Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How should this holiday bill be split?

143 replies

aibuuname · 19/05/2022 13:21

AIBU to think we are being short changed in this set up? As a disclaimer I don't think I will kick up a fuss this time as its a pretty good deal regardless but interested to see what would be considered normal for such a situation incase it arises again.
4 couples, 2 couples have 2 young children each between 3-7, one couple has a small baby and myself and DH are childless. We are all going away for 4 nights booked for September. Now I love my friends children and am excited to spend time with them all as we all live spread out and its been hard to see each other often due to covid etc. However its been assumed the villa bill will be split 4 ways is this normal? all my previous trips where pre-children with this group or with other childless couples. It feels a bit like us and the couple with the baby are subsidizing the cost of the older children as they will be sharing 2 rooms between them and therefore it would be fairer if the bill was split by room. Particularly as a 4 bed villa would cost quite a bit less than a 6 bed one.
As I say I don't plan to cause a fuss over this as its a good deal, i'm excited to go and we can afford it but I'm wondering if this is normal and cautious about setting up a precedent for any future trips.

OP posts:
Aprilx · 19/05/2022 14:25

resuwen · 19/05/2022 13:57

I've taken part in a lot of shared holidays weekends over the years with various combinations of a large group of friends. Kids always go free. Sometimes there are extra rooms and they get a cushy spot. Sometimes we're squashed and they get a ready bed on the floor. Families have anywhere between three and no children. Mine are older now and sometimes don't go. It's only the adults that pay. This makes things nice and simple!

Maybe your child free friends weren’t as happy with the arrangement as you were though.

Sofasogood1 · 19/05/2022 14:23

Do you know what though - I said split by room but if this was couples and one singleton I'm not sure it would feel right splitting by room, essentially making the singleton pay double what everyone else does.

Never super easy is it!

Alovelydayatlast · 19/05/2022 14:19

They are Cfers aren't they? Bet they try to split food bills in the same manner!!

countrygirl99 · 19/05/2022 14:17

When we did a group holiday with 3 other families adults counted as 1, children over 2 as half and under 2 weren't counted. We added all the costs of accommodation, food etc and split on that basis.

thisplaceisweird · 19/05/2022 14:17

If there was a small bunk bed room I would let it drop. But, I would have to text and say 'since all the rooms are the same, might it be fairer to split by room rather than by couple?' maybe get baby couple on board behind the scenes before you mention. They probably just haven't thought of it like this.

Thing is, if a couple liked to sleep in separate beds, and got a bedroom each, they would of course be expected to pay for the extra space, the group wouldn't subsidise it. There's no difference.

BuanoKubiamVej · 19/05/2022 14:11

My friends and I do lots of holidays like this. Our attitude is that it's just as unfair for the people with kids to pay double as it is for them to pay no extra at all. A family of 2 adults and 2 kids does not actually get double the value out of the holiday compared to a couple without kids, and certainly a 2 bed holiday home doesn't cost anywhere near twice a 1-bed of similar standard. We split half the cost per bedroom and half the cost per family which means that the people with kids pay a little more than those without but nowhere near half. This also allows the families who want to economise by having the kids on floor matresses in one bedroom can pay less than the ones who want a separate bedroom for their kids.

I don't think there's anything wrong with raising this. If you're good friends then no one will be offended if you just say "what do people suggest is the fairest way to split the costs? Doesn't seem fair for {XXX} to pay double what {YYY} pay but doesn't seem fair for them to be exactly the same either. Any suggestions for a sensible split that's fair to all?"

TidyDancer · 19/05/2022 14:10

I think I would split by room, and I say this as someone who has two DCs and would therefore need to pay more in this scenario. If you don't feel comfortable suggesting this, perhaps they could absorb increased costs in another way, such as paying for activities or food or something like that. I definitely don't think you should be subsiding their DCs though, certainly not to this degree.

AtwilightRebellion · 19/05/2022 14:09

If all rooms are of same calibre then its split by room. Anything less is unfair.

I say this as a villa owner and frequent villa renter.

Your friends need to pay for the second room they will be occupying.

ZekeZeke · 19/05/2022 14:04

I'm not sure. The villa sounds great but I would probably split it per family.

That said, not a hope in hell I would be going on holidays as a child free couple with two couples and their young children. This would be hellish for me.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 19/05/2022 14:00

charge by room.

Not quite sure why you'd put yourself through this though tbh- to hang out with lots of other peoples young children, I foresee no end of issues from costs/activities etc.

GhoulWithADragonTattoo · 19/05/2022 13:58

When we've done this it's usually worked out that children in their own beds are half the costs of adults and (no charge for babies toddlers in parents rooms). Possibly because their rooms have been much smaller.

resuwen · 19/05/2022 13:57

I've taken part in a lot of shared holidays weekends over the years with various combinations of a large group of friends. Kids always go free. Sometimes there are extra rooms and they get a cushy spot. Sometimes we're squashed and they get a ready bed on the floor. Families have anywhere between three and no children. Mine are older now and sometimes don't go. It's only the adults that pay. This makes things nice and simple!

Caulidop · 19/05/2022 13:57

I would most definitely expect to pay more if my family was using 2 rooms. Splitting 4 ways isn't reasonable, unless both you and couple with baby have said explicitly that you are happy to do this for whatever reason without any pressure to do so. CF's!

Portiasparty · 19/05/2022 13:53

Sharrowgirl · 19/05/2022 13:49

You split by room because the price of the accommodation goes up as the number of bedrooms goes up.

The families using two rooms should be paying 2/6ths each and the couples having one room pay 1/6th each.

This. It's just like paying the extra for children's meals. Why should childfree people subsidise those with children?

Livercool · 19/05/2022 13:52

Oh, just saw the rooms were all the same size with en suites so ignore my comment. Sounds like nice accommodation!

mewkins · 19/05/2022 13:52

How about a child is a half. The baby is free. So split it by people rather than rooms. Agreed that the kids room is usually a small bunk room or something.

So split the total 12 ways and have the couples with kids pay for 3x12ths each. The couple with no kids and the ones with babies just pay 1/6 of the bill each. Sorry if I have miscounted!

Sharrowgirl · 19/05/2022 13:49

You split by room because the price of the accommodation goes up as the number of bedrooms goes up.

The families using two rooms should be paying 2/6ths each and the couples having one room pay 1/6th each.

Lilifer · 19/05/2022 13:46

Why would you be expected to subsidize their kids rooms??

theEndisFar · 19/05/2022 13:45

In that case OP just reply and say since the rooms are all equal shall we not split by room then. See what they say to that.

Livercool · 19/05/2022 13:45

I think if you are going to expect the children to pay the same for a room as the adults you need to bear that in mind when allocating rooms. You can't stick the kids in the box rooms and have a double with an en suite if the kids have paid the same as you for their room. Perhaps the couples with children should pay 1.5 times what the couples without pay and use the smaller rooms. It is unlikely the rooms will all be master bedrooms. If the couples only using one bedroom each manage to get the master bedrooms with en suites and the couples with children get 2 smaller rooms each I think you should all split the bill equally. You can't charge them more whilst getting better accommodation than them.

Lilifer · 19/05/2022 13:44

Surely the two couples with young kids pay two sixths each and the couple with baby and you just put one sixth each??

theEndisFar · 19/05/2022 13:44

“Whilst your in the king” - do we still not have an edit button for poor typers like me 😏

aibuuname · 19/05/2022 13:43

Looks like its not normal
It is a couple with 2 kids assuming we will split but they are also the ones who found the villa and are doing the booking so perhaps more of an oversight than intentional cheeky fuckery. All 6 bedrooms are full sized doubles with ensuites, I think that's why its grated on me a bit it would seem less unfair if the kids where in an obvious kids bedroom with bunk beds etc.
The baby will be staying in the same room as her parents as she's only 4 months old.
Food I am not to worried about as we have all eaten out together plenty of times children included and this has never been an issue, I doubt we will be doing much cooking in the villa for foodshops etc. to become a problem.

OP posts:
theEndisFar · 19/05/2022 13:42

Agree with the above poster re the room types. If they are all equally nice (size en suit etc) then splitting by room would be fair. However, if the kids room is smallest no en suite and their parents a double whisky your in the kind with en suite then I can see arguments for a different split. This is why I hate going away with anyone else 😂

butteriesplease · 19/05/2022 13:42

hi, we do this quite often. rather than split by room, adults pay a bigger share of the total price than kids. I can't remember what the split is, but it's essentially a per head price, with dogs going free (!) and kids being much lower than adults (as of course, they don't earn a salary...). I'm sure someone here will have an idea of sensible split.