Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

House purchase - WWYD

110 replies

Animallover87 · 17/05/2022 18:09

Myself and Fiancee getting married next month. Planning on each selling our flats and buying a house together. I love going on holiday/eating out regularly and would like to hopefully have a baby soon so I think we should buy something quite modest and still have plenty of disposable income. Also I would like the freedom to go part time after baby. DFiancee thinks we should stretch ourselves to the max to get the best house we can as it's an investment for the future and will be worth it as we could get a nice house with lots of space. I just worry about having to worry about money and that I might resent the lack of freedom it will bring. The more we buy the more tied to work we are! AIBU to want to live well below our means so we can enjoy more of life?

OP posts:
Treacletoots · 17/05/2022 20:46

Oh and DH is an artist! He built himself a studio in the garden of our last house and has taken over the garage in our new one. He doesn't need a spare room

One thing that we both agreed on when we mortgaged our souls was that we needed to insure ourselves up to the hilt. Life insurance, income protection and Illness insurance. You can't predict everything but this will soften the blow in a few circumstances!

basketb · 17/05/2022 20:45

Your mortgage of 250k will be a small
% of your salary. Surely you live in a relatively cheap area if 300k buys a big property. Cheaper areas tend to have lower salaries so you also must earn above the average for the area.

Animallover87 · 17/05/2022 20:45

@Treacletoots This is the dilemma 😭

OP posts:
WomanStanleyWoman2 · 17/05/2022 20:44

He has quite a lot of stuff and wants a whole room for an art studio.

This is what would worry me. Is he saying ‘More space is a better investment’ when what he actually means is ‘I don’t want to get rid of any of my stuff’? Would he regularly use and get genuine pleasure from a full-time alert studio - or would it end up as overspill for junk, like so many formal dining rooms people convince themselves they need (and end up frantically clearing out a couple of days before Christmas)?

I get his point about the importance of investment value - but remember, added value isn’t just about space. Would your four-bed budget for the areas where you are looking buy you a three-bed in a nicer area, or one predicted to grow in value? Could it get you closer to good schools, seeing as you’re planning on having a child?

By all means don’t dismiss extra space - but make sure you’re paying for it for the right reasons.

Animallover87 · 17/05/2022 20:44

@Singinghollybob about 1300 per month as opposed to 750ish. Better LTV with the smaller house so better interest rate.

OP posts:
Animallover87 · 17/05/2022 20:42

DeandraLove · 17/05/2022 20:34

300K is a very reasonable budget. You'll presumably have a chunky deposit from flat sales.. meaning that you'll only need to borrow 250K at most. I thought your DP wanted to do something ridiculous like buy a 500K property!

It would be different if you have to scrimp and save for a deposit.

You may also find that by the time you get around to buying... a few months from now... house prices may have rocketed, although hopefully the rise in your flat prices should mirror this.

Property markets are very localised. Where I am, desirable houses have become 20K more expensive over the last 3 months. Houses are going for well above asking. We can't afford anything in a 'naice area with good schools' anymore, which we could just about have managed 2 years ago, so it's now a question of what we want to give up. Space? School/city distance?

You need to sit down, make lists of what you want, and work out the figures.

"Only 250k at most" you are correct with your figures (hopefully deposit wise) but to me that seems HUGE! Especially when our incomes aren't going up (no promotions on the horizon etc) and we will (hopefully) have a baby today for on less income than we have now. It's useful for me to get other perspectives on it though so thank you for responding to my post 🙂

OP posts:
DeandraLove · 17/05/2022 20:40

Also (although I'll probably take a flaming for this) it can be difficult to get used to budgeting if you had lots of disposable income.
I used to be able to buy whatever I fancied without thinking too much about it. Like a takeaway on bad work days, or impromptu drinks with mates.

However having kids changes all that... they cost so much, and there's ALWAYS something that needs buying. Also, you'll hardly have time to do all of these days out, in the money sink years when childcare costs a fortune. so it doesn't matter that much really.

Singinghollybob · 17/05/2022 20:39

What would the difference be in monthly mortgage payments between the 280,000 house and 300,000 house? What would that mean re: standard of living for you both; how much of an impact would it have on you and would you be severely limited in how you live?
What % of your disposable income does it represent?

Treacletoots · 17/05/2022 20:35

We did the 'buy a modest house' initially and for the same reasons. 2 years later, a baby in tow in a very cramped house that was totally unsuitable and had to wait another 2 years to buy the bigger house we needed until the 30 hours free childcare kicked in and our childcare dropped from more than #1k a month to £400.

There's no right or wrong answer. Can you afford the larger house if you get pregnant and are on maternity pay, followed by eye watering childcare costs/single income.

Can you stick with living in a modest house' if a baby does come along and all their shit.

I don't envy your decision.

DeandraLove · 17/05/2022 20:34

300K is a very reasonable budget. You'll presumably have a chunky deposit from flat sales.. meaning that you'll only need to borrow 250K at most. I thought your DP wanted to do something ridiculous like buy a 500K property!

It would be different if you have to scrimp and save for a deposit.

You may also find that by the time you get around to buying... a few months from now... house prices may have rocketed, although hopefully the rise in your flat prices should mirror this.

Property markets are very localised. Where I am, desirable houses have become 20K more expensive over the last 3 months. Houses are going for well above asking. We can't afford anything in a 'naice area with good schools' anymore, which we could just about have managed 2 years ago, so it's now a question of what we want to give up. Space? School/city distance?

You need to sit down, make lists of what you want, and work out the figures.

Animallover87 · 17/05/2022 20:33

Aaaabbbcccc · 17/05/2022 20:27

This logic does not work on two fairly low salaries with a plan to have a baby.

Not sure what bit you're referring to?

OP posts:
Animallover87 · 17/05/2022 20:32

Isonthecase · 17/05/2022 20:24

We bought a smaller house a few years ago as we knew we'd be paying an extra mortgage in childcare and we could buy bigger once that was over. Most people only stay in their first house 5 years or so and it minimises the stamp duty wasted when you upgrade. I do occasionally get pangs of what if but equally well our lives are much less stressful with a smaller house and more disposable income. Can you actually even afford childcare of maybe £1000 a month with a £300k house?

Not without having to survive on beans and toast. This is what concerns me. I'm used to having plenty of disposable income to spend on days out etc.

OP posts:
KarrotKake · 17/05/2022 20:29

Look at a full time childcare place round you, and factor paying that plus all current expenses. See what that looks like on current salaries.

We did your preference (in a cheap part of the uk) at the top of the housing market in 2007. It's done us very nicely (as in property wise, currently trying to sell for 25k more than we bought it for) and made decisions like me taking a massive pay cut possible.

I dont fancy the life we would have had if we'd borrowed what the bank was offering.

Aaaabbbcccc · 17/05/2022 20:27

This logic does not work on two fairly low salaries with a plan to have a baby.

Aaaabbbcccc · 17/05/2022 20:25

Have you looked at stamp duty? Its outrageous. But now, max out, get a long fixed mortgage and thank yourselves in the future. Part time is a trap too. It is worse than you think.

Isonthecase · 17/05/2022 20:24

We bought a smaller house a few years ago as we knew we'd be paying an extra mortgage in childcare and we could buy bigger once that was over. Most people only stay in their first house 5 years or so and it minimises the stamp duty wasted when you upgrade. I do occasionally get pangs of what if but equally well our lives are much less stressful with a smaller house and more disposable income. Can you actually even afford childcare of maybe £1000 a month with a £300k house?

user1471457751 · 17/05/2022 20:05

He's hardly wanting to push yourselves to the limit. Even with zero deposit (which wouldn't happen) your mortgage would be less than 4x your salaries. So by the time you account for the equity from your current places you will have a very modest mortgage. More than enough for you to take some time away from work to have a child. Particularly as you say you are only having one.

Ireallycantthinkofagoodone · 17/05/2022 20:04

It’s really important to factor in the costs of buying and selling once you outgrow your smaller property. It can be huge. Also, the percentage difference in price makes it harder to go up the ladder in future. I would definitely go for the ‘family, long term house’ as soon as possible. Cheaper in the long run.

MRex · 17/05/2022 19:59

You're both estimable reasonable, it's just about choices.

We decided to get a decent house that needed renovation, so we didn't have the mortgage issue when just about to get pregnant (planned and lucky) but with the ability to improve the property as our own pace for expenses. The leap from our house price to the next size bracket is much larger than yours because it's two steps between what we bought and what we ended up with renovated. The decision about buying even larger was a lot easier, because we would have had such significant additional costs that it would have prevented me from having much maternity leave. I haven't regretted the extra time off.

I would work on a compromise between you; e.g. look for a property you can expand; large garden for a future extension / garden office, or suitable for loft conversion. It's also useful to consider what shape of house will work best for you specifically; some like everything open plan but you might prefer properties with a garage he could convert for use (put velux windows in the roof for light), or an extra reception room downstairs, or one of those attics that isn't tall enough for an official bedroom but great for a studio. Ideally, you'd get more space for your money when there are features you can use that aren't worth quite as much to someone without a plan for how to use quirky space.

olympicsrock · 17/05/2022 19:57

Agree that it’s worth stretching yourself . Multiple moves are expensive. I would stretch yourselves if you can. In reality you won’t be eating out much with a young child - but you might want to work less.

D0lphine · 17/05/2022 19:55

I actually think there is a really good mid point for you and your DH.

You just need to sit down and go through the numbers.

girlmom21 · 17/05/2022 19:50

Why don't you start living like you're on part time earnings plus maxed out on a mortgage now - and put everything you'd be losing or spending into a savings account? Then you'll get an idea of how comfortable or uncomfortable you'll be.

Animallover87 · 17/05/2022 19:44

RinklyRomaine · 17/05/2022 19:36

I think you need to compromise. He wants a studio, you'd like to go part time. CoL increases and BoE raises are scary, but moving more than you need because you've underestimated how much space you need is expensive.

We've moved twice in the last 5 years, then had a delightful surprise baby and have just finished extending purchase number two. Ultimately worth it, but two lots of fees, stamp duty and everything else even before extending was eye watering.

Yes. I think it's important that we get somewhere that we could see ourselves long term. Neither of us want a stepping stone house.

OP posts:
GCMM · 17/05/2022 19:44

One room for his art studio and he plans to continue with his art in his free time? After the baby is born and he's still working full time to pay for the bigger house, when is he anticipating having all this free time? If he doesn't do his share of child care at evenings and weekends, you'll end up doing it all...I would definitely say go for the modest house, leave yourselves some financial breathing space and one or both of you reduce your working hours to spend time with your child. I never regretted going part time after my first child was born. It meant we didn't have as much money coming in as we might have, but so what? We had enough and I valued the time with my children more. I appreciate that not everyone can afford to make that decision, but if you can, grab the opportunity with both hands!

RinklyRomaine · 17/05/2022 19:36

I think you need to compromise. He wants a studio, you'd like to go part time. CoL increases and BoE raises are scary, but moving more than you need because you've underestimated how much space you need is expensive.

We've moved twice in the last 5 years, then had a delightful surprise baby and have just finished extending purchase number two. Ultimately worth it, but two lots of fees, stamp duty and everything else even before extending was eye watering.