Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that Sally Rooney and her mates must be really bloody boring company? NO SPOILERS PLEASE

111 replies

PorkySisyphus · 18/05/2022 06:32

Am currently 10 eps into Coversations With Friends.

How are all of her characters so interminably navel-gazey, muttery and downright boring? Her lead females especially. Jesus, this new one is the drippiest drip that ever dripped.

And the love interest? Eurgh. All the charisma of a lumpy bowl of yesterday's porridge. He also looks like Zach from Gilmore Girls if he were a try hard actor (emphasis on the or) which is tickling me every time he comes on screen.

I'm Irish. I'm not young and have zero experience of Dublin uni life. If these shows are reflective of it then I'm pretty glad about that.

QUB circa 1999 was much better craic with actual parties and fun and people not living in phone-glued-to-hand, frumpy jumper clad perma-misery over their own shitty relationship choices.

Its all so bloody draining and avoidable.

I know I can just not watch but I'm sick and need distraction.

Also it's my birthday but I can't eat. Please send virtual cake.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EarringsandLipstick · 23/05/2022 07:30

Sparklingbrook · 23/05/2022 06:16

I disagree about Marianne & her looks.

Absolutely she is taken as plain in the early part of the book, and importantly, sees herself as such.

And yet even in the early part of the tv show she is anything but plain. Especially when she goes to the club. Making the glow up at Uni less of an impact.

Well she's not amazing - she's naturally pretty sure but I think that was needed for the screen - it's not that Marianne is unattractive per se in the book. It's the perception of her - by herself and others.

In the screen adaptation, she stands out against the accepted attractiveness of Rachel et al, eg when she arrives in the rain & when she spills yogurt on herself.

I agree Daisy E-J is beautiful regardless!

Sparklingbrook · 23/05/2022 06:16

I disagree about Marianne & her looks.

Absolutely she is taken as plain in the early part of the book, and importantly, sees herself as such.

And yet even in the early part of the tv show she is anything but plain. Especially when she goes to the club. Making the glow up at Uni less of an impact.

darisdet · 23/05/2022 01:37

I'm going to have a look at some of these recommendations for alternative reading.

I confess that I was initially puzzled watching the Conversations with Friends and wondered why they'd started it from a different time point. I was confusing it with Beautiful World! There are some similarities between the novels and characters, in my opinion.

EarringsandLipstick · 23/05/2022 00:59

I watched Episode 1 of CWF tonight.

I can see why some would hate it. I found it dream-like, beautifully shot & delicate. Frances is pure annoying tho, which I love!

EarringsandLipstick · 23/05/2022 00:58

I disagree about Marianne & her looks.

Absolutely she is taken as plain in the early part of the book, and importantly, sees herself as such.

But when she gets to Trinity she perceives herself & is perceived, very differently.

I think that's captured well on screen.

But for me they make two quite unlikeable characters highly appealing on screen, and they weren't in the book.

Even little details - in the book when Marianne meets Connell in her house, at the beginning, she's eating Nutella from the jar, and offers him some! In the TV series, she's eating ice cream. Small detail but big difference.

Abitofalark · 23/05/2022 00:15

The Irish Times has put together a collection of articles, some by Rooney herself and some by reviewers and others which give some insights for anyone wondering about her life, her ideas, the writing and of course, the books.

www.irishtimes.com/culture/books/sally-rooney-a-profile-of-the-author-in-28-articles-from-the-irish-times-archive-1.4659814

There's useful short extract from each which gives a flavour without having to read the whole article.

CallMeMabel · 22/05/2022 19:47

I wouldn't recommend Anne Enright, I hated The Gathering. I preferred Naoise Dolan's Exciting Times to SR, but it's also a bit shallow and unlikely.

CampervanKween · 22/05/2022 18:40

Totally agree op. My mis-spent youth at University was a blast. Youth very much wasted on the current batch.

Abhannmor · 22/05/2022 18:38

Sparklingbrook · 22/05/2022 17:58

Yes, the descriptions of Marianne in the book were definitely not someone that looked like Daisy Edgar-Jones, who was actually stunning.
They changed a few things from the book for no apparent reason.

Part of the appeal for Irish viewers was an English actress doing a damn good Irish accent. Not a fan of Enright either , though she is a good critic. Claire Keegan , William Wall. And Kevin Barry is just amazing.

HollowTalk · 22/05/2022 18:36

I can't remember whether it was normal people or conversations with friends which ended so suddenly that I was about to write to Amazon to ask them if there was any way an e-book could be sold to customers without the final pages. It's a miracle I got as far as the end actually.

pixie5121 · 22/05/2022 18:33

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

Vermetastic · 22/05/2022 18:07

I tried listening to an audio version of CWF a few times but gave up. I’ve watched a few episodes but so boring. I liked NP but what befuddled me about it was that the male lead was studying English but could barely string a sentence together.
Give me Thursday nights at QUB anytime if this is what life at Trinity is like.

Sparklingbrook · 22/05/2022 17:58

Yes, the descriptions of Marianne in the book were definitely not someone that looked like Daisy Edgar-Jones, who was actually stunning.
They changed a few things from the book for no apparent reason.

IcedPurple · 22/05/2022 17:47

SooopDragon · 22/05/2022 17:39

I quite enjoyed Normal People but maybe that was all the sex and Paul Mescal’s willy. I just get the impression that all Sally Rooney books are (VERY) thinly veiled autobiographies. I mean, come on, how about coming up with some characters who haven’t had the exact same life as you? I also really didn’t like the token fat friend in Normal People - who of course is the one who does the cooking while tiny skinny Marianne wafts around, skinnily

Also, wasn't Marianne meant to be quite plain in the book? As in, all the kids were in disbelief that school hunk Connell would be with someone so unworthy? But of course they have to cast a very pretty actress. I guess it's an example of that joke in The Simpsons about being 'TV ugly, not ugly ugly'.

EarringsandLipstick · 22/05/2022 17:40

If you want to read amazing literature by an Irish novelist, you should read Anne Enright,

I'm mixed about Anne Enright. I like her non-fiction / essays. Less so her literature. I find her characters unbelievable.

Emilie Pine is my recommendation - her memoir is amazing and very raw; she has a novel out now which I can recommend (Ruth & Pen)

SooopDragon · 22/05/2022 17:39

I quite enjoyed Normal People but maybe that was all the sex and Paul Mescal’s willy. I just get the impression that all Sally Rooney books are (VERY) thinly veiled autobiographies. I mean, come on, how about coming up with some characters who haven’t had the exact same life as you? I also really didn’t like the token fat friend in Normal People - who of course is the one who does the cooking while tiny skinny Marianne wafts around, skinnily

Lesperance · 22/05/2022 17:31

I haven't seen the TV series of CWF but I didn't like Conversations with Friends or Normal People. I didn't finish watching NP. Neither of them had interesting characters, except perhaps the mother in Normal People. Maybe some day Sally Rooney will write a whole book from that character's perspective. If you want to read amazing literature by an Irish novelist, you should read Anne Enright, if you want to read great literature about ordinary every day people and their lives, you should read Anne Tyler. I won't be reading any more Sally Rooney for a while.

Sparklingbrook · 22/05/2022 17:25

I agree that the popularity TV adaptation of NP was helped enormously by the lockdown.

IcedPurple · 22/05/2022 17:15

Attictroll · 18/05/2022 07:27

Read both and vaguely enjoyed them but nothing amazing. The young people at work raved about the tv version of normal people but yams it wasn't radically sexy or profound. Quite sweet but basically Dawsons Creek with a bit of sex. May dip into conversations with friends but only if I run out of other stuff to watch 😊

I think the reason that 'Normal People' became such a huge hit was lockdown.

People were bored and lonely and had nothing to do, so it became a talking point. Same thing that made Joe Exotic into an international superstar. If either series had been released at any other time, they'd have attracted much less attention.

Agree that 'Normal People' was pretty average. I also found the characters dull, whiny and incredibly self absorbed. Many times I asked myself why I should care about them and their boring love lives, but with there being nothing else to do, I persevered with it. Is that what the yung uns are like these days?

EarringsandLipstick · 22/05/2022 17:09

I suspect another reason she's so hyped is that she's Irish. The British left, which dominates the BBC, publishing and the arts, has got a real thing about Ireland – a weird post-colonial guilt. Because of that, anything Irish tends to get over-praised and over-promoted.

Bollocks!

There are many fine artists - writers, filmmakers, actors and so on - in Ireland. We possibly over-hype it ourselves, and certainly don't support the arts as much as we should (viz: many Irish-created films/programmes getting commissioned by UK TV)

But it's not 'because she's Irish'. It's because she has a fresh innovative style & spoke about an aspect of Irish life & society that hadn't at that point been well-described.

Not everyone likes her - that's fine too.

DorritLittle · 22/05/2022 17:08

I thought I was missing some subtlety that made all that tedious waffle about unpleasant people incredibly insightful

Me too.

Pennox · 22/05/2022 17:07

I quite liked Normal People but I honestly bcant believe how boring CWF was. I've only seen the TV shows, can only hope that the book was better.

Badger1970 · 22/05/2022 17:04

I finished the series this morning.

I'm not sure whether I enjoyed it or not tbh......... they were all so dreary and so full of angst.

And I don't know if they were all horribly mis-cast or if it was deliberate.

Kris02 · 22/05/2022 16:44

She's massively overhyped. Don't get me wrong, she's a good writer. But that's all – a good writer, nothing special. Fifty years from now she'll be forgotten.

I suspect another reason she's so hyped is that she's Irish. The British left, which dominates the BBC, publishing and the arts, has got a real thing about Ireland – a weird post-colonial guilt. Because of that, anything Irish tends to get over-praised and over-promoted. No way would she be so popular if she was an Oxford-educated English girl with a posh accent. On the contrary, The Guardian would be tearing her to shreds.

Snoopsnoggysnog · 22/05/2022 16:28

darisdet · 22/05/2022 15:50

There's definitely something emperor's new clothes about Conversations with Friends, so I'm glad of this thread and that it's not just me.

TV Bobbie talked of Frances' silence being interpreted as mysterious. I thought she was just extremely socially awkward with nothing much to say. The dialogue! Harsh? Such bland, bored characters, too.

Yeah I thought this about NP too!