Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For forcing DS to go to Scouts?

90 replies

Belovedgi · 19/05/2022 16:53

DS is 12, having problems making friends at secondary school. Some of the boys in his form go to the local Scouts. In fact there are a few boys from his old primary that go too.

DS has been twice now and is refusing to go back. Says it is boring and he feels awkward as everyone knows each other and are friends.

I told him he needs to go a few more times rather than just give up and the more times he goes the easier he will get. They do all sorts of fun activities like camping, going to the cinema and indoor wall climbing.

I NEED him to make more friends, get some confidence and ultimately leave the house to do stuff other than just going to school.

AIBU to force him to keep going? He says he hates it but I think in the end this would be good for him. I keep reading that joining clubs is the only way to make more friends.

OP posts:
MintIceCream1 · 20/05/2022 10:11

That was YOU! Many girls LOATHE Girl Guides. I couldn't think of anything worse if I tried. I feel you are trying to force your personality on your son and you should back off! Some of us are quiet and shy and would hate Guides/Scouts with the passion of a thousand sons. Stop trying to force your son to be like you, you're being selfish. If he wanted to go, he'd go. Let him find his own way. If he wants to stay in his room reading, let him. Leave him alone. He'll find his own way. Parents who force their extrovert personality on an introvert really boil my blood.

AWorldWithoutDoors · 20/05/2022 08:33

Is it Scouts that he dislikes or just the particular group, as they can vary? Maybe a different one could be better.

My sons went to Cubs group where there was a large clique of boys who all knew each other from school/since they were very young and were resistant to anyone else joining in with them. My two sons who are fairly close in age are completely opposite in personality but neither of them could penetrate the group and DS2 who was a bit younger was bullied by them. One of the boy’s mum was a leader, which I think made the other leaders reluctant to do anything about it because there was a shortage of adult volunteers. My two both left early in the end, which was a pity because live fairly rurally and there’s very little else in terms of clubs here.

DogsAndGin · 19/05/2022 19:41

Why do you NEED him to make more friends?! Some people are introverts. I don’t understand forcing someone to do something they hate just because it’s something YOU find appealing.

moomintrolls · 19/05/2022 19:24

Yes, I think that's very unreasonable. He says it's boredom and feeling awkward but what if it's comments and things he's not told you about? It would make his school situation worse.

I would leave him be on this one and just work with him on his confidence myself by taking him places he would actually like to go on weekends, and mixing with children outside of school.

School just shoves a group of people the same age together and that's that. There's not one reason you would make friends with someone just because they are the same age, and this is contrary to how friendships work in the real world.

I don't have any friends from school, few people do. If he gets through school then great, but you should be offering to do something else with him instead of trying to force him into a situation which sounds absolutely horrible for him because it's the same people he can't get on with daily, and you want him to spend MORE time with them?

You have no idea the ripping he is going to get if he's seen as someone whose mummy is trying to force him to be friends.

Knittingchamp · 19/05/2022 19:13

Belovedgi · 19/05/2022 17:02

I have suggested so many other things and he says NO to everything. He hates sports, enjoys swimming but refuses to join local swimming club or any after school clubs.

it’s exhausting. I thought Scouts would be good because he actually knows boys there already so less scary. He is a shy quiet boy.

I’m just worried he’s going to spend his whole life in his bedroom playing Roblox.

Why not limit Roblox and ask him to choose an activity indoors or outdoors that he can do instead? There's no point forcing him to be sociable if he hates it! That'll just make him miserable. A hobby would be great but that could be model making in your front room, whatever, he really doesn't need to be social. If he is shy and introverted that's his personality and there's nothing wrong in it! All this social stuff will sap his happiness.

AllMyExesWearRolexes · 19/05/2022 19:12

Rugby, judo, boxing one of the cadet forces?
All encourage & reward commitment, hard work & comradeship as well fostering discipline & confidence.

stepuporshutup · 19/05/2022 19:04

How would you feel if someone FORCED you to do something you didn't want to do. There are different groups that he might like, swimming, athletics, football or whatever he is interested in. I feel sorry for him

Natsku · 19/05/2022 19:00

I'd ask him to try for a couple more weeks (or to half term whenever that is) and if he still doesn't like it he can choose something else but have a rule that he must do at least one activity. That's a rule I've had for my DD since she started school and its been great for meeting new people and making friends outside of her class at school but there's been times when she's been reluctant so I've said finish the term then choose something else and she ended up sticking with them after all.

yikesanotherbooboo · 19/05/2022 19:00

Did he want to go or did you initiate it?
If he wanted to go I would encourage him to go for a term.
If it came from you and he doesn't like it I would be more amenable to him stopping.

Ijustreallywantacat · 19/05/2022 18:57

I’m actually with you. It’s worth it to commit to things and I’d encourage him to continue him to continue, at least for a while. Two sessions and he won’t have found he is feet properly.

MrsRinaDecker · 19/05/2022 18:48

The thing you’ll find with most clubs is that the same kids will have been there since they were about 5! So beavers / cubs / scouts, football is particularly bad for it, swimming if the whole cohort have been together since beginners one. It’s really hard to join at age 12, and even more so if he’s not really into it. Maybe finding something which is for older dc only or a new club starting up. Sometimes libraries run coding clubs, or tabletop gaming, that might be more his thing. But being an introvert isn’t a character flaw!

savehannah · 19/05/2022 18:45

I'm torn on this one. I usually would say I wouldn't let my kids give up an activity on a whim, I'd tend to suggest they give it half a term or so. But then I've only ever signed them up for things they wanted to do, at least at first.

I do think encouraging a child to experience new things, do something non screen based and meet new people is a positive thing, not just from the point of view of making friends but for general well-being. But if he's taken against Scouts, and it wasn't his idea in the first place you may not win this one because you pushing it will make him more determined to hate it.

I'd say he has to go to some kind of club or activity outside of the house but he can choose what (within reason) If he's uninspired try to find as many different possibilities to suggest as possible and say he has to try one for a half term to see how he gets on.

Petronus · 19/05/2022 18:38

It’s exhausting, because you’re making it exhausting. Leave the poor kid alone, he will find his own way. Forcing people to do none essential things is a recipe for resentment.

Armychefbethebest · 19/05/2022 18:35

I found the same with my son. When I was 12 I joined the army cadets and stayed until I joined the army at 16 I loved it as does my son they do lots of outdoor activity and military stuff too as well as using adapted weapons on the ranges ,then there are weekends away èaster and summer camps I'm 41 now but still I touch with many cadet friends . He maý find something like this more interesting he will only resent going if forced and kind of defeats the object of going to make friends.

Ponderingwindow · 19/05/2022 18:34

You need to find him the right activities. He is most likely to find friends who are enthusiastic about the kind of things he is excited about.

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 19/05/2022 18:28

Write a list of local clubs sports ect and get him to try 1 new thing a month to see what he likes I did this with ds turns out he loved a few different ones like archery, and rugby he was never into sports before though

Darbs76 · 19/05/2022 18:24

I still remember being forced to go to the brownies as a kid, as my mum paid for a second hand uniform. No it didn’t scar me for life but I’ve never forgotten it and never forced myself to go to clubs. And trust me my eldest needed to go really but no point forcing someone

TheYearOfSmallThings · 19/05/2022 18:24

Just wasn't my thing, I'd much rather have been at the stables or in a swimming pool.

If the OP's son was raring to go to the stables or swimming pool she would care about scouts. She just wants him to do something a bit social that gets him out in the world.

TooManyPJs · 19/05/2022 18:23

If he struggles to make friends in school going to clubs that have those same people is just awful and like a extension of the hideousness that is school. I speak as someone who also struggled to make friends and was bullied.

Why don't you offer a deal - he can give up scouts if he finds another club or activity to replace it. You could come up with a list of suggestions for him. He also needs to find something that works for him that involves getting away from a screen and getting some exercise. Perhaps he'd prefer something solitary?

I also hated guides btw. Bullying was even worse there.

I am ND and what you describe is a common problem for ND people. Maybe something worth looking into if you haven't done so already.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 19/05/2022 18:22

I think you are right to keep pushing him, at this age, and when he is declining to do other activities. I would have a word with the scout leader and see if she can arrange groups so he's not the odd one out with an established friendship group, but in a truly mixed bunch.

I would never extend "love the child you have" to mean "never push them out of their comfort zone". Some people are hesitant and could easily retreat from the world, and the older they are the more they fall behind the usual teenage experiences. If they want to retreat as an adult that is their choice to make, but at the age of 12? No way. Unless he has other ideas then he needs to give this a longer trial, and pick up something else (sport, music group, martial arts - anything) if he does quit later.

bellac11 · 19/05/2022 18:19

Its difficult to get the balance right.

Personally I cant bear anything structured, hate school. But wasnt encouraged to join clubs and because I was shy I didnt argue because it would have been painful to do so, but equally I often felt left out of things

But some clubs and activities are so boring, do you have exciting things near you like
bmx club
mountain biking clubs
board games cafe clubs
rock choir for kids
steel drumming or something funky like that

All places that are nothing like school but exciting and different

nearlyspringyay · 19/05/2022 18:13

Belovedgi · 19/05/2022 17:22

What was so wrong with Guides? I went and really enjoyed it!

Just wasn't my thing, I'd much rather have been at the stables or in a swimming pool.

Topseyt123 · 19/05/2022 18:12

Greensleeves · 19/05/2022 17:57

What is it with parents of preteens/young teens forcing them to participate in things they have said they don't want to do? There's been a whole rash of them lately. Confused

@FineWordsForAPorcupine gave you good advice when they said "love the child you have, not the one you want". Rather than dismissing it as cruel, maybe take the advice on board and consider it properly. Your OP is quite a lot about you and what you need - you need him to make more friends, you need him to be sociable. You're sociable, so why can't he be? When posters have shared with you that they were forced to go to Guides and hated it, your response was "what's wrong with Guides? I loved it"

Your DS isn't you! He's probably got enough on his plate socially adjusting to secondary school. He has told you he does not want to continue with Scouts - you may feel crestfallen about that, because in your opinion the activities they do are great fun, but your child doesn't agree, so that should be that. He's at an age when you need to be beginning to cede a bit of control to him, and allowing him to have some boundaries and some agency over his time.

Have to say that I agree with this.

I also thought @FineWordsForAPorcupine gave fair and reasonable advice. OP took offence for some reason though.

He is not you, OP. He likes and dislikes different things. You might be a social butterfly, he doesn't have to be. You might have loved the activities that scouts and guides do, but you can't force him to love them if he just doesn't.

Perhaps he feels lonely when he goes to scouts because it isn't really his thing so he doesn't feel inclined to join in much. Perhaps he likes his own company at home or with his small group of school friends.

You don't NEED him to make more friends. Maybe you just don't understand people who don't mix in big circles of friends so you are on his back a lot. Maybe you need to back off and let him be himself, whilst being there to support when needed. Support and advise, but not push and dictate. Sorry if I have that wrong, but it does read as though that is your approach, intentionally or not.

Lavenderlast · 19/05/2022 18:01

Clubs are a great idea to make friends. Well done for helping and pushing him.

A club full of boys who have already rejected him at school - I’m not so sure, I’d find that tricky but it could help at school depending on whether the other boys just haven’t got to know him at school, or if they just are different personalities to him. Is worth trying for a couple more sessions though, maybe even a full term if he’s (like my son) the kind of boy who rejects everything and wants to stay on the sofa with nintendo. If he can’t find friends there after a few weeks - a term then it’s time to try something else.

Do also look out for clubs where he can reinvent himself without being around school people. Like drama club, sea/army cadets, coding, street dance, fencing, sailing, see what else is near you.

Greensleeves · 19/05/2022 17:57

What is it with parents of preteens/young teens forcing them to participate in things they have said they don't want to do? There's been a whole rash of them lately. Confused

@FineWordsForAPorcupine gave you good advice when they said "love the child you have, not the one you want". Rather than dismissing it as cruel, maybe take the advice on board and consider it properly. Your OP is quite a lot about you and what you need - you need him to make more friends, you need him to be sociable. You're sociable, so why can't he be? When posters have shared with you that they were forced to go to Guides and hated it, your response was "what's wrong with Guides? I loved it"

Your DS isn't you! He's probably got enough on his plate socially adjusting to secondary school. He has told you he does not want to continue with Scouts - you may feel crestfallen about that, because in your opinion the activities they do are great fun, but your child doesn't agree, so that should be that. He's at an age when you need to be beginning to cede a bit of control to him, and allowing him to have some boundaries and some agency over his time.