Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s the general MN verdict on donor eggs?

460 replies

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 14:22

The general critical re-examination of surrogacy is quite evident, and I have my own views on that, which I’ll keep quiet for the purposes of this thread.

Now I find myself chewing over other fertility treatment. I’ve had fertility treatment myself and so have family members. So I have a sense of how private clinics put you on a conveyor belt and normalise things.

What is the general view on donor eggs & embryos (implanted into the birth mother and gestated by her)?

Im trying really hard not to bias the result so have tossed a coin to assign YABU/YANBU to viewpoints. Don’t read into that.

YANBU = Donor gametes are ethically fine.
YABU = Donor gametes are problematic.

OP posts:
Robinni · 19/05/2022 23:27

DonorConceivedMe · 19/05/2022 22:42

You're right, of course. I wasn't untimely ripped from my father's arms. He couldn't give a toss about me (pun intended). That doesn't make me feel great.

As for the fact that my parents "really wanted" me -- sounds like the sort of thing adult children from dysfunctional families complain of in the thread "But we took you to stately homes". Them really wanting me doesn't make it ok.

The point about autonomy is misplaced. What about my body? What about my human rights?

This sort of leads back to what I said before, plenty of children feel aggrieved for the circumstances they find themselves to be in life - no relationship with father, parents didn’t do xyz etc.

The emotion you have tied to this is huge, and valid and I’m sorry you’ve felt distressed as much as you have.

It comes across, to me, such as the pro life argument - at the gamete, early embryo stage is there a human rights case or are the rights of the adult superior?

Your Dad may have genuinely wanted to help other people, knowing you’d likely go to a comfortable home and be loved. Or he may have had financial issues. Who knows? Arguably, more consideration may have gone into the experience than occurs with many fathers where the primary motivation is to get their leg over.

Sortilege · 19/05/2022 23:13

Oh I see. Missed that. I thought she meant “the State” as in “the government”.

OP posts:
DonorConceivedMe · 19/05/2022 23:12

Robinni · 19/05/2022 23:07

@Sortilege they kept referencing legislation in different states - we don’t have states in the U.K.

I think @mucky123 talked about "the state" ie the government, not "the states".

Robinni · 19/05/2022 23:11

@DonorConceivedMe
Re. Genetics really matter - I already said upthread I think that donors should have genetic testing done along with a full medical history and remain accessible to the child throughout life if possible (friend/family) or at least be contactable at 18. Because to not do any of that causes problems such as you’ve described.

Robinni · 19/05/2022 23:07

Sortilege · 19/05/2022 22:56

@Robinni what makes you think @mucky123 is in the States? I have no idea if you’re right, I just feel like I’m missing something.

@Sortilege they kept referencing legislation in different states - we don’t have states in the U.K.

Sortilege · 19/05/2022 22:56

@Robinni what makes you think @mucky123 is in the States? I have no idea if you’re right, I just feel like I’m missing something.

OP posts:
Robinni · 19/05/2022 22:51

mucky123 · 19/05/2022 22:12

Understand your point but I think what is different here is we are talking about the regulated fertility industry. Of course you can't interfere in who people have sex with, what drugs their parents take, where they live etc (unless social services have to be involved); however, where you have the health industry intervening , like adoption, the decisions should be taken in the best interests of the child. You wouldn't argue that we shouldn't vet adoptive parents etc because parents who conceive naturally are not vetted. So the same with DC. Furthermore, DC legislation means that the non-bio parents go on the birth certificate of the child. That should only be allowed if the first birth certificate references the actual bio parent(s) as well so that the state is not complicit in the parents lie.
Of course people will do unethical, online sperm donation (egg donation is a bit harder to do like that but assume some might go abroad) that doesn't mean that they proper process shouldn't be organised and thought through as well as we can.
Legislation is a very powerful influencer on people's behaviour. If the state legislates to say this is the correct way to go about donor conception, this centres the child as best we can then it will change lots of people's minds about what is ethical and what isn't.

I completely hear you and I’m guessing you’re based in America where the process may be a bit different anyway.

I wasn’t suggesting prospective parents not be vetted or donors counselled what I mean is every child may have a potential problem with some aspect of their upbringing/parentage or what their parents did/didn’t do, it’s not unique to DCP.

I don’t believe anyone should be lying to their children about their origins. A child should know as soon as they’re old enough to understand the concept.

Policy is key to everything of course. I feel there needs to be room for donation of gametes - not specifically as a person who has had fertility concerns, as I don’t think I would go this route - but if you don’t have it (well regulated) then you’re going to be facing people doing at home insemination, child trafficking and exploitation on a bigger scale which all things considered is a bigger evil.

I’m glad people such as yourself are now of age to be able to voice opinions to shape the way legislation should be for future generations.

DonorConceivedMe · 19/05/2022 22:49

WalkerWalking · 19/05/2022 21:09

The genetic "donor" parents and the birth parents may all have made an informed and conscious decision that they don't believe genetics play a big part in families or personal identity.

But the CHILD has no say whatsoever. They don't get the opportunity to make that decision. No one seems to care whether they will turn out to be one of the people who don't think it's a big deal, or one of the people who think it's a massive deal.

Genetics really, really matter.

Genetics mattered when my child had a serious inherited disease and I didn't know my family medical history to answer the doctor's question.

Genetics mattered when one of my donor conceived siblings had bowel polyps... so we all had a colonoscopy. Another sibling was found to have polyps which would have become cancerous if she hadn't had the procedure.

Genetics mattered for an Australian woman called Narelle, who died of bowel cancer -- she'd inherited the gene from her bio father, a sperm donor who she'd tried to trace for years. She died six weeks after meeting him. Narelle's story

DonorConceivedMe · 19/05/2022 22:42

Robinni · 19/05/2022 19:09

@DonorConceivedMe I may be barking up the wrong tree here.

However, the way you’re talking is like you were a babe in arms, untimely ripped from your loving parents who so desperately wanted you and were deprived of a relationship with them by this action.

The fact is donation of eggs and sperm, as with adoption, is the choice of the biological parent. They make an active choice to give up a physical and emotional relationship with their child. Whatever the circumstances that is their choice. And the people who gave you a chance at life and who so desperately wanted you are the ones who presumably had you through ivf.

I realise it is disappointing to not have a relationship with your biological Dad or to know your exact origins. To make it clear - I think parents should tell children the story of their adoption/ivf conception from an early age and that the children have access to the details of their biological parents upon adulthood if that information is forthcoming…

Is what you’re saying that you think all embryo donation should cease to prevent people from having to go through this deprivation of relationship with biological parents? And how do you think that assertion marries to people having autonomy over their own bodies?

You're right, of course. I wasn't untimely ripped from my father's arms. He couldn't give a toss about me (pun intended). That doesn't make me feel great.

As for the fact that my parents "really wanted" me -- sounds like the sort of thing adult children from dysfunctional families complain of in the thread "But we took you to stately homes". Them really wanting me doesn't make it ok.

The point about autonomy is misplaced. What about my body? What about my human rights?

DonorConceivedMe · 19/05/2022 22:36

BetsHilton · 19/05/2022 12:39

@DonorConceivedMe I know my adopted friend would be very affronted at you saying her mother is not her mother just because they don’t share genetic material. I would say many adopted children and mothers would be upset at you saying they are not mother and child because of their DNA.

But adoptees are "allowed" to say birth mother and adoptive mother? Or birth mother and "mum" or whatever. The point being that the birth mother is (also) the mother.

Mif4 · 19/05/2022 22:29

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

DonorConceivedMe · 19/05/2022 22:26

Understand your point but I think what is different here is we are talking about the regulated fertility industry. Of course you can't interfere in who people have sex with, what drugs their parents take, where they live etc (unless social services have to be involved); however, where you have the health industry intervening , like adoption, the decisions should be taken in the best interests of the child. You wouldn't argue that we shouldn't vet adoptive parents etc because parents who conceive naturally are not vetted. So the same with DC. Furthermore, DC legislation means that the non-bio parents go on the birth certificate of the child. That should only be allowed if the first birth certificate references the actual bio parent(s) as well so that the state is not complicit in the parents lie.

Well said @mucky123

Delphinium20 · 19/05/2022 22:18

HeadNorth · 19/05/2022 21:17

But the problem with ‘the currency of youth’ is that you are too inexperienced to understand its value and the implications for you. It is like when people claim good looking young women have all the power because older rich men drool over them. But to my mind young women can look beautiful and fearless but can in fact be insecure, naive and ripe for exploitation. I don’t think our NHS should have taken an 18 years old’s eggs, it seems cavalier about the longer term psychological implications. I think the health service should have looked after her better and considered it more holistically, not just ‘your eggs are healthy, let’s have them’.

Completely agree. My DD was 15 when she received social media advertisements to sell her eggs. She had been doing some university internet searches and the algorithms noticed and sent ads her way. It's a form of grooming and it's very unethical. I saved screenshots as I was so angry about it...she was only 15!!!!

I could never 'shop' a catalogue of young women's eggs. I'm so sorry they convinced your daughter @HeadNorth to do this.

What’s the general MN verdict on donor eggs?
What’s the general MN verdict on donor eggs?
What’s the general MN verdict on donor eggs?
mucky123 · 19/05/2022 22:12

Robinni · 19/05/2022 21:35

@WalkerWalking some children are born to drug addicts or alcoholics, some have poor or rich parents, some a single parent, some live in Australia, some in Iceland…. You get the idea. Some of these people will consider their circumstances to be a problem and some won’t.

None of these very important children - as all children are - get a say in who their parents will be, what their family will be comprised of or what they are exposed to environmentally. The parents make the decision and they are born - blended families, adoptive families, families where the bio parents give them up at a later point, all sorts of families.

I don’t see how people conceived with 1-2 donors are a special case in this.

The process does need to be regulated better to protect vulnerable women (donors and those seeking fertility treatment) and to ensure that where possible the bio parent is a friend/family member or someone who is prepared to be contacted later and will leave info for the child.

But if you’re going to go down the road of child being centred then we better go around demanding that everyone wishing to have a baby has to have a specific set of circumstances deemed to be desirable to any potential offspring just so they’ll be ok with it all.

Understand your point but I think what is different here is we are talking about the regulated fertility industry. Of course you can't interfere in who people have sex with, what drugs their parents take, where they live etc (unless social services have to be involved); however, where you have the health industry intervening , like adoption, the decisions should be taken in the best interests of the child. You wouldn't argue that we shouldn't vet adoptive parents etc because parents who conceive naturally are not vetted. So the same with DC. Furthermore, DC legislation means that the non-bio parents go on the birth certificate of the child. That should only be allowed if the first birth certificate references the actual bio parent(s) as well so that the state is not complicit in the parents lie.
Of course people will do unethical, online sperm donation (egg donation is a bit harder to do like that but assume some might go abroad) that doesn't mean that they proper process shouldn't be organised and thought through as well as we can.
Legislation is a very powerful influencer on people's behaviour. If the state legislates to say this is the correct way to go about donor conception, this centres the child as best we can then it will change lots of people's minds about what is ethical and what isn't.

Robinni · 19/05/2022 21:35

@WalkerWalking some children are born to drug addicts or alcoholics, some have poor or rich parents, some a single parent, some live in Australia, some in Iceland…. You get the idea. Some of these people will consider their circumstances to be a problem and some won’t.

None of these very important children - as all children are - get a say in who their parents will be, what their family will be comprised of or what they are exposed to environmentally. The parents make the decision and they are born - blended families, adoptive families, families where the bio parents give them up at a later point, all sorts of families.

I don’t see how people conceived with 1-2 donors are a special case in this.

The process does need to be regulated better to protect vulnerable women (donors and those seeking fertility treatment) and to ensure that where possible the bio parent is a friend/family member or someone who is prepared to be contacted later and will leave info for the child.

But if you’re going to go down the road of child being centred then we better go around demanding that everyone wishing to have a baby has to have a specific set of circumstances deemed to be desirable to any potential offspring just so they’ll be ok with it all.

Sortilege · 19/05/2022 21:27

Cos you could argue that in that scenario the younger woman, your daughter as all the power because she holds the currency of youth…

What power? The power to command a fee of a few hundred quid in return for undergoing an ivf cycle and egg collection before signing away your genetic material?

Teenagers being recruited seems one of the uglier aspects of the industry, to me.Trying to dress that up differently feels distasteful.

Donation could easily be restricted to, say, 25-34 year olds. It doesn’t have to involve extremely young women.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 19/05/2022 21:20

But the problem with ‘the currency of youth’ is that you are too inexperienced to understand its value and the implications for you

Exactly

HeadNorth · 19/05/2022 21:17

LuckySantangelo35 · 19/05/2022 20:56

@HeadNorth

its a tough one isn’t it. Cos you could argue that in that scenario the younger woman, your daughter as all the power because she holds the currency of youth…

But the problem with ‘the currency of youth’ is that you are too inexperienced to understand its value and the implications for you. It is like when people claim good looking young women have all the power because older rich men drool over them. But to my mind young women can look beautiful and fearless but can in fact be insecure, naive and ripe for exploitation. I don’t think our NHS should have taken an 18 years old’s eggs, it seems cavalier about the longer term psychological implications. I think the health service should have looked after her better and considered it more holistically, not just ‘your eggs are healthy, let’s have them’.

orwellwasright · 19/05/2022 21:16

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 17/05/2022 15:38

Personally I think if you cant have children naturally you have no right to buy body parts/ substances from other people.

I would love to hear from children conceived as such once adults, and their opinions and feelings- rather than parents who insist everything is fine because they got what they wanted.

Personally I think you haven't got a fucking clue.

TheKeatingFive · 19/05/2022 21:15

Cos you could argue that in that scenario the younger woman, your daughter as all the power because she holds the currency of youth

The daughter does hold something very valuable.

You could argue that they're persuaded by those more powerful than themselves to hand it over very cheaply.

I too feel uncomfortable about university students making money like this. They are a vulnerable group financially. Who knows how they will feel about this down the line, the consequences of having their own biological children out there somewhere?

Have they really thought this through? What happens if the child wants to contact them in the future? How will they feel if they struggle to conceive themselves when they want to? I'm not sure anyone's particularly motivated to help them understand how this might actually impact them emotionally in the longer term.

WalkerWalking · 19/05/2022 21:09

Robinni · 19/05/2022 19:09

@DonorConceivedMe I may be barking up the wrong tree here.

However, the way you’re talking is like you were a babe in arms, untimely ripped from your loving parents who so desperately wanted you and were deprived of a relationship with them by this action.

The fact is donation of eggs and sperm, as with adoption, is the choice of the biological parent. They make an active choice to give up a physical and emotional relationship with their child. Whatever the circumstances that is their choice. And the people who gave you a chance at life and who so desperately wanted you are the ones who presumably had you through ivf.

I realise it is disappointing to not have a relationship with your biological Dad or to know your exact origins. To make it clear - I think parents should tell children the story of their adoption/ivf conception from an early age and that the children have access to the details of their biological parents upon adulthood if that information is forthcoming…

Is what you’re saying that you think all embryo donation should cease to prevent people from having to go through this deprivation of relationship with biological parents? And how do you think that assertion marries to people having autonomy over their own bodies?

The genetic "donor" parents and the birth parents may all have made an informed and conscious decision that they don't believe genetics play a big part in families or personal identity.

But the CHILD has no say whatsoever. They don't get the opportunity to make that decision. No one seems to care whether they will turn out to be one of the people who don't think it's a big deal, or one of the people who think it's a massive deal.

LuckySantangelo35 · 19/05/2022 20:56

HeadNorth · 19/05/2022 20:50

I don’t really know, like I say I am conflicted, but it does feel a bit Handmaids Tale. Like you can decide to commission a baby in your 40s using the eggs of a naive young girl who grew up in a village and really knows nothing of the world. I think it is the power imbalance.

@HeadNorth

its a tough one isn’t it. Cos you could argue that in that scenario the younger woman, your daughter as all the power because she holds the currency of youth…

HeadNorth · 19/05/2022 20:50

LuckySantangelo35 · 19/05/2022 20:26

@HeadNorth

whats your issue with your daughters eggs being used for women who are older than her?

I don’t really know, like I say I am conflicted, but it does feel a bit Handmaids Tale. Like you can decide to commission a baby in your 40s using the eggs of a naive young girl who grew up in a village and really knows nothing of the world. I think it is the power imbalance.

Robinni · 19/05/2022 20:36

imperialminty · 17/05/2022 21:04

But having a child isn’t necessary in any medical way??

And also the NHS already does that - it makes decisions on when to offer and withdraw treatment all the time.

But having a child isn’t necessary in any medical way??

Actually you’re wrong - I was facing another major surgery and having a colostomy unless I got pregnant. Thankfully avoided, but endo has come back again and I’m being told pregnancy is my best “treatment”.

Then there’s all the people whose mental health, relationships, earning capacity etc suffers due to infertility. It’s perfectly valid to be on the NHS, I just wish what was offered was uniform across the U.K. as it is a postcode lottery at present.

LuckySantangelo35 · 19/05/2022 20:26

HeadNorth · 19/05/2022 20:04

I am very conflicted on this as my young daughter chose to donate her eggs as a first year student. It was all done correctly through the NHS and I found that pretty appalling. She was only 18, just left home for University, what did she know about the implications of her actions? But the NHS was happy to harvest her healthy young eggs, probably for a much older woman, which I cannot feel is right and feels a bit Handmaids Tale.

So I may well have a biological grandchild out there. And my lovely altruistic daughter will have to live with this as she grows up and matures and may well get a door knock in 18 years time. So I think far more caution and circumspection is needed than currently exists in the process.

@HeadNorth

whats your issue with your daughters eggs being used for women who are older than her?