Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wish I had a regional accent?

138 replies

turnyourmattress · 18/05/2022 11:08

I don't know why, but I don't have a strong regional accent. There are occasional hints of it, and it comes out when I'm really angry. Most people think I am southern, or sound a bit RP (not really imo).

I am from Liverpool. Went to an inner city state comp, lived around people with strong scouse accents. My parents don't have strong ones, but do have accents. My grandparents were near unintelligible to outsiders 🐲

I think my accent softened a bit at uni. Or in other words, any accent I did have, disappeared. I never ever made a conscious effort to change it.

People are always surprised when I tell them I'm from Liverpool. They don't believe me, or ask if I went to boarding school/grew up down here. Ask when I changed it. I've had other people from Liverpool claim that I am pretending to be someone I am not. Some people think I am a huge snob, others think I am trying to hide where I am from.

AIBU to wish I had a regional accent, just so that I could conform to what people expect from people from Liverpool?

OP posts:
TheOriginalEmu · 20/05/2022 12:38

cottagegardenflower · 20/05/2022 10:26

Duh is the same. No accent at all His brother sounds like a Hampshire country bumpkin

He has an accent. Everyone has an accent.

cottagegardenflower · 20/05/2022 10:27

The Liverpool accent isn't particularly nice and voted the least trustworthy in some poll or other, so don't fret it

cottagegardenflower · 20/05/2022 10:26

Duh is the same. No accent at all His brother sounds like a Hampshire country bumpkin

Rhodora · 20/05/2022 09:33

DH had to go on a few training courses in Milton Keynes for work. DH is from West Lothian which is quite a well known commuter area for those working in Edinburgh and Glasgow. As a result of being a commuter area it has quite a wide range of accents.

DH was asked by someone else on the course if he was moderating his accent as he always thought the Scottish accent was difficult to understand yet he could understand DH perfectly. DH was a little put out but calmly explained that he was not moderating his accent that was just the way he spoke and saying the Scottish accent was like saying that everyone from Manchester spoke the same way as everyone in Cornwall and the East End of London.

Thepeopleversuswork · 20/05/2022 09:12

Staynow · 19/05/2022 10:39

YABVU because regional accents are generally hideous. I loathe it when janner slips into mine. But could be worse, could be Bristolian.

Give me strength. I am marvelling at the bigotry on display on this thread.

Seymour5 · 20/05/2022 09:06

I’m from the East of Scotland, been in the North of England since my 20s, more than 2/3 of my life. DH is English, but lived in Scotland for much of his childhood. I’m still obviously Scottish, but have always had a moderate accent rather than a strong dialect. I’ve never had a problem being understood. DH varies between accents, a result of having to fit in as a child. He sounds more English than I do.

DC sound Northern English, but not specific to one area, they’ve moved around a bit in adulthood. No way were they picking up the local dialect where they grew up. Fortunately we lived in an area where there were a mix of people with different accents.

Moderate regional accents are great, but outside one’s local area strong dialectal speakers might need to modify their speech to be understood.

mintich · 19/05/2022 12:39

I'm Glaswegian but have lived in England since I was 10 and my accent is very soft. I do wish I sounded more Glaswegian, I hate when people can't believe that's where I'm from

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 19/05/2022 12:37

OP you do have a regional accent, everyone does.

chorizoe · 19/05/2022 12:30

What on earth is a “polite and educated” accent?!

I always thought I was educated with an excellent set of GCSEs and A Levels, 2 first class degrees, I’m a pharmacist, an independent prescriber, and owner of 2 businesses... However, my thick Bristolian accent must suggest otherwise 😔

Willyoujustbequiet · 19/05/2022 12:28

Yanbu.

I adore accents. They are a wonderful extension of dialect, culture and identity.
Only an idiot would perceive them as uneducated.

CruCru · 19/05/2022 12:06

Have you never visited a place where people have such a broad accent that you struggle to understand them? And, on seeing that you are struggling, have them make no effort to help you? It isn't necessarily a north / south thing - many of the kids at my south coast comprehensive could broaden their accents to make them difficult to understand (if you didn't live there).

Kanaloa · 19/05/2022 11:56

Oh, also lots of Polish people, plus a big Indian community where I live. No trouble understanding their accents either. Sometimes I may have to say ‘sorry what was that?’ And that’s it. They sometimes have to say the same to me. But I think having varied and rich cultures (whether from Britain or elsewhere) is incredibly valuable. However, I’m a good listener and make the effort to understand others, rather than expecting the whole world to behave exactly like me so I never have to feel out of my comfort zone.

Kanaloa · 19/05/2022 11:54

CruCru · 19/05/2022 11:50

Someone upthread made a reference to people having a "polite or educated accent" and I sort of understand what they mean. I remember (absolutely years ago) a poster said that she and her family had moved to a very different part of the country and were finding it difficult to understand anyone (even the children's teacher). There's nothing wrong with having a distinctive accent but speaking in a way that makes it difficult for non-locals to understand is quite rude (obviously speak however you want with your friends and family).

Gosh, all those rude people who don’t speak the exact same as you do. Maybe if you can only tolerate people with your own exact accent you should stay in your own area.

For what it’s worth, I’m Scottish, lived all over England, and have never ever found an accent I physically couldn’t understand. I think people who insist they can’t understand have a listening problem and are very rude themselves.

CruCru · 19/05/2022 11:50

Someone upthread made a reference to people having a "polite or educated accent" and I sort of understand what they mean. I remember (absolutely years ago) a poster said that she and her family had moved to a very different part of the country and were finding it difficult to understand anyone (even the children's teacher). There's nothing wrong with having a distinctive accent but speaking in a way that makes it difficult for non-locals to understand is quite rude (obviously speak however you want with your friends and family).

JudgeJ · 19/05/2022 11:48

Hbh17 · 18/05/2022 13:30

Goodness me, no. An educated accent will get you a long way in life. Strong regional accents are often not appealing - I don't like them on the radio, for instance, as it can be too distracting.

You do realise that every region has an accent? The majority of people have a variety of accents depending on what they're doing, most people's accents become more pronounced with family.

Rhodora · 19/05/2022 11:42

I was born in West London, I moved to Hook, Hants when I was two and Edinburgh when I was five. My parents are from Hertfordshire and Ayrshire.

This has resulted in me having a very mixed accent. Some people assume I’m from where I live now as while the accent is distinctive it’s not broad. Others guess I’m English but have a hard time placing my accent.

DH was the first person I’ve ever met to correctly place West London, Ayrshire and where I live now. In another life though DH was an HGV driver and so spent a lot of time travelling the length and breadth of the country.

You likely do have a Liverpool accent OP just not the broad one that people from where you grew up expect.

Goldenbear · 19/05/2022 11:21

Can you have an RP accent if you grew up with a regional accent- im not convinced that happens. The RP accent is quite rare now anyway, even in the south-east, there is a modern version of it but it is not that common. My Dad was originally from the South Midlands so Warwickshire area but moved to London at 23 and sounds 'posh' according to the fellow residents of his new over 60s flat back in the Midlands but I can hear the Midlands accent notes, just as he states that sometimes I sound very much like a 'Londoner' despite most people telling me I don't have an accent. I agree that everyone has an accent before anyone jumps on that but this is what people have said to me in person in casual conversation over the years. I know I can sound like a Londoner one from South West/West London but I grew up with RP being spoken all around me. I just don't think you shake of your regional accent as much as you think. Yes people might not guess your Northern, Welsh etc town village but there is probably a bit of a give away somewhere, is it possible to grow up with a strong regional accent but talk RP like Prince Charles as an adult? I know someone who went to private school in Lincolnshire and she thinks she speaks with RP accent but the way she pronounces my daughter's name, it starts with a long vowel, she shortens it and she makes the e in the name sound like an I - it is the Lincolnshire notes of an accent coming through so not RP at all!

Staynow · 19/05/2022 10:39

YABVU because regional accents are generally hideous. I loathe it when janner slips into mine. But could be worse, could be Bristolian.

Kanaloa · 19/05/2022 10:31

BobbinThreadbare123 · 19/05/2022 10:12

@Kanaloa they do let some northerners out to do these education things. There's a quota though and a lot of them are for being a professional northerner e.g. Maxine Peake, Christopher Eccleston types. 😆

😂

Libertaire · 19/05/2022 10:25

I’m the same, OP. I grew up in an ex-mining town in Derbyshire & spoke wi’ a proper ‘ay up mi duck’ accent. When I went to university and started associating with people from very different backgrounds my accent progressively softened to the extent that by my mid 20s it was very neutral. I still basically sound northern, eg I pronounce the ‘a’ in clap, bath & grass the same, but apart from that I sound like I could come from anywhere or nowhere.

I envy people who speak well & with cool accents eg Lauren Laverne, Sara Cox.

BobbinThreadbare123 · 19/05/2022 10:12

@Kanaloa they do let some northerners out to do these education things. There's a quota though and a lot of them are for being a professional northerner e.g. Maxine Peake, Christopher Eccleston types. 😆

Thatswhyimacat · 19/05/2022 10:08

I'm also from Liverpool and have also pretty much lost any accent I had and speak with pretty much RP, except I still have Northern vowels. People are often very surprised to hear where I'm from. Generally, people from up north are sad for me having lost it, and people from down south are snobbier and say it sounds better or that having a regional accent would make me sound less educated (I have a PhD and a lot of people seem surprised that anyone from above the home counties could possibly do that).

The worst is that when I come across people with very strong scouse accents, mine starts to creep back and I get worried they'll think I'm imitating them.

darisdet · 19/05/2022 10:03

People think I'm not from my place of birth because I don't have the regional accent. I'm sure I must use some dialect. I never had an accent though. Mix of private education, peers, family. People think I'm southern because of long vowel sounds, but I'm not.

Perhaps people are wondering how you lost your accent. I know people whose accents have diluted to almost neutral in adulthood and some where they haven't altered at all. Similar circumstances of having left local area to attend university.

Kanaloa · 19/05/2022 09:57

BobbinThreadbare123 · 19/05/2022 09:52

An educated accent indeed! There's some absolutely clack spouted on this thread.
High time we moved on from "you sound thick because you sound like that"...
Yours blackboardnailingly, a Scouser with a PhD.

A scouser with a phd? Sorry hun, you must be mistaken. You see, the Liverpool accent isn’t ‘polite and educated.’ I’m afraid you’re actually rude and uneducated. Only people with RP accents have phds. You can’t even do them at universities outside of London actually. Sorry xx

BobbinThreadbare123 · 19/05/2022 09:52

An educated accent indeed! There's some absolutely clack spouted on this thread.
High time we moved on from "you sound thick because you sound like that"...
Yours blackboardnailingly, a Scouser with a PhD.

Swipe left for the next trending thread