Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to rip flowers out of my garden and plant edibles?

35 replies

Cookiecrumblepie · 18/05/2022 22:01

As above. Thinking of trying my hand at growing some veg and maybe buying a dwarf apple tree, but I wonder if this will make my garden look like an allotment, or whether a lot of people grow veg at home?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DdraigGoch · 18/05/2022 23:41

If you're looking primarily to save money, then concentrate upon soft fruit. Raspberries, blueberries, strawberries etc.

wallpoppy · 18/05/2022 23:39

Sorry this is sort of off topic but someone mentioned that the supermarket herbs in the plastic pots always die - this is because there are approximately eleven thousand plants in each pot, which is way too crowded for long term survival. They are absolutely fucking DOUSED in fertiliser to get them big and bushy but that only gets them so far. If you do want them to live on, take them out of the pot, gently pull all the separate plants apart, and choose a few to replant. If it's basil, you don't even need to do that - just cut a few pieces and root them in a glass of water for a few days and then plant them out in well-draining soil.

You'll usually have luck with basil, rosemary, oregano, and thyme and mint of course but be careful about sticking that in your garden unless you want an ALL MINT GARDEN. Chives, coriander, parsley, and dill are a bit more delicate but still worth a try.

WDTABNONONO · 18/05/2022 23:37

Came on here to read people telling you how magic mushrooms are illegal to grow in this country but you insisting anyway.

I'm not sure if I'm disappointed or relieved 😌

DdraigGoch · 18/05/2022 23:35

What about an espalier for your apple tree(s)? Really reduces the land take whilst upping output

elephantoverthehill · 18/05/2022 23:22

Jeff/Geoff Hamilton wrote a good book on this. I think it was called ' The cottage vegetable garden'. My copy has long since disappeared but it did give some good tips about pairing edibles and flowers.

FineWordsForAPorcupine · 18/05/2022 23:21

I grow veg, but space is limited, so I don't bother with cheap-to-buy stuff like potatoes and carrots. Courgettes (pick them as babies if you're worried about getting overwhelmed) and cucumbers give a great return, and garlic is fun, since you can harvest them, dry and plait them together to use through the winter. Tomatoes are patchy, but an excellent chutney ingredient for all the green/misshapen ones.

Herbs are great (buying fresh herbs is expensive, the supermarket pots always die and I end up chucking away half of the cut packs). I think they are the only thing that actually save me money.

Think about what you'd most like to eat - I long for asparagus, but it takes several years to show a return. Or what you can process into long lasting products. An apple tree will give you all the dried apple rings you could ever want, soft fruits can be made into liqueurs, etc. Tbh, I think it's hard to actually save money on buying veg, once you've factored in time,dealing with pests, stuff failing, etc, but you can have lovely fresh stuff, make nice treats to share and give as gifts and maybe break even if you're lucky.

Vikinga · 18/05/2022 23:19

Just seen you ask for what ti grow. I have no green fingers but these seem to be thriving in my garden: raspberries, redcurrants, strawberries, pears, greengage plums, bay leaves, chives, sage , mint, parsley, apples., crab apples. Gonna add an apricot tree and pumpkins and courgettes this year.

Mossstitch · 18/05/2022 23:16

I planted 3 raspberry 10 years ago, they send out runners and expand every year, I now have two raised beds full and they are very prolific, also very expensive to buy. I've had no joy with carrots or tomatoes so given up on them but lettuce, rocket, perpetual spinach, beans and peas all seem to grow without much attention and potatoes are delicious. I've planted a couple of gooseberries last year too, unfortunately birds stripped them clear one night as I was waiting for them to reach peak ripeness so I'd advice netting over soft fruits, I have a kind of netted tent that fits one of the raised beds. 🍒🍓

wallpoppy · 18/05/2022 23:15

Growing fruits and vegetable is a lot of fun and a great hobby. However-unless you have at least a quarter allotment (or equivalent sunny space in your garden) and a lot of time, you're going to spend more money than you save. Even if you do have the space and the time, it will take a few years before you start to realise any savings. You have to invest in equipment and learn how to maximise your yield. Most people end up with about four radishes and a single broad bean their first year before they get things sorted out 😅. The only allotment holders I know who grow enough to save (or say they save) significantly on their grocery bill are the oldies who are out there all the time working their arses off and who have years of experience and knowledge of what grows and what doesn't and how to get the most out of their patch.

I have a quarter allotment that's 50 metres away from my house that I spend at least 4-6 hours per week on (and much more than that at certain times of year when I'm transitioning to a new season) . I don't see that as a cost because I enjoy it, but I could pick up an extra half day of work (freelance consulting gubbins) and that would pay for far more vegetables than I could grow in a year.

For me, growing regular beetroot and onions and carrots and potatoes that I can get at Tesco isn't really worth the bother. Those are the cheapest part of my shopping, anyway. So I have worked out over the years what grows well in my particular location that would be expensive or hard to find and I focus on that. I try a few new things every year but my standard collection includes broccoli raab (AKA rapini, an italian green that's amazing on pizza or in pasta), mizuna (Japanese leafy green), raspberries, strawberries, beetroot and carrots in unusual colours, big white German radishes, asparagus, rhubarb (forced under a couple of buckets so it's bright bright pink and tender), and I always try for artichokes even though they only really work out half the time.

Vikinga · 18/05/2022 23:14

95% of the plants in my garden are edibles - herbs and fruit. Haven't tried my hand at veg yet. Looks like a garden and not an allotment

SpinMeRightRoundBabyRightRound · 18/05/2022 23:13

Just make sure you sieve the soil well for carrots, I didn’t when I grew them and they were absolutely delicious but looked like aliens because they grew so twisty in the soil 😂

We’ve got a dwarf apple tree and the garden would seem weirdly empty without it, the apples don’t keep well, so I end up making apple jam or freezing them chopped and semi cooked.

beautifulandslightlymad · 18/05/2022 23:12

My whole garden is a mix. I've just relocated my blackcurrant bushes to a shady part. The variety I have like shade. I'm going to plant a rose bush in the hole.

My rhubarb is next to my delphiniums. My onions are next to my iris and clematis.

Onions are looking lovely this year. Mine were a bag of red onions from Tesco I planted last year.

Amicompletelyinsane · 18/05/2022 23:07

I grow strawberries in hanging baskets. They do really well and aren't ugly plants

FleurDeLizz · 18/05/2022 23:07

You can grow carrots in a dustbin. Nice and deep and you don’t have to sacrifice other plants for it

CamomileCream · 18/05/2022 23:04

DH is a keen gardener. The best thing he has is two blueberry bushes - they crop really well and not difficult to take care of

RoseAndGeranium · 18/05/2022 22:34

Definitely go for a mix. Flowers are a great way of attracting pollinators to your veg and they can also help to keep pests at bay (or just give them something else to eat). I always plant nasturtiums in amongst my climbing squash (the cabbage white butterflies go nuts for it so it helps keep them off the brassicas), sweet peas at the back of the bed up the wall with French beans mixed in. Flowering carrots in amongst the beets. Marigolds and calendula scattered about and so on. I’ve got ox eye daisies, aquilegia, borage, and forget me nots blooming amongst the gooseberry bushes (helps keep the birds off) and foxgloves towering over the strawberries.

Melroses · 18/05/2022 22:32

Tomatoes, courgettes, beans, herbs lettuce and squash (not very successfully) and garlic (very successfully)

We made a raised bed with wood sleepers in the best bit of the garden. It looks nice and decorative. Originally I was going to dig up some of the lawn, but it is poor soil and would take years to make it productive. There is a greenhouse next to it with a little path in front and herbs with a gravel mulch and a topiary bay plant. Compost and rhubarb behind. I think it looks lovely.

We have lots of flowers round the seating area (and more herbs in pots).

RedWingBoots · 18/05/2022 22:31

I have herbs and flowers in my garden. Some of the herbs rosemary and thyme do take over.

Currently growing a few edibles which include flowers for my DD.

Btw there are some small carrots you can easily grow in large pots. The advantage is they can be raised up so carrot fly don't get to them.

AnotherForumUser · 18/05/2022 22:28

Have a mix. there are some easy to grow veg. Corn on the cob -easy to grow. Stunning high vertical plants that also look good. (Try the corn on the cob raw and freshly picked-yummy) Courgettes are prolific, you harvest a couple pop them in your bag turn around and there's another one snaking out trying to trip you up. So two/ three courgette plants will feed you well. Cauliflower and broccoli are also easy to grow.

User02jcuicen · 18/05/2022 22:27

Look up companion planting. Good for maximising yields and using your space well.

Babdoc · 18/05/2022 22:27

My garden is mainly flowering shrubs and bulbs, but I have a very productive plum tree that has attractive blossom in spring, a rhubarb patch, a redcurrant bush, a thornless blackberry, and a herb garden outside the kitchen with bay trees, rosemary, sage, mint, lemon balm, oregano, thyme and lavender.
Many vegetables have attractive foliage and can be planted among flowers - eg the feathery tops of carrots, or the purple leaves of beetroot. Have fun mixing and matching, OP!

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 18/05/2022 22:24

What kind of soil have you got? Clay, sand? Where you want to grow is it full sun or part?

we are on heavy clay, we dig over the patch (full sun) and things that grow well are: rhubarb, raspberries (take a couple years), Apple trees, carrots, beetroot, marrow, runner beans and sweetcorn. Not had much success with brassicas (cabbage etc) but that’s more down to cabbage whites.

dogschewbones · 18/05/2022 22:21

What do you like to eat that’s also expensive? For us it’s fruit, green beans, herbs and lettuce. I absolutely wouldn’t bother w carrots. - I have never grown one that’s worth eating, even organic ones are cheap, and they need so much space and care. Start from what you want and work on from there. Raspberries are the biggest winner in my book.

bridgetreilly · 18/05/2022 22:21

And yes, if you grow courgettes, plant 1/3 of the amount you think you could possibly need.

bridgetreilly · 18/05/2022 22:20

Beans are both pretty and productive. Strawberries and raspberries are my favourite thing to grow. Rhubarb is also super easy. An apple tree or a pear tree looks lovely.