Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry that no state, non-selective secondary schools are good enough.

211 replies

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 13:08

I know I am BU. I know there will be loads of people who send their kids to the local comp and their kids do fine and get good results and aren't exposed to hideous language and behaviour daily.

But.

I can't see how that could happen having researched all of the local schools.

Oldest DD is 9yo. So this reality is suddenly hitting me.

We're in a non-Grammar area. (DH and I grew up in a different county and went to grammars)

There's a girls grammar 10 miles away which has its own entrance exam so that's where I'm keeping my fingers crossed for her.

I'm also trying to work out how we can afford private school.

Because I've looked at results, spoken to friends who work in local comps, had them kids pass me when out and about, seen them walking to and from school, seen posts on local Facebook pages.

And I just can't see how my DD would get through 5 years at any of them and achieve what she's capable of and come out happy and confident like she deserves to be.

I don't want her to get straight A*s but I do want her to feel comfortable and supported enough to achieve the best she can.

I know this will get flamed by most. As it sounds horribly horribly snobby. I guess my background of going to a school that expected a lot of us means I was sheltered from the reality of a lot of teenage life.

But I'm hoping there are some mums out there like me who are worried at how secondary schools are.

And if so how did you make it work for your kids? Private education? Moving house?

OP posts:
rnsaslkih · 19/05/2022 14:14

Do not hold private education up as the golden solution.

My ds is at a private school, now taking GCSEs. Bullying is rife. So are drugs. Teaching is variable. There are several excellent teachers. But there are also some severely overworked ones (who would be good if they had time). And then there are the ones who have their own problems to deal with and miss lesson after lesson after lesson. My ds has to take a GCSE next week - teacher missed 50% of Y11 lessons.

Overall, I would say that much of the "added" stuff is extra curricular. And kids get forced to do stuff that they either wouldn't choose to do or don't want to do, as well as the stuff that they do choose to do.

The grass might be a little greener, but it is still not that green. The bullying that my ds has encountered was utterly wicked.

titchy · 19/05/2022 14:14

Anecdotally more self harm and eating disorders at girls selectives.

Your dd will come across arsehole males in life - do you want her to be unfamiliar and scared of them, or feel familiar enough with them to ignore them/flick them the v's...?

Tomnooktoldmeto · 19/05/2022 14:13

I live in a non grammar area and used to work with lots of surgeons, anaesthetists, dentists etc

A fair few paid for private education but the rest all moved close to 2 secondary schools in our county which achieved the best results and destinations for their students

When I married and had the DC I made sure we were in catchment for one of these schools to give our DC the best opportunities

DC1 had to leave due to disability and had a place at a private school paid for by an EHCP DC2 is just finishing said school

Both have excellent predicted grades on par with their peers, many peers have excellent destinations from their non selective secondary school

it doesn’t need to be a selective school in my opinion but having bright peers with great aspirations undoubtedly improves outcomes, so look for that school in your area

x2boys · 19/05/2022 14:13

standoctor · 19/05/2022 13:56

Mate of mine was a teacher in London state
Went to work in a private school
Said the state school class had 23 kids out of or 32 for whom English was not the 1st language
Made it impossible for the kids who wanted to learn to do so
He just got depressed by it and had to get out
No way would I let my kids go to state education
It is too important

Most of us don't have that luxury it's either state or no schooling
We also don't all live in London it's a bit ridiculous to write off then entire population of state schools due yo your "mates" anecdotal experience.

Abouttimemum · 19/05/2022 14:13

Yea where I live ALL of the secondary’s have 3/4 ofsted ratings. Not even one ‘good’ one. I don’t even know where to start tbh.

Clymene · 19/05/2022 14:11

You're a snob and also hopelessly naive.

lanthanum · 19/05/2022 14:11

Plenty of good comps round here. There are always going to be some badly-behaved kids, and lots of loud, sweary but basically lovely kids. Without grammars creaming off of the top end, the badly-behaved ones are usually reasonably well-diluted in a good comp. What you see coming out at the end of the day doesn't necessarily reflect what they're like in school - they've been behaving all day and now they're letting off steam a bit.

DD is nearing the end of her time at our local comp. She's learned swear words (and now looks back at how naive she was when she didn't realise people were swearing) but doesn't usually use them in front of me and never in front of teachers, grandparents, strangers, etc. She's never been bullied, despite being bright, geeky, uninterested in appearance, etc. She's timid but her confidence has grown. She's got a great set of friends, and most of them are going to do very well at GCSE. They haven't ever had to do very much homework, but that's given them time for other interests, as has the fact that it only takes 15 minutes to walk to/from school.

Whitedamask · 19/05/2022 14:10

It can depend on your area. Where I live there is an outstanding state secondary and one 'good' as rated by Ofsted.I see the children on their way home from both schools and it is immediately obvious which of the two schools they attend.

Is moving house to an area with good state schools an option?

I agree that your DD will be exposed to swearing whichever school she attends, but that's a by product, the important thing is that she needs a good education.

There are plenty of excellent state schools, you just need to find one and live in the catchment area, making sure you are as close to the school as possible.

mumsiedarlingrevolta · 19/05/2022 14:09

My DD was at a top Girl's Independent school and hated it.
Bullying, low level nastiness and the feeling that the parents were paying so there were very little consequences for anyone's actions.

She moved to local comp and thrived.

A comparison she told once me sticks with me-
At her Independent in top set English the girls were asked what they read over the summer-not one girl would put her hand up to admit to reading-too uncool.

The same question in her top set in local Girl's Comp had girls raising their hands and waving them enthusiastically to share the books they were reading.

Thos obviously won't be the case in every Independent or Comp but just a suggestion that you mustn't assume one will be better because of it's presumed "status"

Lots of good comps out there.

She is on track for a First from a very good Uni and has just been accepted to do a Masters.

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 14:09

Thanks all.

Totally appreciate all of the replies. Needed a reality check as in a bit of a "schools are awful" echo chamber currently.

Will just clarify on the language.

I have zero issue with swearing. I swear a lot. And DC know swear words when they hear them and not to say them.

The hideous language I was referring too is the appalling and upsetting sexually aggressive language I've heard groups of teens saying. Along with what they expose each other to with their phones etc.

Really I think my concern is teenage boys with parents who aren't bothered about what the internet is teaching their children.

I think that's where my sudden interest in selective/single sex schools has come from. To try and shelter her the best I can from how scary the internet is and how children are reacting to then things they're seeing.

I guess in my mind a girls school full of girls with parents who (I hope) feel similar to me will be a safer environment.

And that that in turn would lead to a better education and experience.

OP posts:
Mumwantingtogetitright · 19/05/2022 14:08

standoctor · 19/05/2022 13:56

Mate of mine was a teacher in London state
Went to work in a private school
Said the state school class had 23 kids out of or 32 for whom English was not the 1st language
Made it impossible for the kids who wanted to learn to do so
He just got depressed by it and had to get out
No way would I let my kids go to state education
It is too important

🤣 And there is no way that I would have wanted my dd going to a private school because I'd have been so worried about exposing her to kids with idiotic parents like this!

countrygirl99 · 19/05/2022 14:08

standoctor · 19/05/2022 13:56

Mate of mine was a teacher in London state
Went to work in a private school
Said the state school class had 23 kids out of or 32 for whom English was not the 1st language
Made it impossible for the kids who wanted to learn to do so
He just got depressed by it and had to get out
No way would I let my kids go to state education
It is too important

Friend of mine was a teacher in a pretty rough company in a particularly rough area. Thought he'd died and honestly to heaven when he got a job at a private dchool in a nice town. For about 2 terms, then he was looking for jobs in state schools again and had to be back there. Stayed in state schools ever since snd eould never go back to private. The final straw wax realising the Head was serious when he said there needed to be 2 teachers in each loo for a school disco. 1 to make sure there was no drug taking and one to chaperone the first to protect them against allegations of assault or worse when they caught the drug takers/seller's.

LondonWolf · 19/05/2022 14:06

I understand how you feel. The thought of feeding my child with additional needs into our local, fairly new, so unproven secondary had me waking up in a cold sweat. It didn't help that the known bullies from primary were all going there. We got lucky and decided to go slightly out of area but still in our borough and got a place at an all girls school. Some of the things dd reports back to me are shocking but on the whole, it feels like the safer option. Even the supposed "trouble makers" are generally kind to dd and the staff are very committed, with bullying stamped on ruthlessly as soon as it's reported. I'd make the same choice again. I think, especially in city schools, choosing single sex can ease the process.

YarnHoarder · 19/05/2022 14:06

I honestly don't think it's children that are likely to do average to very well (nothing wrong with average) that suffer least in secondary school. You sound like a parent who will encourage and provide what you can to help your child to do well. It's children who don't have that home environment or who struggle themselves who are likely to benefit more from smaller class sizes and greater support.

I grew up in a rough area with the nearest grammar schools 10 miles away (there were 4 to choose from if you could travel and get in) but 5 other schools within 4 miles with varying Ofsted reports so most went to the non-selective schools. My cousin (same age, same sex) went to a grammar and of the 2 I got the better grades and followed the more traditional route to university. I was a more motivated student rather than more academically gifted. What I'm trying to get across is that a child can learn anywhere but their personality and support system at home can have a large impact.

elliejjtiny · 19/05/2022 14:06

My 2 dc are doing well at the local comp. I'll admit it wasn't that great when dc1 started but they got a new head when he was in year 7 who is very enthusiastic and has turned the school around. DC1 is predicted mainly 7's, 8's and 9's in his gcse's this summer.

Triffid1 · 19/05/2022 14:05

YABU to suggest that all state schools are hideous and filled with terrible behaviour, no discipline etc.

YAalsoBU if you haven't actually gone to look at the schools in your area. I find it hard to believe that in an area where by the sounds of it there's at least the chance some children are going to private, that ALL the state schools are soooo bad.

We have a number of excellent state schools around here. One of them however was not always so good. It has a fairly bad reputation as a sort of hangover from that. Never ceases to amaze me how often people have lots of opinions about the school without actually attending it, visiting it, or talking to the students or their parents.

If you live in a spectacularly bad area for schools, then move house.

titchy · 19/05/2022 14:01

standoctor · 19/05/2022 13:56

Mate of mine was a teacher in London state
Went to work in a private school
Said the state school class had 23 kids out of or 32 for whom English was not the 1st language
Made it impossible for the kids who wanted to learn to do so
He just got depressed by it and had to get out
No way would I let my kids go to state education
It is too important

Well yes because all state schools have majority Non-English speaking students don't they? Oh wait, not they don't. So what fucking use was this post?

maeveiscurious · 19/05/2022 14:01

We are catchment for Grammar most state kids don't get in as the Prep
Schools spend their whole curriculum getting the kids over the line. The majority are at the local comprehensive. Children are getting into University, complete the DoE and know how negotiate all the challenges that the real world have to offer. My DCs know all the swear words but chose not to use them.

titchy · 19/05/2022 14:00

She'll be exposed to foul language at grammar, though possibly in a slightly better accent. She'll also be more likely to be exposed to incredibly bitchy toxic behaviour and anorexia at a girls selective. But again, posher sounding swear words which seems to be your priority....

Remember she won't be going to secondary school as the 9 year old she is now. She'll be going as an 11/12 year old adolescent and all the attitude that goes with that.

Testina · 19/05/2022 14:00

My Y9 tells me that language is awful in her state comprehensive, and there’s a lot of vaping in toilets, breaking rules round phone use etc. A boy in her class was expelled (she thinks) in Y7 for bringing in a pocket knife. Not a lesson goes by without someone getting some kind of sanction for poor behaviour, but that’s often only a name on the board for talking. Isolations and even one day exclusions aren’t even gossip worthy, they’re so common. There’s a separate unit on site for worst behaving children - as they have enough to justify that.

She and her friends are signed up to DofE, are excited about volunteering at a primary sports day, and play in the school football team. They all have many As in their effort and attainment results. They are, when you chat to them, “wholesome”. They’re not the nerds and complain loudly if you suggest it. They say they’re just ordinary, possibly seen as “a bit sporty”. They leave the mouthy vape girls to it - privately think they’re stupid but also slightly impressed by the bravado. They know them to say hi to, and are not bullied by them.

I expect there are pockets like this is very many state schools.

Mumwantingtogetitright · 19/05/2022 13:59

There was plenty of hideous language and a fair bit of bad behaviour at my dd's comprehensive school. On the other hand, they didn't have the massive drugs problem that they have in the prestigious selective private school down the road.

My dd came out of her comp with straight 9s at GCSE, an abundance of confidence and lots of really lovely friends. She plans to be a doctor.

You're massively overthinking this. Family support and home environment have a far, far bigger impact on outcomes than the type of school attended.

Sweettruelies · 19/05/2022 13:59

Er most kids go to state comprehensives despite what you read on mumsnet! If the schools in your area are poor you could always move.

And lol at the idea that private school and grammar pupils never swear or behave badly.

EntreMummy · 19/05/2022 13:57

I would consider whether you think that all the children who go to their local comps don’t achieve their full potential and end up under confident and low achieving?

Not all of the “bright” kids go to grammar or private.

bad language and behaviour is present amongst all teenagers, regardless of what school they go to. It doesn’t mean that they will become derailed drop outs of society,

My DS is starting our local comp in September, he didn’t want to go to a grammar school miles away from our house. He wanted to go where he knew some friends were going and that he could walk to by himself.

Educate yourself by going to visit the actual schools, speak to the teachers and staff, the headteachers. Ask them all of the uncomfortable questions. Then form your opinions.

My view is you need to make these decisions in cooperation with your child.

standoctor · 19/05/2022 13:56

Mate of mine was a teacher in London state
Went to work in a private school
Said the state school class had 23 kids out of or 32 for whom English was not the 1st language
Made it impossible for the kids who wanted to learn to do so
He just got depressed by it and had to get out
No way would I let my kids go to state education
It is too important

rickandmorts · 19/05/2022 13:56

Sorry another point, when you say you don't want your DC exposed to 'hideous behaviour'. We once had to have an assembly because someone smeared shit on the walls and threw bloody tampons around one of the toilets. The head asked us not to do this again. I'd consider that pretty hideous behaviour and none of my friends at state schools had to deal with things like that 🤣