Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not feel proud of my country at the moment?

285 replies

Livingtothefull · 18/05/2022 19:29

I really want to be proud - there are plenty of things to be proud of in the UK (great people/culture/heritage) - but the way we are governed at the moment just sickens me.

We have a liar and a criminal as Prime Minister, I can't bear the sight or sound of him now. 'Partygate' showed us just how much contempt he has for the British public. People are facing huge cost of living rises and poverty, and the Government offered nothing to help address this in the Queen's speech.

The latest is their proposal to break international law.

By the way the Monarchy was shown up as the useless and empty institution it is through the prorogation of Parliament episode, far from a supposed guardian of democracy. I don't have anything against the RF personally, but as an institution it has presided over all of this and yet has nothing to say about it all.

I am sick of hearing about the Jubilee as well, I see nothing to celebrate in what we have all been through over the past couple of years and are facing now. 'Rich privileged woman lives a long time' does not mean anything imo, in the context of the huge numbers of people who have died before their time due to Covid. Many of them elderly and vulnerable people in care homes - where the Government has recently been found (again) to have broken the law by putting them in harm's way.

OP posts:
orwellwasright · 21/05/2022 21:40

I'm with you, OP. Blighty's overrun with mendacious incompetents and racist halfwits. As soon as my parents have shuffled off I'm outta here.

angeLavn · 21/05/2022 21:32

Oh Northern Ireland! That as well.

angeLavn · 21/05/2022 21:32

The latest is their proposal to break international law.

In what way? The nuclear program? That's appalling isn't it, but I haven't seen very much discussing it.

AchatAVendre · 21/05/2022 21:29

DownNative The only part you got right is the fact our constitution is spread over various documents. Acts Of Parliament is where its mostly derived.

I'm not going to respond further to you, because I can see that you aren't at the same level as me and you are more interested in points scoring on an internet forum than accuracy. Best of luck with your reading. Try to avoid internet sources such as websites and stick to formal sources. I'm not entirely convinced that UCL can be quoted under standard referencing sources. Perhaps you could link to an article or a textbook. However, given that they are agreeing with what I said and most of the world of academia thinks and you are trying to say the opposite, I'm not sure where you are trying to go with this.

AchatAVendre · 21/05/2022 21:24

DownNative No, the UK has a written constitution. From the University College of London: "The UK is often said to have an 'unwritten' constitution. This is not strictly correct. It is largely written, but in different documents. But it has never been codified, brought together in a single document."

You really need to be more accurate instead of scathing. The UK Constitution is found in various statutes dating from the Magna Carta in 1215 and the Bill of Rights 1689 through to the Act of Union 1707 between Scotland and England and to more recent statutes such as the Scotland Act 1998, the Human Rights Act 1998, the Freedom of Information Act 2000 and the Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010, alongside common law doctrines such as parliamentary sovereignty and judicial precedents, parliamentary rules of procedure and convention, international treaties and various constitutional conventions.

I suggest you read Dicey (bit out of date but nevertheless), Raz, Tomkins, Tierney, etc. You might find Griffith, J in G Gee & G Webber, What is a Political Constitution, (2010) 30(2) Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 273 at 277 a good starting point.

The only part you got right is the fact our constitution is spread over various documents. Acts Of Parliament is where its mostly derived.

I'm sure my colleagues will be interested in this version of our constitution!

It really doesn't make a huge difference to codify it all into a single document as the constitution will still be the same.

See above. This provides the answer to your assertion. It is the answer in the rest of the world. The UK Constitution is holding the UK back and now needs to be modernised and collated. That means a single document modern written constitution.

"Also noticeable in the UK is that the constitution can be changed by simple majority (e.g. the Brexit vote) and not by special majority." The written constitution of the Republic of Ireland can also be changed by a simple majority with no special measures required. Slovakia is another where simple majority can amend a written constitution and very easily too. I'm not going to list more examples, but the UK is neither notable or unique for this as you're suggesting.
"What on earth is wrong with written single document constitutions? The whole of the rest of Europe has them."

Slovakia and Ireland, eh? Well, no other western European nations' constitutions can be changed by simple majority. The reason being is that its not a very good idea because it leads to instability and lack of predictability. I suggest you have a look at the German constitution, most novices start of by reading Solange I and II (Case 11/70 International Handelsgesellschaft v. Einfuhr-und-Voratsstelle Getreide (“Solange I”) [1970] ECR 1125 [1972] CMLR 255, Case 197/83 Re Wuensche Handelsgesellschaft, BVerfG (“Solange II) [1987] 3 CMLR 225.

Europe has the highest number of written constitutions with low rates of interpretability. This does not always mean its clear to citizens what their rights, duties and responsibilities are.

Erm, what is it you are trying to say here?

Written constitutions can be distorted by authoritarian governments as well. Like anything else in life, there are pros and cons to both our and other European states' approaches.

But no other large successful country has the UK model.

Most European states have required a Written constitution due to war and revolution. France, for example, had to redo theirs on several occasions with 1940 the most recent. The UK, in contrast, has not experienced the kind of constitutional upheaval most of Europe has. This has meant the UK has been able to evolve at its own speed, sometimes slow, sometimes rapidly.

And France managed to get rid of feudalism about 300 years earlier than the UK too. Really, none of this above means it isn't a good idea. I'm pretty sure that counties such as Switzerland and The Netherlands had neither wars or revolutions which led them to adopting modern single document constitutions and constitutional courts.

An example of that was the rapid constitutional change in the late 1990s - GFA, devolution and reform of Lords.

Erm, well done. Devolution hasn't been done well from a constitutional perspective because it was done in a hurry with insufficient accountability for the large amount of legislation passed by the devolved governments, which are unicameral. The already weak separation of powers is eroded even further. Seriously, if you don't understand the importance of separation of powers, start with Montesquieu and read on.

By and large, constitutional change is very disruptive which the UK has largely avoided.

You just wrote yourself a few paragraphs above about the enormous amount of constitutional change that the UK has experienced so far...

Meiji Japan the rare exception of a state that formally codified its constitution without it being a result of war or revolution. European states are the precise opposite.

Well, apart from most of them...

The popular saying is "if it isn't broke, don't fix it". The UK's uncodified constitution is no more or less valuable than other European states' codified constitutions.

Why?

Keep trying and you might find an absolute example with which to beat the UK over the head with. It's quite interesting you will ignore things you can't argue with such as the UK's placing in the UN HDI.

Thats because I'm an EU lawyer who writes on EU law and EU constitutions...

Livingtothefull · 21/05/2022 19:50

DownNative · 21/05/2022 13:39

Yes, it is, isn't it?

What's more, the current UN HDI score is the highest the UK has ever had from 1990 to present day. In all that time, it's only gone up, up, up. Higher than under the Government's of Major, Blair, Brown, Cameron/Clegg, Cameron and May.

Globally, out of 189 countries, the UK ranks 13th. In terms of European states, the UK is 10th.

It does not suit the trashing the UK as a whole from some in this thread.....

The latest HDI scores I can find online relate to 2019, prior to Covid and Brexit and in the same year of the latest UK election - so not sure if any changes will emerge as a consequence of these? Again, I would honestly expect to see the UK near the top in relation to European states, not 10th.

There are 66 of a total of 189 states in the 'very high' HDI category, so around a third - we are not talking about a tiny elite group.

Nobody is denying that when viewed worldwide the UK is a good place to be relative to many other countries. But when comparing the reality of life and its problems here with its potential, I consider that it is a much more nuanced situation than 'We're doing great'.

And I take issue with the suggestion that I am trashing the UK. Completely the opposite: I think that as a nation we deserve far better than what the ruling elite has been delivering to us.

OP posts:
Ferngreen · 21/05/2022 19:22

The latest is their proposal to break international law.

I feel sorry for NI - every thing has to have a dozen bits of paper - why should they be screwed over.

Lonelycrab · 21/05/2022 19:20

You know this makes no sense whatsoever, don't you?

Yes I was thinking that too, mental gymnastics looks like.

CapMarvel · 21/05/2022 19:14

DownNative · 21/05/2022 13:43

Firstly, Scotland and Northern Ireland weren't named on the ballot paper. Only the UK was and only the UK voted since it was only the UK that was the EU member state.

Secondly, look at the numbers closely and you should come to the conclusion that Leave won the day due to votes in Scotland and Northern Ireland. You should note that those two parts had the lowest turnouts which only added to Leave winning it there. The numbers tell us England was very much divided and required votes from the other parts.

You know this makes no sense whatsoever, don't you?

Livingtothefull · 21/05/2022 19:12

DdraigGoch · 21/05/2022 19:01

Some consequences of leaving may be inevitable. Some on the other hand are a result of deliberate attempts to make the process as bumpy as possible pour encourager les autres.

That's as may be but given that we chose to leave the EU, they are under no obligation to make it easy for us and as we left we have no way of compelling them to play fair.

I am also appalled by Brexit, opposed it at every turn so the consequences are not on me or anyone like me.

OP posts:
CapMarvel · 21/05/2022 19:11

picassobride · 21/05/2022 08:13

Oh, do get a life. Boris is doing a splendid job on Ukraine war, NIrish need to sort out their own government and learn to co-operate like adults.
The fucking party-gate has been done to death. Move on🤬

You know, I'm really sick of people - and tory mps - saying we should "move on".

No, fuck off. We'll move on when we have a government that isn't entirely consistent of either corrupt wankers of people who are just. plain. stupid.

DdraigGoch · 21/05/2022 19:01

AtwilightRebellion · 21/05/2022 18:26

It's quite common for some to claim the EU has no reason to punish the UK for the Leave vote with a firm eye on Euroscepticism in the EU without a shred of evidence. And attempting to downplay it as a "trope

Again, the UK left the EU.

My dear, try to understand the nuance.

The UK LEFT the European Union.

The consequences are on the UK.

Possibly hard for you to accept.

But what is unfolding is because we left.

The UK will continue to suffer as a result.

I will remain gutted over the Brexit result.

How you aren't appalled about how you and your children have been robbed by this is beyond me.

Some consequences of leaving may be inevitable. Some on the other hand are a result of deliberate attempts to make the process as bumpy as possible pour encourager les autres.

BobbyeinArkansas · 21/05/2022 18:42

Thought you were going to say you were Russian!

DdraigGoch · 21/05/2022 18:41

DownNative · 21/05/2022 06:54

Such a flippant response from yourself fails to further any kind of mature discussion, but I'm not surprised.

Like any country, Northern Ireland has its problems, but is still a very good place to live in today.

The idea of a civil war IS very much unrealistic and nearly always pushed by those with no actual experience of Northern Ireland. Especially misused by Remainers, funnily enough.

On that note I'm getting rather fed up with Americans rolling along and pretending to be experts in Northern Irish politics (usually on the basis that their Great-Great-Great Grandmother was from Limerick). Perhaps they might try sorting out their shitshow of a nation, where I bet that they have more violent deaths per capita than NI ever did, even in the height of the Troubles.

MarshaBradyo · 21/05/2022 18:30

DownNative · 21/05/2022 13:39

Yes, it is, isn't it?

What's more, the current UN HDI score is the highest the UK has ever had from 1990 to present day. In all that time, it's only gone up, up, up. Higher than under the Government's of Major, Blair, Brown, Cameron/Clegg, Cameron and May.

Globally, out of 189 countries, the UK ranks 13th. In terms of European states, the UK is 10th.

It does not suit the trashing the UK as a whole from some in this thread.....

There is a disconnect between these threads and this

Then again I find a big gap between these threads and posts and rl

AtwilightRebellion · 21/05/2022 18:26

It's quite common for some to claim the EU has no reason to punish the UK for the Leave vote with a firm eye on Euroscepticism in the EU without a shred of evidence. And attempting to downplay it as a "trope

Again, the UK left the EU.

My dear, try to understand the nuance.

The UK LEFT the European Union.

The consequences are on the UK.

Possibly hard for you to accept.

But what is unfolding is because we left.

The UK will continue to suffer as a result.

I will remain gutted over the Brexit result.

How you aren't appalled about how you and your children have been robbed by this is beyond me.

Sumtimesiamgreen · 21/05/2022 18:19

Your gripes are fair but you are fortunate enough to be moaning about it on the internet without fear of reprisals, not everyone can enjoy that freedom. I am proud to live in the UK.

Choopi · 21/05/2022 18:10

Quite why Sainsbury goods need to be subject to checks on entry to Northern Ireland from Great Britain is anyone's guess. They have no stores in the Republic.

This can't be serious? You cannot bring meat or dairy, certain plants and plant products etc into the EU from a non EU country. Are they just supposed to pinky promise that they won't end up over the border and that's grand? Ireland is supposed to accept the risk of pests and diseases from non EU regulated food etc because why? What's in it for us exactly?

Livingtothefull · 21/05/2022 16:58

Thank you very much @SunscreenCentral, that is a really kind message.

OP posts:
DownNative · 21/05/2022 15:25

AtwilightRebellion · 21/05/2022 14:30

The EU has also pushed and pushed the agenda with Northern Ireland which destabilised it too. We're just a pawn in the EU desire to punish the UK for the Leave vote. Barnier's comments have not been forgotten

This trope that the UK is being punished is embarrassing. It was the UK that held the referendum and voted leave. It isn't for the EU to then accommodate this ridiculous decision.

From Le Point International in 2016 regarding Barnier's role:

"I would have succeeded in my mission if, in the end, the deal is so hard for the British that they would prefer to stay in the Union", he told his friends during the summer of 2016. Because for Juncker - and the majority of European leaders are, at this time, in the same state of mind - Brexit must be a form of punishment for these "deserters" and dissuade any other Member State from doing the same... the survival of the EU is at stake.

The choice of Barnier is also a signal sent by Juncker to 10 Downing Street. Indeed, the former Commissioner for the Internal Market and Services (2009-2014) is the public enemy number one in the City. Throughout his mandate, British officials had conducted an endless skirmish with malicious attempts to trip the Savoyard [native of Savoie], who is anxious to push the fires of banking regulation to the markets in the aftermath of the financial crisis. The 28 texts regulating the markets which he had driven to adoption had earned him strong enmities on the shores of the Thames."

It's quite common for some to claim the EU has no reason to punish the UK for the Leave vote with a firm eye on Euroscepticism in the EU without a shred of evidence. And attempting to downplay it as a "trope".

Much the same way some baselessly claimed Brexit breaches the GFA with Jo evidence at all.

SpiderVersed · 21/05/2022 15:03

I agree, OP, we’re an international embarrassment.

Governed by liars and crooks, out to line the pockets of themselves and their friends, a government prepared to destroy the GFA to keep the 1922 committee quiet. Brexit was a nation making itself irrelevant and impoverished in an no act of self-harm. The work-shy compulsive liar in Downing Street shows us up every time he opens his mouth.
Food poverty rising, foodbanks were almost unheard of pre-2010 and are in record demand. Services cut to the bone, the vulnerable of society abandoned by a government that ought to serve and protect.

A police force riddled with violence against women and not prepared to do anything meaningful about it.

I’ll still be volunteering at the street party. Not because I give a stuff about monarchy or flag-waving, but because it’s great to get together with my neighbours and have fun.

Livingtothefull · 21/05/2022 14:55

"As in my original post, when it really mattered - the prorogation of Parliament - the Monarch proved to be useless as a defence. We had to rely on the Courts, not our Head of State, to find the prorogation to be unlawful."
'No, you're simply misunderstanding what the Constitutional role of the Monarch is - to deny power to any would-be usurper and to be a figurehead for the UK under the Government's orders.
'It is the role of the Supreme Court to rule on constitutional matters. Even the Scottish Parliament was found to have acted beyond their powers.
'We have a Constitutional Monarchy and the Monarch has a passive role except for the highly unlikely situation aforementioned.'

I am not misunderstanding anything, I am saying that the current model does not and cannot work both in practice based on experience, and on its own terms. How would the Monarch deny power to a usurper or dictator in practice? How would/could they do that? Who decides whether an individual is a usurper and at what point?

"Returning to comparisons with other countries; many have written constitutions and elected Heads of State with real power to hold politicians accountable to the constitutions and act as effective arbiters of the democratic system."
'You're suggesting here that the UK doesn't have a written constitution which is completely wrong. We actually do - it's written in Acts of Parliament. Unlike the United States, our written constitution is uncodified which allows the UK to change constitutional laws very quickly if needed.'

There is no actual "British Constitution" just a set of rules and regulations constituted by jurisprudence and laws (English and Scottish law), and by various treaties and international agreements to which the UK has signed up.

The lack of a written constitution caused a major constitutional argument about what a government can do without the consent of Parliament. Just to summarise here, the problems this led to following the 2016 Brexit referendum:

Constitutional experts agreed that Parliament had to be consulted, and vote, before the Prime Minister could activate Article 50 of the Lisbon Treaty, to take the UK out of the European Union. However Theresa May (PM at the time) did not want a debate, or a vote, in Parliament before Britain left the EU, and sought to go ahead with Article 50 regardless.

In July 2016, a group of citizens appealed to the High Court to stop the government activating Article 50 without Parliament's consent.
The verdict was confirmed by the Supreme Court on 24th January 2017; Parliament must vote before Article 50 of the Lisbon Treaty could be triggered. It did so.

Nevertheless, Parliament was not bound by the result of the Brexit referendum, which was consultative, not legislative. Before the referendum, three quarters of elected MPs were against Brexit, and until the 2019 General Election, it remained possible that Brexit would not actually take place; Parliament had the power to veto it.

Vetoing Brexit, however, would have been a dangerous step. If Parliament had vetoed a process that was approved (however marginally and on the basis of however many lies) by a popular referendum, it would have sparked a massive constitutional crisis and possibly serious public unrest. In the end, Parliament held up the Brexit process, but could not stop it. While some Conservative MPs rebelled, enough remained loyal to their party to ensure a situation of stalemate (impasse) in Parliament, where MPs could not agree on a way forward.

Eventually there was a new General Election in the autumn of 2019, and Boris Johnson secured a majority on his promise to "get Brexit done". Although the Conservatives secured the highest total number of votes, overall fewer voted for them than for other parties. In some countries that might have resulted in (the equivalent of) a hung parliament, however with our first past the post system that was enough to secure a huge majority for the Conservatives. With this Parliament approved Brexit, and the UK duly left the EU.

The debates and arguments did not stop there. Later in 2020, Johnson proposed a law that would allow the UK to renege on parts of the international agreement signed with the EU concerning Britain's terms of exit from the Union (the Withdrawal Agreement). So apparently, despite the Constitution being constituted in (among other things) international treaties, those treaties can be broken at will by the PM of the day and there is no mechanism for stopping this. Parliament is accountable, but not the Government.

No wonder there is lasting anger from many people about Brexit. It has opened up the deep divisions among people within the UK; how we are meant to repair that, and how the Monarch is meant to act as a 'unifying' figurehead I don't know. BTW Johnson's actions were severely criticized by ALL of Britain's living former Prime Ministers (3 Conservatives, 2 Labour), as well as another former leader of the Conservative Party.

There are therefore strong arguments for the need for a UK constitution which are made by many. The attached article is helpful for further explaining the issues: www.ft.com/content/bf81ea49-96b0-4329-bbaf-f58fdf6e0630

You cited a number of existing models for the role of Head of State. I agree that there are pros and cons with each of them; I point out that in other countries the HofS would have the power to force the Government of the day to comply with its own laws.

I would disagree with you that the UK's checks and balances work well: imo they do not. Or nowhere near well enough.

OP posts:
EngTech · 21/05/2022 14:46

Come the GE vote accordingly and get another party in 😳😳

Be careful what you wish for 😳

Livingtothefull · 21/05/2022 14:41

"You see that is all part of the problem of the Monarchy imo. How exactly would the Monarch be the final line of defence against a dictator?"
'Suppose we had PM who became a dictator, the Monarch would be able to command the Armed Forces to depose that person. Same happens for a dictator from outwith the UK.
'The Armed Forces are in no doubt to whom allegiance is owed in that case.
"Why do the Armed Forces swear allegiance to the Monarch and not the people? That seems more of a recipe for dictatorship if anything."
'Why would they pledge allegiance to the people? That would be chaotic in batte or times of emergency. Crucially, the Monarch cannot become a dictator because the Crown Prerogative is exercised by the democratically elected PM.'

Who makes the judgment that a PM has become a dictator? At what point is the command to depose the dictator made and by what process is it triggered? By the Monarch (who is supposed to act on the advice of the PM) or through another source? Why is it 'crucial' that a Monarch cannot become a dictator if others can?

I disagree entirely that the Armed Forces pledging allegiance to the people would lead to chaos in battle; I think it is pretty clear what it means to defend one's country. By way of example, how about Germany's military oath: 'I pledge to loyally serve the Federal Republic of Germany and to courageously defend the rights and the liberty of the German people.'

'Essentially, the PM and Monarch are able to provide checks and balances to each other, if needed.' Again, I just don't see any checks and balances happening in practice. What I see is the PM being free to act without restraint as the Monarch acts on the advice of the PM. Monarchy, and a lack of appropriate division of powers, is imo at the root of the problem.

OP posts:
AtwilightRebellion · 21/05/2022 14:30

The EU has also pushed and pushed the agenda with Northern Ireland which destabilised it too. We're just a pawn in the EU desire to punish the UK for the Leave vote. Barnier's comments have not been forgotten

This trope that the UK is being punished is embarrassing. It was the UK that held the referendum and voted leave. It isn't for the EU to then accommodate this ridiculous decision.