Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry that no state, non-selective secondary schools are good enough.

211 replies

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 13:08

I know I am BU. I know there will be loads of people who send their kids to the local comp and their kids do fine and get good results and aren't exposed to hideous language and behaviour daily.

But.

I can't see how that could happen having researched all of the local schools.

Oldest DD is 9yo. So this reality is suddenly hitting me.

We're in a non-Grammar area. (DH and I grew up in a different county and went to grammars)

There's a girls grammar 10 miles away which has its own entrance exam so that's where I'm keeping my fingers crossed for her.

I'm also trying to work out how we can afford private school.

Because I've looked at results, spoken to friends who work in local comps, had them kids pass me when out and about, seen them walking to and from school, seen posts on local Facebook pages.

And I just can't see how my DD would get through 5 years at any of them and achieve what she's capable of and come out happy and confident like she deserves to be.

I don't want her to get straight A*s but I do want her to feel comfortable and supported enough to achieve the best she can.

I know this will get flamed by most. As it sounds horribly horribly snobby. I guess my background of going to a school that expected a lot of us means I was sheltered from the reality of a lot of teenage life.

But I'm hoping there are some mums out there like me who are worried at how secondary schools are.

And if so how did you make it work for your kids? Private education? Moving house?

OP posts:
effoffyouseeyounexttuesday · 19/05/2022 16:43

You will get a lot of support options in a large secondary. Elsa, counselling, inclusion, send. Big doesn't mean bad.

Definitely don't make assumptions. I was like you 10 years ago though no options available other than my local school.

NavigatingSEN · 19/05/2022 16:41

I went to an all girl school. I left with no idea how to talk to boys, and very, very vulnerable when at university as a result. There were no boys in my family, so I just had no idea at all of boys as normal people, no male friends, just a TV-led idea that all boys were potential boyfriends (1990s TV has a lot to answer for!).

Don't shelter your daughter as much as I was. If you choose an all girl school, make sure she still has plenty of opportunity for friendships with boys outside school.

My DS was offered a private school place, but having local friends and learning to get along with a wide range of people were more important to us. He'll get his grades wherever he goes, it's the life experience we want for him.

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 16:40

effoffyouseeyounexttuesday · 19/05/2022 16:31

Your use of the word comp seems negative before you start. The grammar system really creates a divide and you've been sucked in.

Many people have a preconceived idea of awfulness about the school my kids go to.... until they go to the open day and hear the HT speak and the results pushing above average.

Issue is historically it's been poorly run with issues but now- it's not at all like that. Locally - small area and lots of kids at home time means the kids are everywhere going home and locals don't like it so moan about the children all the time building issues that are much smaller in reality than made out.

Of course there is bullying (see all schools) swearing (see all schools) and behaviour (also, see all schools) but how it's dealt with is what you need to know.

There will be stuff you don't like everywhere. I echo point about selective private girls schools generating issues of their own ( I went to one of these schools)

Look at the school, get in there, observe all the children not just the 'naughty ones'.

I have a sinking feeling you are partly referring to challenging behaviour issues that stem from neuro diverse children - of course you won't get that at your selective schools 😱😱😱

I am definitely going to be going to the open days and then to the ones we like on non-open days.

Myself and my DD are neuro-diverse. Probably a part of why I'm so desperate for her to have as positive teenage years as I can make them. As she is going to feel like she doesn't fit in wherever she ends up.

Pastoral care at any school she attends is a huge part of what's making me lean towards the favourites I have. Somewhere she will be understood and treated as an individual is hugely important to me.

OP posts:
Teachertotutor · 19/05/2022 16:39

I grew up in a local area where there were no grammar schools. My parents could never have afforded private schools. I worked hard and got straight As in GCSEs and A Levels. (Before A*s were available!) There will be lots of other bright, motivated students at a non-selective state school, so don't worry!

effoffyouseeyounexttuesday · 19/05/2022 16:39

Of course it's your choice to go private etc but why start a thread in such a judgemental way - this site covers such a wide area no way would there be one answer.

Were you expecting everyone to agree and say it's ok it's all awful use a private school?

Maybe post the same on the local FB group instead - then you might get a better view.

user3199 · 19/05/2022 16:37

There are no state grammars in Scotland so I can't really relate to that aspect.

What I will say is that looking at overall exam performance of a school is misleading. Online you can see results/progress scores by 'type' of pupil - this includes by sex, free school meal status, and prior educational attainment. The good exam results of many schools are largely explained by the high prior attainment of their intake. Whereas some schools with poor overall outcomes might have very strong performance for some types of pupils and might have much better 'value added' scores. So do consider the strengths of each school carefully.

I would also say that of the students I teach at uni level, on average those who have a private education do no better than those who have had a state education.

Toddlerteaplease · 19/05/2022 16:37

I had no idea until I came to Mumsnet that the 11+ and grammar schools still existed.

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 16:37

Hallyup89 · 19/05/2022 16:28

I went to a private secondary school after being in a state primary. I'd say that behaviour was marginally better than at my sister's state secondary school, but we still had bad language, kids sneaking off for a fag and the police being called.

It was a selective girls' school. I went from being the top of the class to being mediocre. I never won a prize, I never got a commendation and I never felt recognised. My kids attend state school now, and they're often commended and rewarded for their behaviour, achievements and effort. I got none of that.

I wouldn't write-off all state schools.

Thanks @Hallyup89

That's a really good point.

My DD is outstandingly academic in her current class. She tends to get one of the end of year awards each year but compared to the rest of the class gets fewer of the weekly prizes as she never causes any trouble and so doesn't need the encouragement.

In my mind I've been thinking a smaller class will mean more encouragement and so she'd gain confidence.

But. I do realise there are a lot of children a lot brighter than her and in a grammar she won't be top of the class anymore. To me that's not important and I won't pressure her to be. But I don't want school to give her that impression.

What she does struggle with is being easily upset/annoyed/distracted by the children who misbehave at school. Her class teacher knows this and so keeps her near the front.

I worry that in a state secondary if she still struggled with that frustration it could hugely affect her learning. But she'll be older then so maybe isn't a consideration.

OP posts:
effoffyouseeyounexttuesday · 19/05/2022 16:31

Your use of the word comp seems negative before you start. The grammar system really creates a divide and you've been sucked in.

Many people have a preconceived idea of awfulness about the school my kids go to.... until they go to the open day and hear the HT speak and the results pushing above average.

Issue is historically it's been poorly run with issues but now- it's not at all like that. Locally - small area and lots of kids at home time means the kids are everywhere going home and locals don't like it so moan about the children all the time building issues that are much smaller in reality than made out.

Of course there is bullying (see all schools) swearing (see all schools) and behaviour (also, see all schools) but how it's dealt with is what you need to know.

There will be stuff you don't like everywhere. I echo point about selective private girls schools generating issues of their own ( I went to one of these schools)

Look at the school, get in there, observe all the children not just the 'naughty ones'.

I have a sinking feeling you are partly referring to challenging behaviour issues that stem from neuro diverse children - of course you won't get that at your selective schools 😱😱😱

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 16:31

FreddyVoorhees · 19/05/2022 16:27

I wouldn't send DS1 to the local private school even if we could afford it. There are horrendous bullying issues and from what I've seen now and in the past, the kids are in the main arrogant and ill mannered.

Nor would I send them to the local selective/religious school. Again there is bullying and the pastoral care is severely lacking. They may have consistently high grades but when you cream off the top and cull the less able it's not that difficult.

DS1 goes to the local state school. He's very well supported there as he is at home. Bullying is stamped down on HARD. Unlike the children of our friends who attend both the selective and fee paying schools, he looks forward to going. That works for me.

I wouldn't send my DC to the closest private either. It's also horrendously snobby and has a lot of boarders so she wouldn't have local friends.

The ones I'm considering are day schools with good reputations.

I've not seen that the local comps have shit results and just decided without any research that a fee paying school must be better.

It's that currently the only schools whose ethos' and results are what I'd like are all single sex and selective or private.

OP posts:
Hallyup89 · 19/05/2022 16:28

I went to a private secondary school after being in a state primary. I'd say that behaviour was marginally better than at my sister's state secondary school, but we still had bad language, kids sneaking off for a fag and the police being called.

It was a selective girls' school. I went from being the top of the class to being mediocre. I never won a prize, I never got a commendation and I never felt recognised. My kids attend state school now, and they're often commended and rewarded for their behaviour, achievements and effort. I got none of that.

I wouldn't write-off all state schools.

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 16:28

stopthepain · 19/05/2022 16:25

I went to a local state school. Straight A student. My best friend went to a private all girls school. She also got straight As. However, her mental health and self-confidence were in tatters by the time she left. Everyday, all the girls were toxic and competitive. She falls into bad relationship after bad relationship. She didn’t grow up around boys and men so she was very naive and is only now starting to see red flags. She’s not alone. The opposite sex will appear a novelty and more exciting if you’ve been kept away from them.

We’re both in our mid 20s, just for reference.

Just to play devils advocate with your comment about her getting into bad relationship after bad relationship.

How is her parents relationship compared to yours?

As honestly my DC could not have a better role model than my DH for when it comes to how a man should treat a woman. So I like to hope that even without boys are school my DD will have high expectations of how any boyfriends should treat her.

OP posts:
FreddyVoorhees · 19/05/2022 16:27

I wouldn't send DS1 to the local private school even if we could afford it. There are horrendous bullying issues and from what I've seen now and in the past, the kids are in the main arrogant and ill mannered.

Nor would I send them to the local selective/religious school. Again there is bullying and the pastoral care is severely lacking. They may have consistently high grades but when you cream off the top and cull the less able it's not that difficult.

DS1 goes to the local state school. He's very well supported there as he is at home. Bullying is stamped down on HARD. Unlike the children of our friends who attend both the selective and fee paying schools, he looks forward to going. That works for me.

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 16:25

Thanks @clary

You're right. I do totally worry that by going to a single sex school all that happens is delaying real life.

I was dead against going to an all girls school and actually have always enjoyed male company and at my school had as many friends who were boys as I did girls.

I don't have brothers so I do wonder how I'd have found uni if I'd have gone into it having left an all girls school. (I had the choice between single or mixed sex grammar and didn't even view the girls grammar!)

But then DD does extracurricular activities already that includes boys, and we have family friends with sons her age.

So then part of me thinks would it mean the boys she is exposed to are ones who will help to (along with DH) give her a good sense of what is decent behaviour to expect from any males in her life.

As even at my nice mixed school I suffered sexual assault more than once.

Again, not that I realise sexual assault can't happen in a single sex school before I get accused of that.

OP posts:
stopthepain · 19/05/2022 16:25

I went to a local state school. Straight A student. My best friend went to a private all girls school. She also got straight As. However, her mental health and self-confidence were in tatters by the time she left. Everyday, all the girls were toxic and competitive. She falls into bad relationship after bad relationship. She didn’t grow up around boys and men so she was very naive and is only now starting to see red flags. She’s not alone. The opposite sex will appear a novelty and more exciting if you’ve been kept away from them.

We’re both in our mid 20s, just for reference.

Lancelottie · 19/05/2022 16:24

Or the schools themselves change. One near us is on its fourth head teacher since we've been here. A new head might love sport and hate music, or want to create an Ofsted factory, or demand silence in the corridors and No Homework Excuses Unless Actually Dead.

MarshaBradyo · 19/05/2022 16:23

Oblomov22 · 19/05/2022 14:16

I'm always baffled by where people choose to live. Or rather that they don't plan ahead. Where do you live? Why do you live there? Why didn't you try and buy in an area with better schools in the last 15 years. Why didn't you move nearer to the grammar, which is 10 miles away.

Admittedly we chose Catholic, but all the schools here are ok. DH's huge family is all Catholic so as soon as I found out I was pregnant I put Ds1's and then DS2's name down at the local Catholic primary and then they automatically go to the catholic secondary which is superb and one of the top schools in the country. They have both thrived.

When you discussed what Primary and then secondary school you wanted your children to go to with your DH what did you decide all those years ago?

The op says she’s moving at some point to get closer to whichever school but it’s not that easy especially in London

A house price premium close by means you need very high amount for a house or even a flat

Myhousemyhome · 19/05/2022 16:19

Oblomov22 · 19/05/2022 14:16

I'm always baffled by where people choose to live. Or rather that they don't plan ahead. Where do you live? Why do you live there? Why didn't you try and buy in an area with better schools in the last 15 years. Why didn't you move nearer to the grammar, which is 10 miles away.

Admittedly we chose Catholic, but all the schools here are ok. DH's huge family is all Catholic so as soon as I found out I was pregnant I put Ds1's and then DS2's name down at the local Catholic primary and then they automatically go to the catholic secondary which is superb and one of the top schools in the country. They have both thrived.

When you discussed what Primary and then secondary school you wanted your children to go to with your DH what did you decide all those years ago?

It’s not always that simple. People can be priced out or lose their homes due to redundancy, disability etc and not being able to afford their mortgage. Catchments change. Or rules change. Schools, which are out of catchment but have traditionally always taken children from a certain area / village stop due to policy changes or new homes being built closer to the school. People get divorced. Renters are not in secured housing and therefore vulnerable. People can’t just click their fingers and buy in the right area and so forth.

clary · 19/05/2022 16:16

OP you ask about people who went to a single-sex selective private school - mine was not private but it was the other two. It was a long time ago and of course there was no internet or mobiles; but there was still poor behaviour and unsupportive parents. I was a swot and sailed through on a wave of great results, but the school dd not prepare me at all for the real world as I left my clever fancy echo chamber. I went to uni and knew nothing about relationships or boys, blundered through it all and made a bit of a mess. As it happens, I also had a salutary moment when I realised I wasn;t as smart as I thought I was haha. I am hoping that my own DD, having been to school with boys all her life, is a bit better prepared.

I have no doubt that the situation for today's girls in single-sex selective schools is better, as in, they will communicate with boys (and girls) via the many ways now available that I could not use and hopefully have a wide and varied circle of friends. But of course doing that is likely to expose them to the dangers you fear. I think you need to educate your DD on how to
behave and what to do in certain situations - then let her get on with it. Sheltering her behind a curtain of non-knowledge until she is 18 will not help - believe me.

ZandathePanda · 19/05/2022 16:09

OP excellent plan. Just research the hell out the schools around you. Take the Ofsted reports with a pinch of salt. Some Outstanding ones have not been seen in 10 years but they are getting round to it. When we moved Dd from an outstanding to satisfactory school, she was much happier and did better academically. They were satisfactory as there was political pressure to make them an academy.

Sweepingeyelashes · 19/05/2022 16:05

One of my children dropped out of a private school and went to the local state school. The teaching was better and the children were nicer - the private school was a viper's nest of bullying and spitefulness. They're in medical school now.

FrodisCapering · 19/05/2022 16:04

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

axolotlfloof · 19/05/2022 16:01

My sister was driven to the next county everyday (30 miles) for secondary. High achieving girls grammar. She was miserable and bullied.
She would have been better at the local comp my brother and I went to (but my Mum thought she was doing her best for her).
Incidentally all three of us have similar gcses, a levels and degree, and my comp school brother has a science PhD.
I think the "good kids do well anywhere" , is partly true.
Focus on where she will be happy.

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 15:59

Thanks so much everyone. I'm really grateful for the vast majority of replies and actually really glad I posted this.

DD1 is only Y4. We're moving house before we need to decide on/apply for schools. So our plan is to go by results/word of mouth to know which to look at and then move based on where we like after the open days.

Early research and word of mouth has made DH and I really disheartened though. Hence then looking into independent schools and the grammar etc.

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 19/05/2022 15:58

The best thing you can do is prepare dd for high school over next couple of years. Make sure she knows about nspcc type issues - body image, sexualised terms, coersive control, peer pressure, dealing with bullying. Giving her a sense of self and knowledge how to handle situations she may come across.