Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that Sally Rooney and her mates must be really bloody boring company? NO SPOILERS PLEASE

111 replies

PorkySisyphus · 18/05/2022 06:32

Am currently 10 eps into Coversations With Friends.

How are all of her characters so interminably navel-gazey, muttery and downright boring? Her lead females especially. Jesus, this new one is the drippiest drip that ever dripped.

And the love interest? Eurgh. All the charisma of a lumpy bowl of yesterday's porridge. He also looks like Zach from Gilmore Girls if he were a try hard actor (emphasis on the or) which is tickling me every time he comes on screen.

I'm Irish. I'm not young and have zero experience of Dublin uni life. If these shows are reflective of it then I'm pretty glad about that.

QUB circa 1999 was much better craic with actual parties and fun and people not living in phone-glued-to-hand, frumpy jumper clad perma-misery over their own shitty relationship choices.

Its all so bloody draining and avoidable.

I know I can just not watch but I'm sick and need distraction.

Also it's my birthday but I can't eat. Please send virtual cake.

OP posts:
Sparklingbrook · 22/05/2022 16:02

I have just been to lunch with a friend. I asked if she had seen NP or CWF. She asked me what were they about. Having listened to my summaries on both she didn't seem keen. I said I'd like her to watch to see if she agreed so she's tentatively going to watch the first episode of NP. Grin

darisdet · 22/05/2022 15:50

There's definitely something emperor's new clothes about Conversations with Friends, so I'm glad of this thread and that it's not just me.

TV Bobbie talked of Frances' silence being interpreted as mysterious. I thought she was just extremely socially awkward with nothing much to say. The dialogue! Harsh? Such bland, bored characters, too.

EarringsandLipstick · 22/05/2022 13:27

I’m relieved to hear everyone else feels the same way about SR

Not everyone! As with life in general.

Boood · 22/05/2022 12:48

I’m relieved to hear everyone else feels the same way about SR, I thought I was missing some subtlety that made all that tedious waffle about unpleasant people incredibly insightful. I suppose I should give her credit for boring and irritating me enough that I really wanted to tell her I was bored and irritated.

pixie5121 · 22/05/2022 12:43

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

Sparklingbrook · 22/05/2022 11:41

Momicrone · 22/05/2022 11:27

The book was soooo boring, just don't understand this sally Rooney hysteria

Me neither. I’ve another to read but not sure I can be bothered if it’s more bleakness and angst amongst students. 🥱

EarringsandLipstick · 22/05/2022 11:37

bakey9 · 19/05/2022 12:49

I went to QUB in the 2000s and my best friend went to Trinity. We both think it's quite an accurate depiction of Trinity life, the dinner parties, the conversations, even down to the clothing (lots of rich kids in thrifted jumpers). I like normal people, wasn't fussed on cwf. The shots of dublin then suddenly they're in established or general merchants in belfast is very distracting too.

I agree. It's a very accurate depiction of a certain part of Trinity - definitely not all.

Haven't started watching CWF yet; loved both books in the sense of her writing - I thought it was amazing. Hated the characters! Which made the reading experience more interesting, for me.

I loved Normal People the TV series but the characters were much more relatable & attractive than in the book.

Lenny Abrahamsom is utterly gifted & part of my enjoyment of watching the series is his talent & craft.

And YY re the point that Rooney is not anti-Semitic & it is unforgivable to bandy that term around casually.

Momicrone · 22/05/2022 11:27

The book was soooo boring, just don't understand this sally Rooney hysteria

Snoopsnoggysnog · 22/05/2022 11:24

I agree, I’ve read all the reviews of CWF in the papers this weekend and it sounds shite.

found NP the book SO boring. The TV version was better but that was probably due to lockdown.

darisdet · 22/05/2022 11:13

I read the book and it was dreary.
I've just started watching the series and think it should be renamed Awkward Conversations.

frogswimming · 19/05/2022 13:43

Yeah. So DREARY.

givethatWolfAbanana · 19/05/2022 13:15

Oh I will check it out

Enjoyed the book, and liked the tv version of NP which was very true to the book I thought

bakey9 · 19/05/2022 12:49

I went to QUB in the 2000s and my best friend went to Trinity. We both think it's quite an accurate depiction of Trinity life, the dinner parties, the conversations, even down to the clothing (lots of rich kids in thrifted jumpers). I like normal people, wasn't fussed on cwf. The shots of dublin then suddenly they're in established or general merchants in belfast is very distracting too.

Sparklingbrook · 19/05/2022 12:35

Frances was pure Marianne at points. Nick marginally better than Connell though, he said actual words much more.

Bit off topic but I saw an article about NP's Paul Mescal the other day. He's sporting quite an unattractive 'tache and going to yoga with Phoebe Bridgers his gf/fiancee depending on what you read. He was set for great things, but not sure what happened to the films etc.

ArabeI · 19/05/2022 12:31

"How are all of her characters so interminably navel-gazey, muttery and downright boring? Her lead females especially. Jesus, this new one is the drippiest drip that ever dripped."

They really are, OP!

thisplaceisweird · 19/05/2022 12:28

Elsiebear90 · 18/05/2022 14:24

Okay 🙄

I thought someone interested in reading would want to know!

Sparklingbrook · 19/05/2022 10:20

RoseLunarPink · 19/05/2022 10:09

Well in book publishing, the winning formula is always a thing of mystery. Who would have thought screeds of excruciating, unbelievably badly written BDSM soft porn would suddenly be a massive bestseller for example. Countless bestsellers are terrible and mystifying. Then because they were bestsellers, they start a trend and loads of other people write like that for a few years.

Yes, there's some proper awful stuff out there, and people love it. Weird.

Curioushorse · 19/05/2022 10:19

Ha ha. I do love her books, but I also always wonder about her friendships. In Beautiful World it actually ramps up the discussions because main character and her friend have loads of email discussions- and l cannot imagine anybody I know having the patience for those deep philosophical chats. The craic is weak.

@PorkySisyphus I was also at QUB in 1999, and the level of mad sarcasm and wild banter I'd have got if I'd even started into some sort of deep chat would have been hilarious. My friends would still be taking the piss out of me now.

RoseLunarPink · 19/05/2022 10:09

Well in book publishing, the winning formula is always a thing of mystery. Who would have thought screeds of excruciating, unbelievably badly written BDSM soft porn would suddenly be a massive bestseller for example. Countless bestsellers are terrible and mystifying. Then because they were bestsellers, they start a trend and loads of other people write like that for a few years.

JeremyPine · 19/05/2022 10:06

I agree the books are shit. I like the TV shows for all the sex as it brightens up my own middle aged dull and mundane life. However only on iplayer so I can fast forward over the boring bits.

Sparklingbrook · 19/05/2022 09:57

Who would have thought a winning formula would consist of two unlikely stories with Hmm endings ,about deeply unlikeable characters from dysfunctional families that seem troubled and depressed the whole time.
Chuck in Trinity College and a trip abroad for no apparent reason. Grin

Ownedbymycats · 19/05/2022 09:22

Amor Towles covers decades of the minutiae of a man in captivity in' A Gentleman in Moscow'.
The slow pace of the book is actually elegiac and beautiful.
Life's too short for reading books you don't enjoy and I can't say I'll read any more Rooney novels but all credit to her for hitting on some sort of winning formula in terms of literary popularity.

RoseLunarPink · 19/05/2022 08:26

Writing about people with dull or mundane lives can be a literary thing and can be done amazingly well. There are short stories by Alice Munro that are about minutiae of someone’s dull life that are things of beauty and brilliant writing. And there are novels about mundanity, loneliness and the boredom of life, but they are exploring that deliberately.

I thought the article linked to earlier was interesting as it does suggest she has a deliberate agenda and is writing like this for a reason, rather than just being an accidentally bad, dull chick lit writer or similar. But the writing does seem hard to get through, now I’ve looked at some extracts. And the navel-gazing might be a symptom of the time, so if you’re under 30 or so it seems normal and if you’re older it grates on you (as a generalisation).

Tillsforthrills · 18/05/2022 20:24

siucra · 18/05/2022 07:34

I think calling someone an anti-Semite is a bit foolish. She just doesn’t support Israel’s treatment of Palestinian people. It’s a political stance not a hatred of an entire people. We need to be careful with language.

This!

Ownedbymycats · 18/05/2022 20:16

Maybe life is bland and boring but that's definitely how I find her books.I'm not sure why liking or not liking her books is so contentious.