Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To sell our house because of new developments

114 replies

Yorkie88 · 18/05/2022 07:48

We love our house and have only been here a few years. It's a great location for school, work and I think we got a bargain.

However we are in the countryside and there are plans to build 400 houses behind us and 300 houses in front of us. Planning permission not applied for yet but it feels inevitable. Big companies. Rubbish council.

Is it unreasonable to sell quickly? I feel bad selling a house that us surrounded by countryside with the knowledge that it will become surrounded by houses in years

Also is it even OK to be upset about housing developments? People need homes. But the thought of living in the middle of two huge building sites isn't great

With the current inflation/COL issue...is it a stupid idea to move? I don't really understand the implications but houses seem v expensive

OP posts:
Workwork21 · 18/05/2022 13:36

Yorkie88 · 18/05/2022 09:56

You lot are very helpful. Mostly.

Basically we would have to downsize massively because we don't have anymore money and our current house is big, tad run down but very pretty and big and surrounded by fields. Hahaha.

So hard to get excited about the kids needing to share bedrooms, no space for me to work from home etc but trying to be sensible and get out before it turns into a building site. There is already flooding and road issues and cars parked all over the pavements etc.

It seems a bit mad to be thinking about all this during cost of living and I have pre school age kids so would really rather not to do this at all but otherwise will just sit back and watch our house value plummet? Maybe that's already happened though as seems concensus buyers will find out about all the proposals even if planning application hasn't been made yet

In the politely way possible you are being ridiculous. I wouldn't make all those sacrifices for a view, I find it baffling anyone would!

Having lived with young children in too small a home I'd much rather take the bigger, nicer home in the middle of some developments than what you've just stated. I think you've lost sight of what actually matters.

FreddyVoorhees · 18/05/2022 13:23

SweetSakura · 18/05/2022 07:51

Don't just blame the council. The conservative government brought in planning policies that are very pro development. It is an incredibly high bar to refuse development. But people don't realise this so they attack their local council rather than the Tory MPs

So Labour would make it incredibly difficult to build at a time when house prices are rocketing due to increasing demand and a lack of supply?

You either want houses or you don't.

jevoudrais · 18/05/2022 13:17

This is why I bought a house down a quiet street in a village but surrounded by other (in keeping) houses. There is a quiet lane off my road and so many have sold down there due to a small development on the end. It's an eyesore and I would have hated it too. Unless I owned all the land around it I wouldn't buy anywhere with countryside views on my doorstep Sad

CurbsideProphet · 18/05/2022 13:15

It's really difficult.

Our local Labour Council has had their housing quota quadrupled, the 3 nearby Conservative councils have not. This means developers have been granted permission by the Government to build on green belt land and no one can do anything about it.

QuestionableMouse · 18/05/2022 13:07

Here's my experience of living right next to a building site.

Constant noise. Lorries coming and going. Building noise. There was a particularly wonderful couple of weeks while they were pile driving in which my house literally shook for hours on end. Dust and filth everywhere, to the point I couldn't use the garden at all. Trying to squeeze down the narrow road to my house with huge lorries coming the other way. Constant power cuts, because they hooked the new houses into the old grid and it can't cope. Not to mention the mature trees and hedges that they ripped out. It's been hell. Started in 2019 and still going on now!

Puzzledandpissedoff · 18/05/2022 12:54

300 new houses next to an already oversubscribed primary school in an urban area with no good doctors provision, a serious shortage of dentists, also is a rubbish idea

You're right, it is, but try that with over 3200 homes built and no primary school at all, which is what happened on the estate I used to live on

In fairness three schools were slated in the original plan, but the requirement for them actually to be built waxed and waned according to who was in power, the political complexities involved and what money was being made and by who

Just one school was eventually built 7 years after the homes were completed, but its intake represents just 12% of the local children, so most have to go elsewhere - and often quite far to avoid the large but appalling schools in the surrounding area

Nice, huh? Hmm

Testina · 18/05/2022 12:52

I think you’d be mad to sell.

You say you got it for a bargain - so, sounds like you got it for what it was worth - just everyone else either knew about the potential building work, or sensibly assumed. So more houses going up won’t change that.

Moving would:


  • cost you money. EA fees, search fees, stamp duty, removal costs, legal costs, furniture / decoration / repair - there’s always something in a new house

  • put you in a smaller house!

  • will presumably not deliver you a rural location if this house was more than you could buy if you move


The current economic situation? Largely irrelevant I think, if you’re swapping one house for another at same price. Same mortgage then.

But if cost of living gets harder, (if 🤣) then you would struggle to get a bigger house again and kick yourself.

Honestly, it sounds like you didn’t think the purchase through, and not are similarly not thinking this through.

Keep the bigger house, get planting good screening shrubs on your border now, remember that you’re years away from the full build being approved and actually built, and that building work isn’t the nightmare you think it is.

Reassess once the new development is complete. My guess is you won’t want to leave.

Testina · 18/05/2022 12:44

The idea of living on a building site seems to be a big driver for you.

I think you don’t actually have any experience of these new build sites, though?

They build in phases, so some new homebuyers are literally living on the building site.

You won’t be.

Honestly, find your nearest large scale development that’s still got building phases and go drive around it, on a work day. Park up. Walk around.

Base your decisions on reality!

Puzzledandpissedoff · 18/05/2022 12:41

Glad you find it amusing, Bumtum126 - I doubt the chair of our planning committee does any more, since he's now being prosecuted

In this particular case it was £90k from two different developers, but investigations are continuing into other payemts (and other staff) so who knows what else may come out?

mumda · 18/05/2022 12:40

Yorkie88 · 18/05/2022 08:23

I'm absolutely not saying people can't live here or that houses shouldn't be built. But I think 1000 houses in a rural area with no additional infrastructure isn't great idea. I'm not actually trying to stop it. I'm just considering moving.

300 new houses next to an already oversubscribed primary school in an urban area with no good doctors provision, a serious shortage of dentists, also is a rubbish idea.

cushioncovers · 18/05/2022 12:37

Sit tight for now op no point making a knee jerk reaction and regretting it.

CoastalWave · 18/05/2022 12:36

Yorkie88 · 18/05/2022 07:56

So do future buyers have to be informed? Planning permission has not been applied for and I only know because people in the village are talking about it. Nothing official yet. It feels sneaky. If we have to tell people about it then we are already screwed because the plans are huge and will take years to complete

Their solicitor will inform them if they're any good.

hattie43 · 18/05/2022 12:34

Bit off topic but how / who is going to be able to buy all these new build houses . The costs of materials is spiralling so therefore the cost of housing because developers won't build at a loss . The number of affordable homes section in a 6000 new housing town near me is minimal and reducing all the time .
Genuine question . Councils can't afford to buy them either so who ...

PurassicJark · 18/05/2022 12:33

Yorkie88 · 18/05/2022 08:31

Yes I guess people will buy if the price is right. I just can't imagine buying a house knowing it will have building sites surrounding it for years possibly

Some people don't care. I don't care if they build new homes near me. What I do care about is them not building the infrastructure around it first or at the same time. Expecting us to cope on crap with rising taxes is shitty behaviour most councils are doing.

StageRage · 18/05/2022 12:32

Local rumour and gossip does not have to be disclosed.
Buyers do searches for a reason.
If you are asked directly all anyone can say is ‘as far as I know there is nothing approved’ (if that is true).

QuestionableMouse · 18/05/2022 12:30

There's two developments in my village and I hate it. It's totally changed the village, loads of traffic and my little street keeps suffering power cuts because of the new estate! Move if you can.

Bumtum126 · 18/05/2022 12:26

Puzzledandpissedoff · 18/05/2022 12:13

Its not council's that are building!

No, but it's council staff who enjoy the backhanders offered by developers to make sure their proposals go through

Or at least it is with ours - can't speak for others

LOL 😂

Of course it is , hope you have complained to the local government, the ombudsman and police . How much do they get paid a percentage or per house ? Who gets the money?

Calmdown14 · 18/05/2022 12:25

Have you checked what is actually in the local plan?

These identify areas suitable for housing. It means if the right scheme is put forward in terms of density and design it is more likely to get planning approval. But there will be loads of areas identified and it doesn't mean they'll all be approve because effects on local services etc still have to be considered and balanced with other development

Puzzledandpissedoff · 18/05/2022 12:13

Its not council's that are building!

No, but it's council staff who enjoy the backhanders offered by developers to make sure their proposals go through

Or at least it is with ours - can't speak for others

averythinline · 18/05/2022 11:56

Its not council's that are building! The ability to stop/minimise development has been massively reduced by the government.....
And its much easier to build big developments on fields than squeeze developments in on brownfield sites...that will not provide the numbers of homes needed....

justasking111 · 18/05/2022 11:41

Friends pulled out of buying a house in Cheshire when they discovered they were going to be on the other side of the road from a complete village that was being built. Houses, flats, shops, businesses. Schools One of Boris seven new villages. The plan looks amazing but the roads aren't great

ImplementingTheDennisSystem · 18/05/2022 11:33

This is one of the reasons I won’t move rurally. Anywhere that is near enough to the main town or the satellite communities to be easily commutable or a useful location is prime development land. At least our city centre conservation area won’t be further developed and has protected green space nearby

Same. We bought in a leafy cul-de-sac in a little town where, in the immediate vicinity at least, there is nowhere else left to build. At least our view will remain unchanged for the entire time that we live here.
Sorry OP, that doesn't help, but these massive developments are a nightmare. My biggest concern would be that it gets half built and then the developer goes into administration, circa 2008, leaving you looking at a building site for a half a decade.
I'd only buy rurally if I could afford to buy a decent wedge of land too.
I'd try to sell now before it starts.

dottiedodah · 18/05/2022 11:26

YANBU to sell .However at present the Govt/local Councils are having a ball! Building everywhere.There is a beautiful green space nearby .We go through it when we go to the next town .Now to be completely filled with New Detached homes, (This is Green Belt land too) will completely spoil the area <Also no plans for affordable housing! Unless you own an Island there are no guarantees here

Puzzledandpissedoff · 18/05/2022 10:26

So do future buyers have to be informed? Planning permission has not been applied for and I only know because people in the village are talking about it

Unless it's just a village rumour the use of the land will be in the council's "local plan", and since this is a public document there's no way it won't be discovered if buyers and their solicitors use due diligence

Like PPs I wonder if this was already slated when you bought the house, but it's why I'd hesitate to buy a place with large tracts of open land close by if there's a chance it could be built on

MimiSunshine · 18/05/2022 10:24

Yorkie88 · 18/05/2022 09:56

You lot are very helpful. Mostly.

Basically we would have to downsize massively because we don't have anymore money and our current house is big, tad run down but very pretty and big and surrounded by fields. Hahaha.

So hard to get excited about the kids needing to share bedrooms, no space for me to work from home etc but trying to be sensible and get out before it turns into a building site. There is already flooding and road issues and cars parked all over the pavements etc.

It seems a bit mad to be thinking about all this during cost of living and I have pre school age kids so would really rather not to do this at all but otherwise will just sit back and watch our house value plummet? Maybe that's already happened though as seems concensus buyers will find out about all the proposals even if planning application hasn't been made yet

It seems completely mad to try and sell now to basically be entirely worse off actually in the home you buy just to avoid living next to a potential development.

your house isnt going to plument in value just because some new houses get built but what you may find is that any house you buy now is at a peak price and should a big recession hit then you’ll have lost a lot of money.

also if it is a big development then issues around doctors surgeries and school places etc have to be addressed. Get involved in the planning aspect and put your comments forward when the time comes.

ok so the location may end up not being what you bought into but I honestly don’t think it’ll be as bad as you fear and personally I don’t think now is the time to rush to sell.