Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

House purchase - WWYD

110 replies

Animallover87 · 17/05/2022 18:09

Myself and Fiancee getting married next month. Planning on each selling our flats and buying a house together. I love going on holiday/eating out regularly and would like to hopefully have a baby soon so I think we should buy something quite modest and still have plenty of disposable income. Also I would like the freedom to go part time after baby. DFiancee thinks we should stretch ourselves to the max to get the best house we can as it's an investment for the future and will be worth it as we could get a nice house with lots of space. I just worry about having to worry about money and that I might resent the lack of freedom it will bring. The more we buy the more tied to work we are! AIBU to want to live well below our means so we can enjoy more of life?

OP posts:
Animallover87 · 17/05/2022 19:30

Snoken · 17/05/2022 19:23

I am on your side OP. Given that you have the most expensive years ahead of you with reduced pay during and after maternity leave, combined with nursery fees and increased living expenses I think it would be foolish to stretch yourselves now. It’s no fun living with financial worries in a big house, I’d much rather have money in the bank and be able to work a little less.

I came on here for a range of opinions, but it's nice to be agreed with! 😛

OP posts:
Horseshoe5 · 17/05/2022 19:27

You may have twins, who knows

Animallover87 · 17/05/2022 19:26

billy1966 · 17/05/2022 19:23

OP,

I would be careful.
He wants a larger house for a studio?
Not a good enough reason.

He wants to have you living a quiet life because of his studio?

What about if you have a child and interest rates are higher and you are stuck without any flexibility with your job.

Not a chance would I be committing to beyond my means for the reasons you have stated.

Does he really want a child?
Sounds like his hobby is a priority.

In his current flat (from when before we met) an entire room is dedicated to his art supplies. It feels unfair to ask him to get rid of this when it's his only hobby. He definitely wants a child and his art doesn't take over our time together or anything. He does it in his free time to relax but always puts me first.

OP posts:
Animallover87 · 17/05/2022 19:23

moomintrolls · 17/05/2022 19:11

You hit the nail on the head.

Firstly a mortgage (death grip) ties you to earning enough to cover it, or your home is repossessed. The liability is huge, often lifelong, and on purpose, so you cannot quit work, ever.

Secondly, living below your means is wise if you ever wish to become wealthy. If you have extra money to invest you could eradicate the need to work at all.

Your partner is being very short-sighted. Introduce him to Robert Kyasaki, Rich Dad, Poor Dad. It could transform him. He is living how we are told, not what is smart.

This is EXACTLY how I feel.

OP posts:
Snoken · 17/05/2022 19:23

I am on your side OP. Given that you have the most expensive years ahead of you with reduced pay during and after maternity leave, combined with nursery fees and increased living expenses I think it would be foolish to stretch yourselves now. It’s no fun living with financial worries in a big house, I’d much rather have money in the bank and be able to work a little less.

billy1966 · 17/05/2022 19:23

OP,

I would be careful.
He wants a larger house for a studio?
Not a good enough reason.

He wants to have you living a quiet life because of his studio?

What about if you have a child and interest rates are higher and you are stuck without any flexibility with your job.

Not a chance would I be committing to beyond my means for the reasons you have stated.

Does he really want a child?
Sounds like his hobby is a priority.

Animallover87 · 17/05/2022 19:21

Passanotherjaffacake · 17/05/2022 19:06

We bought a starter home with a plan to have our little ones there and then move. It got cramped and we became unhappy in a relatively few number of years.

just bought our big, proper family home in great school catchments and we are all so much happier now! Was a huge stretch (and we were lucky we could stretch) and the jump was bigger then it would have been if we had just bought the current house straight away (if that makes sense).

my DH used to worry about mortgages and stuff and that is why we bought the smaller house even though I knew we would make a better investment with somewhere bigger (and not have had to move). He has acknowledged that maybe it wasn’t the best of his decisions.

so I’m with your DH.

Thank you, this is helpful!

OP posts:
moomintrolls · 17/05/2022 19:11

You hit the nail on the head.

Firstly a mortgage (death grip) ties you to earning enough to cover it, or your home is repossessed. The liability is huge, often lifelong, and on purpose, so you cannot quit work, ever.

Secondly, living below your means is wise if you ever wish to become wealthy. If you have extra money to invest you could eradicate the need to work at all.

Your partner is being very short-sighted. Introduce him to Robert Kyasaki, Rich Dad, Poor Dad. It could transform him. He is living how we are told, not what is smart.

Qwill · 17/05/2022 19:11

I would allow yourselves a contingency for interest rate hikes. What ever the mortgage repayment is, double it and make sure that’s still affordable. Especially if you are going to have a child as the first few years can be very expensive in terms of nursery (ours is more than our mortgage!). Also, I would look at schools, something we didn’t really consider when we moved!

JustFrustrated · 17/05/2022 19:08

I personally think anyone who stretches them selves to the max for a house is absurd.

Where possible you should be looking at being able to cover the running costs inc. mortgage on just one salary.

I don't think any sensible lender would allow anyone to max themselves now.

I say where possible because I know I live in a low-cost housing area, 220k here would buy you a lovely 3 bed, with a nice garden.

I agree with a Pp about looking at the plot.

Since buying ours our entire lifestyle changed. We both took new jobs working from home. Having a big garden with a garage meant we converted the garage into a home office. Makes a world of difference.

Passanotherjaffacake · 17/05/2022 19:06

We bought a starter home with a plan to have our little ones there and then move. It got cramped and we became unhappy in a relatively few number of years.

just bought our big, proper family home in great school catchments and we are all so much happier now! Was a huge stretch (and we were lucky we could stretch) and the jump was bigger then it would have been if we had just bought the current house straight away (if that makes sense).

my DH used to worry about mortgages and stuff and that is why we bought the smaller house even though I knew we would make a better investment with somewhere bigger (and not have had to move). He has acknowledged that maybe it wasn’t the best of his decisions.

so I’m with your DH.

Hankunamatata · 17/05/2022 19:06

Really depends on your personalities. We went for the more affordable option and got stuck due to several issues. On plus side the house is very affordable, I could go very part time when we had disabled dc and affording was never a worry. However we have been out priced of the area in terms of moving, house hasn't gained much value due to area.
I do regret slightly not pushing a bit more in terms of moving somewhere bigger but no one knows the future

basketb · 17/05/2022 19:01

I'd say 300k on 80k is conservative

Calmdown14 · 17/05/2022 18:55

Could you compromise by buying something with future potential? So focus on plot rather than just the house?

Neither of you is wrong but no one knows what the future holds so it's hard to say which approach is best.

I think that if you can get a three bed with room for improvement (not a complete renovation project but something that can be done in future decades) then there's no need to overcommit.

I'd then overpay the mortgage from the beginning so you are making similar payments to a bigger property but can cut them for mat leave or when you have a child

Animallover87 · 17/05/2022 18:53

DeandraLove · 17/05/2022 18:46

What sort of houses are you envisioning btw? Does he want, say a 5 bed? And you're happy with a 3 bed? What does a 'nice' house mean? What's the upper limit of affordability?

I'm happy with a 3 bed and he is too as long as it's big enough but as PP said, a lot of them are quite pokey. He has quite a lot of stuff and wants a whole room for an art studio. So he would prefer bigger. We are both on around 40k per year and he would like a 300k house and I would prefer more like 220ish.

OP posts:
basketb · 17/05/2022 18:49

Wow! This definitely puts doubts in my head about my perspective then lol.

Whilst I don't think it's a bad idea to stretch yourself now (frequent moving is expensive & if prices rise it's harder to move up the ladder) with the way the economy is looking I wouldn't presume we will see anything like the historic growth in house prices.

DeandraLove · 17/05/2022 18:46

What sort of houses are you envisioning btw? Does he want, say a 5 bed? And you're happy with a 3 bed? What does a 'nice' house mean? What's the upper limit of affordability?

Riverlee · 17/05/2022 18:42

Neither of you are wrong, but you need to sit down and develop a life plan. Ie. When do you plan to buy a house, have children, etc. it’s a grown up conversation, but needs to be had.

The budget planner on Moneysavingexpert is good for working out expenditure etc.

Animallover87 · 17/05/2022 18:41

DeandraLove · 17/05/2022 18:37

With the BoE base rate being increased (yet again!), costs soaring and the UK heading into recession.. it's a bad time to be extending yourself.
Once you factor all these rises in what you 'can afford' isn't going to be that much.
Earning 30K each for example gives a range of £168,000 and £252,000.
You'd both be U to insist on either extreme, but wise to stick to the lower end (180 at most maybe?)

Especially since a lot of '3 beds' are 2 proper sixed bedroom and a box...

Totally agree. Everything is getting more expensive and it terrifies me.

OP posts:
DeandraLove · 17/05/2022 18:41

Nothappyatwork · 17/05/2022 18:31

In 2003 my ex and I will look into that exactly the same as you were only we already had three children in tow we were gonna sell both our houses down south and buy one in Altrincham for 445,000 this would’ve meant that I would’ve had to have continued working full time but we need into paid school fees because the local Primary‘s were excellent might of needed to reconsider for secondary but as it happened actually all three were capable of passing the 11+ so basically we would’ve been in an amazing position .

I got the hormonal heebie-jeebies I’m basically did not want to get into that much debt we would’ve been borrowing about £300k

That house is now worth £1.1 million.
upon getting divorced literally we both could’ve bought a house with the proceeds in the profits. Outright.
what actually ended up happening was we bought a house in a much cheaper area for 250,000 and nearly 20 years later in the boom that we’ve just had it sold for 280.

I wish I could go back in time.

where did you buy?
I rent in Altrincham currently but it's too expensive... tying in what you said.

Honestly a lot of people were lucky, but that's the way it goes. You were lucky to have kept your jobs, many lost theirs in 2008 and their lovely houses along with it, no matter what the prices are now.

No matter what a future house price is a huge mortgage still has to be paid off,..meaning less £££ for other stuff.

Fleurty · 17/05/2022 18:40

If it was me I would want to buy somewhere that was suitable as a long term house. Moving is expensive, when youre buying and selling it can cost £10k+ for solicitors, movers, stamp duty EA fees.

I would stretch myself as far as it took to try and make sure it was a long term house and I wouldn't have to move again in a few years time.

Animallover87 · 17/05/2022 18:39

Nothappyatwork · 17/05/2022 18:31

In 2003 my ex and I will look into that exactly the same as you were only we already had three children in tow we were gonna sell both our houses down south and buy one in Altrincham for 445,000 this would’ve meant that I would’ve had to have continued working full time but we need into paid school fees because the local Primary‘s were excellent might of needed to reconsider for secondary but as it happened actually all three were capable of passing the 11+ so basically we would’ve been in an amazing position .

I got the hormonal heebie-jeebies I’m basically did not want to get into that much debt we would’ve been borrowing about £300k

That house is now worth £1.1 million.
upon getting divorced literally we both could’ve bought a house with the proceeds in the profits. Outright.
what actually ended up happening was we bought a house in a much cheaper area for 250,000 and nearly 20 years later in the boom that we’ve just had it sold for 280.

I wish I could go back in time.

Wow! This definitely puts doubts in my head about my perspective then lol.

OP posts:
DeandraLove · 17/05/2022 18:37

With the BoE base rate being increased (yet again!), costs soaring and the UK heading into recession.. it's a bad time to be extending yourself.
Once you factor all these rises in what you 'can afford' isn't going to be that much.
Earning 30K each for example gives a range of £168,000 and £252,000.
You'd both be U to insist on either extreme, but wise to stick to the lower end (180 at most maybe?)

Especially since a lot of '3 beds' are 2 proper sixed bedroom and a box...

cloudchaos · 17/05/2022 18:36

If you're going to "max" yourselves out, make sure you fix your mortgage for as long as you can and factor in any potential interest rate increases into your calculations to make sure you can still afford it. Interest rates are only going one way.

Animallover87 · 17/05/2022 18:31

Yes 100% on board.

OP posts: