Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry that no state, non-selective secondary schools are good enough.

211 replies

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 13:08

I know I am BU. I know there will be loads of people who send their kids to the local comp and their kids do fine and get good results and aren't exposed to hideous language and behaviour daily.

But.

I can't see how that could happen having researched all of the local schools.

Oldest DD is 9yo. So this reality is suddenly hitting me.

We're in a non-Grammar area. (DH and I grew up in a different county and went to grammars)

There's a girls grammar 10 miles away which has its own entrance exam so that's where I'm keeping my fingers crossed for her.

I'm also trying to work out how we can afford private school.

Because I've looked at results, spoken to friends who work in local comps, had them kids pass me when out and about, seen them walking to and from school, seen posts on local Facebook pages.

And I just can't see how my DD would get through 5 years at any of them and achieve what she's capable of and come out happy and confident like she deserves to be.

I don't want her to get straight A*s but I do want her to feel comfortable and supported enough to achieve the best she can.

I know this will get flamed by most. As it sounds horribly horribly snobby. I guess my background of going to a school that expected a lot of us means I was sheltered from the reality of a lot of teenage life.

But I'm hoping there are some mums out there like me who are worried at how secondary schools are.

And if so how did you make it work for your kids? Private education? Moving house?

OP posts:
Clymene · 19/05/2022 19:10

A boy in the year above me died of an overdose and three of my friends had abortions under the age of 16 at my very expensive selective private school.

There are no guarantees. What is important is how much the parents are involved. Which is what you've said but to be honest that's lip service in a private school. if you pay, you can get them to say pretty much anything.

You only have to read the bio of not remotely bright BongBong Marcos who went to Oxford and then Wharton to realise that money still buys eduction.

cantkeepawayforever · 19/05/2022 19:04

I often post my family’s experience on threads like these, though it is a generation old. My parents were 1st generation grammar school products, worried about our local schooling options, gramnars abolished 5 years before ds due to start secondary. Our secondary destinations ranged from 11-16 just ex-secondary modern with almost no O level passes per year to highly selective boarding independent on a scholarship.

Our final A level and degree results (all Oxbridge) were essentially identical. The deciding factor was family not educational institution.

JoshLymanIsHotterThanSam · 19/05/2022 19:03

I went to an all girls grammar…still had sex at 13!
I have DC at comp and 1 at super selective grammar…it’s all the same language and filth out of all their mouths. Seriously OP, your kiddo is growing up and you need to get used to it

cantkeepawayforever · 19/05/2022 18:57

I think it is always worth digging down into schools’ results to see ‘how well the group of children that my child is likely to fall into’, rather than looking at headline results.

it is obvious that, if you compare a grammar school with almost 80% high attainers and the rest high middle; very low SEN; very low Pupil Premium /SEN with a school with a fully comprehensive intake, the comprehensive school’s ‘headline’ results will look worse.

The question you are trying to answer is ‘on average, how do high ability girls with SEN (if your dd’s ND is recorded formally as such) do in this school?’ You can get an inkling of this from the results and Progress 8 of the high attaining group alone; you can gain more by considering how large a percentage of the school falls into this group and still more by talking to the SENDCo at an open day.

Assuming a school is good because a selected intake gets better results than one with a more diverse intake is …. dubious. Newspapers do it all the tine. So do parents, and thus MN. It doesn’t make it true.

bookworm14 · 19/05/2022 18:56

Don’t make the mistake of thinking you can buy your way out of bad behaviour. My DH went to one of the most prestigious public schools in the country and was bullied mercilessly, to the extent that it has had a lasting effect on his mental health. Other pupils also referred to local state school kids as ‘plebs’, to give you an idea of the kind of people they were.

You get horrible twats whatever school you go to.

HappyHappyHermit · 19/05/2022 18:55

@stoneysongs This was my experience too, I totally agree.

stoneysongs · 19/05/2022 18:51

It's more that I want them to avoid twats.

Ha, this is partly why mine go to state school, having experienced private school myself. (NB not saying all private school students are twats but nearly all of the ones I was at school with were.)

Pinkishpurple · 19/05/2022 18:48

I went to bog standard comp (with some rough behaviour) but in my year people went onto to become doctors, dentists, solicitors, business, IT professionals etc. One of my children is now at a secondary, the behaviour of students is hit and miss (to say the least) but the exam results are very good. The very bright kids are a comps dream and they put alot of effort into making sure they achieve! I would say if your child is middling then these are the children that are sometimes forgotten so it's up to parent's to push. Also remember not all Independent Schools are good, in fact some are shocking! And in addition Grammar Schools take very bright kids in and funnily enough of course they do well. It doesn't mean the teaching is better.

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 18:47

Headteacher415 · 19/05/2022 18:32

A "typical" secondary school is a microcosm of society. Yes, there will be kids who are seriously off the wall. Many others will look at them with somewhere between dislike and pity. There will be others who are broadly decent sorts and who the posters here might perceive as a bit rough round the edges in terms of language etc. There will be others who are there to make the most of their education. By and large, most kids gravitate to their own sort, just as happens in adult life.

My own (completely unevidenced) perception is that the worst preparation for life are the extremes - yes, avoid the deprived inner city school where there may not be too many others like her; but equally avoid the highly selective private school where there isn't anyone who is not. At some point in life, your DD has to become aware of society and find her place in it, and while 11 is too young, 18 is also too late.

Look at (i) the balance of children going there - is it skewed in a particular way and (ii) the track record for more able - do they actually stretch the most able and conscientious or just leave them to it. And most of all, find a place which makes her feel comfortable and happy and the adults smile at the kids!

Thank you SO much.

You're so right and have given me so much to think about.

I don't want our desperation to protect our pre-teen to be at the detriment of her future life.

I think I need to really look harder at the state schools and as another poster said to ask hard questions.

Also consider perhaps a further move than we have been considering.

I don't mind a 20-30 minute commute for her (& I) during Y6 if it makes Y7-11 easier.

OP posts:
SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 18:45

mbosnz · 19/05/2022 18:36

OP, I think you'll find the 'our child could do no wrong' sort of a parent also exists in a select school, or an independent. If not more so. And that, yes, it's all the fault of the school. . .

Ah see I was sort of hoping the whole "interview the parents" process might weedle that out.

OP posts:
mbosnz · 19/05/2022 18:36

OP, I think you'll find the 'our child could do no wrong' sort of a parent also exists in a select school, or an independent. If not more so. And that, yes, it's all the fault of the school. . .

stopthepain · 19/05/2022 18:33

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 16:28

Just to play devils advocate with your comment about her getting into bad relationship after bad relationship.

How is her parents relationship compared to yours?

As honestly my DC could not have a better role model than my DH for when it comes to how a man should treat a woman. So I like to hope that even without boys are school my DD will have high expectations of how any boyfriends should treat her.

We both have amazing parents. Our parents are still together. No abuse. We are loved and our parents encouraged us to love learning from as soon as we could talk. The only difference really is that my parents are very young (early 20s when they had me) and working class and hers are much older (they were in their 40s when they had her) and have more money.

She doesn’t have brothers. There were boys in extracurricular clubs but, by the time she was 16 and in college, boys were pretty much a new concept. Her dad is great, but you can’t really compare a 60 odd year old man (the age he was when she was 16) to other 16 year old boys. This continued into her 20s. She’s learned now, but only because she’s observed more male behaviour since being at Uni and can compare behaviours.

Headteacher415 · 19/05/2022 18:32

A "typical" secondary school is a microcosm of society. Yes, there will be kids who are seriously off the wall. Many others will look at them with somewhere between dislike and pity. There will be others who are broadly decent sorts and who the posters here might perceive as a bit rough round the edges in terms of language etc. There will be others who are there to make the most of their education. By and large, most kids gravitate to their own sort, just as happens in adult life.

My own (completely unevidenced) perception is that the worst preparation for life are the extremes - yes, avoid the deprived inner city school where there may not be too many others like her; but equally avoid the highly selective private school where there isn't anyone who is not. At some point in life, your DD has to become aware of society and find her place in it, and while 11 is too young, 18 is also too late.

Look at (i) the balance of children going there - is it skewed in a particular way and (ii) the track record for more able - do they actually stretch the most able and conscientious or just leave them to it. And most of all, find a place which makes her feel comfortable and happy and the adults smile at the kids!

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 18:30

stoneysongs · 19/05/2022 18:24

But I like the idea that her peers will have parents who feel like DH and I when it comes to education.

This is a weird thing to say - there are parents who are committed to their DCs' education in all types of schools.

I went to a selective private school, as did my 3 siblings. None of us has chosen that for our children. We all understood how important parental involvement is and wanted our children to experience the social diversity that only state schools can provide. Plus there is no way I would want my kids being exposed to the attitudes that were prevalent amongst the people I went to school with.

It's not a weird thing to say at all.

I frequently hear mums at our school gates moaning about their two sons school (local comp)

About how the boys are getting detention every day, but they "aren't bad boys" and it's the schools job to sort their behaviour not the parents as school is boring for them and their sons are just having a laugh, boys will be boys.

Don't take so personally what I'm saying. MN is a very unlikely place for parents who don't care about their kids education to be.

But there are PLENTY of mums at my DCs primary who see school as an "us and them" thing and won't cooperate with the school at all.

Their kids can do no wrong and it's all the fault of the school.

It's damaging enough at primary level, and a lot worse at secondary. Any school teacher will tell you the worst part of teaching is the parents.

OP posts:
MsTSwift · 19/05/2022 18:30

Any issues we have ever had with our two teens have been caused by other middle class girls from “nice” families displaying cruel or even psychotic behaviour. The vaping / non academic / sweary type girls that some parents pearl clutch about their kids going to school with have always been very decent and friendly to my two.

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 18:24

KnitPurlKnitPurl · 19/05/2022 18:09

There are no grammar schools at all in Scotland. There are no single-sex state schools in Scotland. (actually, there might be one catholic girls' school, but it's very much the exception).

Your choice in Scotland is state or private. My kids are at a very good state comprehensive and we are more than happy with they are getting. Your "worry" is clearly not a worry at all, OP, as you have gone on to say you are only considering "2 specific girls independent schools".

Just leave the state education to the rest of us plebs who clearly don't want the best for our little darlings.

You mid understood me.

The only private schools I'm considering are those 2. There are at least another 6 close to us but don't hold the same things that we do as important for school life.

At least 5 state schools in consideration.

OP posts:
stoneysongs · 19/05/2022 18:24

But I like the idea that her peers will have parents who feel like DH and I when it comes to education.

This is a weird thing to say - there are parents who are committed to their DCs' education in all types of schools.

I went to a selective private school, as did my 3 siblings. None of us has chosen that for our children. We all understood how important parental involvement is and wanted our children to experience the social diversity that only state schools can provide. Plus there is no way I would want my kids being exposed to the attitudes that were prevalent amongst the people I went to school with.

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 18:22

Cliftontherocks · 19/05/2022 18:04

Daughter goes to an outstanding state but I’m getting frustrated she is level 9 predictions across the board but recently her English teacher gave her two level 7 s for assessments and then when she asked what she needed to do to improve to an 8 she was told a 7 is plenty good enough - and instead told her that 7s were fine and she shouldn’t worry about not getting 9s. In my view that isn’t helpful.

That's disheartening.

Our closest state school don't put ANY of the kids in for the higher level maths GCSE. So even if they were capable of high grades none of them achieve it.

This is what makes it almost a no go before I've even gone to the open day for me. Limiting the kids.

OP posts:
Darbs76 · 19/05/2022 18:17

My son got 9x9’s at GCSE (and a few 8’s) and is predicted 3 A*’s at A level. He went to the local comp after not getting into the grammar as we didn’t tutor him to sit the test. If you’re not happy with that then your best option is to move before you need to submit your choices in year 6

Loopytiles · 19/05/2022 18:14

in a ‘fully comprehensive’ area the popular schools with the ‘best’ results (% of DC getting whatever grades) will be clear and reflected in housing prices.

Doubleraspberry · 19/05/2022 18:13

Of course you want your little girl to be alright. Secondary full stop feels pretty big and scary, especially if she has additional needs.

We used to live in a part of London with some excellent state schools (very much the expensive sought-after catchment issues), some less prestigious but fine state schools - single sex mostly, and one really undesirable state school. We were also surrounded by famous public schools. And our primary head said the truest thing at the year 6 transition evening - 'never judge a school based on what you see on the bus because they are all awful on the bus'. He was quite right! Kids from all those schools behaved in ways you'd never want your own children to experience, but the reality is that teenagers can be pretty vile.

The public schools did appear, of course, on Everyone's Invited, including examples of the times that the kids from the boys' schools mixed with the ones from the girls schools.

Simonjt · 19/05/2022 18:10

I went to a bog standard comp in Nottinghamshire, I did very well and went to a very good university.

There are several outstanding comprehensive secondary schools where I live now, that I would be more than happy to send my son to.

KnitPurlKnitPurl · 19/05/2022 18:09

There are no grammar schools at all in Scotland. There are no single-sex state schools in Scotland. (actually, there might be one catholic girls' school, but it's very much the exception).

Your choice in Scotland is state or private. My kids are at a very good state comprehensive and we are more than happy with they are getting. Your "worry" is clearly not a worry at all, OP, as you have gone on to say you are only considering "2 specific girls independent schools".

Just leave the state education to the rest of us plebs who clearly don't want the best for our little darlings.

PickySlackTastic · 19/05/2022 18:05

There's bullying, drugs and anti social behaviour in private schools. Grammar schools, especially girls, are a hotbed of mental health issues with eating disorders and anxiety the main issues.

My dd was bullied at private prep and is happy and thriving at state comp - just a much more diverse, accepting community.

Groups of teens out and about are terrifying, I agree, but I wouldn't let that put you off state school.

Cliftontherocks · 19/05/2022 18:04

Daughter goes to an outstanding state but I’m getting frustrated she is level 9 predictions across the board but recently her English teacher gave her two level 7 s for assessments and then when she asked what she needed to do to improve to an 8 she was told a 7 is plenty good enough - and instead told her that 7s were fine and she shouldn’t worry about not getting 9s. In my view that isn’t helpful.