Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not feel proud of my country at the moment?

285 replies

Livingtothefull · 18/05/2022 19:29

I really want to be proud - there are plenty of things to be proud of in the UK (great people/culture/heritage) - but the way we are governed at the moment just sickens me.

We have a liar and a criminal as Prime Minister, I can't bear the sight or sound of him now. 'Partygate' showed us just how much contempt he has for the British public. People are facing huge cost of living rises and poverty, and the Government offered nothing to help address this in the Queen's speech.

The latest is their proposal to break international law.

By the way the Monarchy was shown up as the useless and empty institution it is through the prorogation of Parliament episode, far from a supposed guardian of democracy. I don't have anything against the RF personally, but as an institution it has presided over all of this and yet has nothing to say about it all.

I am sick of hearing about the Jubilee as well, I see nothing to celebrate in what we have all been through over the past couple of years and are facing now. 'Rich privileged woman lives a long time' does not mean anything imo, in the context of the huge numbers of people who have died before their time due to Covid. Many of them elderly and vulnerable people in care homes - where the Government has recently been found (again) to have broken the law by putting them in harm's way.

OP posts:
OMG12 · 20/05/2022 18:59

AchatAVendre · 20/05/2022 18:22

DownNative The problems in the UK are simply not unique and is observed right across the EU. The biggest economy in Europe is Germany and they have about the same number of food banks as the UK.

Having lived in The Netherlands (and non-EU Switzerland) recently and currently buying a house in France, at least other countries do basic things, such as collect rubbish correctly, cut grass verges (they get once per year here which means the footpath outside my home is unusable and I have to walk on the road), provide affordable regular trains, have good standard roads, have health systems that doesn't do things such as limit cataract surgery to one eye or "fix" kidney stones not by removing the stone but by giving you a catheter to live with for years. Its just little things like that that all add up. For instance, theres also no footbridge across the dual carriageway where I live near for miles. If you want to cross it, you literally have to dice with cars doing 70mph. Its as if things like underpasses and bridges hadn't been invented. I live in Scotland, and theres not even motorways between many of the cities. Theres not even any plans for there to be. Its like progress stalled here at some point in the eighties and you're expected not to notice.

Good luck in France, because obviously the systems there run superbly😂😂😂😂

OMG12 · 20/05/2022 18:57

SomethigWentBang · 18/05/2022 20:06

I’m not sure we can be proud of our culture and heritage. Okay we’ve had some decent moments… but we have pillaged and plundered the globe for many centuries. Sun never sets on the empire and all that.

Bit like, France,Spain, Portugal, Italy, Greece, Germany, scandanvia etc etc

DownNative · 20/05/2022 18:50

AchatAVendre · 20/05/2022 18:22

DownNative The problems in the UK are simply not unique and is observed right across the EU. The biggest economy in Europe is Germany and they have about the same number of food banks as the UK.

Having lived in The Netherlands (and non-EU Switzerland) recently and currently buying a house in France, at least other countries do basic things, such as collect rubbish correctly, cut grass verges (they get once per year here which means the footpath outside my home is unusable and I have to walk on the road), provide affordable regular trains, have good standard roads, have health systems that doesn't do things such as limit cataract surgery to one eye or "fix" kidney stones not by removing the stone but by giving you a catheter to live with for years. Its just little things like that that all add up. For instance, theres also no footbridge across the dual carriageway where I live near for miles. If you want to cross it, you literally have to dice with cars doing 70mph. Its as if things like underpasses and bridges hadn't been invented. I live in Scotland, and theres not even motorways between many of the cities. Theres not even any plans for there to be. Its like progress stalled here at some point in the eighties and you're expected not to notice.

The context of my post you quoted was the reality that inequality between rich and poor has increased in Europe.

As well as the fact Europe saw an increase in millionaires whereas the UK didn't.

There's a reason I don't pay much attention to people's anecdotes and anecdotes lead to logical fallacies.

If we just go by the UN HDI, the UK is ranked 10th in Europe. You mentioned the Netherlands, we're very close to their score - just 0.012 points behind them. France, on the other hand, is much lower than the UK and is 0.031 points behind us.

By this measure, the UK is much higher placed than many like you seem to think.

AchatAVendre · 20/05/2022 18:22

DownNative The problems in the UK are simply not unique and is observed right across the EU. The biggest economy in Europe is Germany and they have about the same number of food banks as the UK.

Having lived in The Netherlands (and non-EU Switzerland) recently and currently buying a house in France, at least other countries do basic things, such as collect rubbish correctly, cut grass verges (they get once per year here which means the footpath outside my home is unusable and I have to walk on the road), provide affordable regular trains, have good standard roads, have health systems that doesn't do things such as limit cataract surgery to one eye or "fix" kidney stones not by removing the stone but by giving you a catheter to live with for years. Its just little things like that that all add up. For instance, theres also no footbridge across the dual carriageway where I live near for miles. If you want to cross it, you literally have to dice with cars doing 70mph. Its as if things like underpasses and bridges hadn't been invented. I live in Scotland, and theres not even motorways between many of the cities. Theres not even any plans for there to be. Its like progress stalled here at some point in the eighties and you're expected not to notice.

DownNative · 20/05/2022 18:12

Livingtothefull · 18/05/2022 19:29

I really want to be proud - there are plenty of things to be proud of in the UK (great people/culture/heritage) - but the way we are governed at the moment just sickens me.

We have a liar and a criminal as Prime Minister, I can't bear the sight or sound of him now. 'Partygate' showed us just how much contempt he has for the British public. People are facing huge cost of living rises and poverty, and the Government offered nothing to help address this in the Queen's speech.

The latest is their proposal to break international law.

By the way the Monarchy was shown up as the useless and empty institution it is through the prorogation of Parliament episode, far from a supposed guardian of democracy. I don't have anything against the RF personally, but as an institution it has presided over all of this and yet has nothing to say about it all.

I am sick of hearing about the Jubilee as well, I see nothing to celebrate in what we have all been through over the past couple of years and are facing now. 'Rich privileged woman lives a long time' does not mean anything imo, in the context of the huge numbers of people who have died before their time due to Covid. Many of them elderly and vulnerable people in care homes - where the Government has recently been found (again) to have broken the law by putting them in harm's way.

"We have a liar and a criminal as Prime Minister..."

Except he doesn't have a criminal record since its a Fixed Penalty Notice. Better to be accurate otherwise you'll hurt your own point.

"People are facing huge cost of living rises and poverty, and the Government offered nothing to help address this in the Queen's speech."

Cost of living is a problem outside the UK and poverty is also on the increase in Europe. Did you know the UK has a decrease in millionaires whereas France, for example, saw an increase?

Unsurprisingly, Germany has more millionaires than any other country in the EU and Europe.

You'll find that inequalities between the rich and poor has been increasing across the EU as well.

An excerpt from an EU Parliament report dated 6th April 2022:

"Since the onset of the crisis, income inequality in the EU has increased because the process of income convergence between countries has stalled and income inequalities within countries have expanded. Pay and income inequality remains a concern and the working poor are still a substantial group among workers in the EU."

The problems in the UK are simply not unique and is observed right across the EU. The biggest economy in Europe is Germany and they have about the same number of food banks as the UK.

That tells you we aren't the only ones with problems governments have so far failed to address adequately.

As for the Queen's Speech, we're told measures to address the cost of living will be available in the Autumn which is when it'll increase again. Let's see.

"By the way the Monarchy was shown up as the useless and empty institution it is through the prorogation of Parliament episode, far from a supposed guardian of democracy. I don't have anything against the RF personally, but as an institution it has presided over all of this and yet has nothing to say about it all."

The Monarchy has no direct involvement in politics and is certainly not supreme. Parliament is supreme which is why the door is slammed in the face of Black Rod every time Parliament is opened.

The Monarchy presides over nothing. The actual role of the Monarch is to be the final line of defence against a would-be dictator which is why the Armed Forces swear allegiance to the Monarch.

Not the people or government.

Think you'll find millions in other countries will have similar views about their own countries as you do ours. And millions will hold the opposite views.

DownNative · 20/05/2022 17:47

ChocolateDeficitDisorder · 19/05/2022 01:21

Neither the UK or GB are countries.

If I were English, I wouldn't be proud. They English voters have made some awful voting decisions in the past few years and have ended with the worst possible government, unfortunately a decision that affects the other countries of the UK.

I'm Scottish, we don't vote for Tories and we didn't vote for brexit. We have a devolved govt that is trying hard to mitigate for the cruel policies of the Tories but have one arm tied behind their back. I'm proud to be Scottish and would like Scotland to leave the union with England join the EU as soon as possible. We can't allow ourselves to be sucked any deeper into what the people of England vote for.

@ChocolateDeficitDisorder said:

"Neither the UK or GB are countries."

You're incorrect about the UK which IS a country and recognised as such by the EU and United States, for example.

Great Britain isn't a country, that's correct.

"I'm Scottish, we don't vote for Tories..."

Except Scotland clearly DOES vote for the Conservatives as they've been the second biggest party in Scotland for a few years now.

".....and we didn't vote for brexit."

Quite apart from the fact Scotland wasn't named on the ballot paper, but Leave literally won the UK vote in Scotland and Northern Ireland.

"We have a devolved govt that is trying hard to mitigate for the cruel policies of the Tories but have one arm tied behind their back."

Are they? Highest drug death rate in Europe for the first time under the SNP and educationa shambles under them too. This wasn't the case before devolution or under a devolved Labour administration. Indeed, SNP have tripled any austerity from Westminster themselves in order to stoke a grievance which hasn't worked.

"I'm proud to be Scottish and would like Scotland to leave the union with England join the EU as soon as possible. We can't allow ourselves to be sucked any deeper into what the people of England vote for."

It's a union with Wales and Northern Ireland too, you know. People in Scotland are still not convinced by the SNP on the economy, especially since their own Growth Commission report has been quietly dropped due to being austerity on stilts.

England and their electorate are not somehow the black sheep of the British family, so let's not talk in those terms, shall we?

AtwilightRebellion · 20/05/2022 16:50

PrettyMaybug · 20/05/2022 15:30

@Userg1234

Love people like you.....so negative. perhaps some of us like the royals, not resent and envy them. I bet your from a very middle class background, university, but resent that others have done better than you! I think that whilst there were errors we got through covid ok. Remember that we actually counted deaths very strictly many countries did not.

Economically we have spent a shit load to save jobs and push on and we will get through this year and come out a much stronger country than most of the western world will do. Remember, we have had a world wide pandemic, a war in Europe and massive problems of economic supply resulting from them. We are a great nation. If you don't like living here don't let the door hit you on the arse on the way out.

100% this Well said! As that poster said @Livingtothefull you know what to do if you don't like it here.

You do realise you are dense responding to someone like this.

How can there be any meaningful dialogue about the state of this nation when anyone who objects - with legitimate reasons - is told to leave.

Easy to see how Brexit got its teeth.

AtwilightRebellion · 20/05/2022 16:47

Post's like the OP's always bring out the defenders and those who seem to want to race to the bottom with examples from regimes and beleaguered states that will never present as any comparison to Britain.

Just because we don't string up gays in trees (blithe example) it doesn't mean the UK is a great place to live anymore.

Instead of telling people to leave and reaching for extreme examples like life in North Korea, everyone should listen to each other.

The UK has been on a massive downslide for a while. I barely recognise it anymore. I am a resident of a EU country but I am and will remain British.

This government and Brexit is bringing a special and once strong nation to its knees. It makes me sad watching on.

To deny it is foolish.

onthefencesitter · 20/05/2022 15:32

@Lazerbeen you know how when you say you live in *insert name of leafy green suburb with pretty little shops and strong community spirit, people would go 'ahhh thats a really nice place to live, lucky you'. I would say that if you say you live/come from the UK and foreigners say that, you would probably feel a little proud/puff your chest up a little.

PrettyMaybug · 20/05/2022 15:30

@Userg1234

Love people like you.....so negative. perhaps some of us like the royals, not resent and envy them. I bet your from a very middle class background, university, but resent that others have done better than you! I think that whilst there were errors we got through covid ok. Remember that we actually counted deaths very strictly many countries did not.

Economically we have spent a shit load to save jobs and push on and we will get through this year and come out a much stronger country than most of the western world will do. Remember, we have had a world wide pandemic, a war in Europe and massive problems of economic supply resulting from them. We are a great nation. If you don't like living here don't let the door hit you on the arse on the way out.

100% this Well said! As that poster said @Livingtothefull you know what to do if you don't like it here.

onthefencesitter · 20/05/2022 15:28

And in my view, for the people who are not in poverty (80% of the population), it's not all bad, it depends on what you are used to. Like DH and I bought a flat in London and we will probably always live in a flat (though we hope it would be bigger). Maybe many middle class Brits consider this Outrageous and symptom of a unequal unjust society but apartment living is very common outside the UK. The NHS isnt very good and much worse than what I was used to but hey it's free at the point of service so I guess one can't complain in that sense? Most of us are not paying very much for it when you consider the cost of medical caree.dental care is expensive in any country...

but for the people in poverty, I am very sorry, it isn't justifiable...

PrettyMaybug · 20/05/2022 15:26
Biscuit
OMG12 · 20/05/2022 15:24

Meh, such is life, these things go in cycles, tbh there’s not much you can do. If Labour were in charge the edges might have a slightly different pattern but very little would change regarding the underlying problems.

Get rid of the monarchy, get a president, well that would likely be someone who you didn’t like either.

unless we change the predisposition of human nature and societal values (I’m talking massive changes, not just sticking Keir Starmer with a questionable character in number 10 which would piss off other people) you’re wasting a lot of energy. Your anger is really not going to help anyone.

Lazerbeen · 20/05/2022 15:23

What does it even mean to be proud of your country. Proud of the government? Proud of every single citizen? Proud of how we perform in sporting events? It's a very weird notion imo in the first place.

luckylavender · 20/05/2022 15:19

Userg1234 · 18/05/2022 19:45

Love people like you.....so negative. perhaps some of us like the royals, not resent and envy them. I bet your from a very middle class background, university, but resent that others have done better than yoI

I think that whilst there were errors we got through covid ok. Remember that we actually counted deaths very strictly many countries did not

Economically we have spent a shit load to save jobs and push on and we will get through this year and come out a much stronger country than most of the western world will do.

Remember, we have had a world wide pandemic, a war in Europe and massive problems of economic supply resulting from them

We are a great nation. If you don't like living here don't let the door hit you on the arse on the way out.

Rose tinted specs

onthefencesitter · 20/05/2022 15:12

I am an immigrant.Just got my indefinite leave to remain. In my view, the most interesting beautiful countries with the nicest people often have the most abysmal governments. I do think it is correlated; when life is hard, people have to learn to laugh at the little things which is probably why British comedy is so good, and develop a better personality. My home country is very efficient; but the people are also very demanding. If there was an Olympics on complaining, we would take the gold medal every time.

I love the UK esp London where I live. People have a soft side to them, they generally listen more. But goodness your government is dreadful and causes no end of problems. But the people are what makes the place.

the80sweregreat · 20/05/2022 14:46

Rishi rich is on the rich list?
The cost of swimming pools eh? It is a scandal.

Livingtothefull · 20/05/2022 08:40

Still let's look on the bright side.....Rishi Sunak is getting a new swimming pool. Not a great look during a cost of living crisis, though he is personally impacted by this too as it will cost him £13,000 a year to heat it.

OP posts:
Livingtothefull · 20/05/2022 07:44

I agree @Shamplade that positive action is required and it is not enough to complain on here. And I do try to do that: I am in touch with my MP and do most of the things you mentioned, and I always vote. It is important that people engage directly.

I am lucky of course that my MP is not a middle aged male Tory, as in this case I could not be sure he is not the individual being investigated on suspicion of rape and abuse in public office. Although he is not attending Parliament, other people (including constituents) could be at risk.

There are at least 56 MPs facing sexual misconduct allegations with a total of around 70 complaints; is it just me or are those figures horrendously high set against the total numbers of MPs? What does it say about the so-called 'governing class'?

I don't agree at all with those who equate criticising the way the UK is being run with hating it. Loving one's country surely leads to wanting to better it and put right the things that are going wrong; you can of course celebrate the things that are good without being an unthinking cheerleader.

OP posts:
ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 20/05/2022 00:03

I was actually referring to funding for pupils not building.

But under the Tories l taught in a room with huge fungus growing up the walls. Leaks everywhere. All the time. They were disgusting, the kids hated it. New schools needed to come from somewhere.

DdraigGoch · 19/05/2022 23:19

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 19/05/2022 20:43

Labour under Blair funded education properly, reduced hospital wait lists, opened Sure Start centres, recruited more medical staff. Negotiated the Good Friday agreement which Boris wants to ignore.

Sure, they did nothing at all.

All of those new schools and hospitals paid for under PFI deals. Neatly keeping the capital debt off of the government's balance sheets, while lumbering future generations with exorbitant costs to service the debt and change lightbulbs.

BanjoKnickers · 19/05/2022 22:47

TankFlyBossW4lk · 19/05/2022 22:40

"We are a great nation. If you don't like living here don't let the door hit you on the arse on the way out."

God, depressing but predictable response. The simpletons are out in force tonight. I'm with you OP. Yanbu.

It's so true! You can absolutely spot the brexit voters Grin

TankFlyBossW4lk · 19/05/2022 22:40

"We are a great nation. If you don't like living here don't let the door hit you on the arse on the way out."

God, depressing but predictable response. The simpletons are out in force tonight. I'm with you OP. Yanbu.

Shamplade · 19/05/2022 22:33

I feel the same. There is such a long list of the ways the current government has, and is, fucking us all over and making sure we can’t do anything about it. I feel we are evolving backwards rapidly. But we only have ourselves to blame. People don’t look beyond the headlines when they vote. People don’t actually look into the policies. They make knee jerk reactions based on the main stream media dog whistles. If anyone complains about the current situation and they voted this shit show of a government in - I’ve run out of sympathy. We knew he was a lying, selfish and incompetent psychopath.

My answer to feeling this way OP, is to turn it into positive action. I have become more political. I write to my MP and volunteer around election time. I sign petitions and donate to groups campaigning for positive change. And I limit my time looking at the news. I try and remind myself that most people are kind and there is lots going on that is good. The little things in life can bring joy.

Please all - next election do your research- look at the party manifestos yourself. Look at the voting records of the politicians. Remember how important it is to have a government that has our best interests at heart. Don’t just rely on headlines, social media and news for information. Remember that there are powerful forces trying to influence our political stability (Russian influence for example) for their own gain. Go direct to the party websites. Vote for the common good, not just selfish gain.

Lipsandlashes · 19/05/2022 22:11

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 19/05/2022 20:43

Labour under Blair funded education properly, reduced hospital wait lists, opened Sure Start centres, recruited more medical staff. Negotiated the Good Friday agreement which Boris wants to ignore.

Sure, they did nothing at all.

Yeah Blair - he was an honest, upstanding gentleman. Oh wait…