Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH pulling out of his friend's wedding due to this

261 replies

TeenyQueen · 19/05/2022 14:17

This is actually DH's AIBU.
17 years ago when DH was a uni student he gave his friend free dental treatment. DH is an extremely loyal friend and he is still good friends with all of his old school friends.

This particular friend, call him John, is a total waste of space and made no effort with DH for years so they just lost touch, and they fell out years ago because I didn't invite him to DH's surprise birthday party. Anyway, DH and John are both ushers at their mutual friend's wedding this autumn and completely randomly John messaged DH to say that he's having issues with the tooth DH treated 17 years (!) ago so he wants several thousand £ or he's going to take legal action against him. He also said that he was planning to discuss this at the wedding this autumn, so he was planning to ambush DH and cause a scene at their friend's wedding.

Now legally, John has zero case against DH because the treatment was done 17 years ago and there are other factors too, but now DH really doesn't want to go to this wedding and be forced to 'work' with
John for the whole day. He's actually worried that they'll end up getting into a fight if John tries to get into an argument with him. Their mutual friend, the groom, knows all about this and is annoyed with John, but still really wants DH to be there for him.

I can't go to the wedding because we have young DC and they haven't been invited, and the wedding is a 5 hour drive from home so we couldn't go up just for a day. I'm also breastfeeding the baby so I couldn't leave DC with anyone, not that we have family here who could look after them anyway.

So is DH BU wanting to back out, but I'm also a bit surprised that John will still be in the wedding party, even after he planned to use the wedding to ambush DH?

OP posts:
Baconandmaplesyrup · 20/05/2022 09:52

God your husband is so dramatic. Scared it will be a physical fight and won’t go to the wedding! Ffs. 😂 the non dramatic adult thing to do is jist gives a heads up to the groom, formally respond to the bloke and then make sure he’s never alone with the guy and doesn’t engage in an emotional way.

so much unnecessary drama, are you not giving him the side eye? I would be.

MintIceCream1 · 20/05/2022 09:41

If the groom knows what John is up to but still won't disinvite John, then I think it's more than fair for your DH not to attend. The groom should have DH's back, but he doesn't, therefore DH doesn't owe him anything.

In fact, it would be wise of your DH to tell the groom that him going will cause a scene at the wedding and it isn't fair to the groom or bride, so therefore he is bowing out, since John is still going.

In short, I advise your DH not to go, and to not feel guilty because the groom clearly doesn't care about DH's discomfort.

Findwen · 20/05/2022 08:40

Mumma Mia - No idea why that text came out so huge !! Any one know if that can be fixed ??

Findwen · 20/05/2022 08:39

Tell John to refer to the response given in Arkell vs Pressdram:

lettersofnote.com/2013/08/07/arkell-v-pressdram/

===================================================

Dear Sirs,

We acknowledge your letter of 29th April referring to Mr. J. Arkell.
We note that Mr Arkell’s attitude to damages will be governed by the nature of our reply and would therefore be grateful if you would inform us what his attitude to damages would be, were he to learn that the nature of our reply is as follows: fuck off.

Yours,
Private Eye

=====================================================

RedHelenB · 20/05/2022 07:41

TheYearOfSmallThings · 19/05/2022 15:25

Obviously dental students need real patients to practice on and DH offered John this free treatment to help him out.

I must say this would not be possible now - dental hospitals have a waiting list of patients, and you can't just perform surgery on your mates. Partly because the hospital/university rather than the student would be liable.

Not true of all places, at Newcastle you self refer for eg., no waiting list.

RedHelenB · 20/05/2022 07:33

Why is your dh allowing himself to be cowed by John. I can't believe he'd miss an old friends wedding over something so petty. If I were a gambler I'd kay money on John being as nice as pie when they're together.

NumberTheory · 20/05/2022 04:34

If I were DH I probably wouldn't want to go either. If John is as crazy as you make him sound there will be no way to avoid him or calm him down. What rational or reasonable person threatens to use a mutual friend's wedding as a way to corner someone on a legal matter? Chances of him making a scene sound very high and then friend's wedding is disrupted and DH has an awful time.

I would be inclined to tell groom that I'm sorry but really think turning up will lead to a scene, however much I try to avoid it, and I don't want to do that to his wedding day.

But what do his other friends think? John surely must have some form for this sort of behaviour? Do they think he would wreck friend's wedding to have a go at DH?

expat101 · 20/05/2022 04:27

I think it's in the Groom's best interest to nip this thing in the bud with John. I doubt the Bride would want any trouble at her wedding and this fellow John sounds like he is up for a bit of trouble making.

Changedagain876 · 20/05/2022 03:11

Your DH is right not to want to go. The groom should be telling John to stay home after what he’s done!

Pickabearanybear · 20/05/2022 01:04

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Sweepingeyelashes · 20/05/2022 00:56

No sane person suggests discussing a legal claim when you are both ushers at a wedding of a close friend.

crosstalk · 20/05/2022 00:11

Underailing.

1 DH emails John saying no chance mate
2 DH waits for response
3 DH talks to groom
4 Groom decides
5 DH considers going.

If John does continue to be invited if his texts are as presented, DH can consider pulling out - anyone planning to have it out with a fellow guest at a wedding is likely to continue to want to after a few drinks.

crosstalk · 20/05/2022 00:07

Derailing here. 5 hours is very likely if you go south to north or to Scotland. Or say rural Dorset to rural Suffolk or lord forbid north Norfolk. I gaily bingmapped a wedding which said 3.5 hours (rural Dorset to major Suffolk city) and after jams on the M25 and roadworks up past Stansted we got there 8 hours later. Luckily, we travelled the day before. Salisbury to Newcastle? Carlisle to Cornwall? Dungeness to Caernarvon? And god forbid weddings should be in the summer with holiday traffic.

Oceanus · 19/05/2022 23:45

What a shit situation to be in! If it were me I'd talk to groom and explain it all. Either the groom says "don't come, I don't want a scene" or he says "I'll uninvite the other guy". I wouldn't want to ruin sb else's special day with an argument and this John sounds like he wouldn't be able to stop himself. He sounds quite unreasonable.

Luculentus · 19/05/2022 23:17

ElenaSt · 19/05/2022 15:55

If it was free dental work then there was no contract between either party so how can he sue?

There doesn't have to be a contract for someone to be able to sue. If someone is injured in a car accident, they are highly unlikely to have any contract with the driver in question but they can still sue for damages.

However, in this case if John has any claim it is against the hospital as they were supervising and took responsibility.

declutteringmymind · 19/05/2022 22:41

DH needs to tell john that now that john has mentioned legal action, he's not going to discuss it further.

Maybe Dh send a 3 way text between groom, saying he wants to come to the wedding and support the groom so could John please give his assurances that he will not bring up the topic of his treatment that day.

LetitiaLeghorn · 19/05/2022 22:29

OuiWeeOui · 19/05/2022 21:56

@LetitiaLeghorn
because he doesn’t know when it’s going to happen
what part of the day it could happen … ruining their day & being on edge
Jesus , you are missing the point completely but you carry on trying to be clever 🙄🙄🙄

I wasn't trying to be clever. I can see someone might not look forward to being tackled over this. But calling it an ambush and walking into it alone, just amps up the dramatics.

saleorbouy · 19/05/2022 22:01

A claim for damages only goes back 7years so poor John isn't going to get very far on the legal front.
I think that he needs to learn to brush his teeth correctly and give up on his absurd claims about your DH's dental work.
Perhaps the best man should preempt John's ambush and include it in the best man's speech. Your DH could hand him a briefcase stuff full of fake bank notes..... maybe John would realise his claim is foolish and laughable then!😂

OuiWeeOui · 19/05/2022 21:56

@LetitiaLeghorn
because he doesn’t know when it’s going to happen
what part of the day it could happen … ruining their day & being on edge
Jesus , you are missing the point completely but you carry on trying to be clever 🙄🙄🙄

WhereYouLeftIt · 19/05/2022 21:33

LetitiaLeghorn · 19/05/2022 21:03

What?! The op says:

John messaged DH to say that he's having issues with the tooth DH treated 17 years (!)* ago so he wants several thousand £ or he's going to take legal action against him. He also said that he was planning to discuss this at the wedding this autumn, so he was planning to ambush DH and cause a scene at their friend's wedding.

How is any of this blackmail, extortion or demanding with menaces? He's asking for compensation or taking legal action. Whether he's off his trolley to expect compensation or not, it's perfectly reasonable to write first before seeking legal redress. He wasn't planning to ambush the ops husband because he told him in advance he'd speak to him at the wedding. Any expectation of a scene or a fight is totally the ops surmisal and has no basis in fact.

"he wants several thousand £ or he's going to take legal action"

How exactly is this NOT extortion? He's clearly not going to be 'seeking legal redress' - he's trying to intimidate OP's DH. He has no case and that makes it extortion.

The work was done 17 years ago at a dental hospital under the supervision of the dental tutors there. Geez, I've had work (done by my qualified and experienced dentist) redone sooner than 17 years (fillings, crowns) because that is the nature of dental work.

LetitiaLeghorn · 19/05/2022 21:03

2bazookas · 19/05/2022 20:42

Sounds like straightforward blackmail/extortion/demanding money with menaces, which are crimes. I'd refer it to the police.

What?! The op says:

John messaged DH to say that he's having issues with the tooth DH treated 17 years (!)* ago so he wants several thousand £ or he's going to take legal action against him. He also said that he was planning to discuss this at the wedding this autumn, so he was planning to ambush DH and cause a scene at their friend's wedding.

How is any of this blackmail, extortion or demanding with menaces? He's asking for compensation or taking legal action. Whether he's off his trolley to expect compensation or not, it's perfectly reasonable to write first before seeking legal redress. He wasn't planning to ambush the ops husband because he told him in advance he'd speak to him at the wedding. Any expectation of a scene or a fight is totally the ops surmisal and has no basis in fact.

H1Drangea · 19/05/2022 20:59

It’s DH problem
though , if it were my DH , he wouldn’t be going … because he wouldn’t travel all that distance leaving me behind with the uninvited DC
he needs to phone the groom and advise him that he sadly is unable to attend ,
arsehole friend can do what he likes

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 19/05/2022 20:47

None of this is anything to do with you. Let them sort it out themselves.

2bazookas · 19/05/2022 20:42

Sounds like straightforward blackmail/extortion/demanding money with menaces, which are crimes. I'd refer it to the police.

splishsplashsploshsplish · 19/05/2022 20:33

I would definitely pay out for a lawyers letter. Put an end to this bullshit asap. Not worth having it hanging over him for the wedding.