Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry that no state, non-selective secondary schools are good enough.

211 replies

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 13:08

I know I am BU. I know there will be loads of people who send their kids to the local comp and their kids do fine and get good results and aren't exposed to hideous language and behaviour daily.

But.

I can't see how that could happen having researched all of the local schools.

Oldest DD is 9yo. So this reality is suddenly hitting me.

We're in a non-Grammar area. (DH and I grew up in a different county and went to grammars)

There's a girls grammar 10 miles away which has its own entrance exam so that's where I'm keeping my fingers crossed for her.

I'm also trying to work out how we can afford private school.

Because I've looked at results, spoken to friends who work in local comps, had them kids pass me when out and about, seen them walking to and from school, seen posts on local Facebook pages.

And I just can't see how my DD would get through 5 years at any of them and achieve what she's capable of and come out happy and confident like she deserves to be.

I don't want her to get straight A*s but I do want her to feel comfortable and supported enough to achieve the best she can.

I know this will get flamed by most. As it sounds horribly horribly snobby. I guess my background of going to a school that expected a lot of us means I was sheltered from the reality of a lot of teenage life.

But I'm hoping there are some mums out there like me who are worried at how secondary schools are.

And if so how did you make it work for your kids? Private education? Moving house?

OP posts:
bathsh3ba · 19/05/2022 17:59

I was privately single sex educated and have worked in state schools. To me there was no question my girls wouldn't go private. We have a 90% bursary, you could look into that if funds are an issue.

When I hear what my state school educated friends got up to in their teen years, I'm grateful I was sheltered from it. I don't think it makes me any less rounded. I get on with friends from all kinds of backgrounds. There are far fewer issues in such schools now pastoral care has improved.

Openup · 19/05/2022 17:21

I have worked in Independent schools for 16 yrs and I can tell you that the kids in indies drink, swear, smoke, vape and behave just a badly as those in state schools.
Another point to consider is that Mose Independent schools are selective, so there would be something very wrong if their results weren’t better than your average state comp. This is not due to superior teaching!

ChickenBurgers · 19/05/2022 17:19

*3 B’s, not AB’s 🙈

ChickenBurgers · 19/05/2022 17:17

Oh my god this is so accurate for where I live. No grammar schools in the area bar one about 20 miles away which became non-selective a while back (which kind of defeats the object of it I thought?! But then I don’t know much about grammar schools). There’s only one high school in our town, I went there, it’s shit, it’s spent the last 11 years since I left bouncing in and out of special measures. I was a relatively bright kid and definitely did not reach my potential (was predicted A*s and A’s, scraped 3 AB’s and 3 C’s). I found at that school you have to choose between friends or grades and I worried too much about what others thought so joined in with getting in trouble, bunking and just generally being a nuisance. Best part was, I was no-where near the worst student despite getting kicked out of lessons for attitude regularly. A boy in our year got expelled in year 11 for drug dealing on site. My sister did quite well at that school, but then we’re very different personalities and she was better at not being bothered about fitting in and getting her head down, whereas I wasn’t.

any decent high school within a 10 mile radius is over subscribed and generally catholic so we wouldn’t even get a look in as we don’t practice religion. As I said previously, no grammar options. We cannot afford private for one child let alone 3. My eldest is nearly 7, is pretty bright (not genius bright, but still pretty academic) but the school are in the early stages of starting a referral for an ADHD assessment and there’s no way he will be able to manage at that school as he’s a complete follower. He frequently gets in trouble now as he’s distracted by a strong gust of wind, that’s not going to get any better in a massive comp full of distractions and is known for poor behaviour. I can’t say what my other kids will be like as they’re only 1 and 4 months, but it’s a massive worry for me. We really don’t have any choices other than move but then we lose our family support system.

IheartJKRowling · 19/05/2022 17:10

My ex went to a very good "public" school, it was and still is rife with bullying and pupils bragging about how wealthy their parents are and looking down on those who were less affluent. It was rife wuth drugs because the pupils had enough money to buy whatever they wanted. It was a miserable experience that literally affected his whole life but if you looked at just his exam results you would think it was an excellent school.

I live in an area with grammar schools but my daughter didn't take her 11+, she knew which school she wanted to attend and I fully supported her. She left with 5 A* which is as good as she would have achieved at a grammar school but more importantly she actually enjoyed her years at school with her friends and peer group. State schools are not dark educational voids, there are good and bad ones.

My niece went to a school in an area of Salford that had a terrible reputation and all the problems associated with an inner city school and she's just qualified as a Doctor and is going to be a GP.

If you child is intelligent and wants to learn and do well, they will, regardless of which school they attend.

sickofthisnonsense · 19/05/2022 17:10

I'd also say about the kids in the selective schools is they have absolutely no idea about people from different socioeconomic backgrounds. All the grammar kids either went to private primary, or have middle class high earner parents who could afford the high house prices that the school catchment created.
There is no empathy at all- it's an abstract thing.
My kids are privileged and they know it, they are aware they have more money and chances than some of their friends. It makes them nicer to be around.

The girls grammar everyone is desperate to get their girls into here has a massive self harm issue, there was even a suicide.
I would not say the girls who go their have benefited confidence wise.

GoodWithCats · 19/05/2022 17:09

I think you need to visit as many schools as you can and find out more. Ask about discipline, what they teach kids about internet usage, respect, bullying, friendships, aspiration etc.

I have 2 teens at different state schools, neither of them is outstanding. One is 18 and sitting A Levels and the other is 15 and just finished year 10 exams. Both are doing incredibly well academically, don't get into trouble, have made great friends and are hard working and respectful. Some of their friends went to private secondary schools and academically they're not doing as well as my kids. On that basis alone I'm really glad I didn't waste my money on private education.

Yes, there are some disrespectful kids at their schools but my kids avoid them. If your DD has support at home, is bright and a good head on her shoulders she'll do just fine. Yes, class sizes are big but my kids have learnt they just need to get on with it and put in the extra study at home if they need to.

If you have the money you can provide additional opportunities outside school - music lessons, sports etc.

I went to a fee paying grammar school on an assisted place in the 80's and 90's and it was an awful place. Full of privilege, bullying and a lot of drug use in the later years.

cecilthehungryspider · 19/05/2022 17:08

OP I do get where you're coming from. Where I live all the local state secondary schools are dire. Fortunately, my eldest (also ND) got a place at the only good school and their siblings just followed.

Of my group of friends with children the same age as my eldest, one other went to the same school as mine, 2 went to different private schools and the rest went to the local catchment school. By year 10 all bar one had left the local school. The main issue wasn't actually the results, although they weren't great, it was the behaviour. Bullying is rife, there have been incidents involving knives, and more than once autistic children have been beaten up while walking home from school. I have a friend who works there as a teacher and her own children go to the same school as mine. She said they'd be eaten alive in her school, all the kids there think they are gangsters. This is supposedly one of the best schools in the area! TBF our area is very near the bottom for performance nationally so it's not surprising they aren't great. I imagine that people who live in an area where the local schools are good would find it hard to imagine just how bad some schools are. My DCs school is not perfect, but it is a lot better than the other options here.

Thedogshouses · 19/05/2022 17:03

Notdoingthis · 19/05/2022 17:02

Opposite problem here.
I would worry about my children going to the closest schools which are single sex. I would worry they won't get a good experience of their teenage years with single sex.

Really? SB

Fluxcapacitator · 19/05/2022 17:02

My youngest child is just finishing at our local very diverse state school. All 3 have or expected to get good gcses, none experienced bullying, all enjoyed school on the whole and importantly mixed with a vast range of children. I am very sure they were frequently exposed to bad language and vaping in the toilets. That's life for you.

Notdoingthis · 19/05/2022 17:02

Opposite problem here.
I would worry about my children going to the closest schools which are single sex. I would worry they won't get a good experience of their teenage years with single sex.

PermanentTemporary · 19/05/2022 17:00

What can I tell you? Ds is just finishing at his local comprehensive. He's not a horrible teenage boy, he's a lovely thoughtful gentle lad surrounded by longstanding friends doing [stealth boast] A levels and heading for [stealth boast] University. I honestly don't see how he could have done better. Go and look at the schools and make your decision based on your child. I'll be honest, the other factor I would always look at is the head teacher - I never regretted going for the head teacher at ds's school, she was absolutely amazing.

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 17:00

Tabitha005 · 19/05/2022 16:49

"... (DH and I grew up in a different county and went to grammars)..."

"... Because I've looked at results, spoken to friends who work in local comps, had them kids pass me when out and about..."

If we're being snobby about kids at state comprehensives, then we'd be failing hugely if we didn't lampoon the poor level of grammar exhibited by, ironically enough, an ex-grammar school pupil.

Another proofreader who is wilfully ignoring the fact that people make typing errors and that MN doesn't allow users to edit posts.

Sorry you weren't the first to show how smart you are.

Also if you had read, and successfully comprehended, my posts you'll see that very little of my concern is around what my children will gain in regards to grammar skills at school.

It's more that I want them to avoid twats. Which obviously isn't always possible. Biscuit

OP posts:
PineappleWilson · 19/05/2022 16:58

@FrodisCapering but I work FT and where we live there is limited public transport i.e. fine to go north to south but you're stuffed if you want to go east to west. There's no chance I could drive DS the sort of distances you cover and still get to work on time. Do what you have to do but remember the mortgage still needs to be paid by the person doing the driving.

We're lucky that DS' school charters a school bus. I stand by my point that a school 10 miles away will be a hassle. It works well for your DC, but you do need to consider how the rest of the DC's life will fit around that. The OP seemed keen to pin her hopes on a school at all costs. I'm asking her to consider how tired her DD will be after long journeys, especially in later years with homework on top, where her after school clubs are, what transport options she has etc.

Harridan1981 · 19/05/2022 16:55

My gut feels the same as you, have a daughter in yr 7 at the moment. But my head tells me otherwise, so I have to get on with it.

Vikinga · 19/05/2022 16:54

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 16:37

Thanks @Hallyup89

That's a really good point.

My DD is outstandingly academic in her current class. She tends to get one of the end of year awards each year but compared to the rest of the class gets fewer of the weekly prizes as she never causes any trouble and so doesn't need the encouragement.

In my mind I've been thinking a smaller class will mean more encouragement and so she'd gain confidence.

But. I do realise there are a lot of children a lot brighter than her and in a grammar she won't be top of the class anymore. To me that's not important and I won't pressure her to be. But I don't want school to give her that impression.

What she does struggle with is being easily upset/annoyed/distracted by the children who misbehave at school. Her class teacher knows this and so keeps her near the front.

I worry that in a state secondary if she still struggled with that frustration it could hugely affect her learning. But she'll be older then so maybe isn't a consideration.

There are sets. If she's in the top sets there won't be kids misbehaving. My kids school have zero tolerance for misbehaviour at any set.

Auntpodder · 19/05/2022 16:53

You posted this while I was composing my post... If your DD is ND, I understand your concern. Thriving at school is often about finding your tribe and that might be at a small private school but can also be easier at a larger schools where there's a greater range of personality types.

mbosnz · 19/05/2022 16:53

You sound a very caring and concerned mother.

Can I suggest - what is even more important than shielding our children from the harder, nastier, and rougher elements in life, is giving them the tools to deal with them, themselves, and also having the lines of communication open with their parents that they feel safe to discuss them, if they feel out of their depth?

It's impossible now, to shield kids from porn, from drugs, from bullies, from social media messaging designed to make a girl feel insecure. . . so it's more important than ever that they feel you're not going to have a fit of the vapours and send them to a nunnery, if you find out that some contamination has occurred!

What I also think is important, is that while a child should not necessarily be given the deciding vote, they should feel their voice is heard, and that they have some input, in deciding what kind of school, and which specific school they would feel most comfortable attending. Because after all, that young person is the one who is going to be spending the next however many years there. Just because it's the most comfortable fit for the parent, doesn't mean to say it's the best fit for the child!

sickofthisnonsense · 19/05/2022 16:50

If you think bad behaviour and foul language are restricted to comps then you are in for a shock!!!!

Teenagers push boundaries and they all swear and have obnoxious conversations about inappropriate subjects.

I'm run a youth group with kids who mainly went to a 'nice' church primary and now go to grammars, private schools, CE comps the whole spectrum. They all have conversations and swear in a way their parents would not approve of. There is also a nasty tendency, from the grammar kids, to be snobby and look down on those who don't attend a grammar.

Tabitha005 · 19/05/2022 16:49

"... (DH and I grew up in a different county and went to grammars)..."

"... Because I've looked at results, spoken to friends who work in local comps, had them kids pass me when out and about..."

If we're being snobby about kids at state comprehensives, then we'd be failing hugely if we didn't lampoon the poor level of grammar exhibited by, ironically enough, an ex-grammar school pupil.

Auntpodder · 19/05/2022 16:48

FWIW I went to a series of private, selective girls schools and had brothers and a great role model in my father. I'd like to say I'd never consider the same for my DD but until a child reaches a certain age, it wouldn't make sense to be so categorical.

However, I don't think single sex education was good for me. It certainly didn't prevent bullying and self-harm (it was pre-internet and social media so that wasn't an issue). TBH, I'd say give things a bit of time. When it comes to making a decision, visit prospective schools - both state and private - with your DD and see how she feels/reacts, consider where her current friends are going and above all, what type of child she is then, as to now.

Will she want good sports facilities, a big bustling school where she can stretch her wings or a smaller one? If you've raised her correctly (and I have no doubt you're a loving parent), she'll have enough self-esteem to thrive in most schools.

NavigatingSEN · 19/05/2022 16:48

If your DD will need provision to support her neurodiversity, in my opinion it's better in state schools (besides the fact you often have yo pay for extra support in private schools). My son is autistic and the huge "requires improvement" secondary he goes to has been outstanding in the support offered to him.

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 16:46

Vikinga · 19/05/2022 16:44

You're being spectacularly snobbish and ridiculous. You think there isn't swearing and issues with kids who have money?

I've been to both private and state schools, have friends whose kids go to grammar, private and state schools. There is no difference. There are issues, kids don't perform better or worse. If they're bright and put in the work they'll do well. There are drugs, sex, smoking, drinking, bullying - everything.

My son got better GCSEs at our local comp than my friend's daughter did at the grammar school. And I didn't have to relocate and drive them to school.

Hmm RTFT

OP posts:
SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 16:44

effoffyouseeyounexttuesday · 19/05/2022 16:39

Of course it's your choice to go private etc but why start a thread in such a judgemental way - this site covers such a wide area no way would there be one answer.

Were you expecting everyone to agree and say it's ok it's all awful use a private school?

Maybe post the same on the local FB group instead - then you might get a better view.

No quite the opposite.

I realise (and stated so in my opening sentence) that I'm being hugely unreasonable and judgemental and (as I have also said on here) am currently in somewhat of an echo chamber and so wanted outside opinions.

Lots of which I've had and am very grateful for. And am feeling a lot more level headed about what to do going forward.

Luckily (as I also stated) I came expecting replies like yours from typical MN keyboard warriors not understanding hyperbole and just jumping in on the attack.

OP posts:
Vikinga · 19/05/2022 16:44

You're being spectacularly snobbish and ridiculous. You think there isn't swearing and issues with kids who have money?

I've been to both private and state schools, have friends whose kids go to grammar, private and state schools. There is no difference. There are issues, kids don't perform better or worse. If they're bright and put in the work they'll do well. There are drugs, sex, smoking, drinking, bullying - everything.

My son got better GCSEs at our local comp than my friend's daughter did at the grammar school. And I didn't have to relocate and drive them to school.