Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH pulling out of his friend's wedding due to this

261 replies

TeenyQueen · 19/05/2022 14:17

This is actually DH's AIBU.
17 years ago when DH was a uni student he gave his friend free dental treatment. DH is an extremely loyal friend and he is still good friends with all of his old school friends.

This particular friend, call him John, is a total waste of space and made no effort with DH for years so they just lost touch, and they fell out years ago because I didn't invite him to DH's surprise birthday party. Anyway, DH and John are both ushers at their mutual friend's wedding this autumn and completely randomly John messaged DH to say that he's having issues with the tooth DH treated 17 years (!) ago so he wants several thousand £ or he's going to take legal action against him. He also said that he was planning to discuss this at the wedding this autumn, so he was planning to ambush DH and cause a scene at their friend's wedding.

Now legally, John has zero case against DH because the treatment was done 17 years ago and there are other factors too, but now DH really doesn't want to go to this wedding and be forced to 'work' with
John for the whole day. He's actually worried that they'll end up getting into a fight if John tries to get into an argument with him. Their mutual friend, the groom, knows all about this and is annoyed with John, but still really wants DH to be there for him.

I can't go to the wedding because we have young DC and they haven't been invited, and the wedding is a 5 hour drive from home so we couldn't go up just for a day. I'm also breastfeeding the baby so I couldn't leave DC with anyone, not that we have family here who could look after them anyway.

So is DH BU wanting to back out, but I'm also a bit surprised that John will still be in the wedding party, even after he planned to use the wedding to ambush DH?

OP posts:
Kennykenkencat · 19/05/2022 17:12

I think your Dh is correct to back out and the groom is naive to think John will be on his best behaviour.

John sounds like he is spoiling for a fight and a fight will be what happens, with or without your Dh being there

stepuporshutup · 19/05/2022 17:12

Sorry op I should have read the full thread. Anyway John is an idiot and dh should stay away from him

Fudgeball123 · 19/05/2022 17:12

I would say DH shouldn't go if arsehole John is going. The latter is a loose canon. Just tell the groom he cannot go because AJ is planning to make a scene and DH doesn't want their day ruined. Then if groom wants DH there he will have to uninvite AJ.

Carrotten · 19/05/2022 17:12

It was 17 years ago carried out as a supervised student. This bloke has literally not a leg to stand on. If he wants to sue anyone it would be the dental school not your DH, but to be perfectly honest if work done as an early dental student has lasted 17 years he's basically giving your DH a glowing review.

Your DH should contact his indemnity. Make them aware and take their advise. But still go to the wedding, this John is being an idiot. If John raises it say okay, if you want to sue contact the dental school.

stepuporshutup · 19/05/2022 17:07

Is dh a dentist, how did he manage to give him free dental treatment. Why is the friend being such an idiot he cannot possibly think he can bring a court case after 17 years. So many unanswered questions is this even true sounds too bizarre to be real

Tessasanderson · 19/05/2022 17:06

Sidisawetlettuce · 19/05/2022 16:07

That's a lot of arseholes.

I know, i got carried away with arseholes. But sometimes it needs saying :-)

JennyAct3 · 19/05/2022 17:01

Wisest thing is not to go.

EcafTnuc · 19/05/2022 17:00

It may not be fair on the groom to cancel, however I question the person who is still friends with such a vile person.

Does the groom know John is planning on making a scene at the wedding?

The children / drive is a red herring as he was prepared to go outside of this situation cropping up.

I’d probably reply to John and tell him he won’t get anywhere with taking legal action due to the points you listed, and a wedding of a good friend is absolutely no place to make a scene about it, so he will in no uncertain terms be discussing this situation with him.

jessica2005 · 19/05/2022 16:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

jessica2005 · 19/05/2022 16:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

jessica2005 · 19/05/2022 16:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

FirewomanSam · 19/05/2022 16:49

Wild guess here but are you and your husband relatively well off compared with this John moron? It sounds like he’s heard you guys have some money and has decided to try and shake down your husband for the most ridiculous reason.

it’s so completely stupid and clear cut that if I were your husband I’d have to fully laugh in John’s face and say ‘nice try mate, if you’re serious you can contact the dental school but you’re obviously joking right? Good one’ and then don’t even entertain any further conversation about it.

Sweepingeyelashes · 19/05/2022 16:46

@ElenaSt
There is something called the law of torts... People can indeed sue without a contract. Not relevant in this case because it sounds like John agreed to be treated by a student dentist and he got free dental care as a result.

MercurialMonday · 19/05/2022 16:46

I wouldn't want to go to an event where I'd been told to be expected to be ambushed at.

I'd be more willing if I wasn't going by myself - but as that's not possible then why spend time and money for a event that you may end up nearer time dreading.

I expect the groom doesn't want to get involved in any way - thus hasn't rescinded John's invite - why open that can of worms for themsleves - but I also expect if anything did happen at the wedding both John and your DH would be blamed.

If your DH really wants to go - then getting other attendees on side and hoping they step in if John tries to kick off or trying to defuse situaton before hand with John are all worth trying - if he's not that bothered then I'd stick with not going.

Though I agree it may occur that face to face John doesn't end up saying anything or is actually fairly easy to shut down - but I assume yoru DH knows what he's like so can best judge that.

If groom really wanted him there he had option of rescinding John's invite or reassuring your DH that other's there will step in and help your DH defuse any potentail situations - so while he's saying he wants him there he's not actually done anything after being informed about John's behavior to make that possible.

HollowTalk · 19/05/2022 16:36

I agree with the poster who said your husband should refer him to his old dental school.

billy1966 · 19/05/2022 16:35

I think if your husband isn't interested in this drama then he doesn't have to go.

The groom knows what is going on and hasn't stepped in to sort John out.

The groom's choice of usher is HIS problem, if the usher is sending threatening texts to another member of the wedding party.

I don't blame your husband to not fancy a 5 hour drive to be in such company.

CorsicaDreaming · 19/05/2022 16:34

HSKAT · 19/05/2022 14:19

All ridiculous.

Your DH backing out of the wedding when it's not the grooms fault isn't fair.

John sounds like a nut job. Tell him to take legal action and see how far he gets, as you know, it won't be far.

This is it in a nutshell 🤣

Seems really unfair on the groom for your DH to back out over this.

John should be asked by the groom to promise not to raise it on the day - and if he cannot do that not to attend.

Then groom could be asked to ensure their usher duties are as far away from each other as possible (opposite sides of church for seating people, sitting on different tables for meal etc. )

Or... DH could go along with it and ask John to provide evidence for DH to consider / get advice on - photos / gp report / dental records and x-rays, etc - spin it out til after the wedding - tell him after the event that he is a CF and can stuff it where the sun don't shine... unless he may possibly have a case, as this may look like accepting some kind of responsibility..

Hawkins001 · 19/05/2022 16:30

TeenyQueen · 19/05/2022 15:20

With regards to the free treatment as someone asked, it was done at the dental hospital when DH was a student as part of his training. Obviously dental students need real patients to practice on and DH offered John this free treatment to help him out. There is absolutely zero legal case to answer to
A. Because DH was a student working under the supervision of clinical teachers and John would have signed a document to say he was happy being treated by a student.

B. It was such a long time ago that clinical records would have been destroyed a long time ago, hence no dental records

C. According to the groom John has mentioned this tooth a couple of times over the years but hasn't tried to make a claim, you have 12 months generally to make a claim once you notice a problem.

D. John is a waste of space who spends his days smoking weed and playing video games so I doubt he'd manage to actually speak to a solicitor.

He must know he's got no case so he's using this wedding as an opportunity to try to stir trouble.

with that in mind, call his bluff

Merryhobnobs · 19/05/2022 16:26

I am not sure what you mean about some sort of 'Scottish loyalty thing'. This has nothing to do with him being Scottish.

saraclara · 19/05/2022 16:25

speak to John and tell him to see his own dentist. If he has a complaint about the treatment 17 years ago he needs to contact the dental hospital where it was carried out. He also needs to explain that he can’t and will not discuss the matter further with John.

Whether or not this applies in this case, it's a useful strategy to use. "Sorry John, as it seems that you plan to take the legal course through this, I'm unable to discuss it with you, whether before, during or after the wedding, as doing so would affect your claim"

diddl · 19/05/2022 16:23

I think that it's entirely up to your husband tbh.

If he thinks that John might cause a scene & he cba with that then why not decline?

It sounds as if he might argue with Op's husband even if he does try to sort things out first.

Trivester · 19/05/2022 16:21

I this is a bit of an alcoholics prayer situation - change the things you can and accept the things you can’t actually control.

Your dh can make a decision not to go and hinbu but to decide what the groom should or shouldn’t do is not fair.

You have no idea what the relationship between John and the groom is, why he’s been asked to be an usher. Things that look manifestly unfair from one perspective might not be so clear cut from another.

I’m going to hazard a guess that the groom might be so used to accommodating John, that he doesn’t understand why your dh won’t (it’s a form of the Missing Stair Phenomenon if you want to Google that) so from his perspective it’s your dh who is being unreasonable here.

You can and should decide what your boundaries are, what you are personally comfortable with but you don’t have control over what other people think of you.

This could be a friendship breaker - for the groom because dh doesn’t come to his wedding, or for dh because the groom didn’t take his side.

Life throws up situations that show us things about our friends and loved ones that we’d rather not know. Sometimes there’s no clear cut right path to take - you just have to pick a path and accept the consequences.

headofpotsandpans · 19/05/2022 16:20

it must be some kind of Scottish loyalty thing

Just FYI, we're not all idiots who maintain friendships with horrible people just because they also happen to be Scottish.

HollowTalk · 19/05/2022 16:20

It sounds as though he hasn't gone to a dentist in the intervening years!

GenderAtheist · 19/05/2022 16:19

If your husband is a GDP then he should know what to do. Which is speak to John and tell him to see his own dentist. If he has a complaint about the treatment 17 years ago he needs to contact the dental hospital where it was carried out. He also needs to explain that he can’t and will not discuss the matter further with John.

Then your husband should refuse to discuss it with anyone including you and you should stop posting about it on the internet. Your husband has a duty of patient confidentiality to John.

He must also stop talking about it with the groom and explain why.

Your husband might consider contacting his defence union.

Im surprised that a practising dentist doesn’t seem to know the correct way to handle such matters.

Swipe left for the next trending thread