Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry that no state, non-selective secondary schools are good enough.

211 replies

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 13:08

I know I am BU. I know there will be loads of people who send their kids to the local comp and their kids do fine and get good results and aren't exposed to hideous language and behaviour daily.

But.

I can't see how that could happen having researched all of the local schools.

Oldest DD is 9yo. So this reality is suddenly hitting me.

We're in a non-Grammar area. (DH and I grew up in a different county and went to grammars)

There's a girls grammar 10 miles away which has its own entrance exam so that's where I'm keeping my fingers crossed for her.

I'm also trying to work out how we can afford private school.

Because I've looked at results, spoken to friends who work in local comps, had them kids pass me when out and about, seen them walking to and from school, seen posts on local Facebook pages.

And I just can't see how my DD would get through 5 years at any of them and achieve what she's capable of and come out happy and confident like she deserves to be.

I don't want her to get straight A*s but I do want her to feel comfortable and supported enough to achieve the best she can.

I know this will get flamed by most. As it sounds horribly horribly snobby. I guess my background of going to a school that expected a lot of us means I was sheltered from the reality of a lot of teenage life.

But I'm hoping there are some mums out there like me who are worried at how secondary schools are.

And if so how did you make it work for your kids? Private education? Moving house?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CheersForThatEh · 11/05/2023 09:26

Friendship groups are the biggest part of it IMO.

I went to a terrible state school and a lot of people left with very little. Half the problem is that the kids arent academic and are shoehorned into doing academic work- half would have been better doing a practical course to learn a trade or skill like cookery, electrician, building etc when they made their Options in year 9 rather than being pushed through years of English Lit and History etc. which they clearly werent interested interested in or suited to. So many boys were absolute tossers at break times and in classes, apart from those classes where they were the top student and applied themselves. Many have gone on to have their own businesses, become chefs, tattoo artists... they were square pegs in round holes.

There were some friendship groups that did well at school and went to outside clubs like swimming. I think kids just need to find their tribe. And the curriculum as it stands has a lot to answer for in failing kids and putting them through years of schooling for things that they just arent capable of.

Basic maths and English is all that is needed and some kids will struggle with that. Lumping them in with kids trying to learn standard deviation is asking for trouble all around.

sashh · 11/05/2023 09:23

standoctor · 19/05/2022 13:56

Mate of mine was a teacher in London state
Went to work in a private school
Said the state school class had 23 kids out of or 32 for whom English was not the 1st language
Made it impossible for the kids who wanted to learn to do so
He just got depressed by it and had to get out
No way would I let my kids go to state education
It is too important

I call bullshit.

I've taught classes where 100% had English as a second or additional language. I've taught in places where I'm the only white person in the room.

The only time I had a problem was that I was supposed to be teaching IT and the room had no computers.

I've done a lot of supply and I've seen some terrible behaviour but that is not the case in every school and in every class.

I mean imagine having to go to school with people who have English as a second language like Michel Roux junior, Natalie Portman, Albert Einstein...

Flamingogirl08 · 11/05/2023 09:14

bookworm14 · 11/05/2023 08:17

This thread is a year old!

Oh bloody hell. I hate that!

Flamingogirl08 · 11/05/2023 09:13

It's hard thinking about secondary school because we can never imagine our babies being in that world. However they grow up fast when they hit year 7 and there's no point trying to shield them from everything.

That being said absolutely try and get her into the school you feel is most suitable for her.

I don't have any experience of private school but I went to the local all girls Catholic school and never had any problems Even though it was in a 'rough' area. All my friends from school came out the other side and have good careers and happy lives.

girljulian · 11/05/2023 09:01

What the…??

I went to a comp in the north east, I got straight A*s and then I went to Oxford. YABU

bookworm14 · 11/05/2023 08:17

This thread is a year old!

MovinGroovinBarbie · 11/05/2023 03:00

We once had to have an assembly because someone smeared shit on the walls and threw bloody tampons around one of the toilets. The head asked us not to do this again. I'd consider that pretty hideous behaviour and none of my friends at state schools had that.

Same at my private secondary - mixed catholic school. Somebody smeared shit all around the girls loos. Twice!

Mum1976Mum · 11/05/2023 02:53

My 2 children go to private school as I’m a teacher in the local state schools and I would not send mine there. The schools have no money, hardly any teachers and behaviour is terrible. And these are good schools! My children have thrived at private. If anyone gets a detention it’s the talk of the school it’s so rare. They do fantastic activities until 6pm, all homework is done in school time and the extra curricular opportunities are amazing. The teachers are fab and there is a lovely, respectful relationship between them and the pupils. Doing well and getting good grades is celebrated rather than being seen as ‘sad’ like it is in some of the local schools.

People are often quick to criticise private schools on here but often it’s the politics of envy. We aren’t rich but give up other things as we believe our children will do so much better in private.

Millysaurus · 20/05/2022 16:45

I went to two independent, selective schools (one single sex and one mixed) and I currently teach in a state comp so it's safe to say I have a range of experience.

Teenagers have the ability to be delightful and vile in equal measure across all types of schools. As a pupil, I experienced the cruelty of bullies and entitled behaviour as well as benefiting from a wider variety of opportunities and resources and smaller class sizes etc. So, a mixed bag. As a teacher I see the difficulties of working with large classes, behavioural issues and less resources but I also see the positives.

I think it really boils down to the school itself not the type of school it is - as there will be issues of some sort wherever you send her.

However, I do think it's best to admit to yourself that vile sexual language and sexist attitudes are a systemic issue and something that, unless things improve drastically in the next two years, your daughter is unfortunately going to be exposed to wherever she goes to school.

SecondarySnob · 20/05/2022 16:01

Sweetleftfood · 20/05/2022 15:32

I think this must be the most nidicolous post I have ever read on MN, are you seriously thinking that grammars for instance are immune to bad language or "bad boys" you are seriously kidding yourself. Go check out your schools and make an informed choice, where we live the poshest school has the biggest drug problem but hey ho they are "naice" kids so it doesn't matter

Thanks for your help. You've clearly read the full thread. Star

OP posts:
Sweetleftfood · 20/05/2022 15:32

I think this must be the most nidicolous post I have ever read on MN, are you seriously thinking that grammars for instance are immune to bad language or "bad boys" you are seriously kidding yourself. Go check out your schools and make an informed choice, where we live the poshest school has the biggest drug problem but hey ho they are "naice" kids so it doesn't matter

Mumwantingtogetitright · 20/05/2022 12:53

I think our perceptions are influenced heavily by our own experience. I am also ND (adhd), same for dd. I didn't have a diagnosis at school. Went to a bog standard state comp, but did really well there, got outstanding results despite my ND challenges, went to Cambridge, have enjoyed a very successful and rewarding career etc etc. I have never felt at all disadvantaged by my comprehensive school background - quite the contrary, actually, as it has given me much better insights into the lives of the people around me and a belief that my success has been founded on merit rather than on any unfair advantages gained as a result of going to a particular type of school. DD is on a similar trajectory and has gained immensely from being in a diverse socioeconomic environment. She has plenty of friends at private school, and I have plenty of friends with kids at private and selective state schools, and neither of us have seen any real advantages in either. The kids aren't any happier. They aren't more confident. They aren't more successful. They aren't better behaved. They aren't more rounded as individuals. They are just ordinary kids like all of her other friends.

MrsRinaDecker · 20/05/2022 11:09

I live in an area with rubbish state schools. The two closest (and as we’re in Scotland it’s a catchment based system) are in the bottom dozen in the country for results. There are very few resources for bright kids, nor for support for those with mild sen. Everything is put into firefighting and the environment is more a holding centre / social work department than focused on education. Don’t get me wrong, they do wonderful things supporting dc with horrible home lives, but older ds was drowning in that environment, and younger ds would never have coped.
I ended up home educating, and it was definitely the right choice for our family. Otherwise I think I would have needed to move (difficult in my personal situation) or (at least for ds1) aim for a scholarship to private school.

SecondarySnob · 20/05/2022 10:04

clary · 20/05/2022 09:30

@SecondarySnob I wanted to say that I think you have taken some serious criticism (not least from me) on the chin here and I salute you for that. Your OP was somewhat tone deaf and definitely came across as snobby; if you had perhaps articulated what you said in your later posts about the reasons for your concerns and your DD's ADHD we might not have come down on you so hard.

Some great posts here from parents of ND children or ND adults themselves; I really hope things are better now than they were for some of you. My DD and DS1 are both ND in different ways and were well supported in a state secondary. Best of luck with your choices but remember you cannot shield your child forever. @Headteacher415 and @mbosnz have articulated well what I feel.

I should add that my single-sex educational issues were compounded because the uni I chose was full of ex-public school boys who had been educated in an all-boy boarding house bubble at Winchester and Marlborough - so they were as clueless as I was! I am sure all of this is very different now.
Very best of luck to you and your DD.

Ah thanks.

For the obvious reasons I NC for this.

The ND part of me is prone to over dramatic knee jerk actions - so that's a big part of the opening post. Blush

Also - I've tried ND based posts in the past and they don't get the traffic. So having been on MN long enough to know wording something like a Daily Mail reader would get the thread some popularity I jumped in with both feet. (And my flame proof suit on.)

Very grateful I did. As apart from the couple of typo idiots even the harsher criticisms have helped me a lot.

But - I am a snob when it comes to my DCs. I want the best for them in every way. But it's figuring out what that best looks like that's proving difficult and I think it was easy to assume that private = best as it's a world I am clueless about. But from the outside seems much better.

I feel that state school didn't do me the best it could have so that made me think the alternative would help DD, who is just a little me, but a lot kinder and gentler and I don't want her broken.

OP posts:
twistyizzy · 20/05/2022 09:36

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 13:08

I know I am BU. I know there will be loads of people who send their kids to the local comp and their kids do fine and get good results and aren't exposed to hideous language and behaviour daily.

But.

I can't see how that could happen having researched all of the local schools.

Oldest DD is 9yo. So this reality is suddenly hitting me.

We're in a non-Grammar area. (DH and I grew up in a different county and went to grammars)

There's a girls grammar 10 miles away which has its own entrance exam so that's where I'm keeping my fingers crossed for her.

I'm also trying to work out how we can afford private school.

Because I've looked at results, spoken to friends who work in local comps, had them kids pass me when out and about, seen them walking to and from school, seen posts on local Facebook pages.

And I just can't see how my DD would get through 5 years at any of them and achieve what she's capable of and come out happy and confident like she deserves to be.

I don't want her to get straight A*s but I do want her to feel comfortable and supported enough to achieve the best she can.

I know this will get flamed by most. As it sounds horribly horribly snobby. I guess my background of going to a school that expected a lot of us means I was sheltered from the reality of a lot of teenage life.

But I'm hoping there are some mums out there like me who are worried at how secondary schools are.

And if so how did you make it work for your kids? Private education? Moving house?

Not BU, this is exactly our situation being in a non-grammar area with less than ideal state secondaries so we are now aiming for private school. Tutoring and keeping everything crossed that she gets in.

SecondarySnob · 20/05/2022 09:35

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

Yes exactly.

I intended to type "the children" and an 'm' got added to the end. Or perhaps I originally worded it as "them" and decided to change it to "the children" and forgot to remove the 'm'

But, even if I did say "them people" instead of "those people" that isn't the point of this thread and you're not helping anyone by picking on it.

Which school did you go to as I'll make sure to avoid it? I'd sooner my kids had friends who used English grammar incorrectly than were bullies.

OP posts:
jeaux90 · 20/05/2022 09:34

I posted earlier but just wanted to come back and say my DD13 has adhd and ASD. The best setting for her was an all girls private school with small class sizes. She is flourishing there.

It's all about the right setting for an individual child.

If she was NT and super confident the local secondary may well have worked well for her.

So that's the parents perspective.

A feminist perspective (which I also am) is that girls do academically better in single sex schools. The numbers on sexual assaults within mixed secondary schools over a three year period in the UK was over 5000 including over 500 rapes. These are only the ones that were reported.

And whilst 98% of sexual crimes are committed by males I'd say you should be looking at a single sex school for your bright ND DD.

clary · 20/05/2022 09:30

@SecondarySnob I wanted to say that I think you have taken some serious criticism (not least from me) on the chin here and I salute you for that. Your OP was somewhat tone deaf and definitely came across as snobby; if you had perhaps articulated what you said in your later posts about the reasons for your concerns and your DD's ADHD we might not have come down on you so hard.

Some great posts here from parents of ND children or ND adults themselves; I really hope things are better now than they were for some of you. My DD and DS1 are both ND in different ways and were well supported in a state secondary. Best of luck with your choices but remember you cannot shield your child forever. @Headteacher415 and @mbosnz have articulated well what I feel.

I should add that my single-sex educational issues were compounded because the uni I chose was full of ex-public school boys who had been educated in an all-boy boarding house bubble at Winchester and Marlborough - so they were as clueless as I was! I am sure all of this is very different now.
Very best of luck to you and your DD.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 20/05/2022 09:13

SecondarySnob · 19/05/2022 14:26

Since I saw the typo as I reread my (uneditable post) I've been waiting for this reply.

Thanks for not disappointing!

That isn't a typo. A typo is where you spell something incorrectly.

Doubleraspberry · 20/05/2022 08:13

PickySlackTastic · 19/05/2022 21:32

Its hard for bright girls with either ASD or ADHD. This is something my dd articulates really well - she says she feels really ashamed of not being perfect because girls 'like her' (bright, articulate, middle-class) are 'supposed' to be super-organised with a love for neatly drawn margins! She also talks about how she feels like she's held to higher standards with regards to her social skills, and she can't meet these standards. These things really affect her confidence.

I just wanted to say thank you to your DD, @PickySlackTastic for articulating so beautifully something that has bothered me for 40 years. Another person who went through school in the 80s and 90s as a high achiever with undiagnosed ADHD salutes her.

I still remember my teacher in the last year of primary saying to the whole class ‘Raspberry’s project is full of information but it’s a total and utter mess’ and feeling so upset. I’ve never got rid of that feeling that my colouring and margins just made me a bad girl.

Murdoch1949 · 20/05/2022 01:41

Hands up, successful secondary school teacher, with 4 adult children who all went to state schools and developed into successful and happy adults, achieving exam success that took them to university. I specifically chose a comprehensive school for my children, although 2 of the 4 would have passed the 12+. I saw the effects of single sex grammar & private schools on teenage girls - bullying, eating disorders, sexuality issues etc. In some grammar/private schools there can also be an over-reliance on examination success at the expense of the children's wellbeing. Post 16, many have no interest in children who will not achieve high A'level grades & progress to university. If you have independent, well balanced and self assured children then they'll cope in any school.

TheoSawUs · 20/05/2022 00:30

I think a lot of it depends on the individual child. I would be happy to send my elder DD to our local state school because I know she would do well wherever she goes but I would only consider private education for my younger DD who struggles academically and socially and needs the smaller and more nurturing environment of a non-selective private school.

Nat6999 · 20/05/2022 00:26

Ds went to an outstanding primary school & had a terrible time due to bullying, the staff were awful & the best day he had at that school was the day he was leaving. It doesn't matter what impression you get of a school, you will only really know what the school is like when your child goes there. If your child is hard working they will do well wherever they are.

Nat6999 · 20/05/2022 00:17

Ds went to a school that was graded as requires improvement, it had a demographic of high percentage of children from council estates & pupils who got Pupil premium. Ds got good grades for his GCSE's, there were lots of pupils in his year got grades 8 & 9 for all subjects & the sixth form is the highest achieving in the city.

Ticksallboxes · 19/05/2022 23:59

You need to move house. Sorry.

My DCs are at the most brilliant state secondary in our area (South East).