Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask if my town is typical.

105 replies

Upamountain43 · 18/05/2022 08:27

The town i live in has been a bit run down for decades and it definitely would never be classed as anything but a working class town.

A couple of years ago the almost unthinkable happened and our McDonalds closed down.

Driving through the centre yesterday i noticed our Costa has now shut down.

We do still have them at out of town shopping areas but no longer in our town centre.

Its not that I'm shedding any tears about these companies going - but it has made me wonder if this happening everywhere? I think it must show how dire things are for our town centres now or is our town just an anomaly?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EssexCat · 20/05/2022 08:40

Mercurial123 · 20/05/2022 05:51

No not at you. General question. Not sure why it's rude.

Because to me if they wanted to say something personal about them, then they’d say it. It’s not for me to.

pussycatlickinglollyices · 20/05/2022 06:29

Crikeyalmighty · 18/05/2022 17:50

@pussycatlickinglollyices are you in Maidenhead? We had to go there the other day for something and blimey , it's half demolished and half closed - what a depressing centre for quite an expensive area.

No. Crewe (or Screwed as a local wit changes the signs to)
Nantwich is far nicer and only 4 miles away, we go there.

JanePrentiss · 20/05/2022 06:19

HogwartsForever does your town begin with D?

Mercurial123 · 20/05/2022 05:51

EssexCat · 19/05/2022 17:30

If that’s at me - I don’t mind outing where I live. In fact I couldn’t care less. But if I’m asking other people if they live there then it’s a bit rude to ‘out’ them without their permissions surely?

No not at you. General question. Not sure why it's rude.

ClassicGreen · 19/05/2022 18:39

It's interesting to hear about the exodus of M&S from town centres! We lost ours recently when it moved to a big edge of town store about 10 miles away. It's been a trend at M&S then and not wholly the fault of the Council, onliners and landlord?

The high street was always a destination place in my teenage years (1990s). I imagine folk can still be persuaded there if the mix of shops, services and leisure activities are right? Whatever that may look like. Although the substandard conversion of shops and offices could hinder that.

Fascinating to read about empty shops still being tax assets by absentee landlords. Blimey.

EssexCat · 19/05/2022 17:30

Mercurial123 · 19/05/2022 14:17

Why the mystery about just posting the initial of the town you live, nobody will have a clue of who you are.

If that’s at me - I don’t mind outing where I live. In fact I couldn’t care less. But if I’m asking other people if they live there then it’s a bit rude to ‘out’ them without their permissions surely?

Titsflyingsouth · 19/05/2022 15:40

Our town centre is dying on its arse. Lost Debenhams, Gap, JD Sports, BHS, Laura Ashley, in recent years. TSB and WH Smith are closing soon. M&S are relocating to the out of town centre this summer. The empty units are not being filled. It's all pound shops and bookies now.

Mercurial123 · 19/05/2022 14:17

Why the mystery about just posting the initial of the town you live, nobody will have a clue of who you are.

EssexCat · 19/05/2022 13:21

CooooCoooo · 19/05/2022 11:30

It's not the norm for my town. Our highstreet is thriving. We have two Costas, Cafe Nero, lots of independent cafes, New Look, Specsavers, M&S, Boots, Superdrugs, Greg's, Wetherspoons, a travel agents, a rum bar, a shop selling fabric, a suit shop and a wedding dress shop, butcher, tons of hair dressers, two cake shops, two florists, pet shop, tons of pubs, Wilko, an independent book store, an art studio and so many more.. The small independent shops far outnumber the chain shops. We don't have a McDonalds (or similar fast food place) because the town voted against it - they didn't want it to take away business from the independent cafes.

The town is a busy market town in Wiltshire where we have a large number of elderly and middle aged so the highstreet is always busy especially on market days. We also seem to have a large number of entrepreneurs and as soon as one shop closes someone else is ready to move in.

I think the key to reviving highstreets are small independent businesses but commercial rent can be astronomical. The councils/landlords really need to give their heads a wobble over what's better - empty highstreets and no rent or a busy highstreet with thriving businesses paying a reasonable rate of rent.

I think you live in my hometown!! De?

CandyApplePie · 19/05/2022 12:29

It’s normal where I am and I am in London, high street is dead all shops closing, starbucks closed, now all they open is cheap tacky £5 clothes shops, they are always empty but someone must shop in them as they keep opening new ones there is about 10 of them on my local high street and not much else!

Theforest · 19/05/2022 11:51

I only go in town for the bank really nowadays. Always shocked how run down is. Quite horrible to be honest.

Hoppinggreen · 19/05/2022 11:50

BrioNotBiro · 19/05/2022 09:30

A worrying development is the conversion of empty retail to flats - which are often cheap bedsit-y ones with no parking and bought by investors with no interest (other than financial) in them. The government has changed planning rules to make this easier.

Yes, we need more housing, but is this the best place for it and the right answer for our town centres?

A lot of our empty retail and offices spaces are being turned into Student accommodation (we have a Uni)

womaninatightspot · 19/05/2022 11:44

My closest town is touristy and filled with upmarket delis, bakeries, galleries, whisky, tweed etc. Apart from the tiny co-op there aren't any chains but really I can't afford to shop there so buy everything from Aldi the next town over.

Hoppinggreen · 19/05/2022 11:38

Our Town was never great but there was a nice H of Fraser which now looks like a jumble sale. There was also M&S and Benetton so it was worth me going But they closed
Now I have no reason to go at all and so don’t

CooooCoooo · 19/05/2022 11:30

It's not the norm for my town. Our highstreet is thriving. We have two Costas, Cafe Nero, lots of independent cafes, New Look, Specsavers, M&S, Boots, Superdrugs, Greg's, Wetherspoons, a travel agents, a rum bar, a shop selling fabric, a suit shop and a wedding dress shop, butcher, tons of hair dressers, two cake shops, two florists, pet shop, tons of pubs, Wilko, an independent book store, an art studio and so many more.. The small independent shops far outnumber the chain shops. We don't have a McDonalds (or similar fast food place) because the town voted against it - they didn't want it to take away business from the independent cafes.

The town is a busy market town in Wiltshire where we have a large number of elderly and middle aged so the highstreet is always busy especially on market days. We also seem to have a large number of entrepreneurs and as soon as one shop closes someone else is ready to move in.

I think the key to reviving highstreets are small independent businesses but commercial rent can be astronomical. The councils/landlords really need to give their heads a wobble over what's better - empty highstreets and no rent or a busy highstreet with thriving businesses paying a reasonable rate of rent.

WakeWaterWalk · 19/05/2022 09:53

Evolution or an extinction event?

lurchermummy · 19/05/2022 09:52

Personally I think it's a process of evolution. Yes the old style High Street are dying out and it can be sad to see boarded-up buildings.

However over time I think new businesses will come in to fill the space, many of the empty retail premises will be converted to residential, and town centres will be used more for services rather than shopping. I think it's cyclical and we will see a bounce back over time.

CornishGem1975 · 19/05/2022 09:30

Not in my town, 2 new McDonalds have just opened up! I've noticed a few more empty shops but the restaurants, coffee shops, food etc are ridiculously busy.

BrioNotBiro · 19/05/2022 09:30

A worrying development is the conversion of empty retail to flats - which are often cheap bedsit-y ones with no parking and bought by investors with no interest (other than financial) in them. The government has changed planning rules to make this easier.

Yes, we need more housing, but is this the best place for it and the right answer for our town centres?

DistrictCommissioner · 19/05/2022 09:29

our high street post office has closed down! There are other post offices a bus ride away, it isn’t great.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 19/05/2022 09:26

Oh yes and parking charges

a small off shoot of the high street had 40 minutes free parking, lots of independent shops and you could pop to the bakers and into some of the shops, or go to the podiatrist for 30 minutes

now its 20 minutes free, the shops tried to stop it but the council insisted

i live in a seaside town and they are charging to park on the front, so much oess popping to the shops there as well (people who live here or know the area now park on the residential roads…a bus couldn’t get through the other day)

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 19/05/2022 09:23

It's a shame but I confess I do 90% of my shopping online so contribute to the issue

i didnt, bloody have to do it now

and to be honest i partly blame the greed of big business, they saw the opportunity of online shopping and even though they had a shop in just about every town centre they got an online presence. Quite often thousands of goods on line which obviously couldn’t be replicated in store so if i want that t shirt in blue and not pink i can only buy it online

i went to currys the other day to buy a dvd player….there isnt one in town so i went to the very very large out of town store but they didnt have one single player in stock, a few years ago i went in for a microwave and the member of staff told me to google it! (Nicely, she wasnt rude) so we did google it, found one we wanted, which they didnt have in stock, and bought it with next day delivery and £10 cheaper from john lewis

Upamountain43 · 19/05/2022 09:18

It seems like it is really variable then - i was particularly talking about the big chain food franchises - 50% of all shop units have been empty in our town for years but it seemed the food chains were surviving but no longer.

We do have lots of independents of all types start up but most close again within a few months.

We have always had free parking in our town - there are no charges anywhere. and we have never really had any of the big chains beside Boots and WHSmiths - we have several B&M and pound shops, we did have a lot of charity shops but many of these have closed now as well as have the nail salons - Barbers seem to be flourishing at the moment but nothing else.

I feel for the people with no transport as they are dependant upon the town centre and it really is dying now but i don't know the answer as i am one of the many who rarely if ever use it.

But we have consistently had an appalling county and borough council which i do not think has helped.

OP posts:
easyday · 19/05/2022 09:10

In my part of SW London there's plenty of people around and on the street there's still
quite a number of shops and our own independent department store, but more restaurants than you would think possible! The line of takeaway mopeds is amazing as they wait to get called in for orders.
The mall though lost it's anchor store (Debenhams) and I can't see what would take its place. It's like a ghost town in there - the once buzzing cafe court has gone. They are doing some renovations so maybe they have plans to revive it the mall but currently only the vaccination centre, Boots and Lakeland are the only stores of note. It's a shame but I confess I do 90% of my shopping online so contribute to the issue.

WakeWaterWalk · 19/05/2022 09:01

chipsarnie · 18/05/2022 12:27

My home town in West Yorkshire is literally nothing but charity shops, one workwear shop, a virtually empty market, a shopping centre with loads of closed units. A few coffee shops. That and a million takeaways - some of which never, ever have any customers but mysteriously stay in business and are open about 10 hours a day 🤔- and a massive and very visible drug problem.

Yes these businessess with few customers seem to proliferate. Funny that!

Swipe left for the next trending thread