Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why cheating is so wrong?

334 replies

Tandora · 17/05/2022 19:59

Inspired by another thread, where people are emphatically insisting that no one should need an explanation for why cheating is so wrong.

AIBU to ask for one?

I mean I get that it’s horrible when someone does something behind your back; so the lying aspect of it- I see how that is wrong. But it’s more than that isn’t it? like it’s not just any old lie.. after all people tell lies all the time (including in relationships), yet it seems that cheating is considered almost the worst thing that you can do to someone. But why?

I get that if you’ve committed your life to someone , it’s a betrayal if they suddenly abandon ship for someone else, but why do people get so beyond upset about casual flings, where there’s no intention to leave? Or is it because they are afraid a fling might lead to abandonment?

It seems quite strange to me to be so wound up about what someone else does with their body, and to feel so entitled to control that…

Sooo… can someone explain it to me? I don’t really get the concept. Genuinely..

<Puts on hard hat and ducks for cover 😅>

OP posts:
dustofneptune · 18/05/2022 05:49

OP, it’s a tricky one.

I’ve been in monogamous relationships, polysexual relationships (ok to have casual sex with others), and polyamorous relationships (ok to have deep emotional romantic-sexual relationships with others). I’ve been cheated on in all three scenarios. Infidelity is still possible in ENM, because it’s the ethical aspect that’s important - the openness and agreements made around that.

What I’ve taken from this is that the reason infidelity is so traumatic for most people comes down to one or both of these factors:

Betrayal - When you make a pact of trust with someone, either explicitly or implicitly, the betrayal of that agreement can completely and permanently damage your ability to trust anyone, ever. If what you believed to be true isn’t true, how can you ever be sure that you are aware of reality again?

Abandonment - It’s not just physical abandonment that can deeply hurt someone. It can also be other forms of abandonment - especially emotional abandonment. When you’re in a relationship and fully invested and present, and they are elsewhere emotionally but don’t actually leave you, it can be a devastating feeling.

Humiliation and being taken for a mug are other factors. I guess they come into it, more so for some than others. But I’d say it’s really more about the other two.

In my case, I still have absolutely no problem being in a poly relationship with someone who has an existing long term partner. The thought of them having sex or being emotionally intimate doesn’t bother me at all - I think it’s beautiful, hot, or I’m indifferent. Where I struggle is when new partners come in. For me, it must relate to some kind of feeling of threat, a fear of abandonment (emotional or physical).

I used to think that monogamy was possessive, but I don’t think that any more. I don’t think it’s about possession. It’s about seeing fidelity as sacred. In ENM, fidelity isn’t seen as sacred - but emotional openness and honour of agreements absolutely is. So it’s about trust.

I don’t think that you love with less depth if you don’t feel fidelity is a sacred thing. It may be that you value other things (honesty, etc.) more. Or it may be that you haven’t experienced the specific type of abandonment or betrayal that is deeply triggering for you personally. Or it may be that you are lucky and just wired to be very chill and free about emotional bonds haha. I wish I could be that chill 😅

Mintyt · 18/05/2022 05:39

Because it hurts, it makes you doubt everything you knew, it changes what you expected your life to be. Leaves you financially worst off.

expat101 · 18/05/2022 04:15

I would feel (and did feel) like my trust was broken. I was young when it happened to me with my first serious partner (and the first man (hahaha) I had sex with), he ended up in bed with a school friend of mine who would come and stay over at my place from time to time.

To top that off, apparently having sex with me was like being with a log! How the heck was I to know what I was supposed to do...

I thought both of them would have had moral boundaries in place at least out of some sort of loyalty to me, but no.

I think I was a good person then and now and certainly didn't deserve that, nor the reference I was a log in bed, nor the carry on later when I had moved out of the family property, to find male callers were bugging an elderly family member to find the school friend for a shag, and my name was being used as the ''friend to see''.

Whatever confidence I had then was clearly shattered and I went on to make a couple of bad choices thereafter.

People just don't have the right to treat someone else like that.

Peoniesandpeaches · 18/05/2022 02:22

Infidelity is rarely really about shagging someone else. My partner told lies about me ( the nagging wife) and spilled my secrets to the other woman. In text messages I could see them mocking me about things that were my deepest insecurities. I had made myself vulnerable and trusted this person when they told me I was loved and lovable in spite of my flaws only to find they were using them as a reason to cheat. It destroyed my sense of self magnifying my insecurities and making me doubt my ability to pick friends/partners. The fact that my partner fucked this woman while I was devastated at my aunts deathbed was just further proof of my naive idiocy and their callousness. It’s the feeling of having been utterly vulnerable with someone that you should be safe with and having that trust violated. I’ve never been insecure about my partners fancying someone else or even really worried about the idea of consensual non-monogamy - I’ve had a couple of open relationships previous to this so it’s not about jealousy or insecurity.

SouperNoodle · 18/05/2022 01:08

@Whatever00 your comment made me howl 😂😂😂

AnAfternoonWalk · 18/05/2022 00:56

🙄 whatever.

Onthedunes · 18/05/2022 00:43

There are many types of relationships out there, when I was younger I had a relationship that was more friendship based and honest in the way that we were very much alike and could speak openly about many subjects, including love and sex with previous partners, just generally like best friends with a sexual relationship, we grew close and made each other laugh but there was something missing.

I could have ended up with that man but the drive and effort needed to make it exclusive for a long time was not there. Eventually I met someone else, good looking, just the type for reproducing, he felt the same and from that point a conditional contract was drawn up, it didn't need to be verbally discussed to death, we both knew each other wanted to be manogamous, emotionally, physically and financially, to work as a team.

I think when you meet that match there has to be that level of trust to bare your soul, your weaknesses, your vunerability, it's frightening stuff and takes some real courage to allow yourself to let go and love one person fully, totally and forgo all others to keep one another safe and secure, but you both want it.

Love has many parts to it and I think, and I don't mean to be rude but if you do not care about infedelity then you have not fully given yourself to someone, you have held back to some degree in certain areas of your relationship.

So as I was saying, do you have children, are you married, do you have a mortgage togther are you tied financially in any way?

Only you know your own unique contract that holds you together but to analogize for your lack of understanding for the pain many feel for affairs could be this..

Imagine your partner coming home tommorow, you have your boundaries, you love him and feel you could never be hurt by his actions as you have a pretty flexible relationship, allowing him greater trust and forgiveness, but if you found him to have a second life, a wife, children a house and you never knew, would you be shocked. He has broken your contract, you only said affairs were acceptable.

As for describing that pain, my analagy for you would be imagine your parents if you love them and they love you, all your life nurturing you, making you feel safe and secure in the world, well imagine turning up at their house tommorow and they shut the door in your face, tell you to fuck off when you ask what's wrong, they say nothing is wrong. Then you find out they have re written their will out to the next door neighbour and left them all their money, and they do not want to see you or your children anymore.
You ask why, and they tell you and everyone in the family you are fucking crazy and will phone the police if you do not stop bothering them.
It's brutal and barbaric.

It's the confusion that hurts, that one day someone loves you and the next they hate you, how on earth you ask could they have ever loved me if they could switch so easily. Have I imagined my whole life up to this point ? It's very scary to wake up with a completely different reality.

Quite frankly you wil be less hurt if you do not give all to love, yet despite all my hurt I don't think I could have gone fifty years not experiencing that exclusive love.

BadNomad · 18/05/2022 00:42

but if it was a total stranger , he doesn’t think he’d care that much 🤷🏼‍♀️. I guess we are as weird as each other

Or he has already cheated on with you with a stranger and therefore can't judge you for it. 🤷🏼‍♀️

LorW · 18/05/2022 00:39

For a start by cheating you are risking your partners sexual health (the person you claim to love) and it’s a massive betrayal, you’re not only ruining the current relationship but you also risk ruining future relationships for the person you cheated on, they will always doubt themselves and question everything and that isn’t fair.

not to mention every time someone has sex there is always a risk of pregnancy, selfish risking bringing a child into the world through your infidelity. 🤷🏻‍♀️

NotMushroomInEre · 18/05/2022 00:18

It's called cheating for a reason. You should be honest and loyal if you enter into a monogamous relationship. Sleep with someone else without your partner knowing and you've just thrown those two morals/ethics/values straight into the bin.

I also don't think it's immoral or unethical to sleep with multiple partners, as long as you are both/all on the same page.

If you want to be in an open relationship, and you are both happy with that, then that's grand. If not, you are a liar.

It's the lying that is the betrayal.

girljulian · 17/05/2022 23:58

DixonD · 17/05/2022 23:53

That’s good then 😁

I think you can see, but perhaps may not accept, that your feelings on infidelity are not the “norm”. Why this is, who knows? But to suggest you cannot understand why others would be upset is a bit strange.

I would suggest you did not love your previous boyfriend. When you love someone, the thought of them enjoying the body of another woman is quite awful. Most people would feel this way. You don’t, that’s fine. But to query why others would, when this is the societal norm, is really, really odd. Your feelings are yours - but I find it truly perplexing that you cannot comprehend why others would be upset by such a betrayal.

Maybe consider looking back at your childhood and the relationships you were exposed to?

But surely the OP's question was simply: "is there a real reason this upsets people OTHER than it being the social norm"?

DixonD · 17/05/2022 23:53

Tandora · 17/05/2022 22:49

Incidentally I just asked my DP if I got drunk one night and shagged someone else, would it devastate him/ destroy our relationship. He basically said, if it was someone he knew/ had
to interact with he would be really upset because of the pride factor/ shame/ embarrassment, but if it was a
total stranger , he doesn’t think he’d care that much 🤷🏼‍♀️. I guess we are as weird as each other 😅.

That’s good then 😁

I think you can see, but perhaps may not accept, that your feelings on infidelity are not the “norm”. Why this is, who knows? But to suggest you cannot understand why others would be upset is a bit strange.

I would suggest you did not love your previous boyfriend. When you love someone, the thought of them enjoying the body of another woman is quite awful. Most people would feel this way. You don’t, that’s fine. But to query why others would, when this is the societal norm, is really, really odd. Your feelings are yours - but I find it truly perplexing that you cannot comprehend why others would be upset by such a betrayal.

Maybe consider looking back at your childhood and the relationships you were exposed to?

MrsBlaue · 17/05/2022 23:42

Nothing as such if it’s kept away from your partner. Treat like a dump - flush and wash your hands, and forget. It’s wrong when you let it hurt your loved ones. It’s wrong when it turns out you don’t love the ones you said you loved. This is the reason, OP, why a lot of these “other women” end up getting killed by the man when threatened with being found out.

Colourfulrainbows · 17/05/2022 23:36

Because you have entered a contract with another person. Either legally if married or verbally if not.
Within that contact both parties have agreed to certain clauses.
If one or the other breaks that contact the contact no longer remains.

I get what you are saying but don't enter an agreement with another person if not willing to follow it. Stay single. Some people have open relationships.

There is a huge difference between a full blown affair and one off, people do make errors. People do loose inhabitants when intoxicated on holiday etc. Not saying it's right but people forget that we are human. To err is to be human.

But if you know that you can not be trusted that way don't enter a contract with another.

If you look at marriage a long term relationship as a contract between two people. It makes sense as to why cheating is wrong.

( and no I not cold or unloving)

hellywelly3 · 17/05/2022 23:26

For me the main ones are putting my health at risks, STI’s. The chance it might result in a child so would effect my children.

Tandora · 17/05/2022 23:20

LilyLott44 · 17/05/2022 23:15

SugarNspices - because you can still want to have a bond with someone and be close to them without necessarily being shackled by the enforced constraints of eternal monogamy. I think this is OP’s point.

Quite.

OP posts:
Cantfollowmeround · 17/05/2022 23:20

People are free to make their own decisions relating to their children under the circumstance that they put their safety and wellbeing first. When people don't, it causes trauma for the child that comes up in ways that effect their ability to function normally in life and in a lot of cases, they end up cutting contact with the people who were trusted to care for them and have caused them this needless suffering.

If I was with a man who had enough money to support multiple wives, I wouldn't be happy with them doing so. There are more to relationships than the provisions money can provide. A mother shouldn't be expected to raise children on her own and in an ideal situation would grow up with both parents actively being there nurturing their development and emotional wellbeing, and to provide a sense of stability in the best interest of the child. Babies don't like it when their parents give attention to another child, that must be for a reason. There is a big difference between this care from a biological parent and care from a paid caregiver. The man couldn't be split multiple ways and provide sufficiently other than financially for more than one family.

In the same way there's not enough of a man to sufficiently split his various resources like time and energy and love and respect etc to multiple partners. In certain cases if you're ok with your partner seeing someone else then you must have self esteem issues to believe that you don't deserve all that comes with a monogamous relationship. In my experience with people who don't realise their partners are cheating, its because they're so used to being neglected in their relationship that they don't spot anything and if they do spot something then its because their partner isn't treating them as well as they did at one point in time

riotlady · 17/05/2022 23:20

When my husband and I met we were both experimenting with polyamory- he was in an open relationship with another woman and also occasionally sleeping with other people, I was dating a few different people a few of whom were in open relationships. At the time I was mildly jealous of him sleeping with other people, because I wanted him all to myself, but nothing earth shattering (and obviously I was doing the same thing!)

When we got together officially, we decided to be monogamous and now obviously we’re married. What would really upset me now isn’t the act, it’s the betrayal of the commitment we made to each other. It’s all the steps that would have to lead to the cheating - going out for drinks or going home with her, lying to me about it, knowing that he was potentially risking our relationship for a shag and deciding that it’s worth it. It would feel like him momentarily choosing someone else over me.

I love him a lot and although I do sometimes find another people attractive, I just wouldn’t want to be intimate with someone else in that way. If he cheated I would know he didn’t feel the same way about me, and that would be deeply upsetting

Tandora · 17/05/2022 23:18

leotardrock · 17/05/2022 23:06

Also OP there is a big difference between a drunken one night stand outside the relationship & something like a month affair!

I could probably forgive a one-night stand - shit happens but someone coming home from work everyday is a very different scenario!

Yes agree there is a difference. An ongoing affair involves more lying , active deception and therefore is a much worse betrayal in my view.

OP posts:
LilyLott44 · 17/05/2022 23:15

SugarNspices - because you can still want to have a bond with someone and be close to them without necessarily being shackled by the enforced constraints of eternal monogamy. I think this is OP’s point.

MakeThingsRight · 17/05/2022 23:15

For me it would be the deceit.

I hate any form of deceit.

I am in a monogamous relationship based on honesty and I would expect the same courtesy being afforded to me.

It's all about shared values.

SugarNspices · 17/05/2022 23:09

Surely then you could argue why not just stay single and have casual relationships why think it's ok to hurt someone? It's obvious why, most people who commit would be upset, they love the person and feel betrayed. Also the point you made about it being their body so why not, casual sex/flings can effect the other party passing on stds, unwanted pregnancy to name a few, never mind the emotional suffering.

leotardrock · 17/05/2022 23:09

🙄 coming home from work and lying to your face everyday is a very different scenario

Owwlie · 17/05/2022 23:07

I think you’re missing the point that most people are in a monogamous relationship, where it is understood that neither of you have sex with someone else. If one person then does you have broken the trust, betrayed the other person and shown a clear lack of regard for their feelings. Drunk or not, you can’t accidentally have sex with someone. It’s a purposeful decision to betray your partner. It’s not jealous, insecure or possessive to expect someone to not have sex with someone else in a monogamous relationship.

Whether people believe monogamy is possible (it is for lots of people!) is a different conversation entirely.

leotardrock · 17/05/2022 23:06

Also OP there is a big difference between a drunken one night stand outside the relationship & something like a month affair!

I could probably forgive a one-night stand - shit happens but someone coming home from work everyday is a very different scenario!