Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH pulling out of his friend's wedding due to this

261 replies

TeenyQueen · 19/05/2022 14:17

This is actually DH's AIBU.
17 years ago when DH was a uni student he gave his friend free dental treatment. DH is an extremely loyal friend and he is still good friends with all of his old school friends.

This particular friend, call him John, is a total waste of space and made no effort with DH for years so they just lost touch, and they fell out years ago because I didn't invite him to DH's surprise birthday party. Anyway, DH and John are both ushers at their mutual friend's wedding this autumn and completely randomly John messaged DH to say that he's having issues with the tooth DH treated 17 years (!) ago so he wants several thousand £ or he's going to take legal action against him. He also said that he was planning to discuss this at the wedding this autumn, so he was planning to ambush DH and cause a scene at their friend's wedding.

Now legally, John has zero case against DH because the treatment was done 17 years ago and there are other factors too, but now DH really doesn't want to go to this wedding and be forced to 'work' with
John for the whole day. He's actually worried that they'll end up getting into a fight if John tries to get into an argument with him. Their mutual friend, the groom, knows all about this and is annoyed with John, but still really wants DH to be there for him.

I can't go to the wedding because we have young DC and they haven't been invited, and the wedding is a 5 hour drive from home so we couldn't go up just for a day. I'm also breastfeeding the baby so I couldn't leave DC with anyone, not that we have family here who could look after them anyway.

So is DH BU wanting to back out, but I'm also a bit surprised that John will still be in the wedding party, even after he planned to use the wedding to ambush DH?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SnozPoz · 22/05/2022 15:49

John's a knob and it sounds like he's come up with this ridiculous story because he wants to bully your DH into not going. So DH should absolutely go and if the accusations come up just laugh it off and ignore him.

FantasticButtocks · 22/05/2022 15:16

John is either trying to screw money out of your DH, or perhaps attempting to get DH's services for free for whatever dentistry he now needs doing!

In either case, he is an unpleasant chancer and nobody should give him any satisfaction in any way.

Changechangychange · 22/05/2022 10:02

browneyes77 · 21/05/2022 14:10

John is being unreasonable, but he is neither using extortion nor blackmailing DH.

He is threatening to take him to court. He stands no chance.

He is demanding money in return for not taking legal action. He is not just threatening him with court.

That’s what “settling out of court” is.

Yes it sounds like John has no case and is hoping to be paid to go away, but settling out of court is not extortion.

Do you think employees who accept a settlement in return for not going to tribunal are “extorting” money from their employer? Was Coleen Rooney attempting extortion when she tried to settle with Rebekah Vardey?

Most people try to avoid court, and are happy to settle if they can. Now obviously if this is an entirely frivolous case the dentist probably feels differently, but it isn’t illegal for the claimant to suggest it.

Earlydancing · 21/05/2022 22:52

browneyes77 · 21/05/2022 14:10

John is being unreasonable, but he is neither using extortion nor blackmailing DH.

He is threatening to take him to court. He stands no chance.

He is demanding money in return for not taking legal action. He is not just threatening him with court.

Of course he is! How on earth do people get money they believe they're owed if they don't ask the complainee for it? You say why you believe someone owes you money and you inform them if they refuse to pay, you'll take them to court.

If you leave your laptop in the back garden, and your neighbours child climbs the fence, plays with it and breaks it, you'd ask for the parents to refund you the cost of a new one. If they refused you'd take the matter to the claims court for the matter to be adjudicated on.

That's neither extortion nor blackmail. It's just getting redress in the court system.

007Stocko · 21/05/2022 17:25

Your husband needs to talk it through with the groom. He needs to make it plain that the only reason he would pull out is to ensure that nothing can happen between he and John that could possibly upset the wedding day.

BooneyBeautiful · 21/05/2022 16:50

Roghtab · 19/05/2022 14:20

What a horrible situation!

It would be a shame for your DH not to go to the wedding though. I'd suggest he goes but ignores John as much as possible. They can't fight if your DH doesn't engage with him.

This. Tell DH to just ignore John completely.

Isaidnoalready · 21/05/2022 15:44

I would avoid it what if he tries serving papers at the church

Roo4u · 21/05/2022 15:42

The tooth will come out

browneyes77 · 21/05/2022 14:10

John is being unreasonable, but he is neither using extortion nor blackmailing DH.

He is threatening to take him to court. He stands no chance.

He is demanding money in return for not taking legal action. He is not just threatening him with court.

NicholaSE13 · 21/05/2022 14:08

I’m a health professional and wouldn’t go near anyone threatening me with legal action. It’s asking for trouble.

orangeisthenewpuce · 21/05/2022 14:00

Unpopular opinion but I think your husband should kick the shit out of skanky little weasel John at the end of the night in a quiet corner. I know this will never happen but I felt better for your DH just typing this Grin

DeskInUse · 21/05/2022 12:48

Can the groom have a word with friends at the wedding and say that if John stays to step out of line they will intervene and kick him out. That way the groom won't have to worry on the day and your dh won't have to deal with it on his own

mumofmany81 · 21/05/2022 11:17

TeenyQueen · 21/05/2022 08:26

The groom spoke to DH about it last night and said that he will speak to John to say that this matter will absolutely not be discussed at the wedding and John needs to behave himself. Hopefully knowing that the groom knows about his behaviour will make John pull out. The groom is supportive of DH but I don't think he understands the full malicious intent behind John's actions.

The reason that this is such a big deal is that John is threatening to make an official complaint, which will take up DH's time and energy even if the complaint is completely baseless. In a profession like his reputation is everything, and DH has worked like a dog to build a great reputation and takes great pride in his work. In a worse case scenario even his registration and livelihood might be at risk, although John's claim is so ridiculous that it won't come to that. But basically someone making an official complaint against you is very serious, and to use that as a threat to get money from you is just outrageous.

Had John come to DH in a calm and civil manner asking for his help DH would actually have done his best to try to help him out. Instead he went straight to give me money or 'I will have no choice but to put an official complaint against you'.

I get that it’s a horrible situation, but I don’t think your husband should worry with regard to the complaint. I’m not sure what the deal is in dentistry, but in the NHS (for nurses etc), notes are kept for 7 years and you have that time to bring a case about any injury caused by malpractice. In midwifery it is the same, except for when it’s the baby who has been injured , rather than the mother. In that case it’s 25 years (18 years for the baby to become an adult and then the standard 7 years). The guy can make a complaint to whoever the Governing body is for dentists (for us it’s the Nursing and Midwifery Council), but only if your husband has done something that would bring the reputation of the profession into disrepute and not because he’s unhappy with some treatment he received 17 years ago.

With regard to the personal side of this though, I can only imagine how hurt and angry your husband is. This guy sounds absolutely awful, as well as being ungrateful for the fact he received free dental treatment. I can totally understand that he wouldn’t want to be a part of the wedding, but I think if I was him I would be a bit annoyed with the groom too. He knows what’s going on, agrees with your husband and is annoyed with John and yet is keeping him in the wedding party. Why, why, why would anyone want to be friends with someone like that?

saraclara · 21/05/2022 09:58

I'm glad the groom is having words with John. Given that John had already thrown a hissy fit and refused to go on the stag, I think it highly likely that he'll pull out of the wedding too. Let's hope so

browneyes77 · 21/05/2022 09:50

Dashdotdotdash · 21/05/2022 08:36

What does the groom propose to do if John agrees not to mention this at the wedding but breaks his promise? He needs to have some sort of effective sanction that means John keeps to his word.

Good point

browneyes77 · 21/05/2022 09:48

But basically someone making an official complaint against you is very serious, and to use that as a threat to get money from you is just outrageous.

Had John come to DH in a calm and civil manner asking for his help DH would actually have done his best to try to help him out. Instead he went straight to give me money or 'I will have no choice but to put an official complaint against you'.

Me being the person I am, would’ve sent a message back to John to say “Threatening someone for money, is blackmail/extortion. I will have no choice but to contact the Police and put in a complaint about YOU John, should you persist in threatening me in this way. So do not attempt to bring this up at the wedding and disrupt grooms day. I’ve advised you of the correct channels to take up your concerns. I will not discuss the matter further”.

Might make him shit his pants enough to back off. Obviously it might not, but I wouldn’t be able to resist letting him know that I can make official complaints about him too. I’ve always loved the lesson of the old ‘playing people at their own game’.

But like I said, that’s just me! 😁😁

I think your DH is behaving very honourably and respectfully, trying to ensure the grooms day isn’t ruined by John the Dickhead.

zingally · 21/05/2022 09:19

I think this is DH's call to make. It all depends HOW much he wants to go to the wedding.
Leave it up to him to decide, and he can deal with the fall-out either way.

Dashdotdotdash · 21/05/2022 08:36

What does the groom propose to do if John agrees not to mention this at the wedding but breaks his promise? He needs to have some sort of effective sanction that means John keeps to his word.

burnoutbabe · 21/05/2022 08:35

Ah that's good. I think as long as groom has said to John that he doesn't wants it discussed, hubby can go,conscience cleans.
If John kicks off then groom was for-armed.

Dashdotdotdash · 21/05/2022 08:34

If John is that convinced of the rightness of his cause, surely he would follow your DH's advice and go after the hospital?

The reality is that he thinks he can bully/blackmail it out of your husband. I suspect ultimately your husband will have to tell him sue/complain or be damned. For what it's worth, I doubt that a ridiculous complaint will really affect your DH much. Friends of mine who are lawyers reckon its virtually a rite of passage to have at least one client make a ludicrous official complaint against them.

TeenyQueen · 21/05/2022 08:26

The groom spoke to DH about it last night and said that he will speak to John to say that this matter will absolutely not be discussed at the wedding and John needs to behave himself. Hopefully knowing that the groom knows about his behaviour will make John pull out. The groom is supportive of DH but I don't think he understands the full malicious intent behind John's actions.

The reason that this is such a big deal is that John is threatening to make an official complaint, which will take up DH's time and energy even if the complaint is completely baseless. In a profession like his reputation is everything, and DH has worked like a dog to build a great reputation and takes great pride in his work. In a worse case scenario even his registration and livelihood might be at risk, although John's claim is so ridiculous that it won't come to that. But basically someone making an official complaint against you is very serious, and to use that as a threat to get money from you is just outrageous.

Had John come to DH in a calm and civil manner asking for his help DH would actually have done his best to try to help him out. Instead he went straight to give me money or 'I will have no choice but to put an official complaint against you'.

OP posts:
RachaelN · 21/05/2022 05:59

If I was the groom and I knew about John's behaviour then John would be swiftly uninvited. What awful behaviour from a grown man that has had 17 good years with the dental work.
CF!

Ortega888 · 21/05/2022 00:56

I think your husband is doing the sensible thing by not going as John sounds like a trouble maker he will ruin the wedding. It’s best your husband stays away and at least the groom knows why he won’t be there. It would be awkward if he went as anything could go wrong. It’s the perfect excuse to back out I am surprised the groom hadn’t banned John as it’s a ticking time bomb and these things can turn nasty especially at a wedding where anything can happen. Let us know how it goes.

yzed · 21/05/2022 00:39

Exactly so. This shouldn't involve the groom. Or the bride. Or any of the other guests.
The only way DH can be sure to avoid those things is by avoiding the wedding - at least the after-party.

He could try discussing with John first, but if John's the sort of person to think a wedding's the ideal time for this discussion I wouldn't trust him not to revisit the topic on the day.
He could explain to the groom, then say no more and let him decide what he wants to do. (DH should be very clear that in the current circumstances he simply can't attend. Don't let groom think if he does nothing DH will turn up.)
The only other option I can see is to visit at a convenient date and take bride and groom for a meal.
Unless this is a massive wind up. Does John have a very dark sense of humour? Is this a result of not seeing each other for years, and the dentistry is the first thing that comes to John's mind to have a laugh over. Is he, perhaps, still very grateful for that generous gift?
Please DH, protect your sensitive and precious hands.

saraclara · 20/05/2022 23:05

If I knew someone was trying to extort or blackmail one of the other guests they wouldn't be invited to my wedding.

John is being unreasonable, but he is neither using extortion nor blackmailing DH.

He is threatening to take him to court. He stands no chance. He's stupid, but he's not doing anything that should involve the groom.

Swipe left for the next trending thread