Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry that no state, non-selective secondary schools are good enough.

211 replies

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 13:08

I know I am BU. I know there will be loads of people who send their kids to the local comp and their kids do fine and get good results and aren't exposed to hideous language and behaviour daily.

But.

I can't see how that could happen having researched all of the local schools.

Oldest DD is 9yo. So this reality is suddenly hitting me.

We're in a non-Grammar area. (DH and I grew up in a different county and went to grammars)

There's a girls grammar 10 miles away which has its own entrance exam so that's where I'm keeping my fingers crossed for her.

I'm also trying to work out how we can afford private school.

Because I've looked at results, spoken to friends who work in local comps, had them kids pass me when out and about, seen them walking to and from school, seen posts on local Facebook pages.

And I just can't see how my DD would get through 5 years at any of them and achieve what she's capable of and come out happy and confident like she deserves to be.

I don't want her to get straight A*s but I do want her to feel comfortable and supported enough to achieve the best she can.

I know this will get flamed by most. As it sounds horribly horribly snobby. I guess my background of going to a school that expected a lot of us means I was sheltered from the reality of a lot of teenage life.

But I'm hoping there are some mums out there like me who are worried at how secondary schools are.

And if so how did you make it work for your kids? Private education? Moving house?

OP posts:
overorunder · 19/05/2022 23:36

I agree with you OP. In your situation I would homeschool.

hupfpferd · 19/05/2022 23:31

When your precious little darling is 9, it's impossible to conceive that they will BE the obnoxious teenager you pass on the street.

It just happens. You need to become wise to the reality of teens

BusyMum47 · 19/05/2022 23:11

So you're basing all of this on the assumption that kids who go to grammar school won't possibly ever swear or occasionally be badly behaved?? Good luck with that.

I went to grammar but hubby didn't. Our kid passed the grammar tests but opted for a non-grammar in the end & he's thriving. Predicted grade 9s in all of his GCSEs. Happy as Larry.

Success/happiness etc for a child at secondary school is about SO much more than whether or not it's a grammar.

Tigofigo · 19/05/2022 22:43

JudgeJ · 19/05/2022 13:42

aren't exposed to hideous language and behaviour daily.

Do you think that they wouldn't be exposed to these things at a grammar school or an independent school?

I wasn't exposed to a tenth of the things at my private school that my sibling at state school was

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 22:40

stoneysongs · 19/05/2022 21:53

I am ND too, undiagnosed at school. I think a perfect setting for me would have been a school with at least some other kids like me. It was feeling different, not as good as everyone else, that I struggled with.

If you can find a school with lots of ND kids, where they are celebrated, where the school is proud of them and they are proud of themselves, that might be good (at my DC's school for instance, one of the after school clubs is Autism Club). Not that autistic people should only mix with autistic people, but if I'd had people that understood and offered me a bit of solidarity, I think I would have felt less of a weirdo.

(I hope you know what I mean - of course this is all very personal to me - not saying it necessarily applies to your DC, especially the weirdo bit!)

A school with a fairly large ND population ought also to be very practised in helping ND kids to navigate and get the best out of school. I think asking the SENCO is a really good idea.

This sounds wonderful.

OP posts:
SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 22:39

Momicrone · 19/05/2022 22:11

You sound a bit deluded

Precisely why I needed advice and asked for it.

OP posts:
Essexgirlupnorth · 19/05/2022 22:31

I went to a grammar school but now live in an area that doesn't have and think it is better.
Yes I did well at school but some of my friends who where not as good academically wish they had gone to a comp rather than being made to feel not good enough. One of my school friend has just moved her daughter from a grammar to a comp because she was being horribly bullied mainly online and the school didn't or couldn't do much to stop it and her daughters happiness is more important than attending a grammar school.
It is possible to move schools if you really hate it. Not everyone can afford private school. In an ideal world all schools should offer the same education but schools get a reputation for being food, parents with the means will try and get their kids in to the school and are probably the parents who will support their child's education so the gulf better the good schools and the less good schools grow.

Momicrone · 19/05/2022 22:11

You sound a bit deluded

orwellwasright · 19/05/2022 22:08

I know someone who's recently pulled her child out of the local state school and sent her to the private one instead because girls at state school 'talk about boys too much and don't take their education seriously'.

I remember my school days when it was universally acknowledged that the girls at the private school in question were a right bunch of old slappers. Lol.

PickySlackTastic · 19/05/2022 22:01

Autism club- i love it! What a great idea.

stoneysongs · 19/05/2022 21:53

I am ND too, undiagnosed at school. I think a perfect setting for me would have been a school with at least some other kids like me. It was feeling different, not as good as everyone else, that I struggled with.

If you can find a school with lots of ND kids, where they are celebrated, where the school is proud of them and they are proud of themselves, that might be good (at my DC's school for instance, one of the after school clubs is Autism Club). Not that autistic people should only mix with autistic people, but if I'd had people that understood and offered me a bit of solidarity, I think I would have felt less of a weirdo.

(I hope you know what I mean - of course this is all very personal to me - not saying it necessarily applies to your DC, especially the weirdo bit!)

A school with a fairly large ND population ought also to be very practised in helping ND kids to navigate and get the best out of school. I think asking the SENCO is a really good idea.

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 21:39

PickySlackTastic · 19/05/2022 21:32

Its hard for bright girls with either ASD or ADHD. This is something my dd articulates really well - she says she feels really ashamed of not being perfect because girls 'like her' (bright, articulate, middle-class) are 'supposed' to be super-organised with a love for neatly drawn margins! She also talks about how she feels like she's held to higher standards with regards to her social skills, and she can't meet these standards. These things really affect her confidence.

It's wonderful that she can articulate it.

I always felt that shame. But of course tried to hide it.

Then couldn't be something I wasn't but just got told off for forgetting something or being lazy again.

OP posts:
PickySlackTastic · 19/05/2022 21:32

Its hard for bright girls with either ASD or ADHD. This is something my dd articulates really well - she says she feels really ashamed of not being perfect because girls 'like her' (bright, articulate, middle-class) are 'supposed' to be super-organised with a love for neatly drawn margins! She also talks about how she feels like she's held to higher standards with regards to her social skills, and she can't meet these standards. These things really affect her confidence.

3WildOnes · 19/05/2022 21:19

@Vikinga not all schools have sets, our local comp doesn't. Mixed ability classes increase attainment for the lower ability but I wasn't convinced that they don't bring down attainment in the higher ability students.

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 21:10

I guess my own looking back and seeing how much more I could have achieved with support makes me desperate for her to avoid that.

As well as my desperation to protect her and allow her to grow into the happiest and most confident woman she can be. And I think the private/girls schools pushing confidence is what made me so excited about them.

But this thread has also added something I hadn't considered which is her learning how to navigate the real world in the safety of a school environment rather than avoid it in a bubble.

OP posts:
SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 21:06

PickySlackTastic · 19/05/2022 21:03

Its so hard, isn't it? Because we parents have choice, we feel so much responsibility for making the right decision. Ultimately, so much of a child's school experience is out of our hands. A great form tutor, a new passion for an extra curricular activity, a life long friend your child sits next to in maths in year 8 - these things are so random but can be what makes school life great for a child. Likewise, the best school in the world can go downhill quickly after a change of leadership, or your dd could end up at a brilliant school but in the worst form in a tricky year group.

Also, there's no shame in going private if that feels right. I have ADHD and my mum always says she wishes I'd gone to the small all-girls private she ended up teaching in. Ill never know if she was right, but I really needed a lot more support than my state school secondary was able to give me. That was the 90s though, i was undiagnosed and my state was awful!

You're so right. Star

If my ADHD had been diagnosed (or if I had even myself been aware I was different and not just useless and lazy compared to other kids) I would have had so much less self hatred and disappointment.

I am still going to look at the 2 private schools. But I think I may also sit down with my DDs SENCO and ask their opinion on the local secondaries. As well as asking some of the great suggested questions here.

OP posts:
PickySlackTastic · 19/05/2022 21:03

Its so hard, isn't it? Because we parents have choice, we feel so much responsibility for making the right decision. Ultimately, so much of a child's school experience is out of our hands. A great form tutor, a new passion for an extra curricular activity, a life long friend your child sits next to in maths in year 8 - these things are so random but can be what makes school life great for a child. Likewise, the best school in the world can go downhill quickly after a change of leadership, or your dd could end up at a brilliant school but in the worst form in a tricky year group.

Also, there's no shame in going private if that feels right. I have ADHD and my mum always says she wishes I'd gone to the small all-girls private she ended up teaching in. Ill never know if she was right, but I really needed a lot more support than my state school secondary was able to give me. That was the 90s though, i was undiagnosed and my state was awful!

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 20:20

@PickySlackTastic

Thank you.

Really from the bottom of my heart.

You're SO right about coming from a grammar background how non selective secondaries are perceived.

I'm so grateful for so many of the replies here. Thank you to everyone who's taken the time.

So grateful. And feeling a lot calmer and like I can get some plans in place.

OP posts:
PickySlackTastic · 19/05/2022 20:04

Your opening post very honestly articulates a big reason why many parents send their child to private and grammar schools. As a former grammar school student, these feelings will be so heightened: I have many friends who were privately educated who just couldn't imagine sending their child to secondary. From the outside, state secondaries seem like the scariest of wild wests. Its impossible to envisage how learning, growth, support and happiness could happen in these places - but they do.

There are loads of advantages to private and grammar schools. But if your end goal is for your daughter to thrive and be happy, it might be worth bearing in mind a few things.

SEN provision in state far exceeds that in private. State schools are just much better resourced and there is so much expertise there. Dd has needs but no diagnosis and her school have just been so amazing from the get go. Dh and I are teachers, dds school has a significant number of chn from low-income backgrounds or with additional needs. Dd could easily have fallen out of view, but instead they have been proactive and super supportive.

You say you've looked at results, I would suggest you dig a bit deeper and look at schools Progress 8 data which gives an indication of their grades in comparison to SATS and assements they take in year 7. Covid has changed the requirements for reporting this data but you can look back to pre2020 info and you should get a good idea about academic performance.

I strongly agree with the point an pp made about private/grammar schools being a monoculture. While there are scary elements of state schools, it is easier to find a tribe in a large diverse school.

I would also add to that the importance of having local friends and short commutes that children can do independently. These things are invaluable in building confidence and a social network as your dd gets older. Even if you live right by your private/grammar school, chances are many of her friends won't be local.

Year 4 is a great time to start thinking about secondaries. You can go to open evenings in autumn of year 5 and start to get a feel for different schools. You might find a lot about state schools that you like a lot.

A final reflection about behaviour, bullying etc. State schools expect it, and good state schools are set up to deal with it. My dd is in a rough local comp and behaviour management at her place is seamless. State schools expect these things and see dealing with them as a key part of their job. Privste schools are a lot less comfortable with this and more likely to ignore/deny the worst of teenage behaviours. So homophobia, racism, bullying, social media issues, sexually aggressive language and behaviour - unfortunately, these things happen in all secondaries. Private schools are understandly wary about having their reputation tainted and consequently their responses to these issues are not always as rigorous as they should be and good practice not as consistently embedded.

Good luck with your decision.

cantkeepawayforever · 19/05/2022 19:58

I would ask very pointed questions about how many children who start the school on the SEN register are still there at the end of Y11 and Y1.

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 19:52

gwenneh · 19/05/2022 19:48

Oh, and about ND -- that's something to watch with private school. Neither private school my DC attended will admit to this for obvious reasons, but we watched ND children and their families be gently "managed out" of the setting in both schools. They talk a lot about support, but when it came time for families who needed the support to use it, they were less than helpful.

That's scary to hear. Thanks for the heads up.

My DD has ADHD, but is very bright and very engaged with school.

It manifests in her as anxiety and RSD mainly.

But also means she's very easily distracted by children misbehaving in class (in that she gets frustrated that it's stoping her focusing and then can't focus on what she needs to) and struggles with children who break rules.

So in my head a smaller, more academic setting would be a benefit.

She also (if she's like me) will maybe require more support to be organised once it starts coming to coursework etc. But she'll have the support of DH and I which I didn't from my parents.

OP posts:
gwenneh · 19/05/2022 19:48

Oh, and about ND -- that's something to watch with private school. Neither private school my DC attended will admit to this for obvious reasons, but we watched ND children and their families be gently "managed out" of the setting in both schools. They talk a lot about support, but when it came time for families who needed the support to use it, they were less than helpful.

gwenneh · 19/05/2022 19:45

Don’t make the mistake of thinking you can buy your way out of bad behaviour.

This, x1000. The parents and children of the school community are still human, and you'll find the same range of behaviours at private schools as you do in the state system. You're not any more likely to find parents with like concerns in a private school.than you are in the state system. You'll find people with a similar socioeconomic status and that's really it for common ground; the rest is just an assumption based on your own emotions.

My DC attended a private junior school but we have since changed to the local state school. The only noticeable difference is a slightly less well-funded theatre department.

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 19:44

WeOnlyTalkAboutBruno · 19/05/2022 19:35

Honestly, I think kids who are smart and come from stable, steady backgrounds with loving, interested and involved parents will do well pretty much anywhere.

i went to a private school (Scotland). Some of the kids were fucking bonkers. Parents who worked long hours in professional jobs. Plenty of money but no time. Led to drug problems. Eating disorders. And don’t even get me started on the “rugby boys”

I wouldn’t send my girls to an all-girls school. How else are they supposed to learn how to navigate and deal with real life? It’s such a bubble. I want my girls to be well rounded, normal people, with friends from all backgrounds, happy and likeable and confident and able to get along with anyone. As someone socially awkward with crippling self confidence issues that stem back to my own school days, that’s important to me

Thank you. You make really good points (as have many others) about why not to send DD to a girls school.

Like you I'm trying to avoid my DD suffering the damage I did in school.

I'm hoping wherever she goes it'll differ hugely as her ND is diagnosed, unlike myself, who wasn't until adulthood.

So she will have a lot more understanding and support than I did growing up. Also she doesn't have a mega pushy, totally non-understanding father like me. So she's ahead in that respect.

My desperation to give her every opportunity to be as happy as possible can cloud my judgement.

OP posts:
WeOnlyTalkAboutBruno · 19/05/2022 19:35

Honestly, I think kids who are smart and come from stable, steady backgrounds with loving, interested and involved parents will do well pretty much anywhere.

i went to a private school (Scotland). Some of the kids were fucking bonkers. Parents who worked long hours in professional jobs. Plenty of money but no time. Led to drug problems. Eating disorders. And don’t even get me started on the “rugby boys”

I wouldn’t send my girls to an all-girls school. How else are they supposed to learn how to navigate and deal with real life? It’s such a bubble. I want my girls to be well rounded, normal people, with friends from all backgrounds, happy and likeable and confident and able to get along with anyone. As someone socially awkward with crippling self confidence issues that stem back to my own school days, that’s important to me