Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wish I had a regional accent?

138 replies

turnyourmattress · 18/05/2022 11:08

I don't know why, but I don't have a strong regional accent. There are occasional hints of it, and it comes out when I'm really angry. Most people think I am southern, or sound a bit RP (not really imo).

I am from Liverpool. Went to an inner city state comp, lived around people with strong scouse accents. My parents don't have strong ones, but do have accents. My grandparents were near unintelligible to outsiders 🐲

I think my accent softened a bit at uni. Or in other words, any accent I did have, disappeared. I never ever made a conscious effort to change it.

People are always surprised when I tell them I'm from Liverpool. They don't believe me, or ask if I went to boarding school/grew up down here. Ask when I changed it. I've had other people from Liverpool claim that I am pretending to be someone I am not. Some people think I am a huge snob, others think I am trying to hide where I am from.

AIBU to wish I had a regional accent, just so that I could conform to what people expect from people from Liverpool?

OP posts:
Momicrone · 19/05/2022 08:20

Why do you care so much what people think of you?

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/05/2022 08:15

I find the idea that regional accents are somehow impolite or ill-educated genuinely disturbing tbh. And I'm quite shocked that people consider it acceptable to say on a public forum that they find a regional accent "distracting" as one poster commented. Did you mean to sound so shockingly ignorant?

I also think the desire to conformize and bland over everything so awful. Why would you want everyone to speak with Radio 4 RP?

DaisyWaldron · 19/05/2022 08:07

@Goldenbear I'm not sure that that's necessarily the case. I grew up with a fairly strong regional accent, but moved away from the area where I grew up when I went to university in England. I genuinely don't have my original accent any more, and now speak in a sort of RP tinged with the accent of the city where I live. If you heard me talk, you would probably think I was from the Home Counties but settled in the north of England, or else possibly that I was from the north of England but educated at a boarding school. If you were good at accents, you might be able to narrow the generic vague "Northern" to the city where I live. But you wouldn't guess where I come from from my accent.

Goldenbear · 19/05/2022 07:48

I would imagine OP that you do have an accent that is discernible. IME people will say this but actually the accent notes are there. I think if you you know your UK Geography you can easily place people's accents. I am originally from London, started out a private school where most had RP accents as it was the 1980's, my Dad lost lots of money and I had to go to a huge London comprehensive where I got bullied mercilessly for my accent, got called a snob and a posho even though non of it was true. After years at secondary school with London accents I developed a hybrid I think. But I can tell the subtle differences in London accents so North/South, even east/west, I can tell when someone is from Kent or Hertfordshire. However, most would say the southeast estuary accent is the same for all those places and it isn't so I would imagine you can definitely hear notes of your accent OP so why worry.

Merryclaire · 19/05/2022 07:47

I feel your pain. I grew up in an area with a strong regional accent, but my parents (originally from another area) loathed it and ironed any trace out of me through constant correction.
I now can’t even mimic the accent beyond a few words.
That meant I grew up sounding ‘too posh’ for my working class estate and never fit in or made real friends there. Have constantly been told that I’m not local and made fun of.
I have now moved to another area and in my adult professional life a neutral accent suits me very well, but it did cause me issues growing up.
I personally think a regional accent can be nice, but don’t think it should be the same as speaking lazily, which sometimes it can be used as an excuse for.

Belephant · 19/05/2022 07:46

PeachPizza · 19/05/2022 00:03

Just me then who has a few different accents?

Maybe it's due to growing up/going to secondary school in a city school with incredibly strong accents, plus having family with a different very strong accent. And then university with a mix of lots of accents and people there (gently and usually kindly) mocking my accent. And now living in a "naice" part of the south.

But I have an accent for my school friends (which DH can't always understand apparently...), my normal/at home voice (which isn't a voice I had before university, and my 'naice' phone call/school mum voice/talking to the teachers vice.

They all of course are similar enough and I don't purposely change them. It just sort of happens depending on the company I'm in.

Yes!!! I think for me it's because my mother has one regional accent, my dad has a different one (but a lot closer to modern RP), and I was brought up in an area with another different regional accent.

My accent sometimes changes several times just in one conversation!

catfunk · 19/05/2022 07:34

PearlclutchersInc · 18/05/2022 11:47

A polite or educated accent is nice - and that's what you probably have. People are so used to hearing the extremes via the media which is why they think you don't have one.

Broad Scouse accents are like nails down a blackboard to me.

I'm from the north east - have educated to masters level and I'm incredibly polite - how exactly should I be speaking @PearlclutchersInc 😂

secretllama · 19/05/2022 07:09

eddiemairswife · 18/05/2022 22:10

Seem to be a lot of touchy Liverpudlians reading this.

What response were you expecting from your original comment though? This isnt a hypothetical question, I'm actually asking. Of course you knew people would respond that way.

BarbaraofSeville · 19/05/2022 06:19

And yet again we have all the people who feel it is acceptable to make derogatory assumptions about people from different parts of England that would be called out as racism or xenophobia if talking about people from other parts of the world.

Listen to yourselves will you. You'd never admit to assuming that someone from Pakistan or Poland is impolite or uneducated based on how they speak and where they're from do why you think you can say the same about someone from Liverpool, Yorkshire, the West country, etc?

torquewench · 19/05/2022 06:13

Furrbabymama87 · 18/05/2022 14:34

I am also scouse. I think there's a big difference between the north and south Liverpool accent. I have got an accent but it's nothing like the thicker variations that you would hear in North Liverpool. When I'm talking to people from other places they notice straight away and they're like "I love your accent, I could listen to you talk all day". So it must be noticeable to some.

"Is right!" as they say round here 😁

I was going to say this. I live in South Liverpool, the accent is far softer in my postcode (I live in Mossley Hill/Calderstones area) than it is in L8 which is 10 mins drive away, or places for eg like Page Moss/Kirkdale/Bootle/Fazakerley. Another thing I've noticed is that the older generation (70+) have a really soft accent.

No one Ive met on holidays or travelling has ever asked me to say "chiccchkken" or told me to calm down, and I don't think I have a strong accent.

I worked with someone who was born and raised in the Glasgow suburbs. He also had a soft accent. I Could always tell when he was on the phone to someone north of the border though as it got a lot stronger as the convo went on

BraveryBot9to5 · 19/05/2022 05:38

Yes, that one correct accent thinking in the UK is an awful albatross for 90% of people.,

It is weird, so many accents are lovely if they're milder versions of the region's accent. I don't know what it's like in other English speaking countries but in Ireland it's perfectly acceptable for people to be able to tell where you're from, that doesn't mean that you're accent is bad in any way. Some people have very strong accents and perhaps a milder version of it might benefit them but there's no suggestion that they should attempt to eradicate all trace of where they come from. It's such a backward way of thinking!

Kanaloa · 19/05/2022 01:21

PearlclutchersInc · 18/05/2022 11:47

A polite or educated accent is nice - and that's what you probably have. People are so used to hearing the extremes via the media which is why they think you don't have one.

Broad Scouse accents are like nails down a blackboard to me.

Which accent is ‘polite and educated?’ I’d love to know. I was always of the impression that anyone who behaves politely to others is polite, and anyone who has achieved a good level of schooling is educated, but perhaps it’s actually to do with where you were raised and what accent you’ve developed.

Kanaloa · 19/05/2022 01:14

Hbh17 · 18/05/2022 13:30

Goodness me, no. An educated accent will get you a long way in life. Strong regional accents are often not appealing - I don't like them on the radio, for instance, as it can be too distracting.

If someone was ‘educated’ in Liverpool, they’ll have a regional accent. An RP accent isn’t the only marker of education. If you’re distracted by any accent other than one you consider ‘acceptable’ on the radio perhaps you’re just a bit small-minded and struggle to understand others who are different from yourself.

Personally, I think snotty little attitudes like yours are the mark of a very closed and ignorant type of person.

RobertaFirmino · 19/05/2022 00:31

eddiemairswife · 18/05/2022 22:10

Seem to be a lot of touchy Liverpudlians reading this.

...and I bet you wouldn't dare make your shitty little comments to our faces either

Chouetted · 19/05/2022 00:12

Libertybear80 · 18/05/2022 23:54

I'm quite pleased I didn't grow up with a Cumbrian accent. Absolutely no one knows where you are from! Except another Cumbrian!

Alreet marra, hos it gaan?

I miss my Cumbrian accent, noone believes I'm from Cumbria now!

PeachPizza · 19/05/2022 00:06

Abhannmor · 18/05/2022 17:32

I like the fact there are so many accents in the UK and Ireland. You can travel 1000 miles in the USA and the first person you speak to sounds like a clone of the last one. There's about 4 accents in the whole continent. Boring 😴

Not in my experience.

I've only been to 10 or so different states but have heard some amazing accents!!

PeachPizza · 19/05/2022 00:03

Just me then who has a few different accents?

Maybe it's due to growing up/going to secondary school in a city school with incredibly strong accents, plus having family with a different very strong accent. And then university with a mix of lots of accents and people there (gently and usually kindly) mocking my accent. And now living in a "naice" part of the south.

But I have an accent for my school friends (which DH can't always understand apparently...), my normal/at home voice (which isn't a voice I had before university, and my 'naice' phone call/school mum voice/talking to the teachers vice.

They all of course are similar enough and I don't purposely change them. It just sort of happens depending on the company I'm in.

Libertybear80 · 18/05/2022 23:54

I'm quite pleased I didn't grow up with a Cumbrian accent. Absolutely no one knows where you are from! Except another Cumbrian!

MrsIronfoundersson · 18/05/2022 23:54

WiseRobin · 18/05/2022 23:34

I’ve not read all of the thread yet but I find this topic really interesting.

Both mine and my siblings accents aren’t as strong as our friends from the same area. Our Dad was from Scotland and never lost his beautiful accent, our maternal grandmother, who also lived in the same area as our Grandad was also Scottish and we saw her regularly.

I’ve often wondered how much our parents accents dictate how strong ours will be, even though we mingle with many others, it’s strange.

This is interesting... I am from Dublin with a soft accent and have lived in the UK twice as long as I lived at home, but a friend says she can hear my accent or a twang of it in my kids who are South East England.

OhNoWhatYouGonnaDo · 18/05/2022 23:46

I'm from Liverpool too, but have never had a strong accent. My father is from another country, which may have influenced my speech growing up. I went to a comprehensive school. I got bullied at school for being "posh", then went to Oxford where I was ridiculed for being common because I didn't have an RP accent. I lived in various parts of England in m 20s and 30s and few people could quite place where I was from.

I now live in Formby and most people here sound like me 😂

Yazo · 18/05/2022 23:37

It can be nice to have an accent as part of your identity, I'm from Sheffield but live in the south. No-one ever really asks me about my accent but in reality it's because most people only move within 30 miles of where they grow up and don't really have a clue what people sound like. When I worked in Sheffield plenty of locals didn't think I was from there but there's not a lot you can do. Don't be ashamed of it. When I studied linguistics it's really common for women to change their accents naturally and for men not to. I hated it when people couldn't understand me when I moved away to uni.

Now I have my own kids I can see that accent isn't necessarily that wilful a thing. They go to a school where most parents are not from the area, we're all from around the country, abroad etc, it's not a private school. So my kids don't have a very strong accent and probably never will. Doesn't mean their identity is any less though!

Be the proud Scouser you are, however you sound!

WiseRobin · 18/05/2022 23:34

I’ve not read all of the thread yet but I find this topic really interesting.

Both mine and my siblings accents aren’t as strong as our friends from the same area. Our Dad was from Scotland and never lost his beautiful accent, our maternal grandmother, who also lived in the same area as our Grandad was also Scottish and we saw her regularly.

I’ve often wondered how much our parents accents dictate how strong ours will be, even though we mingle with many others, it’s strange.

itsnotmeitsu · 18/05/2022 23:32

I have an aversion to certain accents, including Brummie and Liverpudlian. I was born in Birmingham and my husband was born in Liverpool. Since then I've lived in every county in Yorkshire, as well as London, Norfolk and Lancashire. My husband's family moved to West Sussex when he was young. I don't think anybody could guess where we originated from due to our accents. Certainly, in my case, I've lived in too many places for that. Perhaps some sounds just really get to you, as in the condition misophonia. Misophonia is definately a problem for me.

eddiemairswife · 18/05/2022 23:26

I'm almost as far from Manchester as I am from Liverpool, although I've have lived near to both cities. I don't live near my birthplace, but my accent gives my origins.

caecilius1 · 18/05/2022 22:54

@eddiemairswife
Judging by your strong reaction, I'm going to take a guess that you're a Mancunian.

Swipe left for the next trending thread