Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why cheating is so wrong?

334 replies

Tandora · 17/05/2022 19:59

Inspired by another thread, where people are emphatically insisting that no one should need an explanation for why cheating is so wrong.

AIBU to ask for one?

I mean I get that it’s horrible when someone does something behind your back; so the lying aspect of it- I see how that is wrong. But it’s more than that isn’t it? like it’s not just any old lie.. after all people tell lies all the time (including in relationships), yet it seems that cheating is considered almost the worst thing that you can do to someone. But why?

I get that if you’ve committed your life to someone , it’s a betrayal if they suddenly abandon ship for someone else, but why do people get so beyond upset about casual flings, where there’s no intention to leave? Or is it because they are afraid a fling might lead to abandonment?

It seems quite strange to me to be so wound up about what someone else does with their body, and to feel so entitled to control that…

Sooo… can someone explain it to me? I don’t really get the concept. Genuinely..

<Puts on hard hat and ducks for cover 😅>

OP posts:
TheWeeDonkey · 19/05/2022 13:14

Well I mean all of that behaviour is shit, but it shouldn't be an either or. We shouldn't accept any of it. Maybe it is a sign of social conditioning that we have such low expectations of men in particular in relationships.

This idea that a woman is nothing without a man is very helpful to men isn't it?

strivingtosucceed · 19/05/2022 13:02

Evilista · 17/05/2022 22:15

I had one boyfriend who just straight up cheated on me. I was hurt and angry, don't get me wrong. But I would take cheating any day over the financial, psychological, physical and sexual abuse I experienced in another relationship. I used to think it was definitely the worst lie but now I'm not so sure.

This is it for me. I've been cheated on too and I won't lie, the pain was indescribable. But now having seen what other people in relationships have gone through wrt financial, sexual & physical abuse, I would gladly take cheating.

For some reason sex seems to be seen an unforgivable sin, while other things aren't. I wonder how much of it is actual lived pain and how much is the societal view of cheating = monstrous.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 19/05/2022 13:00

5128gap · 19/05/2022 12:36

This is only the case regarding women's adultery. Extra marital relations have been widely tolerated, even expected, in men (particularly men of means) until comparatively recently. It was just 'men being men', and a 'dignified' woman turned a blind eye.
There are also communities where polygamy is still legally and socially acceptable for men.

That's a completely different debate and is not entirely untrue, however, that doesn't make the universal condemnation of Adultery untrue.
I don't tolerate Adultury from my friends and I will judge them initially if they ask for advice or help. Whichever party it happens to be.

I'm not saying it's easy to resist temptation or it isn't exciting, etc, etc.

Onthedunes · 19/05/2022 12:41

I think the institution of marriage and monogamy is seated in the union of rich and powerful dynasties, with benefiial unions throughout history.

Laws created to help spread religion, wealth and polictical power. The unions of the rich and powerful needed to be protected and marriage was the perfect solution for dynasties to continue.

I fear it is less about the emotional aspect, it arose from practicality of conquering in some way or another. Marriage became an institution a way of recognising different unions between countries, making it valid, important and respectable.

Laws have always been passed that benefited men, they understand the laws of ownership and the advantages of that.

5128gap · 19/05/2022 12:36

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 19/05/2022 12:20

You're incorrect.
From a deontological ethical point of view, Adultery is breaking the SACRED VOW. It is indeed universally accepted across all cultures, timelines with minor exceptions as wrong, and is condemned.
It is in fact an explicit contractual agreement between the two parties, the ones breaking the contract are by default dishonest.

The debate will include wiggle room and whataboutery but it still doesn't change the accepted societal norm.
I'm stating my opinion on the facts as I see it, even though people may have plausible reasons or permission from the other to commit adultery.

I was cheated on, now being arrogant, the actual physical aspect I recovered from very quickly. However, the financial/home aftershock had devastating consequences for me personally.
I left within the hour post confession.
I will not tolerate any misdemeanors by the other party on the question of adultery and ultimately loyalty. Now if we come to an agreement between ourselves that's a different set of circumstances altogether.

This is only the case regarding women's adultery. Extra marital relations have been widely tolerated, even expected, in men (particularly men of means) until comparatively recently. It was just 'men being men', and a 'dignified' woman turned a blind eye.
There are also communities where polygamy is still legally and socially acceptable for men.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 19/05/2022 12:20

dumdumduuuummmmm · 19/05/2022 11:46

But it's not. Throughout time, extra marital relationships have been everything from typical through to unacceptable depending on class, society and era. It's just not true that monogamy is and always has been the norm

You're incorrect.
From a deontological ethical point of view, Adultery is breaking the SACRED VOW. It is indeed universally accepted across all cultures, timelines with minor exceptions as wrong, and is condemned.
It is in fact an explicit contractual agreement between the two parties, the ones breaking the contract are by default dishonest.

The debate will include wiggle room and whataboutery but it still doesn't change the accepted societal norm.
I'm stating my opinion on the facts as I see it, even though people may have plausible reasons or permission from the other to commit adultery.

I was cheated on, now being arrogant, the actual physical aspect I recovered from very quickly. However, the financial/home aftershock had devastating consequences for me personally.
I left within the hour post confession.
I will not tolerate any misdemeanors by the other party on the question of adultery and ultimately loyalty. Now if we come to an agreement between ourselves that's a different set of circumstances altogether.

aSofaNearYou · 19/05/2022 12:19

Stabbitystabstab · 19/05/2022 12:15

It's deep rooted insecurity.

I don't understand this statement. The hurt I would feel about DP sleeping with someone else would not be about fear he would leave me. So why is it insecurity?

Stabbitystabstab · 19/05/2022 12:15

It's deep rooted insecurity.

dumdumduuuummmmm · 19/05/2022 11:46

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 19/05/2022 11:15

Monogamy is the fundamental structure for order in relationships, this applies physically and mentally to our well-being.
It's as old as humankind, shared in the main across all timelines, explicitly and implicitly condemned both by the law and social constructs.

Biblically adultery is the only reason for divorce, it was also mentioned in the Ten commandments. And it's interesting to note coveting, adultery, murder, stealing, and honor are all interlinked.

But it's not. Throughout time, extra marital relationships have been everything from typical through to unacceptable depending on class, society and era. It's just not true that monogamy is and always has been the norm

5128gap · 19/05/2022 11:15

Tandora · 19/05/2022 11:12

Touché on all points I think.
In that case would it be fair to say that monogamy is an institution created by men, for men, that benefits women because of their dependency on men?

I think that's a fair summary, yes.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 19/05/2022 11:15

Monogamy is the fundamental structure for order in relationships, this applies physically and mentally to our well-being.
It's as old as humankind, shared in the main across all timelines, explicitly and implicitly condemned both by the law and social constructs.

Biblically adultery is the only reason for divorce, it was also mentioned in the Ten commandments. And it's interesting to note coveting, adultery, murder, stealing, and honor are all interlinked.

Tandora · 19/05/2022 11:12

5128gap · 19/05/2022 10:58

It would be nice to think it had happened due to negotiation with women, but given how long it dates back and how very powerless women were then, I'd be surprised tbh. I'd say more likely it was just seen as the most functional societal structure. Rather than ramaging around impregnating many women, threatening other men, it felt more orderly for men to be encouraged to stick to one woman and take responsibility for one family.
I think women are keen to enforce it because, emotions aside, they have a great deal to lose if a man refuses to remain in an exclusive relationship with them.

Touché on all points I think.
In that case would it be fair to say that monogamy is an institution created by men, for men, that benefits women because of their dependency on men?

OP posts:
5128gap · 19/05/2022 10:58

Tandora · 19/05/2022 10:46

I think it probably evolved in men as part of a negotiation with women? I’ll be faithful to you if you are faithful to me? But infidelity amongst men has of course traditionally been much more tolerated by society as a whole, compared to infidelity in women. Maybe that’s why women today feel so strongly about enforcing it?

It would be nice to think it had happened due to negotiation with women, but given how long it dates back and how very powerless women were then, I'd be surprised tbh. I'd say more likely it was just seen as the most functional societal structure. Rather than ramaging around impregnating many women, threatening other men, it felt more orderly for men to be encouraged to stick to one woman and take responsibility for one family.
I think women are keen to enforce it because, emotions aside, they have a great deal to lose if a man refuses to remain in an exclusive relationship with them.

Tandora · 19/05/2022 10:46

5128gap · 19/05/2022 10:40

I'm not sure that's the question really. Women are devastated because they have the expectation of faithfulness from men and because male monogimy is useful to them too.
I think the question is more why did monogamy in men ever become embedded as a norm. Its difficult to see the advantages for them, or why they signed up for it.
Perhaps it originated as a means for men to protect their women from other men; telling them they should be faithful to their own wives in order to keep them at bay. Or perhaps it evolved from default, as if all women are faithful there is less opportunity. Interesting though.

I think it probably evolved in men as part of a negotiation with women? I’ll be faithful to you if you are faithful to me? But infidelity amongst men has of course traditionally been much more tolerated by society as a whole, compared to infidelity in women. Maybe that’s why women today feel so strongly about enforcing it?

OP posts:
5128gap · 19/05/2022 10:40

Tandora · 19/05/2022 09:44

Agree. But then what you are really suggesting here is that monogamy is an institution largely created to defend the interests of men? So why would so many women be so devastated by cheating ?

I'm not sure that's the question really. Women are devastated because they have the expectation of faithfulness from men and because male monogimy is useful to them too.
I think the question is more why did monogamy in men ever become embedded as a norm. Its difficult to see the advantages for them, or why they signed up for it.
Perhaps it originated as a means for men to protect their women from other men; telling them they should be faithful to their own wives in order to keep them at bay. Or perhaps it evolved from default, as if all women are faithful there is less opportunity. Interesting though.

Tandora · 19/05/2022 10:36

Badbadbunny · 19/05/2022 09:48

after all people tell lies all the time

No they really don't. Lots of people are fundamentally honest and don't lie.

When I discover someone has lied, (whether family, business, friends or even casual acquaintances), it really changes my opinion of them and I'll never look at them in the same light again, regardless of how trivial or serious the lie is. If they can lie about something trivial, they can lie about more serious things.

That’s fair enough, so what if your partner never lied? He goes out one night, gets drunk and sleeps with his colleague. Confesses all the next morning and says it was just a terrible mistake. Heinous crime or not?

OP posts:
Tandora · 19/05/2022 10:33

TheWeeDonkey · 19/05/2022 10:18

Hi OP, sorry I hadn't read the full thread when I commented which is why I thought your OP was so odd.

I thought you were talking about an exclusive monogamous relationship but you seem to be referring to open or polygamous relationship which is completely different. I guess cheating in that kind of relationship would be having an emotional affair with the affair partner or ending the initial relationship for them.

For me personally loyalty and trust is a huge part of my relationship but I understand that is not a priority for everyone so each to their own.

The only thing that would concern me is people being in an open relationship not through choice but as a compromise because they're afraid to lose their partner.

All makes sense. I think my original OP was about cheating in a monogamous relationship- asking why it was seen as the worst / ultimate sort of betrayal , beyond the many other ways that people sometimes let their partners down that are considered forgivable/ fixable.

The conversation then moved on a bit in a slightly different direction because people started asking whether I would care if my partner had sex with someone else and then suggested I didn’t really love him.

I honestly think I would be ok in theory with a poly relationship , I’m just not sure I have the time/ can be bothered . I’ve had friends who’ve tried this and it sounds like a lot of work 😅.

totally get your last point about poly relationships that sometimes people can feel pressured to accept terms that they aren’t actually comfortable with to please their partner. So I don’t think it’s a simple as ‘as long as there is honesty/ agreement anything goes’.

OP posts:
TheWeeDonkey · 19/05/2022 10:18

Hi OP, sorry I hadn't read the full thread when I commented which is why I thought your OP was so odd.

I thought you were talking about an exclusive monogamous relationship but you seem to be referring to open or polygamous relationship which is completely different. I guess cheating in that kind of relationship would be having an emotional affair with the affair partner or ending the initial relationship for them.

For me personally loyalty and trust is a huge part of my relationship but I understand that is not a priority for everyone so each to their own.

The only thing that would concern me is people being in an open relationship not through choice but as a compromise because they're afraid to lose their partner.

Badbadbunny · 19/05/2022 09:48

after all people tell lies all the time

No they really don't. Lots of people are fundamentally honest and don't lie.

When I discover someone has lied, (whether family, business, friends or even casual acquaintances), it really changes my opinion of them and I'll never look at them in the same light again, regardless of how trivial or serious the lie is. If they can lie about something trivial, they can lie about more serious things.

Tandora · 19/05/2022 09:44

5128gap · 19/05/2022 09:10

Because we are taught that couples should be exclusive to one another, which is largely based in the desire of men to have certainty around paternity.
Because exclusivity is highly functional, particularly to men, its becoming an embedded norm in relationships, reinforced in the marriage contract, and breaking it is taboo.
Add in the emotional aspects of jealousy, insecurity caused by the breech of trust, impact on self esteem that a partner looks elsewhere, and you can see why people have strong feelings on the subject.

Agree. But then what you are really suggesting here is that monogamy is an institution largely created to defend the interests of men? So why would so many women be so devastated by cheating ?

OP posts:
aSofaNearYou · 19/05/2022 09:24

dumdumduuuummmmm · 19/05/2022 07:44

MN is a very special place where cheating is considered the worst crime. Beyond violent crime (against a 3rd party), fraud, probably eating children. I agree with you OP. There are worse things people move on from successfully

That's subjective though isn't it. There may be worse things for you but for others there may not be.

5128gap · 19/05/2022 09:10

Because we are taught that couples should be exclusive to one another, which is largely based in the desire of men to have certainty around paternity.
Because exclusivity is highly functional, particularly to men, its becoming an embedded norm in relationships, reinforced in the marriage contract, and breaking it is taboo.
Add in the emotional aspects of jealousy, insecurity caused by the breech of trust, impact on self esteem that a partner looks elsewhere, and you can see why people have strong feelings on the subject.

ImAvingOops · 19/05/2022 08:35

In all honesty I'm not sure that people move on successfully. I think it's always there, even when a couple choose to stay together. There can be true regret and shame on the part of the cheater and true forgiveness but I think it leaves a scar.
I think what makes a really bad relationship 'crime' is emotional betrayal (because when you trust you make yourself vulnerable and are relying on your partner to care for you and protect you), and actions which threaten the bond and security. That might be gambling all the family money, for example, but this is outside of most peoples everyday experience, whereas cheating is something that many people have lived through. I guess it also comes back to the repeated barefaced lying which cheating requires - it's such a blatant lack of respect and care.

Stifledlife · 19/05/2022 08:06

It sends a message.
It negates trust.
It crosses boundaries.
It's the thin end of the wedge.
Women are essentially monogamous and men, polyamourous.
He has sex with someone else.. and you say "Oh..ok"
So guess what he's going to do next time it's offered?
He figures he can have sex with anyone else, anytime he likes, so why not actively seek it.
Next thing you will find it has now become a regular thing.. he goes out with his mates, has sex, spends money on her, comes home.

One day it won't be a different "her". It will be the same "her" and he is going to mentally check out of your relationship which will crumble.

..and you will be sitting at home alone wondering how he fell out of love with you.

dumdumduuuummmmm · 19/05/2022 07:44

MN is a very special place where cheating is considered the worst crime. Beyond violent crime (against a 3rd party), fraud, probably eating children. I agree with you OP. There are worse things people move on from successfully

Swipe left for the next trending thread