Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry that no state, non-selective secondary schools are good enough.

211 replies

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 13:08

I know I am BU. I know there will be loads of people who send their kids to the local comp and their kids do fine and get good results and aren't exposed to hideous language and behaviour daily.

But.

I can't see how that could happen having researched all of the local schools.

Oldest DD is 9yo. So this reality is suddenly hitting me.

We're in a non-Grammar area. (DH and I grew up in a different county and went to grammars)

There's a girls grammar 10 miles away which has its own entrance exam so that's where I'm keeping my fingers crossed for her.

I'm also trying to work out how we can afford private school.

Because I've looked at results, spoken to friends who work in local comps, had them kids pass me when out and about, seen them walking to and from school, seen posts on local Facebook pages.

And I just can't see how my DD would get through 5 years at any of them and achieve what she's capable of and come out happy and confident like she deserves to be.

I don't want her to get straight A*s but I do want her to feel comfortable and supported enough to achieve the best she can.

I know this will get flamed by most. As it sounds horribly horribly snobby. I guess my background of going to a school that expected a lot of us means I was sheltered from the reality of a lot of teenage life.

But I'm hoping there are some mums out there like me who are worried at how secondary schools are.

And if so how did you make it work for your kids? Private education? Moving house?

OP posts:
Thedogshouses · 19/05/2022 15:57

It's not weird. It's likely if you are young enough to have been at an academy, you were highlighted as needy and given positive discrimination

girljulian · 19/05/2022 15:53

This is such a weird thread OP. I went to a state comprehensive in the North East. It was in fact an academy that had been cobbled together out of two failing schools and was in an extremely deprived area. Lots of the kids came from poor families. They still expected a lot of us; I went to Oxford. I still visit my school and talk to them about Oxbridge admissions and I'm really bloody proud of how hard the teachers work.

PeaHenChic · 19/05/2022 15:47

I went to a private girls school in the 80’s, work in a professional career and I’ve sent my dc to the local comprehensive.

The results are almost as good as the local private schools. Eldest is through and did very well, the only limitation educationally we’ve had is for dd2 who is very bright and wanted to do two languages at GCSE which would have been an option at the private school.

There is bad language at the comp of course but I heard similar at my private school. I once went home and used the word cunt which I’d heard at school that day. I didn’t know what it meant and my mum was furious :-)

FatEaredFuck · 19/05/2022 15:45

Yanbu and I totally agree, we are having similar dilemmas Sad

Thedogshouses · 19/05/2022 15:43

Mine went to private boarding. One awesome and one worse than a failing academy. Schools are schools, focus on the leadership, a decent head is worth more than a school badge. And these days, private kids are less likely to get decent university places. Mine study in the US, bloody expensive but they would have ended up in a seaside town in the UK otherwise. The one we moved to state boarding is oxbridge.

Mumwantingtogetitright · 19/05/2022 15:38

DogsAndGin · 19/05/2022 15:34

It’s not snobby - you just have standards. I am a normal person, from a fairly poor upbringing and I was horrified at the behaviour of the kids in my secondary school.

As an adult I have worked in a very highly regarded state comp, in a beautiful village… and guess what! The behaviour was atrocious there too.

No chance my kids will be hanging out with the scumbags at comps which ruin it for everyone else.

And no way that my dc would ever be hanging out with kids who have the kind of parents who refer to children as "scumbags". I dislike bad behaviour but I dislike snobbery every bit as much.

RatherBeRiding · 19/05/2022 15:34

We used to live in a part of town that had dreadful local secondaries and an excellent church secondary. I got them into the church school - if I hadn't managed that I would have home schooled. Both DC attended top universities and are now both professionally qualified. One of DS's friends from primary attended the local secondary with a poor reputation. He actually did Ok academically and came out with good As and went to Uni, but he didn't find it easy.

DogsAndGin · 19/05/2022 15:34

It’s not snobby - you just have standards. I am a normal person, from a fairly poor upbringing and I was horrified at the behaviour of the kids in my secondary school.

As an adult I have worked in a very highly regarded state comp, in a beautiful village… and guess what! The behaviour was atrocious there too.

No chance my kids will be hanging out with the scumbags at comps which ruin it for everyone else.

Chessie678 · 19/05/2022 15:30

To counterbalance some of the views that private schools tend to have just as much bad behaviour etc., this wasn't my experience either when I was at school or in experiencing the private sector afterwards.

I went to a state comp and then a selective girls' day school. In the former lessons were almost inevitably disrupted by behavioural issues - in some classes it was essentially impossible to work and it made the atmosphere at school very stressful. A sizeable minority of pupils regularly swore at teachers and occasionally assaulted them. I never saw anything approaching this in the private girls' school or any of the other independent schools I've had experience of. If you're paying private school fees you're not going to tolerate a culture where your child can't work because of disruption and most private schools won't allow this. Going into calm classes where most people got on with working made a huge difference to me. The private school I went to had much less "discipline" than the state school in that detentions were rarely used and we were generally trusted much more from a younger age (e.g. allowed to stay in classrooms and move around school freely at lunchtime whereas at the state school we were locked outside ) - there was just a culture of good behaviour at school.

In my experience behaviour outside of the classroom was mostly quite good too (clearly with exceptions) - there were girls with issues around eating disorders, mental health, drugs etc. but most were quite driven academically and most parents had quite a lot of oversight. I've heard that boarding schools tend to have worse behaviour out of class but only anecdotally.

Cleary there's a range of different experiences on this thread and private isn't a guarantee of no swearing or good behaviour but I do think it improves the odds that at least while your child is at school behaviour is unlikely to be so bad that it affects their learning.

jeaux90 · 19/05/2022 15:28

People will have had different experiences at different schools.

It comes down to what environment will work best for your child and whether you can get access to it.

My local secondary is good on many levels but wouldn't work for my neuro diverse DD13. I had intended to send her there previous to working out what was going on with her. She is thriving in a small all girls private school where there is a lot less noise because of 12 girls per class.

So work out what's best for you child and if you can go after it.

Staynow · 19/05/2022 15:20

My ds's state secondary is excellent. he was predicted all 7's based on his SAT's now after 5 years there he's predicted all 8's and 9's. It depends where you live as they vary hugely. They have a fantastic behaviour policy there but you're going to get swearing and problem behaviour no matter where you go.

Villagewaspbyke · 19/05/2022 15:18

titchy · 19/05/2022 14:01

Well yes because all state schools have majority Non-English speaking students don't they? Oh wait, not they don't. So what fucking use was this post?

There’s also no link between children who speak English as a second language and poor attainment. Some very fancy private schools also have kids who speak other languages at home.

TheMullerLightOwl · 19/05/2022 15:10

I completely understand your worries about teenage boys - quite gross creatures, for the most part. I have to say, though, that I'm quite glad my first exposure to boys and boyfriends etc. was when I was living at home with my parents and only at school 9am-3pm.

I think it would have been much worse to suddenly be thrown into a situation where you're potentially living in student halls of residence with boys having been to a single sex school.

TempsPerdu · 19/05/2022 15:02

Haven’t RTFT yet OP. Yes, you will most likely get horribly flamed for admitting this, but I completely understand where you’re coming from. It’s difficult, when you’ve had an excellent education yourself, to feel like you’re having to compromise even slightly with your DC.

While my own DD is way too young for all this yet, I suspect we’ll be in a similar dilemma when the time comes. DP and I went to the same super-selective grammar in the ‘90s and still live locally. It was fairly competitive to get in then, but nowadays it’s gone utterly bonkers - private tutors from the moment they enter Year 3 etc. We both loved the school, and coming from very ordinary backgrounds it undoubtedly broadened our horizons and gave us opportunities we otherwise never would have accessed - culture of aspiration and intellectual curiosity, endless extra-curriculars, you’d walk into assembly each morning to music played by a concert-level orchestra and so on. Almost everyone was engaged and wanted to learn, I never witnessed a fight or any major disruption while I was there, and while drugs etc were present if you wanted them, they never really infringed on school life that much.

We’ve always said that ideally we’d like our daughter to go to a good comp, and that we don’t want to put her through the crazy stress of the eleven plus - but the reality of our local options means I’m already wavering. We’re out of catchment for the best comprehensive options and I wouldn’t be happy sending DD to either of the schools we’d reliably get into. I imagine we’ll either cave and start tutoring, or end up moving down the road to access the better comps.

Several old school friends had their DC long before us and have ended up sending them to the local ‘Outstanding’ comp because they missed out on a place at our old school. While it has by no means been a disaster, they are very honest about admitting that they do feel a level of guilt about this, and recognise the disparity between the amazing opportunities we were given and what their DC are experiencing, which is comparatively mediocre. The main differences seem to be in ethos, depth of curriculum and extra curricular opportunities - overall standard of sport, music, debating etc within the school.

It’s difficult to feel you’re having to adjust your expectations down when it comes to your own children’s education and potential life changes.

ZandathePanda · 19/05/2022 15:00

Don’t worry about the PPs being rude. As you say you want the best for your child. That in itself is one of the greatest indicators they will do well. I taught in lots of different schools and went to private and a posh public school myself. Based on my experiences, my children went/go to the local comp (no grammars here). Eldest one got 2 A stars and an A. And a nice nest egg for a house rather than us paying for her to travel a long way to a private school. We went round them all. It’s a bit of a lifestyle choice to be honest - some of the parents that chose private worked long hours and their social circle did it and also it meant the children were out from 7am - 6pm on the bus/at school. I took reduced hours as we didn’t need the income to pay fees and took them to clubs etc outside school. What also helps is less wasted time travelling and having friends nearby in holidays. If you find a school you fall in love with I would move as with private you’ll be paying 120k+ extra anyway.

Rosehugger · 19/05/2022 14:59

Please don't apply for a school 10 miles away for your DD. She won't thank you for a 20 mile round trip every day, however good the school is, and her friends will be too far away to visit after school

I'm sorry, but this is nonsense. DD1 loved her school which was 10 miles away and the school bus took 40 minutes to get there - same as for my school actually which was much nearer to my home. Loads of kids in my local area travel to go to grammar school. They put them in forms and houses with kids that live near them. She has friends that live in the local town to the school and some that live more locally and they definitely see one another outside school.

However, also do have a look at your local schools and see what you think.

Testina · 19/05/2022 14:55

I’m not against selective private schools btw. I’d have loved to have afforded it for mine. I think mine would do better academically at one, as it happens.

Also the opportunities - sports day at my friend’s private is like the bloody Olympics with the proper equipment, they actually teach hurdle technique in Y5, and have a pro photographer present! I’m beyond jealous.

But behaviour… it’s shocking everywhere, outside of the classroom, and you won’t easily buy your way out of that.

Testina · 19/05/2022 14:50

Interviewing the attitude of the parents won’t guarantee you anything except that some parents lie, or some don’t even lie but the school has a profit to make.

Ever consider you just fell for their marketing trick?

Oh, the things I did to instil a real love of learning in my child! The children’s fun science fairs at the university campus, dressing up in Anglo Saxon clothes in Suffolk museums, taking her children’s theatre as a baby, a home full of books… I’d ace their interview, I really would. The video of her excited and engaged and smiling doing an experiment for her Y5 class at primary science week fair. First prize 😍

Guess what? Y9. Great kid. Intelligent. Still does the bear minimum she can get away with these days 😭

Silverswirl · 19/05/2022 14:47

Some comps are brilliant and really are a complete mix of high achieving / lower achieving / mix of families but the school inspire confidence and get the best out of the kids and have robust discipline policies.
Some comps are nothing like this and don’t get the best out of children or are full of disadvantaged kids with absent parents.
Many schools in grammar areas that are not grammar have difficulties with academic achievement because the highest 30% have all been taken by the grammar schools.
Whilst a grammar school won’t cut out swearing or some behaviours, in my experience the kids who go there mostly have parents who are interested in their kids education. Interested in broadening their horizons. Actively interested in their child being the best they can possibly be. This of course isn’t true for all kids but is true for the majority.
In my experience, parents who are negative about grammars / independents are those that have had a personal grievance or those that are secretly jealous / bitter that their child is not grammar material / haven’t got the money for independent. They won’t admit that of course, even to themselves but instead make themselves feel better by picking holes and finding any negative anecdotes to convince themselves that ‘actually grammar schools and independents are all toxic anyway’
If your daughter is bright and willing to learn, don’t be put off by distance. You know her best and what would be best for her.

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 14:44

HappyHappyHermit · 19/05/2022 14:41

This whole thing reminds of the Scouting fir girls song 'Posh girls'. I went to a selective independent school. Some of the 6th formers supplied the local comp and there was all sorts going on...as I imagine could happen anywhere. I will not be sending my child to private school, I look back in disgust at the attitude and entitlement they tried to instill. That doesn't mean I don't want my child to do well, of course I do, but I feel that understanding and being around those from all walks of life is more valuable.

Thank you so much for replying.

Really I'd love to hear from women who went to independent selective schools as in real life I don't know anyone who did.

All I can go by are their websites etc.

OP posts:
GrannyBloomers · 19/05/2022 14:43

My kids attend an "outstanding" rated comp. Teaching may be good but its a huge school and there are serious problems - regular fights, kids carry knives, serious drug problems (county lines), vaping in the toilets etc. And being a large school they do take rejects from other state schools - including some who have been expelled from other schools and are waiting on court cases for some very serious crimes.
My take is the girls can be as bad as the boys. My DD let me scroll through some Yr8-10 girls' instagrams. These girls come from middle class families, live in a boringly middle class area and yet they present themselves as if they were gangsters with weapons, cigarettes and practically no clothing - apparently it's what the boys like.
In reality most large secondary schools whether comp or grammar will have bullying, drugs and bad behaviour. What is more important is how the kids react to it.

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 14:43

BlusteryLake · 19/05/2022 14:40

Just reading your updates, what you actually mean is you want a girls only school for your DD. That's fine, but if the reason for that is to avoid parents who don't control internet access or indeed exposure to boys, then you are going to be sorely disappointed. Re independent schools, did Everyone's Invited pass you by?

Everyone's invited did pass me by. But I will make sure to find it.

But I also think you haven't seen my most recent update.

It's specifically only 2 private girls' schools I'm considering.

Not state vs private.

I am 100% aware of drug and bullying issues in local private schools and they're fully off the list.

Thankfully though my DC wouldn't be automatically placed in one of those if they didn't get whichever school we list as #1.

OP posts:
HappyHappyHermit · 19/05/2022 14:41

This whole thing reminds of the Scouting fir girls song 'Posh girls'. I went to a selective independent school. Some of the 6th formers supplied the local comp and there was all sorts going on...as I imagine could happen anywhere. I will not be sending my child to private school, I look back in disgust at the attitude and entitlement they tried to instill. That doesn't mean I don't want my child to do well, of course I do, but I feel that understanding and being around those from all walks of life is more valuable.

BlusteryLake · 19/05/2022 14:40

Just reading your updates, what you actually mean is you want a girls only school for your DD. That's fine, but if the reason for that is to avoid parents who don't control internet access or indeed exposure to boys, then you are going to be sorely disappointed. Re independent schools, did Everyone's Invited pass you by?

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 14:39

gwenneh · 19/05/2022 14:30

I think you have an unrealistic view of the benefits of a private school.

Parents can be just as uninvolved in what their children do at a private school, it's just for different reasons. Arguably, private school children have more access to technology, etc, not less.

Appalling and sexually aggressive language doesn't have an income bracket, unfortunately. I find in the private school it's just hidden better, as is bullying.

In one local private school, the closest one to our house, the money involved also means a fairly hefty problem with drugs. The bored, idle teens have a lot of money to spend, and some of them spend it making some very questionable life choices.

I wouldn't assume the parents of pupils at an all-girls school feel the same as you do. The reality is they're likely to be just as much a mixed bag as parents at the local comp, but with a better income.

Thanks for your feedback. I'm really grateful for all the replies and I think I need to find some parents of girls at the grammar and private schools I'm comparing the comps too.

I'm clueless on Private schools.

There are a lot in this area but the 2 I am looking at are both selective and, not only that, they interview the girls' parents to ask how they plan to support their daughters learning and the school.

That's what has, for the first time, made me suddenly think that a private school could be for us. There are plenty around here that are just "bring money" and those I don't have an interest in.

I'm sure I'm still being ridiculously naive. But I like the idea that her peers will have parents who feel like DH and I when it comes to education.

Maybe I'm wrong.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread