Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s the general MN verdict on donor eggs?

460 replies

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 14:22

The general critical re-examination of surrogacy is quite evident, and I have my own views on that, which I’ll keep quiet for the purposes of this thread.

Now I find myself chewing over other fertility treatment. I’ve had fertility treatment myself and so have family members. So I have a sense of how private clinics put you on a conveyor belt and normalise things.

What is the general view on donor eggs & embryos (implanted into the birth mother and gestated by her)?

Im trying really hard not to bias the result so have tossed a coin to assign YABU/YANBU to viewpoints. Don’t read into that.

YANBU = Donor gametes are ethically fine.
YABU = Donor gametes are problematic.

OP posts:
mucky123 · 19/05/2022 13:22

I think the point here is that it is up to DonorconceivedMe and other DCP to frame the terms of reference themselves. I have my mum and dad. My dad is my dad, he's looked after me his whole life, walked me down the aisle etc. Nothing takes away from that (although the lies have detracted a bit from my current feelings). However, I too object to the term donor. My biological father (I know some prefer genetic) is my parent's sperm donor. He's not mine. He never gave me anything. He is purely and simply my biological father - the person with whom I share 51.2% of my dna. More DNA than I share with my mother or my own kids. I don't think I'd call him a parent though but other DCP might.
I do not like the term donor personally as it lessens what has happened, allows people to minimise the relationship.

In my view it's perfectly possible to have a 3-way (or more) family. My Mum (and her family), my dad (and his family that I am very close to and consider my family despite no bio connections) and my biological father (and the siblings that I have through him). One doesn't detract from the other and we should stop trying to see children as possessions "I brought them up they are MY child" not the donor's child, what did they do? Rather we should instead be open to what they want to frame things as.

I'm sure when social workers try to work through modern adoption these days they emphasise that the birth family may continue to have importance to the adopted child (even if they are adopted at birth). They keep memory boxes and letters from birth parents. I'm sure that if an adopted child wishes to refer to her genetic parents as her birth parents or whatever no one educated in this area would seek to shout them down.

Frazzledmum123 · 19/05/2022 13:12

Thank you @Tandora ❤️ Nothing about it is ideal but then I dont believe life is! But watching the two of them interact and seeing what a happy family they are, I don't regret it and I hope she grows to feel the same way x

CounsellorTroi · 19/05/2022 12:59

mucky123 · 19/05/2022 11:28

It's weird isn't it Donorconceivedme we sympathise with kids with deadbeat dads who don't want to see them. We sympathise with kids whose dads died before they were born even if they were raised by a loving stepdad. We also sympathise with families where there has been an ivf mix-up (where the families are given the wrong babies and raise babies not genetically related to them for a period until they realise there has been a mix-up) and yet we deliberately create children via donor conception who will not grow up with and possibly never know one of their biological parents and we tell them they ought to be grateful, they wouldn't have existed without donor conception. It's all wrong and the discussion does not centre the needs of the child in the way it should.

Really good points here. We treat hospital mixups where someone has taken home the wrong baby as a terrible thing - because a genetically related family and baby have been separated. But treat donor conception as though the genetics don't matter at all,all to satisfy the desires of would be parents.

Sortilege · 19/05/2022 12:54

mucky123 · 19/05/2022 08:14

I'm also a donor conceived person (in my 40's). Back then it was completely anonymous, no records were kept and my parents were told to never tell me (which they didn't until I found out on a commercial DNA site). I can't even begin to outline the trauma this has caused. I couldn't look at my face in the mirror for about 6 months after finding out. Every time I walked into a crowded place I imagined that every man I met was my bio father/brother. I'm processing it better over time but it makes me so angry when people only look at this from the point of view of the infertile parents or the donor. The main person who really matters is the donor conceived person as they had no say in having half their biological links severed. This has forever ruined my relationship with the parents who brought me up, I will never be able to trust them or think of them in the same way again.

The donor conceived community is growing (although there are few charities that actually represent us) and there is beginning to be more awareness of the damage this fertility industry can do to us. Unfortunately, when we venture out into the world and express out opinions we are usually shut down straight away (often by recipient parents) and told "but you were so wanted", you should be grateful you wouldn't exist otherwise, it's love that makes a family. Debates like this one are good as slowly people start to hear all the voices in the debate and not just the louder, more powerful voices of the parents.

That sounds incredibly hard @mucky123 - really disorienting and traumatic.

Do you think it would have been easier if you’d been told all along, as per current advice?

I suppose the parents’ and donors voices being louder was inevitable for a generation or two, but donor sperm has been used for so long, and society unclenched 30 years ago so it is time donor conceived adults, of all opinions, felt heard,

Thanks for posting despite the naysayers.

OP posts:
Tandora · 19/05/2022 12:53

Frazzledmum123 · 19/05/2022 12:46

@Beamur I do see your point. I just guess I feel very protective of my friend. Her journey to motherhood was hideous, heartbreaking, awful. No one should have to go through that. She is an absolutely amazing mum, honestly probably better than I am with patience. Her daughter is her world. And to say she will never properly be a mum despite even carrying her child and giving birth to her (and her husband being the bio father) just seems so incredibly insensitive and hurtful. She is a mum and the daughter wouldn't exist without her.
But of course the child's feelings are important and I apologise sincerely if it sounds as if I implied they weren't. If she feels genetics are important then we will explore that at the time, we will always be family my friend and I. My children are aware she is technically their half sibling and she will be too (she's still a baby but it won't be kept from her). That was important to both my friend and I and actually the reason we went down the route of me being the donor
So yes, the child's feelings are important, but I don't think that means you have to exclude the parents feelings at the same time. My friend didn't ask for this to be the only way she could have a child either, she had to go through hell to get here and I sincerely hope her daughter doesn't just wipe all that love out because she shares the same genes as me instead. I will always be here, but as an extra not a replacement

You and your family / friendship sound wonderful. IMO you have nothing to apologise for- I don’t think you were dismissive and your points are so valid. I have no personal experience on which to draw so I can’t claim any authority to my perspective but what you have described Sounfs so healthy and wonderful to me; and a perfect context in which to raise a child. ❤️

Beamur · 19/05/2022 12:52

There are many ways to be a Mother, or a Father.

BetsHilton · 19/05/2022 12:50

@mucky123 I don’t think anyone is saying donor conceived children need to be grateful to be born. But it’s a fact that without their mother they wouldn’t exist.

To answer the question in the OP: giving away your children to be raised by strangers is wrong

If a man donates his sperm, it’s used to create embryos yet none implant and result in a baby has he given away his children to be raised by strangers? I don’t see how he has. So how is donating an egg or sperm giving away a child if without a successful implantation and a mother who grows and births the baby the child wouldn’t exist.

Frazzledmum123 · 19/05/2022 12:46

@Beamur I do see your point. I just guess I feel very protective of my friend. Her journey to motherhood was hideous, heartbreaking, awful. No one should have to go through that. She is an absolutely amazing mum, honestly probably better than I am with patience. Her daughter is her world. And to say she will never properly be a mum despite even carrying her child and giving birth to her (and her husband being the bio father) just seems so incredibly insensitive and hurtful. She is a mum and the daughter wouldn't exist without her.
But of course the child's feelings are important and I apologise sincerely if it sounds as if I implied they weren't. If she feels genetics are important then we will explore that at the time, we will always be family my friend and I. My children are aware she is technically their half sibling and she will be too (she's still a baby but it won't be kept from her). That was important to both my friend and I and actually the reason we went down the route of me being the donor
So yes, the child's feelings are important, but I don't think that means you have to exclude the parents feelings at the same time. My friend didn't ask for this to be the only way she could have a child either, she had to go through hell to get here and I sincerely hope her daughter doesn't just wipe all that love out because she shares the same genes as me instead. I will always be here, but as an extra not a replacement

BetsHilton · 19/05/2022 12:39

@DonorConceivedMe I know my adopted friend would be very affronted at you saying her mother is not her mother just because they don’t share genetic material. I would say many adopted children and mothers would be upset at you saying they are not mother and child because of their DNA.

Tandora · 19/05/2022 12:36

DonorConceivedMe · 19/05/2022 11:23

Being told about one’s origins won’t take away from the fact that the donor conceived child has been deliberately deprived of the right to be raised by his or her own parents. The crumb of comfort of being told that you can contact your own mother or father when you’re 18 doesn’t make up for that loss. And who knows if records will even be kept up to date wrt the parents’ contact details?

I’m not using the word “donor” which is designed to make it seem like blood donation and gloss over the truth of the genetic relations. The “egg donor” is the mother. The “sperm donor” is the father.

I’m so sorry that you feel this way and it’s devastating to hear such perspectives. I can’t agree with you that gamete donors are “parents” though. Parent is a social role, it can’t be reduced to a biological descriptor.

Vikinga · 19/05/2022 12:35

Frazzledmum123 · 19/05/2022 12:20

@mucky123 I just want to add too that my friend and I are extremely close, like family. Her daughter will always be welcome to be part of my family because I consider her that due to my relationship with my friend. I will answer any questions she has and fully intend to validate her views as does my friend. I dont think anyone should be 'grateful' just be alive but I will explain that although she did not come from my friend biologically, she only exists because of her and her love for her. And that is what she and any child should be grateful for, the love and sacrifices made by the person who raised them in exactly the same way I would expect someone to be grateful for a stepdad who has always been round and the way I'm grateful to my own parents- not for conceiving me but for everything they ever did for me

To take my eldest as an example. He didn't see his bio father for most of his childhood. He left when he was too young to remember and the only father he has known is his step father.

He's been loved and raised by his step father.

Yet he has loved getting to know his bio father and seeing his bio paternal family (they now see each other). His bio father has played no part in his life beyond conception and was around when he was a baby. So really, a sperm donor. But to my son, it is important that he knows him. He delights in any physical and personality similarities (as he does me). He doesn't have that with his step father. He is really interested in the family history and photos.

So he didn't 'miss out' on a father figure but having that contact is very important to him. A bio parent is much more than a donor to a child, despite what the adults organising the creation of that child may think.

Beamur · 19/05/2022 12:32

Thing is adoption is a very different thing to any kind of assisted reproduction.
The common factor is that a child come from it, who may have very mixed feelings about their background and heritage.
We do need to listen to their voices.
It's even harder for them to speak if they are told their whole existence is special and they were so wanted and loved. How hard must it be to speak against that they have nonetheless felt unhappy?
Frazzledmum you say i'm biologically her mother, but not her true mother, genetics don't make a family. The title mother is a very special one to me and I don't feel I deserve that over my friend when she has done all the mothering and I have done so little. It's an insult to her which is all well and good but still it's all about the parents not the child. What if a child in similar circumstances turns round and says that the genetics actually really do matter to them? Would you tell them they are wrong? I am talking hypothetically and not about your own situation.
I really don't mean to be unkind but it's still not centering the child or their feelings.
There's a gulf of difference between being existing and not approving of the mechanism of your existence - the argument that you wouldn't have existed otherwise is still denying these people a proper voice.

Tandora · 19/05/2022 12:24

mucky123 · 19/05/2022 08:14

I'm also a donor conceived person (in my 40's). Back then it was completely anonymous, no records were kept and my parents were told to never tell me (which they didn't until I found out on a commercial DNA site). I can't even begin to outline the trauma this has caused. I couldn't look at my face in the mirror for about 6 months after finding out. Every time I walked into a crowded place I imagined that every man I met was my bio father/brother. I'm processing it better over time but it makes me so angry when people only look at this from the point of view of the infertile parents or the donor. The main person who really matters is the donor conceived person as they had no say in having half their biological links severed. This has forever ruined my relationship with the parents who brought me up, I will never be able to trust them or think of them in the same way again.

The donor conceived community is growing (although there are few charities that actually represent us) and there is beginning to be more awareness of the damage this fertility industry can do to us. Unfortunately, when we venture out into the world and express out opinions we are usually shut down straight away (often by recipient parents) and told "but you were so wanted", you should be grateful you wouldn't exist otherwise, it's love that makes a family. Debates like this one are good as slowly people start to hear all the voices in the debate and not just the louder, more powerful voices of the parents.

Oh my gosh that’s terrible that was hidden from you. Do you think you would have felt differently if you had known the truth from the start and had been able to know the identity of your donor? These voices and perspectives are SO important. Thank you for sharing your experience

Tandora · 19/05/2022 12:21

mucky123 · 19/05/2022 08:24

Just jumping in. It's much more complex for dcp than saying I wish I didn't exist. Of course I don't, I generally have a happy life and this is only one aspect of that. However, do I wish someone hadn't played God back when I was born and separated me from half of my biological family - yes. Do I wish more respect had been/is shown to my natural, completely understandable desire to know what my father looks like, my medical history, my siblings - yes. There are a range of views among DCP, generally it's harder for those who were never told until later in life as that adds in the feeling of having been lied to all your life. However, I think where recipient parents treat the subject respectfully and don't allow their own desires to own "their child" and pretend the other half of their biology doesn't exist outcomes are better on the whole (although for some there still is trauma). I would advocate completely open, known donors and force recipient parents to be open by registering the fact of donor conception on the birth certificate.

This is so helpful. Thank you for explaining. Completely respect and agree with all your points ❤️.

Frazzledmum123 · 19/05/2022 12:20

@mucky123 I just want to add too that my friend and I are extremely close, like family. Her daughter will always be welcome to be part of my family because I consider her that due to my relationship with my friend. I will answer any questions she has and fully intend to validate her views as does my friend. I dont think anyone should be 'grateful' just be alive but I will explain that although she did not come from my friend biologically, she only exists because of her and her love for her. And that is what she and any child should be grateful for, the love and sacrifices made by the person who raised them in exactly the same way I would expect someone to be grateful for a stepdad who has always been round and the way I'm grateful to my own parents- not for conceiving me but for everything they ever did for me

Frazzledmum123 · 19/05/2022 12:11

I'm not trying to speak for them, I'm really not. I'm just saying they are being deprived the right to be brought up by their birth parents any more than someone who is adopted is, and people aren't all from abusive homes who are adopted @toastofthetown, I was talking about people who fall pregnant by accident and don't want the child, people who chose adoption over abortion.
I don't mean to sound like I'm belittling the child's feelings at all, it was a very important part of the decision process for us that the child knew who I was from the start as I agree, they should have that right to know. I just think it's wrong to call me her true mother, I'm just not. I'm biologically her mother, but not her true mother, genetics don't make a family. The title mother is a very special one to me and I don't feel I deserve that over my friend when she has done all the mothering and I have done so little. It's an insult to her.
I do not think anonymous donation is right, but donation in general I cannot disagree with. I get they may have the need to know their biological background but to say they shouldn't exist because their genetic parent isn't raising them is wrong, just as saying it for those whose father's are no longer on the scene would be.
To be honest I am confused as I was told at the time that legally they have the right to have my details anyway? Is that just a UK thing?

mucky123 · 19/05/2022 12:02

CupidStunt22 · 19/05/2022 11:53

That's a terrible argument. The idea that you should be grateful and happy for however you came about because you wouldn't exist otherwise is a very bad one.

Your feelings as a donor or as a commissioning parent doesn't mean you know anything about the feelings of children born this way, and you don't get to speak for them.

Hear Hear Cupidstunt. On all of the donor conception groups I am a member of this language of "not having existed without DC" (and therefore the implication that you should be grateful) is considered to be deeply offensive to DC People. Obviously your situation looks ideal Frazzledmum in terms of how donor conception start, that you are there, that you are a known donor etc but as the genetic mother of this child you really should explore this from her point of view a bit. Listen to how DC people view donor conception - there is a wide range of views. Try not to frame this for her. Ultimately she will decide how she wishes to view you and her social mother, what she wishes to call you and whether she is happy for the arrangement that the two of you made.

CupidStunt22 · 19/05/2022 11:53

Frazzledmum123 · 19/05/2022 11:38

@DonorConceivedMe They aren't being deliberately deprived the right to be raised by their biological parents though are they, because they simply wouldn't exist if it wasn't for being conceived this way. They were NEVER going to be raised by the people whose body made them, that hasn't been taken away. What they have been given is life where it wouldn't otherwise have been? I can't see how it is any different in that one respect, to being adopted rather than aborted?
And the donor isn't the mother no. Being a mother isn't about being biologically able to create a life, it is so so much more. That's why people with absent 'fathers' ofter refer to them as donors. I know my case is a bit different to what people are objecting too as the child my friend conceived from my egg will know me and all family so won't have the questions but I am 100% not her mother. I didn't get sick carrying her, I didn't feed and keep her safe in the womb, I didn't give up certain foods and drinks to keep her safe (well briefly during the process to retrieve my egg but not in the same way for months on end). I didn't go through hours of labour or spend soo many sleepless nights with her, soothe her when she is hurt, hug her when she is tantrumming, give up part of my career to raise her, sacrifice my body to bring her into the world. She is not my daughter as much as i care about her and im certainly not her mother

That's a terrible argument. The idea that you should be grateful and happy for however you came about because you wouldn't exist otherwise is a very bad one.

Your feelings as a donor or as a commissioning parent doesn't mean you know anything about the feelings of children born this way, and you don't get to speak for them.

toastofthetown · 19/05/2022 11:52

Frazzledmum123 · 19/05/2022 11:38

@DonorConceivedMe They aren't being deliberately deprived the right to be raised by their biological parents though are they, because they simply wouldn't exist if it wasn't for being conceived this way. They were NEVER going to be raised by the people whose body made them, that hasn't been taken away. What they have been given is life where it wouldn't otherwise have been? I can't see how it is any different in that one respect, to being adopted rather than aborted?
And the donor isn't the mother no. Being a mother isn't about being biologically able to create a life, it is so so much more. That's why people with absent 'fathers' ofter refer to them as donors. I know my case is a bit different to what people are objecting too as the child my friend conceived from my egg will know me and all family so won't have the questions but I am 100% not her mother. I didn't get sick carrying her, I didn't feed and keep her safe in the womb, I didn't give up certain foods and drinks to keep her safe (well briefly during the process to retrieve my egg but not in the same way for months on end). I didn't go through hours of labour or spend soo many sleepless nights with her, soothe her when she is hurt, hug her when she is tantrumming, give up part of my career to raise her, sacrifice my body to bring her into the world. She is not my daughter as much as i care about her and im certainly not her mother

But is is your genetic daughter. She shares half your DNA, if she went onto 23andMe it’s your family that would show up. She’ll look in a mirror and see your eyes, your face shape, your hair colour. That doesn’t take anything away from her loving parents, but for some children it doesn’t matter how wonderful their parents are, they want a link with their biological relations too. I acknowledge it’s different in your case because she’ll have access to you growing up. She still might want a connection with you and your family far more than she would with another family friend. Or she might not care at all. But I think it should be for the child to decide on the emphasis they put on their genetic background, not the adults.

I also don’t think there’s much of a comparison to adoption. When a child is removed from their birth family, it’s to reduce the harm to a child that already exists, not creating a child for adoptive parents. There’s a reason that there’s support (or should be) for families of adopted children. Adoption is least worst option for children who are living in terrible abusive households, or those whose parents are unable or unwilling to care for them. In a perfect world, there would be no need for adoption.

Frazzledmum123 · 19/05/2022 11:38

@DonorConceivedMe They aren't being deliberately deprived the right to be raised by their biological parents though are they, because they simply wouldn't exist if it wasn't for being conceived this way. They were NEVER going to be raised by the people whose body made them, that hasn't been taken away. What they have been given is life where it wouldn't otherwise have been? I can't see how it is any different in that one respect, to being adopted rather than aborted?
And the donor isn't the mother no. Being a mother isn't about being biologically able to create a life, it is so so much more. That's why people with absent 'fathers' ofter refer to them as donors. I know my case is a bit different to what people are objecting too as the child my friend conceived from my egg will know me and all family so won't have the questions but I am 100% not her mother. I didn't get sick carrying her, I didn't feed and keep her safe in the womb, I didn't give up certain foods and drinks to keep her safe (well briefly during the process to retrieve my egg but not in the same way for months on end). I didn't go through hours of labour or spend soo many sleepless nights with her, soothe her when she is hurt, hug her when she is tantrumming, give up part of my career to raise her, sacrifice my body to bring her into the world. She is not my daughter as much as i care about her and im certainly not her mother

mucky123 · 19/05/2022 11:35

www.instagram.com/p/CduKfj9sJno/?igshid=YmMyMTA2M2Y%3D&fbclid=IwAR1cNZ0oGQm3FdQwJPIsSYiEfbSmAdtCgaohDvuQp6XS_LV_4xBY56gUBv0

Something I just saw on one of the many sites for donor conceived people.

mucky123 · 19/05/2022 11:28

It's weird isn't it Donorconceivedme we sympathise with kids with deadbeat dads who don't want to see them. We sympathise with kids whose dads died before they were born even if they were raised by a loving stepdad. We also sympathise with families where there has been an ivf mix-up (where the families are given the wrong babies and raise babies not genetically related to them for a period until they realise there has been a mix-up) and yet we deliberately create children via donor conception who will not grow up with and possibly never know one of their biological parents and we tell them they ought to be grateful, they wouldn't have existed without donor conception. It's all wrong and the discussion does not centre the needs of the child in the way it should.

DonorConceivedMe · 19/05/2022 11:23

Being told about one’s origins won’t take away from the fact that the donor conceived child has been deliberately deprived of the right to be raised by his or her own parents. The crumb of comfort of being told that you can contact your own mother or father when you’re 18 doesn’t make up for that loss. And who knows if records will even be kept up to date wrt the parents’ contact details?

I’m not using the word “donor” which is designed to make it seem like blood donation and gloss over the truth of the genetic relations. The “egg donor” is the mother. The “sperm donor” is the father.

mucky123 · 19/05/2022 11:17

GoingOnce · 19/05/2022 10:48

a terrible example of the commodification of women's bodies

sums it all up for me.

But it doesn't sum it all up. That is one aspect. But it is also a terrible example of putting the desires of adults (with money and power) above the rights of a child to know their biological family. To be able to look into the mirror and know where they came from.

GoingOnce · 19/05/2022 10:48

a terrible example of the commodification of women's bodies

sums it all up for me.