Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH pulling out of his friend's wedding due to this

261 replies

TeenyQueen · 19/05/2022 14:17

This is actually DH's AIBU.
17 years ago when DH was a uni student he gave his friend free dental treatment. DH is an extremely loyal friend and he is still good friends with all of his old school friends.

This particular friend, call him John, is a total waste of space and made no effort with DH for years so they just lost touch, and they fell out years ago because I didn't invite him to DH's surprise birthday party. Anyway, DH and John are both ushers at their mutual friend's wedding this autumn and completely randomly John messaged DH to say that he's having issues with the tooth DH treated 17 years (!) ago so he wants several thousand £ or he's going to take legal action against him. He also said that he was planning to discuss this at the wedding this autumn, so he was planning to ambush DH and cause a scene at their friend's wedding.

Now legally, John has zero case against DH because the treatment was done 17 years ago and there are other factors too, but now DH really doesn't want to go to this wedding and be forced to 'work' with
John for the whole day. He's actually worried that they'll end up getting into a fight if John tries to get into an argument with him. Their mutual friend, the groom, knows all about this and is annoyed with John, but still really wants DH to be there for him.

I can't go to the wedding because we have young DC and they haven't been invited, and the wedding is a 5 hour drive from home so we couldn't go up just for a day. I'm also breastfeeding the baby so I couldn't leave DC with anyone, not that we have family here who could look after them anyway.

So is DH BU wanting to back out, but I'm also a bit surprised that John will still be in the wedding party, even after he planned to use the wedding to ambush DH?

OP posts:
OhNoWhatYouGonnaDo · 19/05/2022 16:17

Presumably as a dental student he had indemnity arrangements in place if he was providing treatment under supervision? I'm a doctor, and if similar happened to me, I'd wait for any claim to come in, then pass it straight to my indemnity provider (+/- NHS Resolution). Not sure exactly how it works for dentists but presumably the same general principle. I'm not sure what John hopes to achieve with his ambush - it's not between him and DH, it's between John and the indemnity provider or dental school or whoever is responsible.

If I were DH, I'd make the groom and other mutual friends aware of the potential for drama. The groom needs to be aware so he can tell John to either keep quiet or stay away.

HedgehogintheFog · 19/05/2022 16:12

burnoutbabe · 19/05/2022 16:06

can;t he just pass on the details of the dental school and tell him he'll need to raise it with them. and see what the response back is. Try to look helpful.

This with bells on. It I were your DH, I would be bending over backwards to be helpful beforehand and still go to the wedding. I bet John won't actually say anything once they are there.

Sidisawetlettuce · 19/05/2022 16:07

Tessasanderson · 19/05/2022 14:26

Looks like John is an arsehole. Groom is an idiot to allow your DH to be put in this position. Groom can sort it in seconds by telling John he is an arsehole.

Sounds like DH is well shot of both of them and correctly deciding to pull out. Life is too short to put up with arseholes and people who allow others to be arseholes

That's a lot of arseholes.

burnoutbabe · 19/05/2022 16:06

can;t he just pass on the details of the dental school and tell him he'll need to raise it with them. and see what the response back is. Try to look helpful.

jessycake · 19/05/2022 16:01

I would show the messages to the mutual friend and let him decide

ElenaSt · 19/05/2022 15:55

If it was free dental work then there was no contract between either party so how can he sue?

TeenyQueen · 19/05/2022 15:50

@ivykaty44 the wedding is in central Scotland, we live in England. I know the 5 hour drive might sound like a cliche but in this case it's actually accurate!

Not important, but DH's friends aren't from uni, he's met them at primary/secondary school. Don't ask me why anyone is still friends with John, it must be some kind of Scottish loyalty thing.

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 19/05/2022 15:49

HummingQuietly · 19/05/2022 15:14

Now legally, John has zero case against DH because the treatment was done 17 years ago and there are other factors too, but now DH really doesn't want to go to this wedding and be forced to 'work' with
John for the whole day.

Ideally your DH should contact John ahead of the wedding, call his bluff, and calmly tell him to take it through his insurance. No one just stumps up thousands from their own money just to prevent a spurious case against them. John needs to know his blackmail is not going to work. I sympathise with your husband, but the grown up thing to do would be to face this off ahead of the wedding.

I think this is how to handle the situation and ensure your dh can attend the wedding.

BluebellField · 19/05/2022 15:46

If I was your DH, I would still go to the wedding. He's going to support his friend.

If John starts an argument, he will be the one to look stupid. He will be showing his true colours. If this does happen, your DH can remove himself from the room. He shouldn't even bother to engage in any arguments.

John should not ruin the wedding for your DH.

SunshineAndFizz · 19/05/2022 15:45

Luculentus · 19/05/2022 15:25

Given that the treatment was given in a supervised hospital clinic, if John has any cause of action it's against the hospital. It would probably be simplest for your husband to point that out to him and give him the address to which he should direct his claim.

100% this.

DH go to the wedding, it would be unfair to the groom. This isn't his fault.

Just calmly give this answer in a 'my hands are tied' way and say you don't want to talk about it any further, especially at the wedding.

VerveClique · 19/05/2022 15:42

Your DH needs to sort this with John straight away. The wedding is not until the autumn FFS!

"Hi John, I've heard you're having some bother with your tooth, you really should see your dentist about that. I know I did some work for you years ago, and if you want to have that looked into, then you will need to contact the school where I trained in the first instance. Also John, I don't appreciate you tying this up with the wedding, it's really got nothing to do with the groom."

And then let the groom know what he has done, and go to the wedding, and carry on with John like nothing has happened. If John brings it up - just repeat the above.

How awful for the groom to have to deal with one usher causing a problem with another usher like this. Out of friendship with the groom, your DH should deal with this as per the above.

godmum56 · 19/05/2022 15:42

so you can't go and that was never the plan? In that case I'd say that its entirely up to your DH and it would be a kindness in you to support him in his decision. I can see why the groom is not happy and if I was your DH I'd be talking it through with the groom but being clear that he doesn't want the issue to cause problems at the wedding so for the sake of peace, if John is going to be there then he won't be. Your DH can only control what he will decide to do, and its up to the groom to decide what he wants to do. FWIW I think your husband is being very adult about this....not putting the groom in a position where he needs to choose and not risking trouble at the wedding.

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 19/05/2022 15:38

According to the groom John has mentioned this tooth a couple of times over the years
Wonder what John's current Dentist has to say on the matter ......that's if John has one . Sounds like the type who would rather smoke weed and not spend money on his oral health ?

Quick Google search shows that weed has a detrimental effect on the gums ....
John is a CF

Sweepingeyelashes · 19/05/2022 15:38

It's 17 years later - there is nothing to suggest that damage was done by the treatment. Dental work is not eternal and neither are teeth. You know he's been using them for the last 17 years.

ivykaty44 · 19/05/2022 15:36

his days smoking weed

the smoking is more likely to be the cause of his tooth decay

AchatAVendre · 19/05/2022 15:35

So the free treatment was done legitimately at the dental hospital and John will have signed a disclaimer to say that he accepted the risks, etc.. Anyway, any claim is thoroughly time barred and even if it weren't, it would be against the dental hospital and not an individual student.

I think John is just a wannabee scammer full of empty threats and I'd still go if it was me and just discretely leave the reception early. I wouldn't let it affect my behaviour or my friendships.

I think all of them need to grow a backbone and stand up to John, particularly if they all professionals who met at uni. Surely they know its nonsense?

ivykaty44 · 19/05/2022 15:33

Good to see the standard MN 5 hour drive is still alive and well

I always want to ask where is it?

catandcoffee · 19/05/2022 15:33

This may have already been asked but if John is so awful, why is the groom having him in the wedding party.
To me he is choosing John over a decent man, so I would pull out of the wedding.

Who wants to attend a wedding where they are going to be harassed.

10HailMarys · 19/05/2022 15:32

If the groom knows that John was planning to use his wedding to 'ambush' DH and cause a scene, I'm amazed that he still wants John to be an usher. If someone was planning to cause a massive argument at my wedding for their personal gain, I'd have fucked them off out of it pretty quick.

amusedbush · 19/05/2022 15:28

This is mental. I had a root canal done ten years ago and now I need an extraction because the weakened tooth has now broken. Should I sue my old dentist??

John sounds like a waster who is out to get some cash wherever he can.

Luculentus · 19/05/2022 15:25

Given that the treatment was given in a supervised hospital clinic, if John has any cause of action it's against the hospital. It would probably be simplest for your husband to point that out to him and give him the address to which he should direct his claim.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 19/05/2022 15:25

Obviously dental students need real patients to practice on and DH offered John this free treatment to help him out.

I must say this would not be possible now - dental hospitals have a waiting list of patients, and you can't just perform surgery on your mates. Partly because the hospital/university rather than the student would be liable.

PutinIsAWarCriminal · 19/05/2022 15:24

The fact that your kids aren't invited and so you can't go means that the groom can't be that desperate for DH to be there. I don't think he should guilt him into going if he won't be comfortable with it. agree with this.

Luculentus · 19/05/2022 15:24

Reallyreallyborednow · 19/05/2022 15:19

John doesn't have a leg to stand on because he is way past the limitation period. The status of the treatment is irrelevant

from pp though it’s 3 years from the date you became aware of the negligent treatment?

so if john has only just had issues, and been told it’s due to the treatment 17 years ago, the clock now starts on the 3 years?

It's wildly unlikely that problems now stem from negligent treatment 17 years ago. Over that period it's much more likely that any problems John now has stem from other causes.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 19/05/2022 15:22

It's perfectly okay for your DH to back out in these circumstances, with apologies to the groom (although I personally would attend the wedding service at least).

I don't think it is reasonable to expect the groom to uninvite John, which I think is what you mean by "bit surprised he's still invited".

Either way, leave it up to your DH since they are his friends and not your problem!

Swipe left for the next trending thread