Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disappointed that DD won’t get a surprise proposal

262 replies

Bluebellewoods · 17/05/2022 23:59

DD is 28 and has been in a relationship with her partner for around a year and a half. They’ve been living together for some time and she tells me they are very happy together. I think the thought of turning 30 in a couple of years has been a big turning point for DD as she’s expressed her desire to get married and think about having children, as she feels time is running out somewhat.

DD tells me that she has decided it’s time to have a chat with her partner about her desire to get married and discuss and agree a timescale for doing so. I can’t help but feel a little sad that in essentially orchestrating her own engagement, DD will lose out on the special surprise moment of a traditional proposal which so many young women get to experience and cherish, which I’d hate for her to miss out on due to her impatience.

DD asked me for my advice on how she should best approach the conversation and I said I’d give it some thought. What I really want to say to her is just wait, she’s still so young and has so much time! I’d understand if DD had been waiting for years, but their relationship is still relatively new and I don’t think rushing an engagement at this time and sacrificing the traditional surprise is justified. AIBU?

OP posts:
TurquoiseSwirl · 18/05/2022 01:12

Tell her to wait, give up her job and start reading the 1950’s handbook for a wife.
i would copy my friend in the future and just discuss things, agree to get married and buy a ring and set a date. How sad for your daughter you think she needs magical moments like this. Wow.

IdisagreeMrHochhauser · 18/05/2022 01:06

FFS. Is it the 50s? The 1850s?

This is much the most sensible and best way to approach it IMHO.

I'm bisexual and so might never get a surprise proposal because if both of us were female we wouldn't be able to take the initiative and we'd be waiting forever....

SouperNoodle · 18/05/2022 01:01

*propose, not promise 🤦‍♀️

SouperNoodle · 18/05/2022 01:00

Whether or not it's a surprise, it's still an amazing moment.

DH and I talked about marriage and children and had a timeline in mind and we picked out my engagement ring together.
I knew he was going to promise within the next couple of months but didn't know when
When he did, I genuinely wasn't expecting it and it was so beautiful and he'd put so much thought and detail into it.
We'd been together for just over a year at this point and now it's years later and I still love his proposal.

Namenic · 18/05/2022 00:55

I got married mid 20s. I didn’t care about surprise. In fact - we went shopping for engagement rings together beforehand - which was fortunate because when I tried on the rings, I realised that I liked a completely different style from what I had thought.

Doggydarling · 18/05/2022 00:48

YABU. I'm happily married and neither of us proposed, I didn't miss out simply because a man didn't stage an old fashioned out of date (now mostly for social media) down on one knee tradition. We discussed our plans for the future and decided together to get married, we went and picked out rings together, we told our families together, no one asked for permission to marry me, I wasn't a belonging to be passed from one male to another, my wonderful father would have told my now husband he didn't know me at all if he'd gone the traditional route of asking the fathers permission. I hate the 'surprise' proposals that are photographed/filmed for social media, I've a friend who knew her boyfriend had the ring because they'd picked it together after discussing the future, he kept the ring and then did the down on one knee at a family event in front of everyone while his friend filmed it, she faked surprise and shock but it was obvious that she knew it was going to happen, that is not romantic, that's attention seeking. I admired a ring in a shop window while on honeymoon, my husband secretly took a photo of the shop and the ring, on our first anniversary he gave me the ring, he had contacted the shop after the honeymoon and bought the ring, he held on to it for a year so he could surprise me, no photos taken, no fb posts, no witnesses, I'll take that over a proposal any time.

Dontfuckingsaycheese · 18/05/2022 00:47

She needs to know if he wants to shit or get off the pot! And make room for someone else. Tick tock and all that. Sounds a bit heartless I know. Your dd sounds incredibly sensible to me.
Marriage is a legal and financial contract. It doesn’t need to be flown in on butterfly wings. She needs to know now if this man is committed for the long run. If he isn’t and children are a dealbreaker for her it’s just cruel at this point to waste her time. I know many many women successfully conceive naturally in their late 30s but that’s not all women. And they’re just saving themselves up a shitload of heartbreak if that’s what they really want.

Seeingadistance · 18/05/2022 00:46

FFS!

HailAdrian · 18/05/2022 00:44

Every woman's dream is not a surprise proposal. I'd be cringing if my boyfriend did that.

Aquamarine1029 · 18/05/2022 00:39

It's a shame that she seemingly hasn't discussed her expectations and needs with her boyfriend before they started living together. So many women walk blindly into this scenario and end up wasting a lot of precious time.

Katypyee · 18/05/2022 00:39

This is 2022. My no DH and I were having a coffee in Costa and chatting about what to do with some money we had given to us. He just came out and said that perhaps we could use some of it to get married. I said, sure. That was it. No grand gesture. Now been married 12 years and have 2 DC. Not having a big romantic proposal is not the end of the world.

whumpthereitis · 18/05/2022 00:35

I don’t think I ever dreamed of a traditional proposal. My husband and I had a number of conversations about marriage before he asked to make concrete plans for marriage. We were sat on the couch on the time. If he’d have done the dramatic, public, drop to one knee in a restaurant I’d have likely cringed.

Not everyone places value on tradition.

lameasahorse · 18/05/2022 00:34

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Wherehasthecommonsensegone · 18/05/2022 00:34

This is such a weird take. Most couples now will discuss where they’re at and a rough timeline or expectations for the future to be on the same page. That doesn’t meant any proposal that may happen wouldn’t be a surprise. Agreeing they’d like to be engaged within the next 6 months or a year doesn’t tell her when/where it would happen, if at home or abroad etc. so still a surprise (assuming he’ll be the one proposing).

LorW · 18/05/2022 00:29

When I was with my XH he had proposed on a beach abroad at sunset and set up a photographer and everything, I think I felt pressured because of how much effort he had gone too and probably at that point shouldn’t have said yes (hindsight is a wonderful thing) whereas me and my current DH just decided to get married, no proposal, no getting down on one knee, just two people deciding they want to get married, no pressure, it was nice and I’m happier than ever.

soooo, YABU 😁

lameasahorse · 18/05/2022 00:26

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Hathertonhariden · 18/05/2022 00:25

Do the maths OP. If she doesn't have a discussion about it, how long does she wait for a proposal? A year? Two? Three? What happens if she waits a couple of years and there's no proposal? If she wants marriage and children giving up on a relationship at 32/33, then perhaps taking a couple of years to find someone who you are compatible with and who wants a family in the same timeframe is quite an ask. That takes you to 35, then how long do you wait for that surprise proposal? How long an engagement? How long to conceive?

Your dd is very sensible to be discussing where the relationship is going. They could decide that they do want marriage & dc and the timing of the proposal is a surprise even if she knows it's coming.

Surely very few proposals come entirely out of the blue? If you've never discussed the future how can someone be sure that a proposal would be welcomed? How many people would risk being turned down?

powershowerforanhour · 18/05/2022 00:23

In order of importance:

the marriage (or relationship if they decide not to get married, or happy singledom if they go their separate ways) >>>>>>> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>(probably a few thousand more > signs)
the wedding >> the proposal

On the bright side, if missing out on the surprise ring proposal is what you are most worried about in your daughter's relationship then her fella is probably a good egg.

RingRingRed · 18/05/2022 00:22

Yabu and totally out dated.

Why should your DD wait? Why can't she take control of her own life?

I had the same chat with dh when we had been together a year, and I was late 20s. He's a couple of years younger than me so was not in a rush.

We've been married now 15 years.

Bluebellewoods · 18/05/2022 00:15

imperialminty · 18/05/2022 00:09

I think you can strike a balance between having the conversations and having a surprise romantic moment. That’s what happened to me - we spoke a LOT about our shared desire for marriage, what our timelines were etc. over the years (we got together young) and then about 18 months before we got engaged we started talking very seriously about the future and agreed we both wanted marriage and what that would look like etc. He then told me to basically shut up about it and that it would happen but just to wait, and he surprised me totally with an incredibly romantic proposal and a beautiful ring he’d designed.

You can have the conversations and the surprise, and your daughter absolutely SHOULD be having the conversations! In this day and age you shouldn’t be completely shocked when someone proposes - it should be something you both know you want and have discussed what your marriage will look like in my opinion.

This is a very good point, I hadn’t considered there’s the potential for the best of both worlds here.

OP posts:
CheesyColeslaw · 18/05/2022 00:15

YABU. I don't think it's usual to just propose out the blue having never discussed marriage or found out how your partner feels about it. Why should she wait around for something that might never happen? If she wants to get married then it's up to her to have that conversation with him. He might not be that arsed about it or not feel ready yet.
It's also not really any of your business, your daughter is presumably fine with not having a "surprise" proposal so not sure why it would bother you.

Vikinga · 18/05/2022 00:14

Good for your daughter, taking charge of her own destiny and not waiting in th wings for some meaningless proposal.

TaranThePigKeeper · 18/05/2022 00:12

We had talked previously about wanting to get married, but DH actually ‘proposed’ when I was waiting for an ambulance to cart me off to hospital with pneumonia. He says it made him realise the depth of how much I meant to him, and that he was terrified I was so ill. That showed me more about his love for and commitment to me than any amount of rose petals and sunsets. We were only ‘engaged’ long enough to plan and have our wedding, so about 6 months. We’re about to have our 20th anniversary.

Proposals can be a lot of old nonsense, and really mean very little.

Time2Move · 18/05/2022 00:11

Oh your poor daughter, how sad for her. Fancy not sitting there waiting on a man to prove her worthiness to her by proposing. How dare she take control of her own life, be open about her needs with her partner and find the best way forward together. Doesn't she know real Princesses never make their needs important???
This.

Threetulips · 18/05/2022 00:10

Not sure why you think we are all sat about waiting to be proposed to?
It’s never as romantic as people seem to think, some get drunk and pop the question others are flown to the moon!
Makes no difference to a couple who are compatible.