Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s the general MN verdict on donor eggs?

460 replies

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 14:22

The general critical re-examination of surrogacy is quite evident, and I have my own views on that, which I’ll keep quiet for the purposes of this thread.

Now I find myself chewing over other fertility treatment. I’ve had fertility treatment myself and so have family members. So I have a sense of how private clinics put you on a conveyor belt and normalise things.

What is the general view on donor eggs & embryos (implanted into the birth mother and gestated by her)?

Im trying really hard not to bias the result so have tossed a coin to assign YABU/YANBU to viewpoints. Don’t read into that.

YANBU = Donor gametes are ethically fine.
YABU = Donor gametes are problematic.

OP posts:
Beamur · 18/05/2022 17:24

And proving precisely the point that some posters have repeatedly made. Being a wanted and loved child still doesn't take away the disconnect from not knowing your origins..or from feeling unhappy about it.
These are complicated issues that the children born from these various arrangements will have to consider all their lives. It must be done in a way that acknowledges and reflects that. It can't be only about the wants of the parents but also about the children.

Tandora · 18/05/2022 17:14

BackOnTheBandWagon · 18/05/2022 14:45

I disagree. I'm conceived from donor sperm, and frequently wonder whether I should exist. I'm largely of the opinion that gamete donation shouldn't exist, it's pretty shit not knowing anything about half your biological heritage. However, it's not black and white, and the pain of infertility is awful (plus I think gay people should be able to be parents). Of course you have strong feelings about this, but it doesn't mean it shouldn't be discussed.

wow , you are the child of donor sperm and of the view that sperm donation shouldn’t be allowed ?

movintothecountry · 18/05/2022 17:13

FourTeaFallOut · 18/05/2022 13:09

Well when donor eggs are used it's the pregnant woman is who is considered the legitimate mother.

When a surrogate is used then the genetic providence reigns supreme.

And when a surrogate with donor eggs is used then it's the person taking the baby home.

Basically the paying customer calls the shots and everything else fades to the background.

This very succinctly outlines what I was trying to say. The logic seems to shift depending on what the 'commissioning' person wants it to be.

greencandlelight · 18/05/2022 15:24

The problem I have with them isn't on the receiving end (the expecting parents) but the donor end. Often young women are targeted to sell/donate their eggs and it is always portrayed as an easy way to make money, comparable to sperm donation. In reality it takes weeks of preparatory hormone injections followed by invasive surgery (and they always take more eggs than they really need, to ensure the best chances of success) and a recovery period which is not adequately compensated for. I really do think it's a terrible example of the commodification of women's bodies.

This is also what I have a massive problem with. I remember at uni there was a stand at the freshers fair encouraging girls to sign up! It was sold as both an easy money maker and also 'look at you being such a good generous person'. But no one was told until much later in the process actually how 'easy' it wasn't and the effects of the hormones on the body, recovery etc...so much later in the process that most of the people who signed up had missed the boat to get other student jobs and were thus stuck with this as their only way to make money to meet living expenses.

There also seems to be an air of sexism to it to me. Why was there a stand for women to donate eggs but not for men to donate sperm? Why for sperm donation are men not coerced into it by language about being generous, and kind, and giving another person a 'gift'. It's not the donation of gametes neccessarily I have a problem with but definitely the medical process involved, and how it's marketed to young women feels deceitful and coercive.

BackOnTheBandWagon · 18/05/2022 14:45

Coldilox · 17/05/2022 15:09

I gave birth to my son, he was conceived from my wife’s egg and donor sperm.

My opinion is that other people debating whether my child and thousands like him conceived from donor gametes should exist or not is pretty grotesque.

I disagree. I'm conceived from donor sperm, and frequently wonder whether I should exist. I'm largely of the opinion that gamete donation shouldn't exist, it's pretty shit not knowing anything about half your biological heritage. However, it's not black and white, and the pain of infertility is awful (plus I think gay people should be able to be parents). Of course you have strong feelings about this, but it doesn't mean it shouldn't be discussed.

BetsHilton · 18/05/2022 14:31

Also had to laugh at this really - clearly someone who doesn’t have an iota of knowledge about how ivf works.

For decades she will have it playing on her mind if she has any children out there, out of the hundreds of eggs she probably donated - because young girls respond well to egg stimulation

BetsHilton · 18/05/2022 14:28

@Overthewine A woman, presumably a young student, in desperate need of money, sold her own biological children

if the embryos created using the donor egg and sperm of the husband didn’t implant has this woman sold her own biological children? If not why not?

CounsellorTroi · 18/05/2022 14:03

Equalbutdifferent · 18/05/2022 13:43

I think this illustrates the problem of using the terms genetic and biological interchangeably. A woman who receives a 5 day old blastocyst and carries it to term plays a critical biological role in producing a child, and the environment she provides determines the material outcomes of the pregnancy, including how inherited genes are expressed. There isn't an equivalence with sperm donation.

Up until recently they were one and the same. Now technology has made it possible to be the birth mother of a child without being the genetic mother. It's bound to lead to confusion.

I remember when having IVF I looked down the microscope at the embryos that were about to be implanted in my womb. I was their genetic mother even though I never became their birth mother.

Equalbutdifferent · 18/05/2022 13:43

Onlywomengivebirth · 18/05/2022 13:34

How often are we asked of our family history in a medical setting? Quite often, in my experience. The egg donor is just as much a biological parent as a sperm donor, surely.

I think this illustrates the problem of using the terms genetic and biological interchangeably. A woman who receives a 5 day old blastocyst and carries it to term plays a critical biological role in producing a child, and the environment she provides determines the material outcomes of the pregnancy, including how inherited genes are expressed. There isn't an equivalence with sperm donation.

VeryTrying22 · 18/05/2022 13:43

Teder · 18/05/2022 13:40

For me, there is a huge difference between U.K. egg donors who are traceable and contactable once the child is 18 and using clinics based abroad. Some of these clinics are ethically corrupt. Young women being paid, yet it is cheaper for the recipient of the egg. Plus the anonymity factor.

Unfortunately many on here don’t understand or don’t want to understand the difference.

ignorance has been a driver in many of these replies it seems

Teder · 18/05/2022 13:40

For me, there is a huge difference between U.K. egg donors who are traceable and contactable once the child is 18 and using clinics based abroad. Some of these clinics are ethically corrupt. Young women being paid, yet it is cheaper for the recipient of the egg. Plus the anonymity factor.

Equalbutdifferent · 18/05/2022 13:36

TheKeatingFive · 18/05/2022 13:04

just trying to address the very confused thinking about what constitutes the biological role of a mother.

Well I think most lay people would expect sharing DNA to be a key aspect of being a biological mother.

The language is very confused. It could do with some work to clarify, certainly.

Agreed. There are three biological actors in this scenario, but by convention we assume there can only be two.

Onlywomengivebirth · 18/05/2022 13:34

How often are we asked of our family history in a medical setting? Quite often, in my experience. The egg donor is just as much a biological parent as a sperm donor, surely.

FourTeaFallOut · 18/05/2022 13:09

Well when donor eggs are used it's the pregnant woman is who is considered the legitimate mother.

When a surrogate is used then the genetic providence reigns supreme.

And when a surrogate with donor eggs is used then it's the person taking the baby home.

Basically the paying customer calls the shots and everything else fades to the background.

TheKeatingFive · 18/05/2022 13:04

just trying to address the very confused thinking about what constitutes the biological role of a mother.

Well I think most lay people would expect sharing DNA to be a key aspect of being a biological mother.

The language is very confused. It could do with some work to clarify, certainly.

Equalbutdifferent · 18/05/2022 12:47

@TheKeatingFive absolutely not downplaying the genetic contribution of the donor, just trying to address the very confused thinking about what constitutes the biological role of a mother.

Loopytiles · 18/05/2022 12:47

It’s not ‘donation’ if money is paid (including reduced charges for fertility treatment).

A PP suggested that DC who don’t know the identity of one (or both) of their biological (genetic) parents ‘don't give a shit’. That seems very unlikely: presumably DC (children and when adults) will have diverse thoughts and feelings about their parentage. They’re probably the most important group in this.

TheKeatingFive · 18/05/2022 12:35

The physical (biological) environment she provides determines the outcome of the pregnancy in multiple ways, including influencing the expression of genetic traits (see epigenetics).

While this is true, we seem to be on the edge of undermining the very significant impact of the donor providing 50% of the child's DNA. Whatever the correct term for the donor mother is, her biological impact is extremely important.

Equalbutdifferent · 18/05/2022 12:25

movintothecountry · 18/05/2022 10:27

She may be the legal mother, but she's not the biological mother. That would be the woman who donated her egg.

Nope @moveintothecountry. @cupidstunt22 is quite right. The donor provides gametes. The recipient carries and nurtures the baby in her uterus. The physical (biological) environment she provides determines the outcome of the pregnancy in multiple ways, including influencing the expression of genetic traits (see epigenetics).

Imaginary · 18/05/2022 12:16

Imaginary · 18/05/2022 12:12

I think if a woman used her own eggs for IVF and then donated spare eggs/embryos to someone, that's fine. I mean, otherwise they would just perish, so might as well use them.

Not sure about other cases.

That said, if I imagine myself in that situation, I'm not sure I would have donated my eggs/embryos, because the idea of "my" child (who might look like me) growing up in strangers' family doesn't sit right with me.

Imaginary · 18/05/2022 12:12

I think if a woman used her own eggs for IVF and then donated spare eggs/embryos to someone, that's fine. I mean, otherwise they would just perish, so might as well use them.

Not sure about other cases.

CaptainMerica · 18/05/2022 12:07

I think in general, it is fine.

However, I know someone who received donor eggs through a matching/swap scheme. She had money for IVF, but no viable eggs. The donor had viable eggs, but no money for the IVF she needed. My understanding is that my friend effectively paid for both sets of IVF, and the donor donated half her eggs in return.

While that seemed to work out well for my friend, who has two lovely children from the donor eggs, I do sometimes wonder about her donor. Was her IVF successful? Or is she walking around knowing that she doesn't have children, but she potentially has multiple out there being raised by someone else. I hope not. It just seems wrong, as I can't imagine anyone agreeing to that risk except through desperation.

TheDuchessOfMN · 18/05/2022 11:36

CupidStunt22 · 18/05/2022 10:32

Wrong. Check a dictionary. Biological mother means the woman who gave birth to a child.

www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/biological-mother

That definition would be based on the assumption that the egg was the birth mother’s

Biological = science, meaning the egg. The egg donor is the biological mother of the child. The genetic makeup of the child, comes from that egg.

roadsweep · 18/05/2022 10:52

orwellwasright · 17/05/2022 14:46

As the mother of a child conceived using a donor egg, I'm just rocking up to let you know you've basically invited a load of women to say incredibly offensive things about something I very much doubt they have any personal experience of.

If you're pleased with that, then crack on. Well done, you.

Very defensive

CupidStunt22 · 18/05/2022 10:32

movintothecountry · 18/05/2022 10:27

She may be the legal mother, but she's not the biological mother. That would be the woman who donated her egg.

Wrong. Check a dictionary. Biological mother means the woman who gave birth to a child.

www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/biological-mother