Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Married to Mum?

60 replies

SaveMePlease · 19/05/2022 00:23

Hi all - AIBU? Big moan/rant ahead

I'm a man who has been married for 8 years. I have a great relationship with my in-laws (and my MIL in particular), but the relationship between my DW and MIL is now impacting me so much that it's reaching breaking point for my marriage.

My DW is very close to her mum and it's something I used to see as incredibly positive. Whilst I did have grumblings about how often they spoke on the phone (personally it seemed a bit unhealthy but more because it might interrupt a movie we might be watching), it wasn't a huge issue. However since having kids, I'm finding their whole relationship unbearable and even consider a breakup reasonable just to maintain my sanity.

Since having kids, my DW speaks to her mum on the phone multiple times a day including in the evenings when the kids are asleep. They talk about fairly unimportant things and whilst that is none of my business, it's the minute run down of what the kids have been up to, what they ate, what time they went to sleep which drives me mad as I'm basically having to next to DW on the sofa, putting our evening on hold or having a show/film on pause to essentially listen to a rehash of our day. Often it will involve my MIL making her own suggestions about why we didn't try this or that as well. I'm sure many of you can understand that when you have two kids under 3, having a few hours in the evening to watch TV is the only time you might get some down time and instead, I have to break this up so that my DW can speak to her mum for the third time to update her on what the kids have done in the four hours since they last spoke.

In the last six months we've been on holiday twice. I was looking forward to having some time with just me, DW and kids and instead, every evening was once again a long video call so they could literally go through everything we did on the day whilst on holiday. At one point, as we were in a hotel room, I decided go and have a 40 minute shower just to hide myself away. I have told DW about how excessive calls are ruining our evenings and it's now got to a stage where when her mum calls, at any time of day, I will just leave the room to try and maintain a calm distance (something DW has actually told my MIL I do).

I should add that MIL actually comes over to pick up and drop off the kids twice during the week so it's not even that she doesn't see the kids and is compensating by video calling all the time. Often they'll spend more time on the phone on the days when they've already physically seen each other!

My in-laws, whilst happily married, basically operate as individuals who do their own separate things 90% of the time. What that seems to mean is that my MIL who doesn't work and has lots of free time, is taking the luxury to call my DW whenever she wants and assumes that like my FIL, I don't want spend evenings with my DW.

I think what upsets me is that I have brought this up with my wife and whilst she said we should sit down and talk about it later this week, she has indicated that I am in the wrong. I'm from an Asian background where there is a lot more emphasis on the 'marrying into the family' but I certainly don't agree with this and in any case, this all feels like too much involvement in our immediate family. I do have wider issues over MIL getting involved in all sorts of decisions but I'll keep this focussed on what I see as excessive phone calls.

I know many women have incredibly close relationships with their mums but I see this as eroding the independence within our relationship and for right or wrong, it's impacting the dynamic of my relationship with my wife. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Eightiesfan · 20/05/2022 00:45

OP, this sounds very much like the relationship my DM had with my DGM. My mums side of the family are also Indian. My DM was the youngest and deferred to my nan on almost everything. My DGP lived with us for several years when we were very young , and when they moved out DM visited them every single day. Growing up our lives revolved around them to an unhealthy degree which I can see once I had a partner and family of my own.

My parents relationship crumbled under the strain of my DGM presence in their relationship and DM reliance on her mum, so much so that my dad just gave up, both being a husband and father. Don’t get me wrong my nan was a wonderful woman, but she enabled my DM inability to make her own decisions and live independently of her parents.

My dad treated my mum terribly, it’s in no way an excuse but my mum involved my nan in every aspect of her life, and to be fair she always made some excuse not to have time with just the two of them, eventually my dad stopped asking and started living his life separately from us all, which eventually led him to numerous affairs and they finally divorced about 5 years ago having had a miserable excuse of a marriage for over 30 years.

I do think my mums relationship with my Nan was at the heart of the failure of their relationship, although I also think my DF was not really cut out for family life and to fair he was a complete dick for most of our lives.

In your position, you are going to have to set boundaries, the issue is with your DW, she is sabotaging your marriage. She seems aware of what she’s doing so the question is why is she doing it knowing that it’s upsetting you to the point that you cannot be in the same room as her?

aloris · 20/05/2022 00:41

I suspect this problem is not going to go away quickly but I think you can do things to help it. I think if you try to make too big a change, she will be unhappy and will be unable to follow through, and it will end up with you feeling like she is not listening to you. I think you need to find out what need these conversations with her mother fill for her, and then see if there is way to get her needs AND your needs met at the same time.

I also think you yourself need to work out, what is a boundary you can draw that meets your own need and that does not step on your wife's boundaries. I don't think you can say, 'You need to not talk to your mum after 7 pm." That is controlling your wife's behavior. But you could say, "I am tired after work and I need to feel like I can relax at some point in the evenings. So I would like that, by 8 pm, I can watch a show and wind down for bedtime. This means I would like the house to be quiet, no more social phone calls after 8 pm, as the noise is distracting. Is that possible for you?" That is asserting your own boundary: you want some downtime to watch tv that is not at the mercy of having to stop for undefined periods and listen to her half of her conversation with her mother.

Now, she may just decide that she will take her mother's phone calls in the bedroom so you can watch a show by yourself. Then you have to decide how to handle that.

Oceanus · 20/05/2022 00:06

It think you actually love your wife which is adorable so just have an honest chat with her. I'm sure you'll be able to work it out. Don't keep it in like you clearly have for a while as it's eating you up. Just TALK to her.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 19/05/2022 23:56

DonnyBurrito · 19/05/2022 10:24

I actually agree with this.

If MIL is providing a fair amount of childcare, then keeping in touch on a day to day basis means she's up to date with what's going on with the kids so she can keep a unified front with your DW when it comes to parenting. What a brilliant support network she's being for your DW. MIL may also be aware that you aren't interested in 'rehashing' the day to consider what went well/can be improved on with your DW, and your DW is obviously interested in doing this, so MIL is filling a gap you're leaving.

Maybe your DW isn't interested in zoning out infront of the TV every night. Why don't you, you know, have a conversation with her?

Probably because she’s on the phone with her mother, so he can’t.

DamnYouMonicaGellerHyphenBing · 19/05/2022 23:54

I just want to thank you @SaveMePlease for posting this. At first I actually thought it was my DH who had posted this about me as this is what me and my mum are like. I FaceTime her at least 2-3 times a day. I have a 15 week old baby and the FaceTime calls have increased. My husband has also commented on it.

Time for me to scale it back - thanks again and to the replies on here for opening my eyes

DonnyBurrito · 19/05/2022 23:38

SaveMePlease · 19/05/2022 11:11

Thanks for your reply. I came on here to see if my way of thinking was unreasonable and therefore am happy to see it from the other side as it were. I do think that since CV, my wife has been working from home and has limited contact with her friends and I've always tried to be supportive in telling her to go out and make plans and I'll look after the kids. She's always spoken to her mum once or twice a day but I think the frequency and length of chats has increased since having kids. I'm certainly not dismissive of what she speaks to her mum about, it's just that I'm not one for small talk on the phone and have told her that I would never want to do anything which would limit or place restrictions on her relationship with her mum and that is why I try and leave the room or suggest we maybe have a few separate holidays.

If truth be told, I don't think she is filling any gap as my DW and I discuss our kids endlessly already and I take a very involved approach to all aspects of our kids lives. I suppose my view is that, despite getting childcare from them, does that mean I should accept that I'm not entitled to wanting to feel like a family of four and having 'our time'? We have had conversations about it and if there is one thing my DW loves, it's zoning out in front of the TV! When MIL takes the kids, she will call multiple times just to tell DW about small things that happened and one thing I accept is that my wife and I see things differently i.e. I see the time we don't have the kids as time to do our own things and switch off from 'parent mode' whereas she will never switch off and I suppose that is why she is an incredible mother. However there are still the other five days of the week when we have the kids - we are a family and most of the time it genuinely feels like we are living in an extended family.

I see, then it sounds like your MIL is maybe more in the driving seat of this unusually intense closeness. I think she's being a brilliant support for both you and your DW, and is obviously very caring and involved with your kids. I'd just tread very carefully because neither of them are doing anything inherently wrong.

You've had loads of good suggestions on how to go about hopefully getting more quality time with your DW in the evenings without creating an enemy out of your MIL.

You could also plan a cinema date with her every couple of weeks when MIL has the kids, go see anything. She can't/won't be on her phone at all then!

ZebraLyghts · 19/05/2022 13:16

My sister in law is like this with my MIL, to the point where her husband has been pushed out and barely has a role anymore...even all 'family' holidays/days out etc are only taken with my MIL. Bizarre

Classicblunder · 19/05/2022 12:23

I think some women basically see their mum as their child raising partner and main emotional support and their husband as someone who dips in and out. And a lot of men are happy with that dynamic too.

But it sounds like you aren't which is a problem.

I wonder if the way to address it is to be less "don't call your mum" and more "once a week, I would really like to have a phones away, just us evening where we can really chat and focus on each other, is that ok?"

Mariposista · 19/05/2022 12:06

Speaking as a woman who is very close to her mum and grandma, this is ridiculous!

Tamzo85 · 19/05/2022 12:01

Peanutbuttercupisyum · 19/05/2022 11:59

Does she not have friends? I’ll discuss stuff like what we’re doing for kids dinner, bedtime, tantrums etc everyday with my friends - whichever friend I’m seeing that day. Evenings are for hanging with DH and tv, like you say.

@Peanutbuttercupisyum

What’s wrong with discussing it with her Mum instead of or as well as friends?

Peanutbuttercupisyum · 19/05/2022 11:59

Does she not have friends? I’ll discuss stuff like what we’re doing for kids dinner, bedtime, tantrums etc everyday with my friends - whichever friend I’m seeing that day. Evenings are for hanging with DH and tv, like you say.

IEatChocolateForBreakfast · 19/05/2022 11:57

YANBU. My husband is slightly similar in that he talks to his mum multiple times a day. It drives me mental.

GregBrawlsInDogJail · 19/05/2022 11:53

Patients in the actual ICU don't require hours of detailed handover a day. When I get home from work, I neither need nor want a minute by minute breakdown of what DC got up to, and I certainly don't call home at lunchtime to get one. "DC had a lovely time at nursery, played with X and made you this paper jellyfish, still coughing a little bit but he enjoyed his pasta for tea and ate it all" is plenty.

YANBU. This is enmeshment, probably driven by anxiety of some sort.

floppybit · 19/05/2022 11:52

I see someone has already mentioned the period between dinner and bedtime as being MIL free, this is a good idea. Then they can chat all day to their hearts content

floppybit · 19/05/2022 11:50

YANBU at all! To keep things clear I think your wife needs to tell her mother no to call after a certain time so that your evenings are protected. Your marriage is being damaged by this and she is not respecting your time together

AmericanStickInsect · 19/05/2022 11:40

YANBU but rather than discuss what is an acceptable amount for your wife and mother in law to be in contact, I would try and leave MIL right out of the conversation and discuss what is an acceptable amount of time you would like to have with you wife. Rather than 'don't talk to your MIL for 2 hours in the evening', go for 'I would like us to have some uninterrupted time in the evening as a couple, it's important for me for x y z reasons...'
For what it's worth, what you're experiencing would drive me absolutely potty. I also think she should leave the room if she's on the phone not you!

Dragongirl10 · 19/05/2022 11:39

Your wife is being unreasonable, l would be pretty cross if my DH regularly interrupted movie night for banal chat with his brother/father etc..making us wait....
Same with family dinners, outings etc, it would become intolerable to me.

I would think a daily chat fine and twice sometimes but this is excessive.

Menora · 19/05/2022 11:35

I can’t believe some of the responses. I imagine if it was the wife posting here about her MIL it would be a very different story. Only women are allowed issues with MIL’s and boundaries

purpleboy · 19/05/2022 11:17

Tamzo85 · 19/05/2022 11:14

Living in an extended family is a good thing.

Sure, but not at the expense of your marriage.

This is way too much contact over things that don't need to be dissected. It's sounds a very unhealthy dynamic between them and way OTT.

I speak to my mum every day but not at the expense of time with my husband. There is a balance and it's not being struck here.

TakemedowntoPotatoCity · 19/05/2022 11:16

It does seem excessive. Look up enmeshment, as it seems like your DW and MIL have this kind of relationship. I hope things improve and she can find a better balance.

Tamzo85 · 19/05/2022 11:14

Living in an extended family is a good thing.

Tamzo85 · 19/05/2022 11:12

@DoItAfraid

As far as from this post goes there’s nothing wrong with their marriage other than the husbands attitude to the wife talking about her children with her mother. If she’s doing most of the caring that’s a big deal and something she wants to talk about, he should be able to understand that.

Unless she never lets him have his own time or style of doing things this is healthy. She could just as easily have a problem with the way he does things, but instead she simply goes about her business happy for him to do the same.

Where is the problem?

SaveMePlease · 19/05/2022 11:11

DonnyBurrito · 19/05/2022 10:24

I actually agree with this.

If MIL is providing a fair amount of childcare, then keeping in touch on a day to day basis means she's up to date with what's going on with the kids so she can keep a unified front with your DW when it comes to parenting. What a brilliant support network she's being for your DW. MIL may also be aware that you aren't interested in 'rehashing' the day to consider what went well/can be improved on with your DW, and your DW is obviously interested in doing this, so MIL is filling a gap you're leaving.

Maybe your DW isn't interested in zoning out infront of the TV every night. Why don't you, you know, have a conversation with her?

Thanks for your reply. I came on here to see if my way of thinking was unreasonable and therefore am happy to see it from the other side as it were. I do think that since CV, my wife has been working from home and has limited contact with her friends and I've always tried to be supportive in telling her to go out and make plans and I'll look after the kids. She's always spoken to her mum once or twice a day but I think the frequency and length of chats has increased since having kids. I'm certainly not dismissive of what she speaks to her mum about, it's just that I'm not one for small talk on the phone and have told her that I would never want to do anything which would limit or place restrictions on her relationship with her mum and that is why I try and leave the room or suggest we maybe have a few separate holidays.

If truth be told, I don't think she is filling any gap as my DW and I discuss our kids endlessly already and I take a very involved approach to all aspects of our kids lives. I suppose my view is that, despite getting childcare from them, does that mean I should accept that I'm not entitled to wanting to feel like a family of four and having 'our time'? We have had conversations about it and if there is one thing my DW loves, it's zoning out in front of the TV! When MIL takes the kids, she will call multiple times just to tell DW about small things that happened and one thing I accept is that my wife and I see things differently i.e. I see the time we don't have the kids as time to do our own things and switch off from 'parent mode' whereas she will never switch off and I suppose that is why she is an incredible mother. However there are still the other five days of the week when we have the kids - we are a family and most of the time it genuinely feels like we are living in an extended family.

OP posts:
Babyvenusplant · 19/05/2022 11:11

orwellwasright · 19/05/2022 08:32

You seem dismissive of the things she finds important to talk about. Details of your day aren't trivial, they're a critical way that people connect with others and particularly important to women who've been chatting like this for millennia.

Does she talk to her mum so much because she's not getting what she needs from you?

The mil really doesn't need a run down of every single thing that happened every day, it's excessive

Tamzo85 · 19/05/2022 11:09

orwellwasright · 19/05/2022 08:32

You seem dismissive of the things she finds important to talk about. Details of your day aren't trivial, they're a critical way that people connect with others and particularly important to women who've been chatting like this for millennia.

Does she talk to her mum so much because she's not getting what she needs from you?

@orwellwasright

Strongly agree. And to add to this point it’s actually alright if he can’t give her this in the relationship, as he’s a man it may not be something that’s natural for him - but that’s why it’s a good thing she can talk this way with her mother and why he should let it be. He can fufill (hopefully) a different need for his wife than her mother and vice versa. That is normal. the genders aren’t the same and it’s foolish modern claptrap to think they should be the all of everything in a marriage to each other.

Swipe left for the next trending thread