Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How should this holiday bill be split?

143 replies

aibuuname · 19/05/2022 13:21

AIBU to think we are being short changed in this set up? As a disclaimer I don't think I will kick up a fuss this time as its a pretty good deal regardless but interested to see what would be considered normal for such a situation incase it arises again.
4 couples, 2 couples have 2 young children each between 3-7, one couple has a small baby and myself and DH are childless. We are all going away for 4 nights booked for September. Now I love my friends children and am excited to spend time with them all as we all live spread out and its been hard to see each other often due to covid etc. However its been assumed the villa bill will be split 4 ways is this normal? all my previous trips where pre-children with this group or with other childless couples. It feels a bit like us and the couple with the baby are subsidizing the cost of the older children as they will be sharing 2 rooms between them and therefore it would be fairer if the bill was split by room. Particularly as a 4 bed villa would cost quite a bit less than a 6 bed one.
As I say I don't plan to cause a fuss over this as its a good deal, i'm excited to go and we can afford it but I'm wondering if this is normal and cautious about setting up a precedent for any future trips.

OP posts:
jessica2005 · 19/05/2022 16:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Clymene · 19/05/2022 16:41

BuanoKubiamVej · 19/05/2022 14:11

My friends and I do lots of holidays like this. Our attitude is that it's just as unfair for the people with kids to pay double as it is for them to pay no extra at all. A family of 2 adults and 2 kids does not actually get double the value out of the holiday compared to a couple without kids, and certainly a 2 bed holiday home doesn't cost anywhere near twice a 1-bed of similar standard. We split half the cost per bedroom and half the cost per family which means that the people with kids pay a little more than those without but nowhere near half. This also allows the families who want to economise by having the kids on floor matresses in one bedroom can pay less than the ones who want a separate bedroom for their kids.

I don't think there's anything wrong with raising this. If you're good friends then no one will be offended if you just say "what do people suggest is the fairest way to split the costs? Doesn't seem fair for {XXX} to pay double what {YYY} pay but doesn't seem fair for them to be exactly the same either. Any suggestions for a sensible split that's fair to all?"

Of course they do! The OP and her husband are literally subsidising her friends. Food, fair enough not to include little kids because they eat bugger all but when it comes to holiday accommodation, it's always costed on how many beds.

justlonelystars · 19/05/2022 16:40

I disagree with the majority here and think the bill should be split between the adults. The children aren’t contributed financially to their families so why should they have to pay? Plus the kids will probably be given the worst rooms - perhaps they should get first dibs if the parents are paying double what the other two couples are!

Alwayswonderedwhy · 19/05/2022 16:39

I think it's rude of the others not to offer to pay more. We have 3dc and pay extra or a least offer when splitting costs with friends who have one or two. You should've brought it up before booking really.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 19/05/2022 16:32

If the couple booking the place have chosen somewhere that the children get en suite double rooms and then they’re expecting to split the bill four ways, they are not good friends, they are pisstaking freeloaders.

As all the rooms are equal size and quality, the cost should be split by room.

getsomehelp · 19/05/2022 16:30

I rented a chalet with my 2 brothers, they were accompanied by their wives. I thought we should divide by number of people. (I also took the room with single beds with small bathroom across the hall )
One couple had a lovely master suite with balcony, the other had a large double room & nice bathroom
One brother said I should pay a 1/5
the other said I should pay 1/3 because they were sharing a room, & I was on my own... (In a room with single beds)
I had organized it all & sorted the car...did a lot of the cooking & most of the washing up. I paid 1/5, I still wonder if it wonder if I was wrong.....

whiteonesugar · 19/05/2022 16:29

We went on holiday a few years ago with another couple with a child (we had 1 DC at the time) and one couple without DC (well, theirs are adults, so didnt come!) - we split per person so us and the other couple paid for 3 people and 3rd couple paid for 2.

HollowTalk · 19/05/2022 16:29

What is difference in cost between a four-bed and a six-bed villa? If it's easy to work out, then the families with kids should really pay the difference.

As far as going out for meals is concerned, I'd be happy to split that four ways as kids' meals aren't that expensive.

Lolllllllllllll · 19/05/2022 16:20

Younger folk nowadays just buy individually at the pub and at first I thought that was a bit weird but it seems to work. No-one is forced into drinking faster to keep up with the rounds, no-one feels obliged to get an alcoholic drink instead of a soft drink just to get their moneys worth and no-one gets to take advantage by skipping off when it's their round

A lot of us 'older' folk do this nowadays too. It's so much easier if everyone simply pays for themselves.

GlitteryGreen · 19/05/2022 16:10

I think on this occasion, given that you're happy with the cost and see it as a bit of a bargain, I'd just leave it.

But in the future when it could work out more expensive, I'd say something then. Nothing wrong with saying "We didn't say anything last time as it was a good deal for us all, but tbh this time it's working out way more expensive for us, is there any way we could split by room/per person instead?"

Sushi7 · 19/05/2022 16:08

The couples with 2 dc each are cf to expect a childless couple and a couple with a baby to cover their costs. Divide the total cost of the villa by 6 (as in 6 rooms). You pay 1/6, the couple with a baby pays 1/6. The rest of the cost is divided between the other 2 couples. I would definitely say something because you’ll forever be treated like mugs and forever walked on.

BinBandit · 19/05/2022 15:58

It's like buying drinks where there are two couples and two singles, it should be my round every sixth round but the two couples are each classed as a single unit so it works out as every fourth round. Not a massive amount but still annoying.

That's madness, if it's two couples then it's a round each couple but if it's a mixed group then clearly it's by person?

Younger folk nowadays just buy individually at the pub and at first I thought that was a bit weird but it seems to work. No-one is forced into drinking faster to keep up with the rounds, no-one feels obliged to get an alcoholic drink instead of a soft drink just to get their moneys worth and no-one gets to take advantage by skipping off when it's their round. Everyone just has what it suits them to have and therefore completely fair and healthier alcohol consumption wise.

BluebellField · 19/05/2022 15:57

You should definitely raise it. Suggest you split per room.

A four room villa would be significantly cheaper than a six room one.

I don't see how this can be an oversight. I think they're being cheeky tbh.

gunnersgold · 19/05/2022 15:54

I divide by the people going and times by the number in each party .
So for example 12 in party , divide total by 12 and the family of 4 pay 4 times that divided amount and etc etc between the parties

Def not divided between families . That's unfair unless of course it's a villa and you wouldn't be able to have it unless everyone else did .

BinBandit · 19/05/2022 15:53

Although mine are grown up now, it was always split by room even when they were younger. Sometimes it wasn't a straight split as not all the rooms were equal, but I always paid and expected to pay. The only time we didn't was a big family weekend of about 20 folk and the only kids were ours and they had a box room with bunk beds in it. Actually by the time you did a split our extra cost was a saving of buttons to the others. We just brought some extra wine - that seemed pretty fair :)

GoodThinkingMax · 19/05/2022 15:51

You do need to say something before you all go, because otherwise you'll be splitting the food bills 4 ways as well ...

LadyCatStark · 19/05/2022 15:49

I hate things like this! The family with more kids always wants it split between adults and the family with less also wants it by room (I’m in the by room camp BTW but we only have 1 child).

we went away with a family last year and they booked a hotel and expected us to split the cost equally despite them needing 2 hotel rooms. We’ll not book that way again, we’ll book for ourselves!

saraclara · 19/05/2022 15:44

JudgeJ · 19/05/2022 15:38

It's like buying drinks where there are two couples and two singles, it should be my round every sixth round but the two couples are each classed as a single unit so it works out as every fourth round. Not a massive amount but still annoying.

Exactly my issue, as mentioned earlier. But though it would be okay to question the share of the costs for this villa,.no single person would dare mention the drinks round issue. Even though it's far more pervasive and a regular issue rather than a one off holiday problem, mentioning it would be social suicide. I don't think it ever crosses any couples' minds that it's unfair, and any single person bringing it up would be seen as a cheapskate.

JudgeJ · 19/05/2022 15:38

Sofasogood1 · 19/05/2022 13:27

Obviously by room. I hate it when people do this. I'm still sore about a self catering holiday I went on with friends years ago when everyone took turns to cook - the couples cooked together and split the food bill between them. As the only single I had to pay on my own for everyone's dinner one night. Very unfair.

I'd just drop them a message and say - aren't we paying for the bedrooms we're using?'

It's like buying drinks where there are two couples and two singles, it should be my round every sixth round but the two couples are each classed as a single unit so it works out as every fourth round. Not a massive amount but still annoying.

MajorCarolDanvers · 19/05/2022 15:35

Split by bedrooms.

Lolllllllllllll · 19/05/2022 15:21

It's so complicated! Split by rooms seems easiest.
I'd watch splitting bills when you go out to eat. The kids might not be having kids meals anymore.

OurChristmasMiracle · 19/05/2022 15:16

I would look at the difference in price so if a 4 bed would be £500 and a 6 bed is £600 I would spilt the original by 4 so £125 each and then the extra £100 difference would be split between to 2 couples needing an extra room

so couple 1- no kids pays £125
couple 2- baby pays £125
couples with kids pay £175 each

if eating out etc you all pay for your own

CocktailsOnTheBeach · 19/05/2022 15:13

I'd split by room or make it so they at least pay more. For example if it was £1000 you and 1 child couple pay £200 and couples with 2 children £300, so they pay a 1/3 more. I have children and wouldn't expect to pay the same and have 2 rooms to everyone else's 1.

mackthepony · 19/05/2022 15:05

How are you paying for the food?

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 19/05/2022 15:01

altmember · 19/05/2022 14:49

Yes, it doesn't sound very fair, would expect the ones with kids to be paying a bit more. Maybe not twice as much as you though, because the other facilities will still be shared, kitchen etc.

However, the bigger issue for me would be a childless couple going away with three young families. I'm a parent, but that sounds hell for the child free couple. You'll probably be woken at night by a crying baby, woken at 6am by the young kids being up, have to share the facilities with messy kids. If you cook together you'll end up with child friendly meals. If you go out together you'll end up doing child orientated activities. You won't be able to go out for an evening meal with the other adults, as they'll have kids' bed times to deal with.

I'm pretty sure the op isn't thick and can work out what a holiday with children would be like. Why can't a childless couple enjoy the fun of having children around??

Although I agree I don't think the people with children should be paying twice the amount. Having a bigger villa normally means the shared facilities are better.