Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be unhappy with noisy abnb

35 replies

Anna713 · 19/05/2022 15:26

I am currently staying in a very nice villa in Portugal with two other couples. The villa is comfortable. It is near a railway station so I expected some noise from trains etc. However there his extensive work on the railway line literally outside our window which goes on all through the night. The digger and machinery noise is incredible and most of us have not slept well at all. The owner was very apologetic when we arrived and provided earplugs. She says she did not know the work would be taking place. (Obviously she knew enough on advance to buy the earplugs!) The owner said she had urgent business in Lisbon and disappeared there for a few days.

To make matters worse we had agreed a late checkout as we have a late flight. We have been told this morning that the owner now has another booking and we have to leave at 11am.

The others in my party are disappointed but not too bothered but I am fuming. I did not book this holiday myself and I dont want to upset my friend who did book it. My husband says to leave it and there's nothing we can do anyway but am I being unreasonable to be fuming? I am doubting my own judgement.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EvilEdna1 · 19/05/2022 20:44

I left a very slightly negative review about a property in a tiny quiet village in France. The house was nice enough but the neighbours were incredibly noisy until about 3 am for about 4 or 5 nights. I had the feeling they were doing it on purpose as either they didn't like being next to a holiday house or because we are English. The other reviews were in French and very positive. Anyway I wish I hadn't as the owner just sent me a lots of messages about how filthy we left it (we didn't) and then left me a negative review. I told her she was just making accusations because of my very kind but not completely positive review and she didn't even bother denying it.

SunscreenCentral · 19/05/2022 20:44

EileenGC · 19/05/2022 18:31

Just because it’s a civilised country, doesn’t mean their laws are the same. Like I said, I’ve lived in a variety of European, civilised countries and only the UK and Germany care enough to let residents know about these kind of things. How was the owner to know about the works, even if they’re planned months in advance? Doesn’t mean they’re made public.

I was inconvenienced traveling out of Paris to CDG airport by rail in October last. (Weekend work upgrades).

Turns out there was plenty of notice about it but I didn't see it because I simply hadn't looked and assumed all would be well. The French had everything perfectly organised (buses waiting from the Stade de France stop) so...

basically shit happens

11GrumpsaGrumping · 19/05/2022 20:31

@Anna713 - you also seem a bit hard to please. The owner did the only thing she could do and apologise and bought ear plugs. She has agreed for you to store your luggage at no charge in the hallway. You say you're going to stomp in and use the toilet whether they like it or not, when you can easily use the toilet in any cafe or restaurant or supermarket or bar or station here and no one will mind. She brought you cake which you complain you won't have time to eat. Like, it's cake. Just eat it! I honestly do get how awful noise and sleeplessness can be, but you have to be fair, and you sound really negative and like you dig your heels in for the sake of it. Get on with your holiday! It's a gorgeous country with amazing food, drink, people, culture, and scenery- stop whining!

11GrumpsaGrumping · 19/05/2022 20:25

@CottonSock, again, even if it is the Lisbon to Madrid project, the government publishing plans on a broad scale will not translate to specific plans (eg we will do X section on X days) that local residents will be made aware of.

Yes, it is Portugal and not Timbuktu, but living here I can tel you first hand that communication is not a priority for the government. Equally, neither is disruption for residents. People are just expected to get on with it.

The number of times our water has been turned off with no warning...!

11GrumpsaGrumping · 19/05/2022 20:20

@CottonSock ha ha ha ha ha.

Well, they might be planned years in advance. (Doubt it). That will in no way translate to any communication to the local residents.

11GrumpsaGrumping · 19/05/2022 20:19

@Anna713, I hate noise and am miserable when I don't sleep, so I really do empathise.

Where in Portugal are you?

I live in Portugal, and can tell you with certainty the owners won't have had any notice. Case on point- we got a notice about a month ago telling us they were going to be hunting for wild boar in the each night that week. Great. Except they had already done the hunting about two week's before that. Noisy, and frightening! Had we let our place out, we would have been equally helpless and just had to do the same- earplugs and apologise.

The roads are the same. All of a sudden-
Closed! No notice at all. Once I couldn't get out of our road because the main road it backs onto was closed for a huge bike race. No notice. Just sudden police escorts shouting at cars to get off the road, as if they should have magically intuited a bike race was coming.

This Is Portugal as I say.

Try to annoy it and don't let your displeasure ruin it for the group. No doubt the person who booked it will already feel bad, and you're really placing them between a rock and a hard place.

CottonSock · 19/05/2022 19:22

Could be this upgrade
int.anteagroup.com/projects/leixoes-line-road-rail-terminal-grande-porto-portugal#87198

I've been to Portugal many times bit not Porto. Hooe you enjoy your last evening.

Anna713 · 19/05/2022 19:10

We are staying just outside Porto, so it could be the Lisbon Madrid project. The owner has just been round with a nice cake for us so I am feeling a bit mean now. Having said that I dont know when we can eat it. We are just on our way out for dinner and leaving at 11am tomorrow. Perhaps she does feel a bit guilty

OP posts:
CottonSock · 19/05/2022 18:37

If its on Google its not top secret is it.
Where are you OP?
Could it be the Lisbon to Madrid project? Its probably worth you having a look at press to see if it's published, aswell as recording noise like a pp suggests. Hopefully Airbnb will be helpful. They do tend to be.

EileenGC · 19/05/2022 18:31

CottonSock · 19/05/2022 18:26

@EileenGC of course I can comprehend it, did you mean to be so patronising.
I was responding to the Op and I work on infrastructure projects like this. It's Portugal, not timbuktu.

Just because it’s a civilised country, doesn’t mean their laws are the same. Like I said, I’ve lived in a variety of European, civilised countries and only the UK and Germany care enough to let residents know about these kind of things. How was the owner to know about the works, even if they’re planned months in advance? Doesn’t mean they’re made public.

CottonSock · 19/05/2022 18:30

And a quick Google will tell you about the Portuguese government rail investment plan.. I'll just add that replacement of a rail line is a major investment, not day to day 'roadworks'.

CottonSock · 19/05/2022 18:26

@EileenGC of course I can comprehend it, did you mean to be so patronising.
I was responding to the Op and I work on infrastructure projects like this. It's Portugal, not timbuktu.

Orpheline · 19/05/2022 18:23

The poor woman won't have been informed in advance. As pp stated, we're lucky to be considered in the UK.

Anna713 · 19/05/2022 18:17

Well, I've had a nice lunch and a few drinks so I'm feeling more philosophical now. Must be the Portuguese wine ! We are going out for a nice meal tonight and I intend to enjoy the rest of our long awaited holiday. Thanks to everyone for your feedback

OP posts:
TabithaTittlemouse · 19/05/2022 17:56

You can hardly blame the noise disturbance from the railway maintenance on the host! I get that you are fed up but it isn’t her fault. What do you want her to do?

The check out change is a pain but what has she said? Just tough luck?

EileenGC · 19/05/2022 17:49

How is leaving a negative review now - which will be published a couple of days later - going to help customers staying there in the next few weeks? Most of those will have already booked. Realistically, it will be read by people wanting to book later on, it will stay on their profile for months and years, by which point the work will probably be done and the noise gone. It’s completely understandable to be annoyed at the unexpected noise and disruption to the holiday, but what really is condescending is thinking that leaving a negative review is going to help matters somehow. It will only cause further loss of income to the owners. Complain, but don’t take it out on them and put off potential customers. I don’t know, maybe I’m just too nice but there’s not much that would be achieved by making a fuss, in this particular situation.

@CottonSock of course they’re planned in advance. Doesn’t mean residents get told about them though. Is it that hard to comprehend that other countries do things differently or indeed don’t do them at all?

nancy75 · 19/05/2022 17:41

If you didn’t book it you can’t leave a review can you?
the late check out is annoying but they E probably lost a lot of money over the last 2 years & didn’t want to turn down a booking

MallampatiCatty · 19/05/2022 17:36

We complained about noise in an Airbnb once. They wanted proof of the noise! So get recordings in. They did refund us 25% or something similar I think. They were very fair about it. I did have acknowledgement in writing from the host that he knew about it and forgot to tell us though

CottonSock · 19/05/2022 17:34

In the UK works and closures to the railway are planned years ahead. I bet they are in Portugal too. Especially a line replacement.

I hate noise and would be fuming too OP.

Anna713 · 19/05/2022 17:31

We did have the late checkout agreement in writing, although we have not paid extra. The holiday has been postponed since the beginning of covid and the owner was most anxious that we did not cancel so was happy to be flexible. She offered the late checkout, we did not ask.

I take on board your comments about customs being different outside of the UK. Although I do not see the need to be condescending EileenGC.

I do not think it is unreasonable to be upset about the amount of noise we have had to put up with when we have looked forward to a quiet holiday for so long. Or to be miffed about the offer of a late checkout being withdrawn with little notice. However, I won't leave any review is probably the best option. I pity the people staying in the villa after we leave though. I hope they dont mind staying nextdoor to a building site.

OP posts:
Caspianberg · 19/05/2022 17:02

We are Central Europe, as above, we only get alerted with 24hrs notice if it affects us ie we can’t drive in or out of our driveway so would have to park elsewhere the night before. Otherwise they definitely do just rock up at 7am with the jackhammer

A particular favourite of mine was the 2 years ago when we drove home from hospital with 24hr old baby, to find we have to park 2 streets away and walk home with tiny newborn in arms, stitches and baby stuff. Our driveway and road was then dug up for 6 weeks, so that was wonderful trying to nap or get newborn to nap.

EileenGC · 19/05/2022 16:41

Anna713 · 19/05/2022 16:03

The work on the line is all along the long railway line though. They must have known surely. Its major work replacing all the line from what I can see and it only takes place at night to avoid disruption to the trains. Having said that they are hammering away right now since 2 PM this afternoon. You need earplugs to sit in the garden. And the villa was expensive too!

What do you mean ‘they must have known surely’?

I come from Spain where you NEVER get notified in advance of any maintenance or building work happening on your street, let alone on the railway. Of all the countries I’ve lived in, only in the UK and Germany have I seen these notices of nearby work / building / maintenance, days or weeks in advance.

In Spain, you just wake up and find the building site up, or suddenly get woken up by loud drilling on the railway (I used to live close to one). You also don’t ‘see it coming’ because they seem to hop from one stretch of railway to another, a bit at random so you never know if you’re next or it’s three towns over that gets picked for the next step.

Unless it’s going to affect on-street parking, or your water supply, the council is not legally required to tell you of anything even if it causes noise or disruption.

I can imagine it’s much the same in Portugal. Before leaving a negative review for something that’s out of the owner’s control, perhaps you can educate yourself on the customs of other countries and not just assume everywhere functions like the UK does?

Also, how will you leave a negative review if you didn’t book the Airbnb yourself? Surely it’s the friend who booked the villa who will be invited to review after the stay is complete?

For bathrooms - use a restaurant’s, a shop’s or go to the train station. Unless you paid extra for a late check in, you can’t complain they’ve now got paying customers they need to welcome on that day.

purplecorkheart · 19/05/2022 16:20

To be honest I would be focusing on enjoying the holiday. As others have said the works could have happened unexpectedly so you cannot hold that against the host. She could have easily nip to a shop to pick up that day.

As you did not book you do not entirely know what the story is with the late check out. Unless they have it in writing and paying for late checkout then I would not expect the owner to delay check in.

I do not really think that you should be leaving a review. The person who made the booking should as they know exactly what the terms and conditions of the booking is.

Anna713 · 19/05/2022 16:03

The work on the line is all along the long railway line though. They must have known surely. Its major work replacing all the line from what I can see and it only takes place at night to avoid disruption to the trains. Having said that they are hammering away right now since 2 PM this afternoon. You need earplugs to sit in the garden. And the villa was expensive too!

OP posts:
Caspianberg · 19/05/2022 15:55

I also don’t think it’s really acceptable to give them a bad review regarding train line works.

yes you can say you pre arranged late check in which wasn’t then possible which is their problem. But you can’t leave a negative review on a property about something not in their control.

One negative review can really bring their overall rating down. I think on air B and B it’s actually in the conditions when you leave review that says you should only review the property and host, you can’t complain there’s a lack of bakery nearby or noisy road for example. Especially if as you say, it does accurately show on booking it’s location is next to a trainline. They aren’t deceiving you

Swipe left for the next trending thread