Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not feel proud of my country at the moment?

285 replies

Livingtothefull · 18/05/2022 19:29

I really want to be proud - there are plenty of things to be proud of in the UK (great people/culture/heritage) - but the way we are governed at the moment just sickens me.

We have a liar and a criminal as Prime Minister, I can't bear the sight or sound of him now. 'Partygate' showed us just how much contempt he has for the British public. People are facing huge cost of living rises and poverty, and the Government offered nothing to help address this in the Queen's speech.

The latest is their proposal to break international law.

By the way the Monarchy was shown up as the useless and empty institution it is through the prorogation of Parliament episode, far from a supposed guardian of democracy. I don't have anything against the RF personally, but as an institution it has presided over all of this and yet has nothing to say about it all.

I am sick of hearing about the Jubilee as well, I see nothing to celebrate in what we have all been through over the past couple of years and are facing now. 'Rich privileged woman lives a long time' does not mean anything imo, in the context of the huge numbers of people who have died before their time due to Covid. Many of them elderly and vulnerable people in care homes - where the Government has recently been found (again) to have broken the law by putting them in harm's way.

OP posts:
ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 19/05/2022 20:43

Labour under Blair funded education properly, reduced hospital wait lists, opened Sure Start centres, recruited more medical staff. Negotiated the Good Friday agreement which Boris wants to ignore.

Sure, they did nothing at all.

Trainbear · 19/05/2022 20:37

Lonelycrab · 19/05/2022 20:01

It's kind of fashionable to hate Britain

It really isn’t. You’d like that to be the case I’m sure, but you’re wrong, and you show an awful lot of ill conceived judgement in your post too. Sure, it’s great to look at our history but the direction of travel with our government is woeful right now.

Yes, amongst some it is and has been.

If Mgr Thatcher broke the mould, no, the fuckup that was the labour failure in the 1970s cap in hand to the IMF for a loan because Dennis Healey was a shite chancellor, but notwithstanding Thatcher and sake if council houses and no right for LAs to build to trace. Labour under Blair did nothing, LibDems when in bed with the Tories did nothing.
If Boris said "I'm giving all UK residents £10000 we would read -
Fucking only £10000 basterd cheapskate Tories.
Fucking same to the poor and middle class
and then again
Fucking Tories giving the same to refugees just off the boat as to uncle Albert who died in three world wars.
Some people in this country would bitch if they were hung with a new rope.

Bunnyfuller · 19/05/2022 20:29

It’s not cool to hate Britain ffs, we are actually adults and can make decisions.

it’s the racism, the Little Britain, the Brexit, the inflated sense of self importance, and the arrogance to other cultures.

I give no shits on ‘cool’ but I’m ashamed to be associated with this confidence trick being swallowed by so many from venal short-sightedness, utter ignorance and taugh
xenophobia.

Lonelycrab · 19/05/2022 20:01

It's kind of fashionable to hate Britain

It really isn’t. You’d like that to be the case I’m sure, but you’re wrong, and you show an awful lot of ill conceived judgement in your post too. Sure, it’s great to look at our history but the direction of travel with our government is woeful right now.

MarshaBradyo · 19/05/2022 19:14

Kris02 · 19/05/2022 18:43

It's kind of fashionable to hate Britain (and especially England). Of course, people who claim to hate it often couldn't care less. It's just a pose – an attempt to appear cool and sophisticated ("I'm not a small-minded suburbanite; I'm intelligent, sophisticated and cosmopolitan"). I'm not criticising the OP. To be fair, she does focus on the government and not the country generally, but it really p**ses me off when people run Britain down – especially sneering, sanctimonious liberals.

I don't like Boris Johnson. But then I can think of very few politicians I do like – or ever have. Macron is a puffed up little twerp, and the Canadian PM is insufferably vain. I didn't even like Obama, who I found unbearably smug. As for the monarchy, it's just an embarrassment, and always has been (a bunch of ugly, vulgar gargoyles).

It's our cultural history that makes me proud. For example, Harold Bloom, the American literary critic, listed the three of four thousand books he considered the best ever written. On that list, there were more from the UK than anywhere in the world. I'm proud of Oxford and Cambridge. And I'm proud of the great canon of English/British writers, beginning with Chaucer, then Shakespeare, Milton, Blake, Wordsworth, Keats, Shelley, Byron, Jane Austen, George Eliot, Walter Pater, John Ruskin, Dickens, Virginia Woolf, etc, etc (to name just a few). If you date British literature from the birth of Chaucer, that's a 600-year-old canon. Plus, of course, philosophers like John Locke, who laid the foundations of modern democracy, and scientists like Newton and Darwin.

We don't make enough of our cultural and intellectual achievements. They mean far more to me than an oaf like Prince Harry. OK, the weather is often sh*t, and the country can be dreary, stressful and overcrowded, but culturally it's a jewel. For anyone interested in art, history and the life of the mind, this is the best place in the world (with the possible exception of France!). If you don't believe me, go to Cambridge or Oxford on a bright, cold Autumnal morning, have a coffee and then spend the day browsing the bookshops. There's nowhere in the world I'd rather be.

Cambridge is pretty close to me, actually, and every time I go there, I think "wow, this is the place Newton studied, and Byron and Tennyson and Milton and Darwin and Wittgenstein and Nabokov and Bertrand Russell and Stephen Hawking. It's the place in which the atom was first described, and the place where DNA was discovered." Virtually every major intellectual figure seems to have lived or studied or died in Britain – Freud, Karl Marx, Lenin, Rimbaud, Van Gogh, Monet, Schopenhauer.

Bill Bryson said that you can never grow bored of Britain. Every square mile contains some fascinating historical or cultural gem – some scientific discovery or poetic masterpiece or whatever. It's no coincidence that Bryson is American, of course. Indeed, it often takes an outsider to remind British people of what they have. And that's because our culture (especially publishing, academia and the arts) is dominated by people on the left who basically hate Britain. That attitude is then instilled in us – we sort of internalise the shame and self-loathing. It was only when I saw Britain through the eyes of an American friend that I really began to appreciate it.

As an outsider who chose to move here I agree

nice post

(not sure about the cool part at top but rest I do)

Lipsandlashes · 19/05/2022 19:13

Kris02 · 19/05/2022 18:43

It's kind of fashionable to hate Britain (and especially England). Of course, people who claim to hate it often couldn't care less. It's just a pose – an attempt to appear cool and sophisticated ("I'm not a small-minded suburbanite; I'm intelligent, sophisticated and cosmopolitan"). I'm not criticising the OP. To be fair, she does focus on the government and not the country generally, but it really p**ses me off when people run Britain down – especially sneering, sanctimonious liberals.

I don't like Boris Johnson. But then I can think of very few politicians I do like – or ever have. Macron is a puffed up little twerp, and the Canadian PM is insufferably vain. I didn't even like Obama, who I found unbearably smug. As for the monarchy, it's just an embarrassment, and always has been (a bunch of ugly, vulgar gargoyles).

It's our cultural history that makes me proud. For example, Harold Bloom, the American literary critic, listed the three of four thousand books he considered the best ever written. On that list, there were more from the UK than anywhere in the world. I'm proud of Oxford and Cambridge. And I'm proud of the great canon of English/British writers, beginning with Chaucer, then Shakespeare, Milton, Blake, Wordsworth, Keats, Shelley, Byron, Jane Austen, George Eliot, Walter Pater, John Ruskin, Dickens, Virginia Woolf, etc, etc (to name just a few). If you date British literature from the birth of Chaucer, that's a 600-year-old canon. Plus, of course, philosophers like John Locke, who laid the foundations of modern democracy, and scientists like Newton and Darwin.

We don't make enough of our cultural and intellectual achievements. They mean far more to me than an oaf like Prince Harry. OK, the weather is often sh*t, and the country can be dreary, stressful and overcrowded, but culturally it's a jewel. For anyone interested in art, history and the life of the mind, this is the best place in the world (with the possible exception of France!). If you don't believe me, go to Cambridge or Oxford on a bright, cold Autumnal morning, have a coffee and then spend the day browsing the bookshops. There's nowhere in the world I'd rather be.

Cambridge is pretty close to me, actually, and every time I go there, I think "wow, this is the place Newton studied, and Byron and Tennyson and Milton and Darwin and Wittgenstein and Nabokov and Bertrand Russell and Stephen Hawking. It's the place in which the atom was first described, and the place where DNA was discovered." Virtually every major intellectual figure seems to have lived or studied or died in Britain – Freud, Karl Marx, Lenin, Rimbaud, Van Gogh, Monet, Schopenhauer.

Bill Bryson said that you can never grow bored of Britain. Every square mile contains some fascinating historical or cultural gem – some scientific discovery or poetic masterpiece or whatever. It's no coincidence that Bryson is American, of course. Indeed, it often takes an outsider to remind British people of what they have. And that's because our culture (especially publishing, academia and the arts) is dominated by people on the left who basically hate Britain. That attitude is then instilled in us – we sort of internalise the shame and self-loathing. It was only when I saw Britain through the eyes of an American friend that I really began to appreciate it.

This is really beautifully put. I agree with everything you have said (apart from having a soft spot for the Queen - sorry!) 👏🏻👏🏻

moomintrolls · 19/05/2022 18:56

I can't be proud of my country, I have nothing to do with how this country is run.

I'm proud to live in my city, that I chose, and is a great city. I'm hardly proud to be human, a, because I can't help it and b, because we are a destructive and cruel species.

But it's neither here nor there. Power corrupts and every person who has got into a position of great power has indeed been corrupted eventually.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 19/05/2022 18:50

Of course, people who claim to hate it often couldn't care less. It's just a pose – an attempt to appear cool and sophisticated

No this is not true. I’m one of those people you’re sneering at. I’m ashamed of being English. I’m neither cool nor sophisticated just emabarrassed and honest

Kris02 · 19/05/2022 18:43

It's kind of fashionable to hate Britain (and especially England). Of course, people who claim to hate it often couldn't care less. It's just a pose – an attempt to appear cool and sophisticated ("I'm not a small-minded suburbanite; I'm intelligent, sophisticated and cosmopolitan"). I'm not criticising the OP. To be fair, she does focus on the government and not the country generally, but it really p**ses me off when people run Britain down – especially sneering, sanctimonious liberals.

I don't like Boris Johnson. But then I can think of very few politicians I do like – or ever have. Macron is a puffed up little twerp, and the Canadian PM is insufferably vain. I didn't even like Obama, who I found unbearably smug. As for the monarchy, it's just an embarrassment, and always has been (a bunch of ugly, vulgar gargoyles).

It's our cultural history that makes me proud. For example, Harold Bloom, the American literary critic, listed the three of four thousand books he considered the best ever written. On that list, there were more from the UK than anywhere in the world. I'm proud of Oxford and Cambridge. And I'm proud of the great canon of English/British writers, beginning with Chaucer, then Shakespeare, Milton, Blake, Wordsworth, Keats, Shelley, Byron, Jane Austen, George Eliot, Walter Pater, John Ruskin, Dickens, Virginia Woolf, etc, etc (to name just a few). If you date British literature from the birth of Chaucer, that's a 600-year-old canon. Plus, of course, philosophers like John Locke, who laid the foundations of modern democracy, and scientists like Newton and Darwin.

We don't make enough of our cultural and intellectual achievements. They mean far more to me than an oaf like Prince Harry. OK, the weather is often sh*t, and the country can be dreary, stressful and overcrowded, but culturally it's a jewel. For anyone interested in art, history and the life of the mind, this is the best place in the world (with the possible exception of France!). If you don't believe me, go to Cambridge or Oxford on a bright, cold Autumnal morning, have a coffee and then spend the day browsing the bookshops. There's nowhere in the world I'd rather be.

Cambridge is pretty close to me, actually, and every time I go there, I think "wow, this is the place Newton studied, and Byron and Tennyson and Milton and Darwin and Wittgenstein and Nabokov and Bertrand Russell and Stephen Hawking. It's the place in which the atom was first described, and the place where DNA was discovered." Virtually every major intellectual figure seems to have lived or studied or died in Britain – Freud, Karl Marx, Lenin, Rimbaud, Van Gogh, Monet, Schopenhauer.

Bill Bryson said that you can never grow bored of Britain. Every square mile contains some fascinating historical or cultural gem – some scientific discovery or poetic masterpiece or whatever. It's no coincidence that Bryson is American, of course. Indeed, it often takes an outsider to remind British people of what they have. And that's because our culture (especially publishing, academia and the arts) is dominated by people on the left who basically hate Britain. That attitude is then instilled in us – we sort of internalise the shame and self-loathing. It was only when I saw Britain through the eyes of an American friend that I really began to appreciate it.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 19/05/2022 18:37

I don’t even watch the Eurovision. I feel nothing that someone has come second.

Kendodd · 19/05/2022 18:25

balalake · 19/05/2022 17:54

Given Brexit (an act of economic self-harm) and now the worst Prime Minister in our history, whilst I am proud of many of our traditions and aspects of our culture, I hide coming from these shores when visiting outside the UK. No clothing that could identify me, and a sudden inability to speak English (usually go places where I can speak enough of the local language or French as an alternative).

Yes, I think I'm going to pretend to be Irish when I travel abroad. I'm embarrassed to admit to being English now, we just look like fools.

Dillydollydingdong · 19/05/2022 18:04

Weren't you proud on Saturday night when Sam Ryder came second in the Eurovision SC?

Lipsandlashes · 19/05/2022 18:01

Livingtothefull · 18/05/2022 19:29

I really want to be proud - there are plenty of things to be proud of in the UK (great people/culture/heritage) - but the way we are governed at the moment just sickens me.

We have a liar and a criminal as Prime Minister, I can't bear the sight or sound of him now. 'Partygate' showed us just how much contempt he has for the British public. People are facing huge cost of living rises and poverty, and the Government offered nothing to help address this in the Queen's speech.

The latest is their proposal to break international law.

By the way the Monarchy was shown up as the useless and empty institution it is through the prorogation of Parliament episode, far from a supposed guardian of democracy. I don't have anything against the RF personally, but as an institution it has presided over all of this and yet has nothing to say about it all.

I am sick of hearing about the Jubilee as well, I see nothing to celebrate in what we have all been through over the past couple of years and are facing now. 'Rich privileged woman lives a long time' does not mean anything imo, in the context of the huge numbers of people who have died before their time due to Covid. Many of them elderly and vulnerable people in care homes - where the Government has recently been found (again) to have broken the law by putting them in harm's way.

Hey there Debbie

To not feel proud of my country at the moment?
ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 19/05/2022 18:01

I bet your from a very middle class background, university, but resent that others have done better than you

Im that person and feel no resentment. I’m low middle class though. I just think the Royals are washed up, expensive, and pointless and don’t really want to support them. I’m a Republican.

l would say going to university probably makes you think about stuff. That’s why the OP doesn’t like the Royals.

Tangled123 · 19/05/2022 17:57

I spent a year in Australia and another year in New Zealand before Covid. It made me realise that living in the UK comes with a lot of perks and we should be thankful for that (like no charges for calling out an ambulance or fire engine for example). However, that doesn't mean the UK can't do better. The handling of Brexit, covid and the cost of living crisis has been appalling. Not to mention all the MPs being accused of rape etc. I don't think there's anything wrong with feeling shame about where the UK is currently at, and its only by acknowledging that can we hope things get better again.

balalake · 19/05/2022 17:54

Given Brexit (an act of economic self-harm) and now the worst Prime Minister in our history, whilst I am proud of many of our traditions and aspects of our culture, I hide coming from these shores when visiting outside the UK. No clothing that could identify me, and a sudden inability to speak English (usually go places where I can speak enough of the local language or French as an alternative).

CapMarvel · 19/05/2022 17:37

We are living under a government who are 50% rotten to the very core and 50% just complete fucking idiots.

YANBU.

Pumperthepumper · 19/05/2022 17:31

TunnelOfGoats · 19/05/2022 17:19

Have you ever lived abroad OP? I lived abroad in a developing country for work, and my DP is from another European country that we spent quite a lot of time in. I can absolutely say I really appreciate this country based on my life in those countries. It is comparatively safe and stable here, with a welfare system that is a safety net if life gets hard. Our climate is not extreme, and our police are (mostly) very honest and compassionate if you need them. Of course there are some issues here as there are anywhere but in the grand scheme of things I'm glad to live here. I wish we didn't have the royal family, but no government will have the balls to offer a referendum on their existence unfortunately. And as far as the tories go, I don't like them or agree that they are at all representative of the vast majority of the public here. But Labour are not some wonderful alternative to them either. They have shown themselves to be shambolic and potentially dangerous to us all too. So, all we can do is make the best of things here, accept what we can do, and exercise our democratic rights at elections. Or move somewhere else and see if other countries are much better, as you are alluding to.

The MET police are neither honest nor compassionate.

Tania64 · 19/05/2022 17:20

Rotten government & rotten monarch & hangers on. I certainly will not be celebrating 70 years of pampering & elitism of a waste of space woman.

TunnelOfGoats · 19/05/2022 17:19

Have you ever lived abroad OP? I lived abroad in a developing country for work, and my DP is from another European country that we spent quite a lot of time in. I can absolutely say I really appreciate this country based on my life in those countries. It is comparatively safe and stable here, with a welfare system that is a safety net if life gets hard. Our climate is not extreme, and our police are (mostly) very honest and compassionate if you need them. Of course there are some issues here as there are anywhere but in the grand scheme of things I'm glad to live here. I wish we didn't have the royal family, but no government will have the balls to offer a referendum on their existence unfortunately. And as far as the tories go, I don't like them or agree that they are at all representative of the vast majority of the public here. But Labour are not some wonderful alternative to them either. They have shown themselves to be shambolic and potentially dangerous to us all too. So, all we can do is make the best of things here, accept what we can do, and exercise our democratic rights at elections. Or move somewhere else and see if other countries are much better, as you are alluding to.

mbosnz · 19/05/2022 17:17

Oh right, fair enough!

(I have a little NZ flag in the window, so I'm a flag waver myself. . ., I'd better put a Union Jack in there to keep it company!)

MarshaBradyo · 19/05/2022 17:15

Mbonsz I should have quoted it may have come across badly - I didn’t mean you, but earlier posts which have been more disparaging re ‘flag wavers’

mbosnz · 19/05/2022 17:11

MarshaBradyo - I did not state anything that implied I was in any way, shape or form, referring to the Jubilee, you - incorrectly as it turns out - inferred it.

I think that for many, the Jubilee will be a jolly old show, especially for many older people, and the monarchists amongst us!

I do see though, that if you are currently unable to afford the power to warm up a pizza, or are a trifle concerned about whether you're going to continue to be able to run your dialysis machine, some might find it a bit hard to stomach. Cos it ain't gonna come cheap.

MarshaBradyo · 19/05/2022 17:05

I think it’s misplaced to use the ‘flag waver’ insult for anyone who wants to do something in the community for jubilee

I’m in a very Labour area, I doubt it’s politically aligned, it’s just something nice for the children and adults

I read these comments from many and I see such a wide gap between what they say they dislike and the niceness of people around me

mbosnz · 19/05/2022 17:02

I think a true patriot is not the one eyed flag waver. It's the individual who loves their country, warts and all, but sees the warts, and wants to improve matters, to get rid of, or at least diminish, the warts.

I think the biggest wart (or should I say boil?), is that this country is run by people who don't care about the country and the people, who are not 'of' the people - who are so far removed from the general life experience of most individuals that they have no understanding, no empathy. Their focus is themselves, and 'their sort of people'. It makes for bad and corrupt governance. If we could lance that boil - perhaps by changes to the electoral system? - I think an awful lot of things would then have the possibility of significant improvement.