Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s the general MN verdict on donor eggs?

460 replies

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 14:22

The general critical re-examination of surrogacy is quite evident, and I have my own views on that, which I’ll keep quiet for the purposes of this thread.

Now I find myself chewing over other fertility treatment. I’ve had fertility treatment myself and so have family members. So I have a sense of how private clinics put you on a conveyor belt and normalise things.

What is the general view on donor eggs & embryos (implanted into the birth mother and gestated by her)?

Im trying really hard not to bias the result so have tossed a coin to assign YABU/YANBU to viewpoints. Don’t read into that.

YANBU = Donor gametes are ethically fine.
YABU = Donor gametes are problematic.

OP posts:
Robinni · 20/05/2022 18:42

@SomethingOnce I am qualified and posted the scientific papers I did because I thought they would be interesting… not to sway argument to one side or the other.. Just to make that clear.

Extracellular vesicles as a means to intercellular communication (one of the many things noted in the second paper), is one of the most interesting things in cellular biology right now going beyond developmental biology to immune response, coagulation etc.

The way things are being thought about now is that the genome is modulated throughout life due to environmental factors, with a key period determining phenotype being gestation and the first 1000 days of life. Which I think is important for people to consider if DCP; that the environment in womb and beyond has contributed towards the person that they are… as with everyone.

‘Science’ is not wishful thinking…

CounsellorTroi · 20/05/2022 18:21

Equalbutdifferent · 20/05/2022 17:50

We're in a lot of trouble in terms of women's reproductive rights if we confuse gametes with the potential to result in children, with children themselves. They are different things.

This is not to diminish the genetic legacy that is passed from donor to child. But it is to say that adoption is a poor comparison.

I agree that adoption is a poor comparison. With donor eggs the child is being conceived especially for you. Not the case with adopting an existing child.

SomethingOnce · 20/05/2022 18:06

The logic seems to shift depending on what the 'commissioning' person wants it to be.

Agree with this. It’s quite telling.

And ‘epigenetics’ is doing some heavy lifting on this thread, and it comes across as wishful thinking.

Equalbutdifferent · 20/05/2022 17:50

We're in a lot of trouble in terms of women's reproductive rights if we confuse gametes with the potential to result in children, with children themselves. They are different things.

This is not to diminish the genetic legacy that is passed from donor to child. But it is to say that adoption is a poor comparison.

torfa · 20/05/2022 14:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Robinni · 20/05/2022 13:56

@mucky123

I see it as a form of early adoption

I think this is kind of the way I see it too, though the modulation of gene expression and potential transfer of genetic material from the gestational Mum muddies the waters quite a bit…. If anything you could say three parent baby.

It probably will become standard practice to have a three parent set up anyway - unless major genetic issue - as now possible to enucleate an egg and add gestational Mum DNA…. Done primarily to avoid mitochondrial disease but only a matter of time really until brought over into fertility treatment, been in the works quite some time.

time.com/5569057/three-parent-baby-dna/?amp=true

There is, what I find to be, fascinating article published this year on the epigenetics of pregnancy. Probably quite hard to grasp if no background in cellular biology - but there are plenty of A level type videos that can help on youtube to fill in knowledge gaps. And some nice diagrams in this as well.

link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10815-022-02451-x

Might I say - hearing from @amoobaa @Frazzledmum123 about their use of sperm/egg donation has been very heartening. As was reading about Cynthia Nixon and her wife’s arrangement with another (male) couple to conceive and rear a child together. Hard to know how the children themselves will feel about it, but a world with more love and support can’t be bad. Of course means developing a close relationship with 2-3 other people rather than just one so a challenge but probably preferable.

mucky123 · 20/05/2022 13:16

Agree donors are genetic mothers/fathers. It is a different terminology to birth mother but no less valid imo.

I understand that the legal position currently is that the person who carried and gave birth to the child is the legal mother. I think in the case of egg donation (and sperm donation) there should be a clear space on the birth certificate for the "third" or "fourth" parent. To ignore their part in the creation of the child or to simply refer to it as a donation of a bunch of cells reduces their role/ignores reality probably to the detriment of the child who then has to process it all later in life whilst trying to adhere to the myth created for them.

I see it as a form of early adoption and I think viewing it this way would start to change the narrative around it for the benefit ultimately of all.

Just FYI, if anyone still cares. No I am based in UK, created in Harley Street. By state I meant the UK government (but could be government in other countries).

Sortilege · 20/05/2022 12:37

Robinni · 20/05/2022 12:20

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6993870/

Paper arguing for use of donor eggs as a general rule in the event of poor prognosis. Lays things out quite well in terms of arguments for/against. Something to chew over.

Also from a biological standpoint, the phenotype is shaped via epigenetic modulation in utero determining for example brain development and metabolism.

One example of this you could say is how babies conceived during rationing in WW2 were predisposed to obesity/diabetes/hypertension in later life due to not only malnutrition but because their bodies had been set up to cope in times of food shortages, but then they were born into a world of plenty.

I haven’t studied epigenetics in detail, however on the face of it the gestational mother would contribute quite significantly to phenotype of the child….. they’d be a different person entirely if gestated in the bio mums womb and exposed to different environmental variables in childhood.

By the by if anyone is reading around this, needless to say read from Mendeley/Science direct/Google scholar and avoid fertility site propaganda.

Thanks @Robinni

I remember finding articles and abstracts, at the time we had to make a decision, that suggested epigenetics were being overemphasised as a salve to intended parents, which completely threw me then. So it will be interesting to read something more comprehensive. I’ll save it for after work,

OP posts:
amoobaa · 20/05/2022 12:37

It’s so complex and emotional.

I believe my desire to have children is important, but not more important than the welfare and emotional wellbeing of my child- who will be an individual in their own right and won’t be my ‘baby’ forever, they will be teenagers and adults with complex questions and feelings.

For this reason, we did everything we could to make our decisions around starting our family accordingly.

We are really lucky. We had the option of a known donor.

Our child knows every single person involved in their conception, from the doctor who collected my eggs to the embryologist who selected the specific sperm to inject into a specific egg to create the blastocyst that was transferred back into me and ultimately grew into the person they are today.

They also know their biological father and although we are a ‘two parent family’ (two mums), our child will grow up knowing exactly who is who and will have access to their full medical history, knowledge about their conception and time/ opportunities to ask any questions directly to the people they choose to ask and will not need to wait until they are 18 to find out about their conception of the identity of their biological family.

They have a stable and loving home with two mums but they also know their biological father, cousins and grandparents, who love them to bits.

My wife, myself, our child’s biological father and his long term partner are all in therapy and also had group counselling prior to ivf.

Ultimately, we all acknowledged that there are infinite uncertainties, unknowns, potential changes and challenges ahead of us so we agreed on one core principle: no matter what issues arise, we will always be honest with one another and maintain good communication so that we always act in the best interest of the individual(s) we are responsible for bringing into the world. That their well-being comes first and we acknowledge and shoulder the complexity of the situation rather than sweeping it under the rug until they turn 18.

Our sperm donor has an irreplaceable and significant identity in relation to our child but he is not a parent- he has no parental rights or responsibilities. Our child has two mums. But our child(ren) knows/will know their biological father from the moment they are born and they will be able to ask him anything they want.

We are incredibly lucky to have had this opportunity. Our donor took a year to decide if he was comfortable with donating his sperm. He is such a stable and thoughtful individual.

We all have very clear boundaries that we put in place collaboratively, and these will always be informed by our child’s needs and desires.

From a reserved and gentle distance, our donor makes it abundantly clear that he loves our son and wants nothing but the best for him.

I’m not sure I know many people who could do that and do it with such calm, trust and clarity.

When planning our family, I needed to be sure I could look my child(ren) in the eyes and say, ‘we made every decision with your best interests at the centre of every stage of the process. You can ask us anything. You can share your feelings no matter what they are. And your biological father loves you, knows you and wanted you to exist and thrive in the world.”

Anything less would have felt like I was putting my desire to be a Mum first, regardless of the rights and welfare of any resulting children.

It’s a tough one. I have lots of friends who have used anonymous donors for a variety of reasons. I love them all and their kids are wonderful. But personally I couldn’t do it.

My heart aches for anyone involved in this complex and emotive process.

Sortilege · 20/05/2022 12:29

torfa · 20/05/2022 00:20

What a horrible, goady thread.

What do you imagine is goady about it @torfa ?

OP posts:
Robinni · 20/05/2022 12:20

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6993870/

Paper arguing for use of donor eggs as a general rule in the event of poor prognosis. Lays things out quite well in terms of arguments for/against. Something to chew over.

Also from a biological standpoint, the phenotype is shaped via epigenetic modulation in utero determining for example brain development and metabolism.

One example of this you could say is how babies conceived during rationing in WW2 were predisposed to obesity/diabetes/hypertension in later life due to not only malnutrition but because their bodies had been set up to cope in times of food shortages, but then they were born into a world of plenty.

I haven’t studied epigenetics in detail, however on the face of it the gestational mother would contribute quite significantly to phenotype of the child….. they’d be a different person entirely if gestated in the bio mums womb and exposed to different environmental variables in childhood.

By the by if anyone is reading around this, needless to say read from Mendeley/Science direct/Google scholar and avoid fertility site propaganda.

TheKeatingFive · 20/05/2022 10:22

Donors are not birth mothers.

They are genetic mothers. We shouldn't be minimising that

CupidStunt22 · 20/05/2022 10:22

Donors are not birth mothers. To suggest they are is nonsense and not how the law sees it either

But they are genetic mothers.

orwellwasright · 20/05/2022 10:16

DonorConceivedMe · 19/05/2022 22:36

But adoptees are "allowed" to say birth mother and adoptive mother? Or birth mother and "mum" or whatever. The point being that the birth mother is (also) the mother.

Because a woman who carries and gives birth to a baby is the mother. That's the legal position. She does not need to adopt her own child and that's why surrogates need to release their children for adoption.

Donors are not birth mothers. To suggest they are is nonsense and not how the law sees it either.

Crikeycroc · 20/05/2022 10:15

I do not agree with intentionally creating a life when that child will grow up not knowing one or both of their genetic parents. Knowing who you are and what you come from is a very deep and powerful need in humans. I have been stunned by how clearly my child has inherited temperament and personality traits from both her parents.

Of course it is incredibly sad when for whatever reason a woman/couple wants a child but cannot have one. It does not mean that we should disregard the impact on any potential child. It is not enough to say that generally speaking most of these children will be glad to be alive. That is setting the bar too low. I grew up without knowing half of my genetic makeup and it is not without negative psychological effect.

TheKeatingFive · 20/05/2022 10:06

I find the attitude that anything done to enable someone to have a child is by definition a good thing and not open for any discussion very worrying.

Absolutely.

There is this odd double think going on also whereby those using donors sometimes seem to minimise what all this means for the donor (just a bunch of cells) but simultaneously talk about how important it is to them (using some very emotive language).

We need a more honest debate and a lot more exploration of the long term impacts on donors and children conceived of donors.

CupidStunt22 · 20/05/2022 09:58

torfa · 20/05/2022 00:20

What a horrible, goady thread.

It's neither. You just don't understand the discussion or why it needs to be had.

Beamur · 20/05/2022 09:42

CounsellorTroi · 20/05/2022 08:49

I find the attitude that anything done to enable someone to have a child is by definition a good thing and not open for any discussion very worrying.

Yes. Refusal to debate or hear anything other than a confirming echo chamber is unhealthy wherever it occurs.

CounsellorTroi · 20/05/2022 08:49

I find the attitude that anything done to enable someone to have a child is by definition a good thing and not open for any discussion very worrying.

Foolsrule · 20/05/2022 07:31

Buying and selling body parts is never going to be in the best interests of the resulting child, is it? People can try and justify their need/desire to have a child any way they want but the psychological implications for that child are huge. Should it be allowed in the first place? IMO, no.

NotDoris · 20/05/2022 06:59

I have two children, one of which was conceived using donated eggs due to being menopausal at just 26 years old. We thought very long and hard, and had counselling before coming to this decision.
The child knows, and as far as I was made aware, there is the possibility to connect somehow with the anonymous donor once they reach adulthood.
The donor was part of an ‘egg share scheme’ whereby they needed IVF but couldn’t fund it and we could, so we essentially helped each other by them sharing their eggs with us in return for us essentially discounting/paying towards their treatment. Without each other, neither of us potentially could become pregnant, and I sincerely hope they achieved their dream as we did. Until you’ve been in that position you don’t truely know what you’d do.

Discovereads · 20/05/2022 01:21

YANBU
I’m just sad that I was born too soon to sell my eggs to the highest bidder. I think the current law requiring them to be donated is unethical exploitation as we literally groom young women with the “be nice and kind” messaging to go through an invasive medical procedure with its own risks and consequences for fuck all.

Brainwashing women into giving away something so intrinsically valuable for nothing is the very definition of exploitation. I am glad that women can get discounts on IVF in return for some of their eggs because it reduces the inequality of access for poor women struggling with infertility. Why should IVF be only for the financially well off? I hope to see further law changes that will allow young women to actually be properly compensated for their eggs and for the stigma associated with it to disappear.

And please don’t compare this to organ or blood or bone marrow donation. They’re only similar in that they all originate in our bodies. Beyond that they are fundamentally different because they are life saving not life creating.

I also agree with the “her body, her choice” argument. I think too that counter arguments about young women being too naive and inexperienced to make decisions about their own bodies is infantilising. They’re adults. They have the right to make their own decisions. If you are deemed mature enough to decide to terminate a pregnancy or have a baby with zero parental knowledge at 16, then you can certainly navigate the decision on whether or not to sell some of your eggs at 18.

torfa · 20/05/2022 00:20

What a horrible, goady thread.

Sortilege · 19/05/2022 23:41

Robinni · 19/05/2022 23:36

Yes I see that now, could be read both ways.

Very informative thread. I think what’s come out of it for me is how much DCP need to be included in the conversation - something I intend on doing should I have to consider a donor egg at a later date.

Yes, I’ve concluded much the same. Which probably means sticking to the U.K. and asking pointed questions at the outset.

OP posts:
Robinni · 19/05/2022 23:36

Sortilege · 19/05/2022 23:13

Oh I see. Missed that. I thought she meant “the State” as in “the government”.

Yes I see that now, could be read both ways.

Very informative thread. I think what’s come out of it for me is how much DCP need to be included in the conversation - something I intend on doing should I have to consider a donor egg at a later date.