Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

renationalisation of energy?

38 replies

Passenger69 · 18/05/2022 06:26

Would you like to see the renationalisation of energy. We are in a crisis but all I see is a tinkering around the edges.....all I hear from Labour is a windfall tax and cutting vat ....a "refund" of 150 from the tories....

I would like to see energy renationalised with proper long term cross party strategy to protect people who need it and include a workable strategy for green energy.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Antarcticant · 19/05/2022 00:25

Don't tell Sid.

Yazo · 19/05/2022 00:10

Plenty of other countries have decent state run infrastructure, in fact plenty also operate here and we don't even think about it. If people can't switch suppliers, can't change their tariffs then yes I think they should be nationalised. As a customer never been so pissed off to be bound to my current and increasingly annoying energy provider spamming me all the time and putting my bills up constantly despite me being hundreds of pounds in credit.

DdraigGoch · 19/05/2022 00:05

EsmaCannonball · 18/05/2022 22:36

Privatisation producing competitive prices for consumers only works if the goods and services being provided are non-essential. If the good and services provided are essential then the private companies act like cartels, raising their prices together and knowing they are guaranteed to make a profit because the consumer has no alternative but to go somewhere. Can you imagine how much private health companies and insurers would hike their prices if the NHS didn't exist as an alternative?

Utilities need to be renationalised and run on a not-for-profit basis. 'Efficiency' when it comes to private companies mainly translates as rubbish wages and precarious employment. Secure, decently paid jobs in an essential sector would actually be good for the economy. We're currently seeing utility companies making record profits while hiking their prices, providing a poor service, employing people with crappy pay and conditions but simultaneously claiming that price rises are inevitable and completely beyond their control. It's a total lie.

When wholesale prices rose, many of the smaller energy suppliers went bust. They'd driven margins so tight that there was no room for price rises. They hadn't even hedged their prices like the larger suppliers had, to insure against the wholesale price changing.

Again, the money is being made by the multinationals responsible for drilling for these fossil fuels in the first place. Blowing a load of money nationalising Scottish Power, EDF et al won't make the slightest difference.

If even Labour haven't suggested nationalisation, that tells you that it's a really daft idea.

DdraigGoch · 18/05/2022 23:57

YouHaventDoneAnyWork · 18/05/2022 22:04

ResentfulLemon · 18/05/2022 14:58
DdraigGoch
MayorDusty
Why is Private sector always the answer instead of demanding efficiency in public sector?
Instead of dismissing nationalisation because we're looking at bad application shouldn't part of the solution be how to do public better?
Well sort out the existing public sector to show how it could run things well before trying to take on something new.
Couldn't agree more!

Just one example of a competent and efficient government run essential service would be a great start.

But that is a bollocks argument that goes both ways. Give just one example of a private utility company that is in the best interest of the public. Polar views don’t work.

I've found Octopus to be quite good, actually.

Actually none of the distributors are that bad, they're not the ones creaming off the profits at the moment - that would be the oil giants like Shell. Nationalising the UK suppliers won't make one bit of difference to that, you'd still have to buy gas at the market rate, a rate which has risen mainly due to the scramble to wean Europe off of Russian fossil fuels.

Gilead · 18/05/2022 23:02

Tory bots. Inflation is running at 9.1%.
Tell me how great this government is at economics.

EsmaCannonball · 18/05/2022 22:36

Privatisation producing competitive prices for consumers only works if the goods and services being provided are non-essential. If the good and services provided are essential then the private companies act like cartels, raising their prices together and knowing they are guaranteed to make a profit because the consumer has no alternative but to go somewhere. Can you imagine how much private health companies and insurers would hike their prices if the NHS didn't exist as an alternative?

Utilities need to be renationalised and run on a not-for-profit basis. 'Efficiency' when it comes to private companies mainly translates as rubbish wages and precarious employment. Secure, decently paid jobs in an essential sector would actually be good for the economy. We're currently seeing utility companies making record profits while hiking their prices, providing a poor service, employing people with crappy pay and conditions but simultaneously claiming that price rises are inevitable and completely beyond their control. It's a total lie.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 18/05/2022 22:34

Instead of dismissing nationalisation because we're looking at bad application shouldn't part of the solution be how to do public better?

That's an excellent idea in theory, but AFAIK nobody's ever found a way of doing it ... which is at least part of the reason utilities were privatised in the first place

underneaththeash · 18/05/2022 22:06

Name one way to make energy less efficient:

YouHaventDoneAnyWork · 18/05/2022 22:04

ResentfulLemon · 18/05/2022 14:58
DdraigGoch
MayorDusty
Why is Private sector always the answer instead of demanding efficiency in public sector?
Instead of dismissing nationalisation because we're looking at bad application shouldn't part of the solution be how to do public better?
Well sort out the existing public sector to show how it could run things well before trying to take on something new.
Couldn't agree more!

Just one example of a competent and efficient government run essential service would be a great start.

But that is a bollocks argument that goes both ways. Give just one example of a private utility company that is in the best interest of the public. Polar views don’t work.

MayorDusty · 18/05/2022 16:35

I feel that pain.
Our dept sometimes has to work with Capita and G4S if people knew how inept and often dangerous they were they'd be shocked. I honestly feel sick sometimes if they're involved.
They're very cheap though.

DdraigGoch · 18/05/2022 16:08

MayorDusty · 18/05/2022 14:59

I wish I had that answer @DdraigGoch I'd be shouting from the rooftops!
I actually work in a dark, murky, almost obsolete corner of the public sector but we are tightly managed with a small CoC and don't replace when people leave.
I think because we are winding down as tech becomes the sensible option we haven't suffered from management bloat or inefficiency.
I wonder why we overlook the failings of public sector though and worry about solution always being privatise.
I see the U.S. and wonder why we aren't put off by the rush to more privatisation.

I work on the railways. Under BR the railways were supposedly nationalised, but in practice the Treasury just handed over its annual grant and left BR's managers to get on with it. By the late '80s/early '90s there were some effective managers about who really did try to run it as a business and encourage growth in demand.

Then it was privatised. In theory. In practice the government started meddling in a way that they never had done under BR. Chris Green (an ex-BR manager) submitted a request to the Strategic Rail Authority to expand the order for new trains on Virgin Cross Country and was told "no", hence why overcrowding is awful on that route even to this day, with prices hiked on the orders of the government to try and keep a lid on demand.

First Great Western and GNER recognised that there would be a need to replace the 1970s HST fleet. They got together with Siemens and created a design for a replacement. The Department for Transport decided that such a project was too big for the private sector and took it over, eventually awarding contracts to Hitachi at exorbitant sums for trains which would be delivered years after the original plan would have been completed. Hitachi laugh all the way to the bank every time a contract variation is needed, the DfT has no scope for redress, thanks to the incompetent idiot in the Civil Service who wrote the original contracts.

It has got worse since covid, with every expense of over £500 having to be submitted to the DfT for approval, costing far more than that £500 in management time as the DfT seem to want a new format for the spreadsheets each week. Meanwhile trains end up parked in sidings awaiting cost approval for a new motor for the disabled toilet door.

Sir Humphrey would have been proud of the mess.

FreddyVoorhees · 18/05/2022 15:36

Have Labour actually said how they'd distribute this "windfall" or is it just the usual "nasty big company/tax the rich" rhetoric to show they're so the party of the poor people?

How would nationalisation work? Would we also buy out OPEC to stop them controlling the price of oil? How would the government take ownership of these companies? Take over? Compulsory purchase? And where the hell is that money coming from?

It's basically a massive non starter.

MayorDusty · 18/05/2022 14:59

I wish I had that answer @DdraigGoch I'd be shouting from the rooftops!
I actually work in a dark, murky, almost obsolete corner of the public sector but we are tightly managed with a small CoC and don't replace when people leave.
I think because we are winding down as tech becomes the sensible option we haven't suffered from management bloat or inefficiency.
I wonder why we overlook the failings of public sector though and worry about solution always being privatise.
I see the U.S. and wonder why we aren't put off by the rush to more privatisation.

ResentfulLemon · 18/05/2022 14:58

DdraigGoch · 18/05/2022 13:13

Well sort out the existing public sector to show how it could run things well before trying to take on something new.

Couldn't agree more!

Just one example of a competent and efficient government run essential service would be a great start.

DdraigGoch · 18/05/2022 14:53

UK wholesale energy prices have been starting to drop, with day ahead gas prices down at £120/MWh compared to £190/MWh in the EU. This means that we can also generate electricity cheaply.

I'm on an Octopus Agile tariff so notice any change in wholesale electricity prices (I get billed by the half-hour), my bills have been considerably lower over the last couple of weeks than they were a few months ago.

www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2022/05/18/uk-energy-exports-europe-hit-record-levels/

DdraigGoch · 18/05/2022 13:13

MayorDusty · 18/05/2022 12:58

Why is Private sector always the answer instead of demanding efficiency in public sector?
Instead of dismissing nationalisation because we're looking at bad application shouldn't part of the solution be how to do public better?

Well sort out the existing public sector to show how it could run things well before trying to take on something new.

jcyclops · 18/05/2022 13:08

The ONLY thing a government can do better than private industry is borrow money cheaply.

MayorDusty · 18/05/2022 12:58

Why is Private sector always the answer instead of demanding efficiency in public sector?
Instead of dismissing nationalisation because we're looking at bad application shouldn't part of the solution be how to do public better?

ResentfulLemon · 18/05/2022 12:49

JustAnotherPoster00 · 18/05/2022 11:06

Is that the magic money tree that the right always bring up yet always seem to strip those leaves with nary a comment when it comes to bribing other political parties so they can stay in power, for ferry contracts with a company that had no ferry's, for a non functioning track amd trace system and never mind all the dodgy ppe contracts, that magic money tree?

It would cost billions...and that's just to sort out the initial mess. Ongoing necessary investment would be further billions which can only be raised via taxes or pricing. There is no economical basis for re-nationalising energy without substantial cost increases.

Plus, the bit that most are consistently missing is this is not a downstream problem (aka suppliers) but an upstream one. They are the ones setting the prices of gas, largely from other countries too - how the fuck nationalising suppliers when we still have to buy gas from Bob in Dubai to burn in power stations will decrease costs for the end consumer I'd love to know.

As others have pointed out, the only way to fix this situation is to make all of our electricity home nation generated, either through nuclear or green energy. Ending reliance on gas for power stations is the only way to control and properly stablise the home market.

Nationalising and increasing the nuclear infrastructure would be a more sensible suggestion given that all of ours is foreign owned, thankfully there are steps towards this now with British investors being preferred for future nuclear capability. In the meantime it's best not to upset France or China.

Notbluepeter · 18/05/2022 12:47

I agree a windfall tax would achieve nothing. Shell, BP etc. pay taxes in boom years but later get it all refunded by utilising carried forward losses, or tax refunds related to the decommissioning of old oil platforms. It means that rather than paying tax on its upstream operations, shell actually received a refund of $121mn last year.

JustAnotherPoster00 · 18/05/2022 11:06

ResentfulLemon · 18/05/2022 10:51

Take a look at some of our essential services run by government...
Passports
Driving licences
HMRC

Do you honestly expect a government run agency to be run more efficiently and effectively than the current private companies? Honestly? We'd have rolling blackouts within a month of the government taking over.

That aside, where's the magic money tree coming from to make this happen? Our trade agreements with other countries would implode if we took back the energy supply (EDF, Scottish Power, EON, Green Network Energy, npower, Octopus and Shell all foreign owned - these are just the suppliers) without fair compensation to the owners/shareholders. Then there's the black hole that would be created in millions of pension schemes because most of them have long term investments in utilities.

At best this is a naive idea which is why not even the Labour party have seriously touted it. At worst it's a fucking terrible idea.

Is that the magic money tree that the right always bring up yet always seem to strip those leaves with nary a comment when it comes to bribing other political parties so they can stay in power, for ferry contracts with a company that had no ferry's, for a non functioning track amd trace system and never mind all the dodgy ppe contracts, that magic money tree?

Daftasabroom · 18/05/2022 10:53

@perenniallymessy I don't expect to see much more onshore wind in the UK, planning is difficult and the wind patterns are less favourable. Offshore is already planned to expand by 500% within 10 years. Floating wind will add even more.

ResentfulLemon · 18/05/2022 10:51

Take a look at some of our essential services run by government...
Passports
Driving licences
HMRC

Do you honestly expect a government run agency to be run more efficiently and effectively than the current private companies? Honestly? We'd have rolling blackouts within a month of the government taking over.

That aside, where's the magic money tree coming from to make this happen? Our trade agreements with other countries would implode if we took back the energy supply (EDF, Scottish Power, EON, Green Network Energy, npower, Octopus and Shell all foreign owned - these are just the suppliers) without fair compensation to the owners/shareholders. Then there's the black hole that would be created in millions of pension schemes because most of them have long term investments in utilities.

At best this is a naive idea which is why not even the Labour party have seriously touted it. At worst it's a fucking terrible idea.

DdraigGoch · 18/05/2022 10:42

I don't know about you but I'd rather look at a windfarm any day rather than a nuclear energy plant

Nuclear power stations might be big ugly buildings, but you can at least look the other way, they only occupy a tiny portion of the view. Windfarms on the other hand are much more expansive. Stick them offshore.

DdraigGoch · 18/05/2022 10:38

Tanith · 18/05/2022 10:20

According to Wikipaedia: “The Gas Light and Coke Company was the first public utility company in the world. It was founded by Frederick Albert Winsor and incorporated by Royal Charter on 30 April 1812 under the seal of King George III.”

That was the fore-runner for British Gas, so I don’t know why a pp thinks it’s “70’s playbook” stuff. It seems the state managed to run public utility companies for over 150 years pre-privatisation.

Pity that you didn't read further down the Wikipedia page then. The Gas Light and Coke Company paid dividends to the holders of its 80,000 shares. It wasn't nationalised until 1949.

It was a "public" utility company in the same sense that First Group runs "public" buses - any consumer in the area they supply can pay to use their services, as opposed to a bus company supplying vehicles for private hire or distributing wholesale gas to a factory or power station.