Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feel stupid to think I could ever look good

60 replies

Wertya · 17/05/2022 14:47

I lost 100lbs, then spent 5 years running and lifting weights. I have a healthy BMI but I look big.

I have very short legs, big boobs and a saggy apron of skin on my stomach that nothing except surgery can help. I have to wear high waist and even then look pregnant (which is extra insult as I'm infertile).

I know I should focus on the health benefits but I can't. I am truly gutted I don't look better. I ran a half marathon last week and the race photos show me how I look - thick-set and wobbly, just so embarrassing.

I've worked so hard. AIBU to be gutted there's no more 'improvement' I can do? I can't change my body type/shape.

I feel like not eating until I eventually look slim.

OP posts:
Fossiltop · 17/05/2022 19:41

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 17/05/2022 15:44

I'm sorry that you are suffering in this way OP Flowers

You are loved and seen as attractive by others but you are very unhappy with the way you think you look and you focus on the things you dislike most.

This unhappiness with the way you look has persisted despite great changes. (Well done on those by the way.)

Is it possible that your unhappiness is really less about your looks and more about the trauma of your past?

Is this something you could get help with?
I think that you might look into this before considering surgery.
( Surgery will not help you change your view of yourself any more than weight-loss/fittness did.)

Yes this Flowers
Speaking as someone with body dysmorphic disorder, it's never really about the way you look.

Wertya · 17/05/2022 19:35

Thank you so much for your replies - honestly they're all much appreciated.

I agree that my self esteem is low, and it's hard for me to accept I've done well as this feels arrogant - I've just been lucky enough to have the time/opportunity to learn about nutrition and then be able to exercise.

To answer PP - I've had some trauma therapy which helped, and CBT for anxiety, which was brilliant.

I think I struggle to have a better self image because the truth is that I have an ugly body. And I wish I could focus on strength and progress, but all I see is a flabby, saggy, unattractive body. No accomplishments are helping. :(

I don't even want to be attractive for the purpose of attracting anyone, I love my husband very much.

How I look takes up a lot of my thoughts. Mirror checking, comparing, checking the size of my stomach, changing outfits a hundred times, I feel like if only I was happy with my body, I'd have my mind back and much more energy.

I just feel so gutted that I've worked so hard for years and years now, but I've not even come close to looking slim/fit and healthy.

OP posts:
GallstoneGlory · 17/05/2022 17:54

Well done on the weight loss. When I managed to get from obesity into a healthy BMI I will admit I was not super thrilled about my looks. I could hide the problem areas with clothes to some extent. I then got into weight lifting quite seriously (not competitive but I can lift more than my body weight now) when I hired a personal trainer. I wasn't doing it for looks but for health (peri meno age and concerns about osteoporosis) but it has made a big difference. It has really pulled in my waist though I have lost very little further weight and am still BMI 24. You say you have been doing weights but have really been going for it and lifting heavy? Might be worth a try. It's a shame to have come so far and still be so unhappy with how you look. Although you should also consider whether you have some elements of body dysmorphia. I realise not much can be done about the apron without surgery but you may be being overly-critical and maybe some counselling could help?

Movingonup22 · 17/05/2022 17:39

What do you think would change about your lifeblood you looked differently?

you have a husband who loves you and finds you attractive so you’ve already got the thing most women would want they think attractiveness could influence.

I suspect this is very much still about the unresolved underlying trauma that led to your weight gain. And you can’t think your way out of that!!

youvw done the amazing work of losing weight - maybe now focus on trying to come to terms with trauma?

that said I personally think a boob reduction and excess skin removal can make people feel physically more comfortable

Illstartexercisingtomorrow · 17/05/2022 17:29

Franklyfrost · 17/05/2022 16:19
This isn’t something surgery can fix. You’ve lost a whole person in body weight, developed good exercise habits and have run half marathon. Please be proud of those achievements. Work with your body, it’s not going anywhere without you so you might as well be friends. I know these things are easier said than done but maybe your at the point in your journey where it’s time to work on your inner voice.

This in buckets.

I don’t know you but I’m proud of you. I had some body image issues for a while and had to over come horrible injuries to be able to exercise again.
I have learnt to love my body. My legs will never be longer or daintier, I’ll never look graceful in photos and my boobs are always going to be a bit saggy. But I’m so grateful and proud my body has served me so well and allowed me the joy of being able to run again.

pattish · 17/05/2022 17:20

Well done OP, you have done an amazing thing for your health and you should be so proud of yourself!

Weight training is brilliant, but it does build muscle, so maybe you could reduce that and try something that tones without bulking? I know people say it doesn’t necessarily bulk you but in some people’s experience it really does.

I have short legs too btw.

I’ve found Pilates the best thing for toning myself. I genuinely look better since starting it as it seems to tone you in all the right places.

Also look up the slim legs programme - Rachael Attard. She looks at your body shape and gives you exercises that are suitable.

I understand that you just want to feel happy in your own skin 🙂

ditavonteesed · 17/05/2022 17:02

Wow you have done amazingly and should feel so absolutely proud of yourself, you ran a half marathon! And it sounds like your dh is lovely as well. I agree with the poster above that if friends don't think you look good they will usually comment on your dress or your shoes not actually tell you you look amazing so I bet you look amazing.

picklemewalnuts · 17/05/2022 16:45

That's why I said 'I don't believe...' @TheGlitterati. It made you happy, it may not make OP happy- or indeed it may.

I have lost 80+lbs, and have the apron, and all the other frustrations about my appearance. My personal concern is more about how I can be sure I won't slip back and pile the weight on, whether my tendency to binge eat is best controlled by controlling my weight or by working my mind... some of the methods that are keeping me at target weight may be perpetuating the deprivation/binge cycle.

There is so much to consider, in managing our physical and emotional health.

I expressed an opinion. Only OP can know. It's also not unreasonable for her husband to fear losing her, and all that involves, over an elective surgery.

Franklyfrost · 17/05/2022 16:19

This isn’t something surgery can fix. You’ve lost a whole person in body weight, developed good exercise habits and have run half marathon. Please be proud of those achievements. Work with your body, it’s not going anywhere without you so you might as well be friends. I know these things are easier said than done but maybe your at the point in your journey where it’s time to work on your inner voice.

TheGlitterati · 17/05/2022 16:17

@picklemewalnuts you really can’t say that unless you’ve actually been in the OPs position. No amount of therapy was ever going to make me happy with my apron of skin. But trust me the surgery made me very happy indeed. It doesn’t even cross my mind any more to worry about what I’m wearing or what the weather is doing. There is something freeing in confidence.

SleeplessInEngland · 17/05/2022 16:14

Get surgery for your skin. You've done the hard work and you deserve that, at least.

picklemewalnuts · 17/05/2022 16:10

I don't believe surgery will make you happy.

You've survived trauma and fought your way to fitness after obesity. That shows incredible strength.

Have you considered therapy? It may help with image issues, as well as self esteem, trauma recovery etc.

RaginaPhalange · 17/05/2022 16:02

I would go down the surgery route if I was that unhappy. Your dh can have his opinion about it but at the end of the day it's your body your choice.

TheGlitterati · 17/05/2022 15:59

Wow well done Op! That’s amazing.

if the problem is skin, it doesn’t matter how much you starve yourself. Could you afford surgery? I had a tummy tuck years ago and it changed my life.

Surfsupsidedown · 17/05/2022 15:53

I would go down the surgery root to be honest, if you really aren’t happy.
I really think life is so precious and of course there are risks involved but if you can change something to help you feel better I would explore it

RoseslnTheHospital · 17/05/2022 15:46

Would it maybe help to have some nice photos taken wearing your favourite flattering outfit, with hair and makeup done if that's something you'd do? Like a family photoshoot type thing?

No one is going to like a shot of themselves mid half marathon, even those other runners who you're comparing yourself to potentially won't like their pictures being taken in that situation. The fact that you can run a half marathon is amazing, it really is. And I know that this isn't about the physical achievements, but you have done such a great thing for yourself and your health by losing a significant amount of weight and increasing your fitness levels.

cordeliavorkosigan · 17/05/2022 15:45

If you want the surgery and are sure it's the best thing for you, don't let your husband tell you you just can't. It's your body.

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 17/05/2022 15:44

I'm sorry that you are suffering in this way OP Flowers

You are loved and seen as attractive by others but you are very unhappy with the way you think you look and you focus on the things you dislike most.

This unhappiness with the way you look has persisted despite great changes. (Well done on those by the way.)

Is it possible that your unhappiness is really less about your looks and more about the trauma of your past?

Is this something you could get help with?
I think that you might look into this before considering surgery.
( Surgery will not help you change your view of yourself any more than weight-loss/fittness did.)

anon12345anon · 17/05/2022 15:43

Oh Op..... I felt so much sympathy when I read this.
I had to look at what lbs are in stone (Blush) and that is an absolutely amazing weight loss!

Obviously you have low self esteem, but you really need to work on that!
As already said, you are obviously fit and healthy, with all your exerciseSmile

I've just been on holiday on my own, and I saw all sorts of shapes of women.......skinny ladies , bigger women..... and no one cared - honestly.....
I'm just getting to the age now, where I genuinely don't care what people think of my physical state - It's bloody liberating!!

I have a bit of a tummy, and I cannot get rid of it.....even when I was 2 stone lighter! (and the same as you, I'm infertile and have also noted the irony of looking pregnant when I'm bloated Hmm)

Anyway, no advice ...just wishing you the best Flowers

Lastqueenofscotland2 · 17/05/2022 15:37

NOONE looks good in race photos
my DP weighs as much as your average ant and looks weirdly chunky in race photos.
don’t use them as a metric!
you ran a half marathon that is incredible!
instead of focussing on how you look what about trying to improve your time or run a full within x years instead?

Veol · 17/05/2022 15:35

I used to look chunky and weirdly big shouldered in race photos even when I was a slim size 8. Don’t use them as a measure!

Crimeismymiddlename · 17/05/2022 15:33

Your friends and family say you look wonderful, you probably do. In my experience if you look a bit shit people don’t say anything, or compliment your shoes or handbag.

NiqueNique · 17/05/2022 15:29

I also should have said congratulations on your fantastic achievement(s), you’ve shown great physical, emotional and mental strength.

Wertya · 17/05/2022 15:27

@Surfsupsidedown I have no more risk than the usual that you'd undergo for breast reduction & tummy tuck - the previous incident was purely one in a million, during a routine operation (gallbladder removal).

DH is not a massively complimentary person naturally but if I ask him, he says I look wonderful and he gets very annoyed when I say how upset my body makes me. He says the saggy skin is proof pf how far I've come, but for me it's a bitter reminder of my past.

I became overweight as a very young teenager after traumatic abuse, and spent the majority of my 20s obese and so have never felt attractive. I had hoped the weight loss would help but I feel so ugly. I know it's vain and I'm incredibly lucky to have a functioning body, I have tried so hard to be grateful for it.

OP posts:
Bunce1 · 17/05/2022 15:25

i look like a bloated beetroot/Mrs Trunchbull in sweats when I am exercising!!!

I would NEVER use that as a benchmark for how I look. It’s when I look the worst!

well done on your weight loss I bet you FEEL amazing.