Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s the general MN verdict on donor eggs?

460 replies

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 14:22

The general critical re-examination of surrogacy is quite evident, and I have my own views on that, which I’ll keep quiet for the purposes of this thread.

Now I find myself chewing over other fertility treatment. I’ve had fertility treatment myself and so have family members. So I have a sense of how private clinics put you on a conveyor belt and normalise things.

What is the general view on donor eggs & embryos (implanted into the birth mother and gestated by her)?

Im trying really hard not to bias the result so have tossed a coin to assign YABU/YANBU to viewpoints. Don’t read into that.

YANBU = Donor gametes are ethically fine.
YABU = Donor gametes are problematic.

OP posts:
Organictangerine · 17/05/2022 22:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TheKeatingFive · 17/05/2022 22:10

I feel they are fundamentally different things but that feels unfair.

From the point of view of the resulting child they are the same.

From the POV of the donor, one is much less impactful on the body than the other.

ChocChipPancake · 17/05/2022 22:07

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ on OP's request.

Clymene · 17/05/2022 22:06

VestaTilley · 17/05/2022 21:52

I dislike it for many of the same reasons I loathe surrogacy - it separates a mother from her baby, cuts mothers out of the pregnancy and birth process, and treats important things as throwaway commodities.

It’s unethical in my view, and something that donors will probably find themselves often regretting years down the line.

I support IVF, but it should be with your own eggs - and not colluding in surrogacy (human trafficking) either.

Do you feel the sane about sperm donation? I feel they are fundamentally different things but that feels unfair.

ChocChipPancake · 17/05/2022 21:59

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ on OP's request.

TheKeatingFive · 17/05/2022 21:58

Eggs are not babies. No different in my view to donating blood

I don't think this stands up to much scrutiny. An egg will ultimately be a person with half the donor's DNA. Thats very significantly different to donating blood.

CounsellorTroi · 17/05/2022 21:56

slugHell · 17/05/2022 14:45

The problem I have with them isn't on the receiving end (the expecting parents) but the donor end. Often young women are targeted to sell/donate their eggs and it is always portrayed as an easy way to make money, comparable to sperm donation. In reality it takes weeks of preparatory hormone injections followed by invasive surgery (and they always take more eggs than they really need, to ensure the best chances of success) and a recovery period which is not adequately compensated for. I really do think it's a terrible example of the commodification of women's bodies.

This. There is a dark exploitative side to egg donation.

housemaus · 17/05/2022 21:53

Eggs are not babies. No different in my view to donating blood, or if you want an example that requires a similar level of physical 'commitment' from the donor, like donating a piece of kidney.

I also have no issue with embryos, but could see why some would. For eggs, I genuinely can't see the issue,

VestaTilley · 17/05/2022 21:52

I dislike it for many of the same reasons I loathe surrogacy - it separates a mother from her baby, cuts mothers out of the pregnancy and birth process, and treats important things as throwaway commodities.

It’s unethical in my view, and something that donors will probably find themselves often regretting years down the line.

I support IVF, but it should be with your own eggs - and not colluding in surrogacy (human trafficking) either.

Sycamor · 17/05/2022 21:31

@AliceAbsolum your story is my story. I'm sure ur as thankful for your family as I am for mine. And if I were to ask my kids their opinion I'm sure they would be as grateful to our donor as I am.

imperialminty · 17/05/2022 21:29

@ChocChipPancake Because having a child is not a human right, let alone a medical condition. I’m not saying those situations aren’t very sad but life is extremely unfair and we have a health service that was not designed to support many things that it is currently being asked to and almost everything is more important than funding IVF. In a world where we’re currently unable to offer many treatments for illnesses such as cancer and MS and thus have some of the worse survival rates of western countries, we should not be funding people trying to have children.

Teder · 17/05/2022 21:23

spongedog · 17/05/2022 21:18

I haven't read the thread. But it's simple. Thank you dear donor mum - and I hoped the shared treatment worked for you too. Lots of love.

But our story was from before the law changed in 2005. Now that opened up the current situation in the UK - which basically allows any infertile family to travel anywhere in the world - buy eggs - and no-one knows. Or for gay male couples to travel to other countries and literally bring babies and children back into the UK without proper legal documentation. Now all of that really isnt OK. Egg sharing was a wonderful MUTUAL arrangement between infertile families.

Is it truly mutual sharing if a woman can only afford IVF if she donates eggs? What if she is sadly unable to conceive and birth a biological child but her egg leads to a successful human for another family? I don’t know, I’ve not been in that position. Just thinking really.
I am pro donor as I support someone close to me going through it. It’s certainly not without ethical questions though.

spongedog · 17/05/2022 21:18

I haven't read the thread. But it's simple. Thank you dear donor mum - and I hoped the shared treatment worked for you too. Lots of love.

But our story was from before the law changed in 2005. Now that opened up the current situation in the UK - which basically allows any infertile family to travel anywhere in the world - buy eggs - and no-one knows. Or for gay male couples to travel to other countries and literally bring babies and children back into the UK without proper legal documentation. Now all of that really isnt OK. Egg sharing was a wonderful MUTUAL arrangement between infertile families.

Norgie · 17/05/2022 21:17

I have no thought or feeling on egg donation or surrogacy either way.
I was fortunate to be able to conceive my children naturally. Not everyone has that good fortune and I can only imagine how heartbreaking that must be.
If someone desperate for a child of their own wants to go down that route to achieve this, and someone else is prepared to donate either their eggs or body to allow that to happen, then who am I to criticise.

WalkerWalking · 17/05/2022 21:14

Mossstitch · 17/05/2022 20:58

To me it's just like eggs on the supermarket shelf, they are never going to become chicks. It's the combining with a sperm (which nobody has a problem with the donation of) and every cell is nourished/grown by the woman who eventually gives birth and becomes the loving mother. End of the story, she is the parent! I don't, however, feel that money should change hands for any of this, it should only be for altruistic reasons that anybody donates, just like blood products.

I have a problem with sperm donation 🙋‍♀️

ChocChipPancake · 17/05/2022 21:14

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ on OP's request.

FourTeaFallOut · 17/05/2022 21:09

I can tell how a post as goady as this on abortion would be taken

It would meet with robust debate. Not people complaining someone had a point of view.

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 21:09

Ifitistobesaid · 17/05/2022 21:07

@Sortilege I expect you and the other posters didn’t notice that because it didn’t make you feel shit to see it. You have the luxury of skimming past. I’m sure anyone who is a parent through donation noticed it.

I never notice the non-contribution posts like “ew” “yawn” etc. I’m surprised anyone does. You certainly can’t let it make you feel bad.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 17/05/2022 21:08

if they don’t like donating eggs, don’t donate an egg.

Its not as simple as that as I'm sure you well know. Some women are manipulated into doing so, or exploited for money. We all have the right to comment on that.

Ifitistobesaid · 17/05/2022 21:07

@Sortilege I expect you and the other posters didn’t notice that because it didn’t make you feel shit to see it. You have the luxury of skimming past. I’m sure anyone who is a parent through donation noticed it.

VeryTrying22 · 17/05/2022 21:07

FourTeaFallOut · 17/05/2022 21:02

They are boards that are managed to build community, the chat forum and aibu are for discussion. You could bring up any one of those topics on this board and expect robust debate with many voices.

People, especially the poorly informed shouldn’t get an outlet to be so nasty about private medical decisions other women make.

I can tell how a post as goady as this on abortion would be taken.

FourTeaFallOut · 17/05/2022 21:07

It’s a topic no one should be entitled to have a view on

Well, there you go. Jesus. But yet, here we are, talking.

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 21:07

That’s complete piffle @VeryTrying22 and not, I’m sorry to say, a very intelligent approach.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 17/05/2022 21:06

but if you honestly think that “there’s no need for discussion on this topic”, please do report the thread to MNHQ.

Exactly. The in-thread policing isn't ok. If you think it's breaking guidelines, report it.

VeryTrying22 · 17/05/2022 21:05

@Sortilege the very fact you posted this shows the side of the coin you fall on this ‘debate’

This post is goady in the worst way possible, offensive to many on this site and allowed certain users a chance to spread nasty, poorly researched and biased views on a matter most have 0 understanding of. It’s a topic no one should be entitled to have a view on, if they don’t like donating eggs, don’t donate an egg. Same applies to most if not all medical decisions for women, and men. It’s not yours or anyone else’s business.

Swipe left for the next trending thread