when DD was 4/5 she didn’t see the difference between girls and boys and played with both happily. Again, it was at about 6/7 when things started segregating.

She’s now 11 and doesn’t have any friends who are boys. That will clearly evolve, although being at an all-girls’ school, the opportunities will have to be extra-curricula.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 20/05/2022 20:27

SomersetONeil · 20/05/2022 20:23

It absolutely goes both ways. The girls don’t want to play with the boys.

It’s age and stage, and it ebbs and flows.

When DS was 4/5 he didn’t see the difference between girls and boys and played with both happily. It was at about 6/7 when things started segregating.

He’s now 13, and starting to come out the other side.

If this was a one way thing - i.e. only boys doing the segregating - I’d get on board with the outrage. But it’s categorically not, so I can’t muster any annoyance.

Exactly, it’s neither one-way, nor permanent, nor universal.

My boy plays with a mixed group, but mainly boys, and whether he ends up with all girls or all boys at some point there’s no problem.

SomersetONeil · 20/05/2022 20:23

It absolutely goes both ways. The girls don’t want to play with the boys.

It’s age and stage, and it ebbs and flows.

When DS was 4/5 he didn’t see the difference between girls and boys and played with both happily. It was at about 6/7 when things started segregating.

He’s now 13, and starting to come out the other side.

If this was a one way thing - i.e. only boys doing the segregating - I’d get on board with the outrage. But it’s categorically not, so I can’t muster any annoyance.

Johnnysgirl · 20/05/2022 20:21

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 20/05/2022 20:09

@Stompythedinosaur I wouldn't worry about @SlightlyGeordieJohn.

There seems to have been a massive influx of a certain type of poster that was not previously seen so abundantly on MN before (at least not in the time I've beeb around). I initially thought it had been some sort of organised campaign but I'm starting to think the repeated articles based on mn posts that appear in a certain "newspaper" has drawn them in.

I suspect once they realise that mumsnet isn't the echo chamber they are used to and that they will actually have to engage in debate AND tolerate opposing views here they'll slink back off again.

Point of thread missed entirely I know.

What post are you referring to? Hmm
Very rude of you to instruct op to ignore a specific poster's posts, because you disagree with them.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 20/05/2022 20:20

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 20/05/2022 20:09

@Stompythedinosaur I wouldn't worry about @SlightlyGeordieJohn.

There seems to have been a massive influx of a certain type of poster that was not previously seen so abundantly on MN before (at least not in the time I've beeb around). I initially thought it had been some sort of organised campaign but I'm starting to think the repeated articles based on mn posts that appear in a certain "newspaper" has drawn them in.

I suspect once they realise that mumsnet isn't the echo chamber they are used to and that they will actually have to engage in debate AND tolerate opposing views here they'll slink back off again.

Point of thread missed entirely I know.

Oh yes, which newspaper are you looking down your nose at today?

I read the FT, the Times and the Guardian, why don’t you amuse everyone with your bigoted views about what that says about me?

titchy · 20/05/2022 20:19

SleepingStandingUp · 20/05/2022 19:37

It's all just learning where they fit into their community, their sense of self (who am I, what am I) and is an absolutely essential part of growing up and learning how to navigate the world. Children with poor senses of self do NOT develop into confident able adults
Good to know KS1 DS having an Asian female as his best friend is a sign of his poor sense of self and an indicator on how he'll fail in later life 🙄

Perhaps read the entirety of my post FFS. I did say that in schools where there are a large number of two different ethnicities (eg white European and South Asian) that often the children play with children of their own ethnicity, although this could be cultural.

At no point did I say that white children playing with black children, or boys with girls, means they haven't developed a secure sense of self. The reverse is likely to be true in fact - it's developed enough for them to be confident in choosing play mates with similar values, rather than because they are in a particular, easy to identify category.

But you go ahead and find offence where there is none. 🤷‍♀️

bellac11 · 20/05/2022 20:16

its a normal developmental stage that most children go through and it fluctuates back and forth through their childhood anyway.

Attempts to change this for some adult fear of 'sexism' or trying to be 'inclusive' which means nothing to children of that age, is particularly misguided and shows a lack of understanding of child development

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 20/05/2022 20:09

@Stompythedinosaur I wouldn't worry about @SlightlyGeordieJohn.

There seems to have been a massive influx of a certain type of poster that was not previously seen so abundantly on MN before (at least not in the time I've beeb around). I initially thought it had been some sort of organised campaign but I'm starting to think the repeated articles based on mn posts that appear in a certain "newspaper" has drawn them in.

I suspect once they realise that mumsnet isn't the echo chamber they are used to and that they will actually have to engage in debate AND tolerate opposing views here they'll slink back off again.

Point of thread missed entirely I know.

SleepingStandingUp · 20/05/2022 19:37

It's all just learning where they fit into their community, their sense of self (who am I, what am I) and is an absolutely essential part of growing up and learning how to navigate the world. Children with poor senses of self do NOT develop into confident able adults
Good to know KS1 DS having an Asian female as his best friend is a sign of his poor sense of self and an indicator on how he'll fail in later life 🙄

SleepingStandingUp · 20/05/2022 19:35

certainly try to play with the girls and maybe that will be alright I missed one. It isn't OK for the kids to exclude another child because of sex. We're not talking about "Billy pulls their heads off" behaviour that's about Billy, but about genitals. And MAYBE that will be alright? You sound like they'll be traumatised if they see a boy cuddle and feed the Dolly 🙄. If they want to exclude Hannah cos she's ginger or has pigtails is that OK? Can Hannah TRY and play with them and if she succeeds we'll all watch and see if it was alright because you know, it's a lot for the brunettes to handle??

SleepingStandingUp · 20/05/2022 19:31

If Eliot wants to play dolls he can certainly try to play with the girls and maybe that will be alright if he is that sort of boy, THAT SORT of boy?? Do you not see how damaging that language is? THAT SORT. What, the sort with a baby sibling or a big sister with dolls? THAT SORT is exactly why the boy at nursery had to make do with a toy shopping trolley because he wasn't allowed a pushchair. And it comes back to the "girl" stuff being less cool, less strong, less superior, just little wife home stuff

and if Lucy wants to play dinosaurs she can do the same. but she doesn't need to be THAT SORT of girl??

The problem is when people act like all the girls must now like Dinosaurs because Lucy does or all the boys must like dolls but no one has. Not all boys like dinosaurs.. Not all girls like dolls. No one cares about that.

When children are left to their own devices they usually seperate based on interests which despite all the attempts to interfere are usually pretty stereotypical plenty of tests show that all the influences up until that point are largely stereotypical anyway. People give girls softer toys, expect boys to be rougher etc. It's ingrained because of socialisation, not the tiny impact of a Y chromosome before hormones have kicked in fully

there’s nothing wrong with trying to find a place for kids that fall outside that though, there's only an outside if you draw lines and put up walls.

But people are kidding themselves making believe that girls and boys will play together as though there’s no difference except it does happen. Plenty of people on here saying it happens just fine and naturally at their school. No teachers are forcing the poor little girls to play with DS against their will. No one of tying younger DS to a toy pushchair and refusing to let him play with anything else.

Abhannmor · 20/05/2022 18:48

Both my DSs played with girls. It was actually mentioned in their reports so maybe it was unusual at the time. They played with their sister too of course. I doubt teachers try to segregate them. Maybe some have a different , more rigid home life ?

autienotnaughty · 20/05/2022 18:38

PurpleandPlatinum · 19/05/2022 22:32

I am a TA and practically the whole of my lunch and break duty is children saying they don’t want to play with someone. It can be boys not wanting to play with girls, girls not wanting to play with boys, two children not wanting to play with a third, three children not wanting to play with a fourth, child x not wanting to play with child z… the list goes on and on and on and on and on and on.

You all deserve medals 🎖

safclass · 20/05/2022 18:11

Staff will be dealing with these things in a discrete manner. They will address 'sexist' comments in the same way they would do racist/homophobic ones.
Boys will say this, as do many girls but actually in a class throughout the day they will mix, play and interact with most of the class.
Don't worry about it, I like how you're speaking to your daughter, be incredulous that someone thinks that, make it fun.
But as a PP said playtimes etc are spent dealing with situations where some kid who doesnt want to play with another.

Beamur · 20/05/2022 18:09

Yep there's certainly a lot of projection in this thread...

titchy · 20/05/2022 17:36

Palease · 20/05/2022 16:50

My little boy started nursery at 2 and a half and after a few months I noticed all of the children he mentioned most (his friends) were blonde haired boys, like him. Maybe children just like those that look similar to them?

Yes very common!

Lots of posters have expressed outrage at the (hypothetical) situation of kids choosing same ethnicity friends. Again their lack of knowledge of development shines. As humans we are hard wired to seek similarities in others. We do it naturally as adults but obvs have to learn how to as children. Children around 2-3 begin to recognise they are the same as other children (up till then they play alongside rather than with). At 4-5 they recognise further groups - boys and girls, and often ethnicity (though much of this is related to parents or external experiences - kids knowing each other from mosque for example), whos good at football etc. As they get better at it then they learn some of their old ways of grouping people may not be the best and by early KS2 friendship groups are often mixed sex and value rather than category based.

It's all just learning where they fit into their community, their sense of self (who am I, what am I) and is an absolutely essential part of growing up and learning how to navigate the world. Children with poor senses of self do NOT develop into confident able adults.

Palease · 20/05/2022 17:24

I find it horrible people saying words like sexism and misogyny. They are 4! My son when he was 3 was told by little girls in the park they don’t want to play with him because he was a boy. It’s what kids do, it’s not limited to just boys.

WiseRobin · 20/05/2022 17:10

YABU they are 4!

purpleboy · 20/05/2022 17:06

*Do you not see the irony in such a sexist post?

No, actually, you probably don’t.*

You find it ironic that due to a large amount of men behaving/acting/speaking in a certain way across my decades of interaction with males, that I was able to (correctly) assume from you posts you were male?

Ironic is not the word I would use to describe that no. Typical is probably more representative.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 20/05/2022 17:06

It’s quite sad seeing people projecting their own prejudices and views onto little children. Nothing in the OP’s post or since suggests prejudicial or gendered behaviour, sexism, racing, bullying, or anything else negative, yet we see accusations of the most appalling attitudes, and suggestions of nascent or emergent poor behaviour.

Little boys and little girls form groups sometimes. Some mixed-sex, some single-sex, and this is not a problem. There is no suggestion here that it is caused by gendered expectations or toys, or by prejudiced parents or teachers.

So much angst over such normal activity.

anewername · 20/05/2022 17:00

musicalfrog · 19/05/2022 22:47

It's sexism though, and needs nipped in the bud. Not cool to allow misogyny to start this young just because it's (apparently) 'normal'. There is no good reason to discount playmates based on their sex alone. Would we accept it if they didn't want to play with a BAME peer? No we wouldn't. As a member of school staff I would absolutely be putting a stop to this. Speak to your daughter's teacher OP.

I personally think it's to do with interests. Boys learn quickly that the other boys like the things they do (generally. ) There still are many parents who limit their children toys to things stereotypically for boys like vehicles or construction type toys and girls to dolls and animals.

However I don't think you can fight against nature to a certain extent. Girls are more nurturing and hence why they often like dolls.

I have a boy in year one. There certainly has been a bit more sex division at playtime, but they work in mixed groups during lessons so that helps.

I also have a younger DD, but she's not at school.

Swipe left for the next trending thread