Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disappointed that DD won’t get a surprise proposal

262 replies

Bluebellewoods · 17/05/2022 23:59

DD is 28 and has been in a relationship with her partner for around a year and a half. They’ve been living together for some time and she tells me they are very happy together. I think the thought of turning 30 in a couple of years has been a big turning point for DD as she’s expressed her desire to get married and think about having children, as she feels time is running out somewhat.

DD tells me that she has decided it’s time to have a chat with her partner about her desire to get married and discuss and agree a timescale for doing so. I can’t help but feel a little sad that in essentially orchestrating her own engagement, DD will lose out on the special surprise moment of a traditional proposal which so many young women get to experience and cherish, which I’d hate for her to miss out on due to her impatience.

DD asked me for my advice on how she should best approach the conversation and I said I’d give it some thought. What I really want to say to her is just wait, she’s still so young and has so much time! I’d understand if DD had been waiting for years, but their relationship is still relatively new and I don’t think rushing an engagement at this time and sacrificing the traditional surprise is justified. AIBU?

OP posts:
godmum56 · 19/05/2022 06:37

Yabu. Butt out.

Tandora · 18/05/2022 22:47

Knittingchamp · 18/05/2022 17:28

I honestly cannot understand why anyone would think this.

I think that giving a bloke (or woman) a timeline i.e. ultimatum to propose is controlling and also would make me feel like I was completely low balling myself. A guy/woman should feel like they'd won the bloody lottery with you, so they propose (or whatever the commitment is) and that shows they genuinely realise theyve won the bloody lottery. This is the rest of our lives after all. I'd feel like I'd devalued myself by forcing their hand and requiring a timeline, like I'd have to persuade them and coerce them rather than them looking at me and knowing, yea, she's awesome and I know it, and I'm going to make the biggest commitment out there because she/he's too good to lose.

It's completely separate from the idea of having a clear cut conversation about where the relationship is going of course. Noone should ever sit around and wait or get messed around. If you're sleeping with someone you should be comfortable enough to have honest conversations about where you both see the relationship going.

Also if your daughter wants to be the one to propose, why not? We can all exercise our agency how we want.

Huh what? You think a woman is controlling/ giving an ultimatum if she wants to have a discussion/ mutually agree a timeline? So it’s just up to the man to decide if and when to propose and a woman has to just wait/ have no input other than agree or disagree when the man has decided the time has come? And you can’t understand why someone would find that sexist or bizarre?

HowcanIhelp123 · 18/05/2022 22:40

YABU. I always have lived by the mantra that while the proposal may be a surprise, getting engaged shouldn't be. Its a partnership and the direction the relationship is going shouldn't be a surprise.

She can still have a surprise proposal, they may decide they want to get engaged between x and y dates, but the partner can still plan a beautiful surprise proposal.

oiwiththepoodlesalready83 · 18/05/2022 19:24

I remember telling my now DH that I was looking forward to having children and getting married and asked if that’s something he wanted/saw in our future. He agreed and we had an honest conversation about our relationship. Guess what….. I was still surprised 6 months later when he proposed. Your daughter is doing the right thing!

Blarting · 18/05/2022 19:02

@Baileysoncereal a wedding is a celebration with friends and family, very often including religion, definitely a legal ceremony, hardly the same is it?

Blarting · 18/05/2022 19:01

Baileysoncereal · 18/05/2022 18:55

@Blarting why is it cringe?

i don’t get the people falling all over themselves to show how practical and unromantic they are.
surely a romantic gesture is nice?
just as if he buys you flowers and says he loves you - why did he need to if you already know

most people getting married will have a wedding with some sort of ceremony and tradition. maybe that’s music, a dress, a party whatever. But the couple knew they were getting married, they’d already committed, why couldn’t they just sign the papers and leave?

the point is as a society we like tradition and ceremony and having a nice day out where someone tells you they love you doesn’t seem like something to be ashamed of to me.

Why is it cringe? Because you've already said yes by discussing and agreeing? It's just a false thing, that makes it cringe IMO!

Baileysoncereal · 18/05/2022 18:55

@Blarting why is it cringe?

i don’t get the people falling all over themselves to show how practical and unromantic they are.
surely a romantic gesture is nice?
just as if he buys you flowers and says he loves you - why did he need to if you already know

most people getting married will have a wedding with some sort of ceremony and tradition. maybe that’s music, a dress, a party whatever. But the couple knew they were getting married, they’d already committed, why couldn’t they just sign the papers and leave?

the point is as a society we like tradition and ceremony and having a nice day out where someone tells you they love you doesn’t seem like something to be ashamed of to me.

Blarting · 18/05/2022 18:37

nxy · 18/05/2022 14:52

MN is weirdly bah humbug about proposals and these kind of threads always bring out this type of poster.

Meanwhile, in the real normal world, it's perfectly possible within a couple to have a general discussion about whether marriage is something you want - along with would you want kids / how many / when; where do you see yourself living / working .... whatever. Just general conversations couples have to see if they're on the same page.

Similarly - any man in a relationship should instinctively know the type of proposal his partner would want - so he will just do that. If she's shy, he's hardly going to make a big hoopla. He'll just ask her privately.

I mean, how hard can this be?

On MN, it either gets presented as this dramatic divide between "princesses" waiting for years on end; or these very matter of fact, "I just sat him at the table" types. As if there's nothing in between!

Also, any type of proposal is assumed to be naff and cringe or "Disney" - with all sorts of doom and gloom forecasts about "the type of man who proposes."

The fact is, most men do propose in some way and it doesn't need to be a spectacle at all. It's personal!

When my husband proposed, he got down on one knee on some cliffs in Italy. It's wasn't cringe and it wasn't a scene for anyone else or Instagram or whatever. I was delighted, but it wasn't exactly total shock. Similarly, I don't think he would have asked if he thought I'd say no! Anyway, it's a lovely memory to have and we've since taken out kids to that place. What's wrong with that and why shouldn't a man make the effort?

OP, I think you're worrying about nothing. Your DD will probably just initiate a conversation about the future in general. He'll probably propose in the near future. No drama.

Oh course it wasn't a total shock. You'd already agreed? So why the "proposal"?

It's cringe!

Thepeopleversuswork · 18/05/2022 17:41

@nxy

I live in the "real world" too and the idea of having to have a ritual in which you both pretend to have no idea that marriage could be on the cards and then the woman is obliged to sit around for years, wandering past jewellers shops, circling pictures or rings in magazines etc is not part of my world.

Apparently its not part of the world of most of the posters on this thread. And yes I do think traditional proposals are beyond cringey. But this is all beside the point really. If people want to play dressing up as princesses in the run up to getting married then its a free country.

The point here is that the OP appears to prioritise this over her daughter's agency in determining her own future. And that's quite worrying.

Sandinmyknickers · 18/05/2022 17:35

If anyone ever did a big romantic proposal.putting me on the spot like that WITHOUT having discussed our future at some point beforehand and ensuring our expectations lined up etc...I'd be furious!!

And id know that they are definitely not the one for me. I think its hugely disrespectful and pretty self centered to propose to someone as a complete surprise...it's a major life decision and it's noones place to put someone on the spot to give them an immediate (and often public or pressurised) answer just like that.

Knittingchamp · 18/05/2022 17:28

Tandora · 18/05/2022 03:25

Dear Lord this has got to be a wind up? One of the most ridiculous and sexist AIBU’s of all time 🙄.

I honestly cannot understand why anyone would think this.

I think that giving a bloke (or woman) a timeline i.e. ultimatum to propose is controlling and also would make me feel like I was completely low balling myself. A guy/woman should feel like they'd won the bloody lottery with you, so they propose (or whatever the commitment is) and that shows they genuinely realise theyve won the bloody lottery. This is the rest of our lives after all. I'd feel like I'd devalued myself by forcing their hand and requiring a timeline, like I'd have to persuade them and coerce them rather than them looking at me and knowing, yea, she's awesome and I know it, and I'm going to make the biggest commitment out there because she/he's too good to lose.

It's completely separate from the idea of having a clear cut conversation about where the relationship is going of course. Noone should ever sit around and wait or get messed around. If you're sleeping with someone you should be comfortable enough to have honest conversations about where you both see the relationship going.

Also if your daughter wants to be the one to propose, why not? We can all exercise our agency how we want.

Reallyreallyborednow · 18/05/2022 17:05

What's wrong with that and why shouldn't a man make the effort?

why is not ok for a woman to make the effort though?

nxy · 18/05/2022 14:52

MN is weirdly bah humbug about proposals and these kind of threads always bring out this type of poster.

Meanwhile, in the real normal world, it's perfectly possible within a couple to have a general discussion about whether marriage is something you want - along with would you want kids / how many / when; where do you see yourself living / working .... whatever. Just general conversations couples have to see if they're on the same page.

Similarly - any man in a relationship should instinctively know the type of proposal his partner would want - so he will just do that. If she's shy, he's hardly going to make a big hoopla. He'll just ask her privately.

I mean, how hard can this be?

On MN, it either gets presented as this dramatic divide between "princesses" waiting for years on end; or these very matter of fact, "I just sat him at the table" types. As if there's nothing in between!

Also, any type of proposal is assumed to be naff and cringe or "Disney" - with all sorts of doom and gloom forecasts about "the type of man who proposes."

The fact is, most men do propose in some way and it doesn't need to be a spectacle at all. It's personal!

When my husband proposed, he got down on one knee on some cliffs in Italy. It's wasn't cringe and it wasn't a scene for anyone else or Instagram or whatever. I was delighted, but it wasn't exactly total shock. Similarly, I don't think he would have asked if he thought I'd say no! Anyway, it's a lovely memory to have and we've since taken out kids to that place. What's wrong with that and why shouldn't a man make the effort?

OP, I think you're worrying about nothing. Your DD will probably just initiate a conversation about the future in general. He'll probably propose in the near future. No drama.

Butteryflakycrust83 · 18/05/2022 14:23

You are totally valid to feel how you feel, but engagements are largely horseshit. Its the assumption that the woman is just waiting around to be asked, when the man is FINALLY ready to commit.

It sounds like two very grown up adults secure in their relationship are discussing their future.

It doesnt mean their wedding wont be lovely and romantic.

With all respect, give your head a wobble.

SallyWD · 18/05/2022 13:46

This was my proposal. My partner sat me down and said "Well we've been together for years now and I think we both know what the next step is." There was a dramatic pause then he said "So don't you think it's time to split up?". After a while he said "Just kidding, shall we get married?". This was perfect for me. I hate anything overly romantic and cheesey. If he got down on one knee I would have told him to get up immediately! We already knew we'd get married. We'd talked about it a lot, had a baby and a house. He just felt pressurised to do some formal proposal which he really didn't need to! I'm so pleased he made a joke out of it.

ZoeCM · 18/05/2022 13:37

Most modern "proposals" are completely fake. Usually, the woman has already asked the man to marry her - to all intents and purposes, she has proposed to him. But our society stigmatises women who propose marriage, so she tells him to get down on one knee and pretend to ask her to marry him, even though she's already told him the answer. She then posts a photo on social media and tells her friends the "romantic proposal story", even though it was all a charade. Your daughter isn't missing out on anything - behind the scenes, most engagements are secretly initiated by the woman.

daisyjgrey · 18/05/2022 12:33

SleepingStandingUp · 18/05/2022 00:02

Oh your poor daughter, how sad for her. Fancy not sitting there waiting on a man to prove her worthiness to her by proposing. How dare she take control of her own life, be open about her needs with her partner and find the best way forward together. Doesn't she know real Princesses never make their needs important???

Mostly this. She doesn't live in a Disney film, she can manage her relationship how she wants.

KettrickenSmiled · 18/05/2022 12:09

The idea that women 'cherish' their 'special surprise moment'

I know, right? Pass the fucking sick bag.

Although I now reckon OP's just dropped a Goady Bomb & ain't coming back ...

gianaInfertilitySucks · 18/05/2022 12:07

She can have a conversation about his future plans so she knows if she is wasting her time with him or not. If she wants her future to be with a family she has to know now. On the other hand you're right she doesn't have to hurry.

CorpseReviver · 18/05/2022 11:46

WhereYouLeftIt · 18/05/2022 11:30

"I can’t help but feel a little sad that in essentially orchestrating her own engagement, DD will lose out on the special surprise moment of a traditional proposal which so many young women get to experience and cherish, which I’d hate for her to miss out on due to her impatience."

The idea that women 'cherish' their 'special surprise moment' - let's have a think about that. Women waiting to be proposed to, fearing being the left-on-the-shelf spinster. No agency, it's the man's choice.

That may have been a thing in the world of teenaged virgin brides where no woman 'lived in sin' or (oh! the horror!) had children with a man she wasn't married to. I personally am glad that that world has gone. I don't feel it was a world to cherish, it feels quite alien to me.

Agree 100%

Thepeopleversuswork · 18/05/2022 11:37

That may have been a thing in the world of teenaged virgin brides where no woman 'lived in sin' or (oh! the horror!) had children with a man she wasn't married to. I personally am glad that that world has gone. I don't feel it was a world to cherish, it feels quite alien to me.

Absolutely

WhereYouLeftIt · 18/05/2022 11:30

"I can’t help but feel a little sad that in essentially orchestrating her own engagement, DD will lose out on the special surprise moment of a traditional proposal which so many young women get to experience and cherish, which I’d hate for her to miss out on due to her impatience."

The idea that women 'cherish' their 'special surprise moment' - let's have a think about that. Women waiting to be proposed to, fearing being the left-on-the-shelf spinster. No agency, it's the man's choice.

That may have been a thing in the world of teenaged virgin brides where no woman 'lived in sin' or (oh! the horror!) had children with a man she wasn't married to. I personally am glad that that world has gone. I don't feel it was a world to cherish, it feels quite alien to me.

KatharinaRosalie · 18/05/2022 11:19

That's not orchestrating proposal. Of course one should discuss the timelines and the future of their relationship, she's not a teenager and 1.5 years at their age is rather on the late side never having discussed their plans at all.

What is the other option, sit quietly assuming he has the same plans until she's 38 and the partner declares that he never wanted marriage and children and why did she even assume otherwise?

And of course she can still have an old-fashioned surprise proposal if she wants. They should discuss if they see themselves getting married in the near future, but leave the exact time and manner of getting engaged, open.

Thepeopleversuswork · 18/05/2022 11:17

thisplaceisweird · 18/05/2022 11:00

I would never encourage my daughter to get engaged to someone she has known for less than 2 years though. It doesn't feel long enough to get to know someone you'll spend your life with. You haven't gone through the 'hard bits' together, that's when it really counts.

Everyone is having babies in their mid-thirties now, she shouldn't feel rushed.

I agree but the point is the OP seems to think the proposal is almost more important than the marriage and seems to be actively discouraging her daughter from playing an active role in this.

I think she means well but her attitude is slightly frightening in this day and age tbh.

MandUs · 18/05/2022 11:02

I find the traditional proposal outdated and sexist. Good for your daughter wanting an equal part in the decision-making about her own life.