Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

renationalisation of energy?

38 replies

Passenger69 · 18/05/2022 06:26

Would you like to see the renationalisation of energy. We are in a crisis but all I see is a tinkering around the edges.....all I hear from Labour is a windfall tax and cutting vat ....a "refund" of 150 from the tories....

I would like to see energy renationalised with proper long term cross party strategy to protect people who need it and include a workable strategy for green energy.

AIBU?

OP posts:
perenniallymessy · 18/05/2022 10:25

Daftasabroom · 18/05/2022 08:20

There's nothing unreliable about renewables if the energy is stored or converted when there's an excess. Nuclear will play a role but it is too expensive to be the main source.

Completely agree.

We are looking to get solar panels and battery storage, but we are incredibly fortunate that we are able to do that.

More people need to be supported to get panels and batteries, just removing VAT is not enough. Even in homes where they cannot put solar panels we could add batteries to help smooth out demand.

Plus reverse the planning rules that have effectively stopped new onshore wind farms, as that is the cheapest form of energy at present (and I don't know about you but I'd rather look at a windfarm any day rather than a nuclear energy plant).

We also need to reduce our energy use by insulating our homes properly. The more expensive energy gets, the less the payback period is. There was a great article in The Times from the Octopus Energy boss acknowledging that lots of homes will be difficult to upgrade, but we need to go for the low hanging fruit first and upgrade the homes that are easiest to insulate (so 1970s onwards). No point complaining and saying we can't do all homes so doing none!

Tanith · 18/05/2022 10:20

According to Wikipaedia: “The Gas Light and Coke Company was the first public utility company in the world. It was founded by Frederick Albert Winsor and incorporated by Royal Charter on 30 April 1812 under the seal of King George III.”

That was the fore-runner for British Gas, so I don’t know why a pp thinks it’s “70’s playbook” stuff. It seems the state managed to run public utility companies for over 150 years pre-privatisation.

perenniallymessy · 18/05/2022 10:15

I'm not in favour of nationalisation (would be horrendously expensive for one thing so would no doubt increase costs), however I do feel there should be additional taxes on profits from selling oil and gas (all the time, not just a one off windfall tax), that could be offset with super tax reliefs for any money they spend investing in green technologies and/or supporting customers with bills and insulation. That way there's still an incentive to invest in new technologies and produce green energy

The extra taxes raised could support the cost of bills, insulate homes and be used to invest in new green technologies.

With new smart technologies then batteries and/or thermal batteries can be charged up when there is an excess of energy in the grid, then discharged when less energy is being produced and/or demand is higher. As we move to electric cars, then they can be used as energy stores too (with an override where people know they have a long journey coming up).

DdraigGoch · 18/05/2022 10:01

I wouldn't trust the state to run a bath, let alone supply the gas to heat it.

YouHaventDoneAnyWork · 18/05/2022 08:46

*quo

YouHaventDoneAnyWork · 18/05/2022 08:46

@sst1234

Snarky much? That’s why I said public-private-partnership as whilst the current govt might not be trusted are you actually suggested fat cat utilities firms have the best interest of the public front and centre of their policies and the status who is acceptable.

And I thought this wasn’t my specialist subject. Seems like it’s not yours either.

Daftasabroom · 18/05/2022 08:20

There's nothing unreliable about renewables if the energy is stored or converted when there's an excess. Nuclear will play a role but it is too expensive to be the main source.

Roominmyhouse · 18/05/2022 08:04

Bluebruin · 18/05/2022 08:01

What we need is a whole load of new nuclear power stations because renewables are too little & too unreliable. Plus loads of research into new methods.

Yep. Clean nuclear power is the way forward.

sst1234 · 18/05/2022 08:02

YouHaventDoneAnyWork · 18/05/2022 06:35

It’s not a topic I know a lot about but philosophically I think all natural resources should be owned by government. It’s nuts to me the highest bidder would come along and buy all the oil/gas/whatever and then make HUGE profits. Utility companies should then have some sort of public-private-partnership to manage the service with caps on profit.

Oh dear, we really have learnt nothing, have we, about the mess governments ALWAYS make when they try and run anything. Funny really, how we don’t trust the govt to run supermarkets. Because intrinsically we know that country would starve.

Bluebruin · 18/05/2022 08:01

What we need is a whole load of new nuclear power stations because renewables are too little & too unreliable. Plus loads of research into new methods.

sst1234 · 18/05/2022 07:59

is re nationalisation that most innovative thing we can think of? Sounds the most lazy and taken straight from 1970s handbook. If the government ran energy companies, you can expect blackouts. Governments are always worse at running things than private companies. Be careful what you wish for.
The problem with energy prices in this country, as with most things, is that everyone want cheap energy but no one wants the infrastructure in their backyard. NIMBYISM and faux virtue signalling around the environment has cause this this mess.
A couple of examples - Fracking which has been hugely successful in the US with no notable risk of earth tremors is opposed by ‘activists’. I use the term loosely as people like this wouldn’t know activity if it hit them in the face. They usually produce nothing and are recipient of other fruits of other people’s work and innovations.
Ok then, you don’t like carbon, let’s build nuclear. Here come the ‘activists’ against nuclear power because it’s not safe apparently because they once heard about Chernobyl and Fukushima on the news, they they probably could point these places out on a map.
Fine, you don’t want renewables. Let’s build an offshore wind farm in one of the best spots in Europe for this sort of initiative - off the Shetlands isles. ‘Activists’ appear to oppose this too. I kid you not, on Radio 4 recently an activists was arguing with the local MP that this would be aesthetically ugly.
Conclusion - we are a nation with too many ‘little islanders’ who want to protest and shave mo interest in getting things done. Opposing everything, solving nothing. So no, nationalizing energy wouldn’t help. You have to deal with the people blocking production to bring down prices.

tothemoonandbackbuses · 18/05/2022 06:40

I think given the changes ofgem are making to the price cap and the protection they are going to give energy companies to protect them against switchers there’s no point in it being a free market any more. If we can’t shop around for the best deal it should be government run then at least the profits will be used wisely (well maybe not with this government)

YouHaventDoneAnyWork · 18/05/2022 06:35

It’s not a topic I know a lot about but philosophically I think all natural resources should be owned by government. It’s nuts to me the highest bidder would come along and buy all the oil/gas/whatever and then make HUGE profits. Utility companies should then have some sort of public-private-partnership to manage the service with caps on profit.