Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DLA

62 replies

DontYouLeaveMe · 19/05/2022 20:42

I’m really not sure if I’m being unreasonable here so coming straight to the viper pit 😁
I've recently applied for DLA for my son. I say recently, 12 weeks ago. It’s taken 12 weeks and I finally got a response today saying my family don’t meet the criteria, and I’m so disappointed. DS has ADHD, global developmental delay, dyspraxia, and a sensory processing disorder. We are waiting for genetic testing for a muscle disorder and for a referral for an autism assessment.

DS is lovely, but he needs help with most aspects of daily life. He can’t dress himself, needs help with food as he can’t cut up meals and struggles with scooping. He can’t read or write, struggles to sit still in school and has daily extra help with the SENCO and headmaster. He does OT twice a week and has regular doctor, paediatrician etc meetings. I’ve had to go part time because I couldn’t keep taking time off work to deal with everything. I know that they don’t consider my financial situation when making a decision, but I really could have done with the extra support to pay for petrol, equipment etc. But they’ve turned me down. Is it worth appealing? Will they change their minds considering nothing about my situation has changed?
YABU- you don’t automatically get money, suck it up
YANBU- keep pushing, fight for the money

OP posts:
toddlingabout · 20/05/2022 08:55

Appeal, speak to welfare rights at your council for help if you have to go to tribunal. Get professional reports to back you up. Also statements from people who know him, e.g. teachers, SENCO, club leaders etc. Carers trust will help you fill in any forms (including DLA form).

dustandroses · 20/05/2022 08:50

DontYouLeaveMe · 19/05/2022 21:01

Ok thanks, I’ve heard of sendiass so I’ll try them or scope tomorrow. I wrote it myself, I didn’t realise I was supposed to get help. I didn’t include anything from the doctor or paediatrician, I assumed the list of diagnoses and treatments would speak for themselves. I included my sons SEN report would be enough. I think I’ve been a bit silly here 😞

Not silly just naïve. The way to think of it is this, the person making the decision will never meet you or your child therefore the only thing the decision maker will have to go on is what you write in the form and the evidence to support this.

Anyone can send a form in with a list of diagnosis but that does not describe the child's needs and every child is different. Think of it like writing a guide for someone who is going to spend time with your child, if someone who didn't know you looked at your form would they see how much extra care your child has or their extra need? If the answer is no then neither will the decision maker.

Ask for a reconsideration write that you genuinely thought the diagnosis would be enough and then explain to them all of the help your child needs, right throughout the day and night if applicable. Put in all of the help he needs with learning and communication, all of the help he needs in school, extra learning, keeping him safe, interaction with peers. All of the help he needs with understanding things around him, any sensory needs, coping with meltdowns, frustration, aggression. All the help he needs with sleeping, settling, soothing, eating, drinking, dressing, bathing, playing etc.

It's quite difficult when it is part of your daily routine to actually realise how much extra care that you give. You will get this, you just need to spell it out, even if you have to go through the whole form again. Do not let them persuade you to start in a new claim or you will lose money.

Morph22010 · 20/05/2022 03:45

DontYouLeaveMe · 19/05/2022 21:01

Ok thanks, I’ve heard of sendiass so I’ll try them or scope tomorrow. I wrote it myself, I didn’t realise I was supposed to get help. I didn’t include anything from the doctor or paediatrician, I assumed the list of diagnoses and treatments would speak for themselves. I included my sons SEN report would be enough. I think I’ve been a bit silly here 😞

I would have thought that would have been enough to get at least lower rate care, did they put reasons why you were turned down? For the lowest rate you only have to prove they need an hour a day more care than a typical child their age. School stuff helps support as if they have a lot of support at school, for example a 1-1 then it’s evidence they are also likely to be needing support out of school. You’ve not put child’s age but the younger the child it is often harder to get as all young children need a lot of care so you are having to prove your child needs more than a typical child of that age

WiddlinDiddlin · 20/05/2022 03:12

That was a quick result - I put in for a change of circumstances at unfortunately, the same time as renewal.. last august. I am still waiting for an assessment!

Your application should state:

What dx, medication etc.
What the applicant cannot do - and link that back to the various issues for EACH question.

Assume that each question is a stand alone, that the person reading it has not read the previous questions and will forget the answer to this one immediately before they read the next.

So using me as an example for the moving around question:

Widdlin' cannot stand and move without her wheelchair without experiencing severe pain, debilitating breathlessness and falling. If Widdlin' attempts to stand or move she falls. This happens every time Widdlin' attempts to stand and move.

SO then when it comes to say personal care, bathing etc - I'd repeat that bit as well, I would not assume they have taken that part into account, they won't.

So I would have to explain that I can't get in the shower, as that would involve standing, which I can't do.

It's really bloody tedious.

Find the list of points and what criteria they're awarded for - remember that it is not sufficient for the person to do something - hell, I can haul my ass up the stairs - they have to be able to do something safely, without pain, in a reasonable time frame - I haul my ass up the stairs on my hands and knees twice a day (loo midday, bedtime), it isn't safe, I fall frequently and it hurts a shitload and takes ages. But im waiting on a DFG, and I won't shit in a bucket.

The point of that is - there are things you/the person involved may be forcing themselves to do now because there is no choice - that doesn't mean its acceptable, it doesn't mean they're actually capable and could be considered able to do a thing the same way a non-disabled person can.

Once you've got the list of points the report you have can be used to pick out whats wrong, what they've missed or misunderstood - and formulate your written MR (never do that over the phone, submit it in writing!).

That way you can hit the specific key points/terms they want to see for the applicant to meet that criteria.

You don't say the age of your son - it is possible they're deeming the level of care he requires to be similar to the level of care a non-disabled child would require, so really spell out HOW it is different.

Purringcat3 · 19/05/2022 23:39

Defo get support from someone who knows what language to use in these forms. After 12 years I can word these forms fine now and I’m well versed in what they require, but if it’s your first application and you’ve done it alone, you probably haven’t said the key things that will help

Babyroobs · 19/05/2022 23:30

I would ask for a mandatory reconsideration asap and send extra evidence. If he has an EHCP etc then send a copy of that.

Afterfire · 19/05/2022 23:03

Please don’t use fightback. They charge for their services, there are lots of other great free resources and groups online and on Facebook- just search for dla in groups there and one will come up with 60k plus members. If you don’t want to post just read the other posts and that will help you. Use the cerebra guide. You don’t need anyone to write the form for you, it’s better if you do it yourself - you know your child better than anyone.

Its also a myth they turn everyone down first time, they don’t. My son got high rate care at 2.5 years old without any diagnosis at all and having only been referred to a consultant and never actually having seen one: they based their award on the form I wrote myself. He’s now 9 and it’s been renewed twice since with no issues - he’s got autism and other related issues and attends complex needs school. He now has an ehcp but he didn’t when I first applied.

I’ve also applied for PIP for myself and had no issues getting this either - I have lupus and other conditions, I’ve been given highest rates on both elements as an ongoing award. I was given this without an assessment in person - they based it on the form I wrote and spoke to my rheumatologist.

So what I’m saying is don’t give up, don’t listen to the horror stories and keep fighting!

EndersGame · 19/05/2022 22:54

you have to lodge a mandatory reconsideration request within 28 days of date on the decision letter. DO NOT miss this deadline. Even if all you do is write saying, please look at this again, make sure you do not miss the deadline. Try to get to Citizens advice, and have a look at their website on challenging.

perfectstorm · 19/05/2022 22:48

DLA is like EHCP, in that it's all about evidence. A parent's word doesn't count for much by itself.

I sent in a copy of my child's EHCP when I applied, as it's a good one (I have a really good caseworker, and then we negotiated via mediation, using a fantastic direct access barrister, to get section F up to speed, too - the best caseworker's never allowed to do much with that, on money grounds, but the B, which is what DLA is based on, is always very good in this area, I think, as they are allowed to be blunt there and they really do read reports and reflect them well).

I then wrote that they had my permission at DWP to speak to the caseworker, too, on the issues within the EHCP. If your EHCP's good - and with NHS/LA funded OT twice a week, I am assuming it is if that funds it! - then it can provide really good evidence. It works as a sort of summary of all the reports and how they affect your child.

Agree you need help on how to complete it. Keep going - the money makes such a difference to my own children's lives (I have 2 with EHCPs).

Graphista · 19/05/2022 21:55

Did you do it yourself with no help or guidance from anywhere else?

They almost always turn down 1st application surely you've seen in the news how many rejections are overturned on appeal?

Don't even attempt to do this yourself with no help from experts in the area. Get help from your local welfare rights advice dept within your local council I find them the best. Cab can be hit and miss, some of their advisors know their stuff but many ime don't.

You could also look at joining organisations who are charities specific to your sons condition/s they can often be very experienced in dealing with the very unfair system too

It's really hard to assess your son objectively yourself there will be loads you haven't thought to include or thought you weren't supposed to include this is very very common

I left out loads the 1st time I applied for anything like this.

These experts also know the key words and phrases the dwp like to see on such applications - nonsensical but unfortunately this is how it works

You haven't been silly you just didn't know which so so many don't I didn't know!

I hold 2 degrees inc a medical one and worked civil service myself and I messed mine up! A small local charity pointed me in direction of welfare rights. I'd taken a photocopy before handing it in thankfully and sent a copy of this to the advisor ahead of our appointment. As soon as I walked in her door she noticed like 3 things I'd left out! That was before I even sat down! Then we went through the form and she noticed a ton of other things I'd omitted and other things I hadn't expressed in the way they like them to be (yes it's ridiculous but this is how the system works)

Ever since in real life and on here and elsewhere online I always tell people don't even TRY and do it yourself you will come unstuck! Frankly I think they can easily spot the ones where people have had no help and mark them for rejection thinking they're a soft target with no support

Fight this! You and your son deserve better

Get as much support as you can

Good luck Flowers

howtomoveforwards · 19/05/2022 21:54

Get some help with an appeal if a mandatory reconsideration doesn5 work. My son gets middle rate care on what I think is a lot less than the issues you are describing.

wetpebbles · 19/05/2022 21:41

And definitely keep going

wetpebbles · 19/05/2022 21:40

Look on Facebook for "fightback", they help fill in forms and with MR with many success stories

AReallyUsefulEngine · 19/05/2022 21:37

Not sending evidence is a mistake. DLA is based on needs rather than diagnosis so it’s important to explain and evidence needs as children with the same diagnoses may have differing levels of needs.

If DS doesn’t have an EHCP you should apply for one of those too.

DontYouLeaveMe · 19/05/2022 21:23

Ok thanks everyone. I’ll get my arse in gear tomorrow and write every single Thing down

OP posts:
x2boys · 19/05/2022 21:18

Hi DLA is about the extra care your child needs above and beyond the average child their age so whilst diagnoses can help you need to prove what extra care your child needs
Evidence from professionals help a lot this includes reports,EHCP,s Evidence professionals are involved such as paediatrician, portage senco etc etc

PoppyStellar · 19/05/2022 21:14

You’ve not been silly at all but definitely don’t assume the assessor will work it out from a list of diagnoses. From years of experience of both DLA and PIP, definitely ask for mandatory reconsideration first and then appeal.

As everyone else has said you really have to spell it out for them. So an example would be something like ‘he is unable to feed himself or cut up food due to the fact he has no control of movement in his hands as a result of (name of condition). This means he always, at every meal time, requires another person to enable him to eat. This assistance takes x mins each time’

In my experience repetition is your friend. Just because you’ve said something at Q7 say, doesn’t mean you shouldn’t repeat it at Q11. Work on the assumption you’re explaining to an idiot (no offence intended to the assessors I just mean make it as clear and simple as possible). Make it really clear how the various conditions impact on your son and how they mean he needs considerably more help than an ‘average’ child his age, even if this means it feels like you’re constantly stating the obvious.

It can be hard to focus on the worst days but that is what you need to do as others have said. Good luck.

Starlightstarbright1 · 19/05/2022 21:05

Yes do a Mr.. Ask for reasons why turned down.. challenge them. The cerebra guude is really helpful for wording.

Onionpatch · 19/05/2022 21:04

Yes to the cereba guide and including evidence - so any ehcp or constant letters or prescriptions.

doadeer · 19/05/2022 21:02

I haven't been awarded mine yet but I had reports from about 5 professionals working with my son printed out. I think you have to send everything. What a pain for you now ☹️

DontYouLeaveMe · 19/05/2022 21:01

Ok thanks, I’ve heard of sendiass so I’ll try them or scope tomorrow. I wrote it myself, I didn’t realise I was supposed to get help. I didn’t include anything from the doctor or paediatrician, I assumed the list of diagnoses and treatments would speak for themselves. I included my sons SEN report would be enough. I think I’ve been a bit silly here 😞

OP posts:
Clymene · 19/05/2022 21:00

How old is he? It really does sound like he's entitled to it. But it's all about how you fill in the form I'm afraid. Take a look at the cerebra guide and ask for reconsideration.

They make it very difficult.

doadeer · 19/05/2022 20:59

I know children with far less complex needs who get it. Did you provide a lot of information and evidence? Sounds like an error from them. I would appeal 100%

AReallyUsefulEngine · 19/05/2022 20:59

If you didn’t look at it when completing the form look at the Cerebra guide.

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 19/05/2022 20:59

I'm waiting for a decision but I'm planning to go to MR.

Swipe left for the next trending thread